ConcreteLoop.com

LOGIN
----------------------------------
GRAVATAR | COMMENTING RULES

STAR JONES DEFENDS MARIAH’S BLACKNESS ON ‘THE VIEW’

Monday, June 19, 2006

*CLICK TO VIEW THE VIDEO*

star_sandrview.JPGComic Sandra Bernhard ran into brick wall trying to rehash her old ‘Mimi’ joke.

Star Jones Reynolds had to bite her tongue to keep from cursing out comedian Sandra Bernhard on “The View” Friday morning.

Bernhard has made jokes in the past about biracial singer Mariah Carey appearing to cash in on her blackness only when her more mainstream pop material became passé. Star, reading from the pre-interview notes on her blue cards, asked Bernhard to explain why she is now claiming responsibility for the success of Carey’s album, “The Emancipation of Mimi.”

Bernhard said it was her jokes eight years ago about Carey “being black only when it’s convenient” that led to the singer’s nervous breakdown, which eventually resulted in this current emancipation. (read more)

178 CommentsCOMMENT?

Posted by: ANGEL

more info on the dope 21MC pharaoh's poncho way-back-like-cornrows callaloo-checks sportin-waves safari-dimebag

178 Comments


1.

blk dds

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

She’s just tryin to save her ass.

2.

Antwone

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

to me mariah aint black she dont act like it, dyed her hair, i mean she look white, so sad!!!!1

3.

shithappens

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Star looks like she’s bout to sneak Sandra

4.

momo

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

This interview was crazy, so much drama went on with her.
I wonder if they are going to invite her back after that.

5.

akamissj

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Sandra Bernhard is just a very offensive person, so I wouldn’t take anything she has to say seriously.

6.

can_jen

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I CAN’T STAND STAR!! EVER SINCE HER FAT ASS GOT A MAD SHE HAS BECOME FAKE!!! MARIAH HAS NOT ALWAYS ACTED BLACK. ONLY WHEN SHE NEEDED A REMIX! OLD STAR WOULD HAVE SPOKEN THE TRUTH. AND SOMEBODY NEEDS TO LET HER KNOW THAT SOME PEOPLE SHOULDN’T LOSE TO MUCH WEIGHT CAUSE THEN YOU START LOOKING UGLY LIKE HER. STAR ALSO STARTED THE “VIEW” SAYING THAT SHE DOESN’T NEED A MAN NOW ALL SHE TALKS ABOUT IS HER GAY ASS MAN!!

7.

Gela

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Interesting. . . .

8.

jaejae

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

sounds like sandra is trynna get her emancpation(comeback) on..

9.

Brian

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I love sandra bernhard. she’s the best.

10.

Ginger

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

OMG THAT WAS FUNNY.

I THINK SANDRA IS RIGHT ON THE MARIAH COMMENT. SO DO YOU YALL.

11.

oyster

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Elizabeth is annoying and the Mariah comment does have some truth to it.

12.

Gela

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

@ Comment #3 (shithappens)

She sure does. . .

13.

ms. piggy

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

sandra’s right! whenever she did a remix it was filled with rappers. She know that pop shit ain’t sellin, so now she works with JD and other rappers! Bitch Please!

14.

sharonda

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

i like Mariah,but I honestly don’t think she has any black in her at all.its all sales.

15.

akamissj

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I have to admit, I always liked some of Mariah Carey’s music, but since I’m not a big pop fan, I became a real fan of Mariah after her Fantasy album, when she began singing more R&B rather than pop. Some people say that Mariah wanted to sing R&B all along but her husband/manager wanted her to have a certain image. Not sure if all that’s true but it’s something to think about. And you can’t totally accuse her of dying her hair blond to look white, you can, but she’s certainly not the only one. I could accuse a lot of other ethnic singers and actresses of the same thing (for example, J-Lo and Beyonce (that’s my girl and all but I’m keeping it real), and their are plenty of others. Personally if I was light as Mariah, Beyonce or J-Lo I would purposely not color my hair blonde because I’m not trying to be mistaken for a White person, but that’s me. White people are cool, but I’m a proud Black woman.

16.

Brooke

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

yeah, but is that a damn SECRET?! no…everybody else plays on the black / white thing too shoot. they just wanna sell as much as possible, so they TRY to cater to EVERYONE. Who cares?

17.

dukesman2000

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

As much as I love the hell outta Mariah Carey, but I don’t buy that “she is black bullshit.”

18.

kefale

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I think Mariah is totally fake, all the way around. She always tries to maintain her image 2 much 2 the point where she looks adickulous! And when I heard her singing, “We belong Together…” (on live tv) I said “No we don’t!” Mimi is just tryin to hustle!

19.

Megan

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Sandra is ignorant! Dykes are evil anyway.

20.

abby

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Mariah’s fake ass. Sandra was on point.

21.

phillylala

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

She is mixed! Her mom is white, and her dad is Afro-Venezuelan.

22.

Nunya

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Sandra Bernhard was only joking about Mariah, but my real problem is with that shrew Elizabeth Hasselback. There was no need for her to get all psycho just because the guest was talking about Laura Bush. I mean dayumn — is she on the Bush payroll? Anyone can see that Laura Bush looks like she is on valium.

23.

Blkbarbi00

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I agree with the Mariah comment but I still love her CD and her diva moments. she looks a mess but for some reason it works for her just because she is Mariah you expect this from her, she still fierce to me.

24.

kat25

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I’ve said this shit about Mariah for years, Sandra is right on the money!!! But yeah Meagan Dykes are evil! Ha Ha Ha!!! And Star needs to shut her fuckin mouth if she ain’t gone keep it real!

25.

Megan

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

White folks getting to comfortable. I don’t care if she was joking or not. Talking about she “hanging with the brothas”. Bitch, she can hang with anybody she wants too.

26.

freshsista

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I think Mariah chose her white side and used the black side to get some soul music. She acts like the old white lady from Green Acres, (Zsa or Eva Gabor) calling people darling. She is the female version of Tiger Woods to me. She NEVER SAID she was a black woman. She says she is biracial. She does not date black men AT ALL,that being said. No black woman (Star) is going to sit next to a white chick and say people use blackness for convenience. Let’s be real Sandra is fond of the N-word.

27.

akamissj

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I gotta’ agree with you #25

28.

tijarah08

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

mariah does only says she is black when its convenient, but many of our other artists look so eurocentric I can’t tell if I am looking at a white woman or a sista girl, but we as a people are still suffering from that WILLIE LYNCH SYNDROME, smh!!!!

29.

bailey

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

mariah is black, if you take in to consideration the one drop rule. mariah is alright with me she can sing, and has always delivered beautiful songs from the jump. Mariah struggles enough with her own identity, it’s so apparent that she has issues. I am so glad that she got herself together enough to deliver another hot album just for all you haters who are obviously hoping for her demise.

She has absolutely nothing to gain by saying her father is black and he wasn’t apart of her life. Many white artists collaborate with black producers etc. and make hit songs, they have been doing this forever, so she doesn’t need to create a story about her nationality to jump on the ole bandwagon.

That white/black (whatever) bit** is bad, you can’t even hate on her. Her skills are unquestionable. When you are that good, color doesn’t matter-she obviously appeals to the masses-check those record sales!!!!!!

30.

jilli

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Why is everyone jumping down Star’s throat and no one mentioned the fact that Barbara Walters also indicated that Mariah had claimed her black side long ago?
Do you all really hate this woman that much?

31.

Meatloaf

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Good! I can’t stand tricks like Sandra and Angie Dickson who think they can say anything that pops into their trailer trashed mines. J-Lo tried talking that smack too, but she got served.

32.

Tyron

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

What’s wrong wit dating brothers? Just because Mariah Carey is an R&B singer doesn’t mean she’s trying to be more black. And she didn’t cause nobody to have a break down because during the time of Mariah breakdown nobody even knew or cared who she was. She says all this crap about “All of us are related in some way.” and then she says racial slurs on National Television. Give me a break Sandra Bernhard!

33.

Megan

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Ok last comment….for now…

And white folks always talking about how we always bring up race.

She need some dyck in her life. That’s all that is.

34.

icandi

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I agree with #25 Megan white folks are getting off the chain. That shit rubbed me the wrong way.

35.

Coffy

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

ok want to impart some things.. first off Mariah had no control over her career in the beginning it was all Tommy Motolla, I think he was the mastermind of the “guess my race game”. He pulled the same technique with Paula Abdul, she was also signed with Sony music. And when she came out no one knew what her ethnic orgin was either, and they (record company), played that for as long as they could. Once Mariah left Tommy everything changed she gained weight, changed her hair, and the kind of songs she sang.

36.

damshespretty

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I have always liked Mariah. When you are mixed you mostly relate to the person who raised you, which was her mother. That’s why she might have related more to white people. When she became of age she decided to learn more about herself, and I respect that.

Her father is half spanish and when she reconected with him, she started claiming spanish people to. Shes just all mixed up. LOL

37.

Such Magnificence

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Sandra better be scared of Star b/cuz she is looking real gangsta in that clip!
I’ve ran into Star (and Al they are joined at the hip) a few times and she is actually (to many peoples surprise) really nice.

38.

Such Magnificence

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

The only thing I would say about Star is she is BOSSY to Al…he is like her man servant more than a husband! I have seen them when I was out shopping a couple times and she is like Al get me this…do that…do this…HURRY UP…and he really does everything she says too! He is really soft spoken…

39.

fatgirlfromphilly

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

sanda looked like she smokes weed hard. she got on everybody nerves. she was kinda right about mariah, i cant tell a lie.

40.

salome

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Sandra is a comedian. It was meant as a joke and Star took it out of control and even apoligzed for stepping on Sandra’s punchline..

41.

SheRoc

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

@19-You must be one helluva dyke, because you look as evil as hell in that picture.

Star’s credibility is somewhat shaky. I mean, she defends her deadbeat faggot husband. She’s not helping Mariah at all.

42.

GG Boo

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I’m gonna have to agree with #29 (bailey) Mariah’s skills speak way louder than Sandra Bernhard (complete nobody) OR star jones. I’m not the hugest Mariah fan, but I am just curious…what is “acting black?” Let’s not put our own selves in a box like that ok? As far as claiming blackness i have always known her as black and her recent collabos with hip hop artists is just a change with the times. many people black, white and whatever are doing the same thing (Anybody know that song Promiscuous Girl? Nelly Furtado? Ok, what are some of her other hits? You may know them, but I sure don’t because giving songs a hip-hop edge in today’s world makes a big difference and makes good business sense).

43.

Siobhan

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

There was an interesting article in a recent publication about a biracial family: black mother, white father, and three children. The parents are raising the children to identify with both races and the children are secure in their racial identity. So secure, in fact, that they each answer differently when filling out questionaires that require them to identify with a particular race. One girl checks both African-American and Caucasian. The son checks Other. The third child just says Bi-Racial.

In this day and age, there are more and more biracial children and requiring them to choose one over the other is not fair. If they are raised properly by both parents then being biracial is not ever going to be a problem for them. It will only be a problem for those who want them to choose. It hasn’t been for me.

Mariah was raised by her white mother. However, as she got older and learned more about her father’s heritage then she began to identify with that side. She may have chosen to call herself one or the other based on the music hotness of the day. As a biracial woman she can identify with both and if that works for her then how can you hate on her? She doesn’t have to claim one race.

44.

HAHAHA

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I like Star, she always expresses exactly how she feels in a more tactful manner, and I respect that even if I don’t agree with some things she says. She’s like a black version of Oprah.

45.

GG Boo

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

oh and looky looky - I swear I hadn’t even looked at the posts for today before responding - is that NELLY FURTADO and TIMBALAND on concrete loop? I wonder how she managed that? Oh because she’s collaborating with a hip-hop artist. Got it.

46.

TryDimeB

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I agree with #30 I think people on here are using this problem to add to the fact that they just don’t like Mariah. Because you can’t be serious about Mariah not being black. It’s a fact. Even if Mariah said I’m not black it’s a fact, she can’t change it and neither can the hata’s. Like I said if Halle, Alicia Keys, Vanessa Willaims,Sade,and Chilli from TLC are black then so is Mariah. Why not? Cause we want to hate? Grow up.

47.

DLady06

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Can someone who is on here trying to prove Mariah is not black and trying to act black. Please tell how you can become black overnight. PLease let me know what that means. Without putting down black people. Please. Since you know it all tell me black acting black means.

48.

RastaMermaid

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

MiMi is living in the skin she’s in. She didn’t chose it, but she’s dealing with it.

I’m biracial and kids are cruel as hell growing up! She’s learned to love herself,so she dyed her hair, why doea it have to be to look white, maybe it just enhances her beauty. I have green eyes and auburn hair by birth I didn’t finally try it(dye my hair) til I was 30 and it was the best move I could make. Not to look white but because it truly enchanced my features. Kinda of like Jade on ANTM she hated the fact they colored her hair, but it really enhanced her for a different look.

I use to say black people don’t have blonde hair and blue eyes! Well I have green eyes and now auburn and blonde hair.

If you are of bi-racial heritage you should love and embrace both cultures to totally love you!

Respect!

49.

sorny

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

“# HAHAHA said:

I like Star, she always expresses exactly how she feels in a more tactful manner, and I respect that even if I don’t agree with some things she says. She’s like a black version of Oprah. ”

Hi-fuckin-larious.

50.

Yosay

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

TryDimeB said:
——————————————————————————–

I agree with #30 I think people on here are using this problem to add to the fact that they just don’t like Mariah. Because you can’t be serious about Mariah not being black. It’s a fact. Even if Mariah said I’m not black it’s a fact, she can’t change it and neither can the hata’s. Like I said if Halle, Alicia Keys, Vanessa Willaims,Sade,and Chilli from TLC are black then so is Mariah. Why not? Cause we want to hate? Grow up.
—————–

Vanessa Williams has TWO BLACK PARENTS!!!!! That’s a little different from having One black and One White. Which in my book does not equal BLACK!

Being black includes all of the following: having black DNA, growing up in the culture, and having a black state of mind.

Mariah is missing two of the above.

And Chilli from TLC mother is Black and father is Native American. And from the looks of him, he’s got ALOT of Black Blood.

Sandra is right Mariah uses her “Blackness” when it is convenient for her.

51.

Yosay

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

damshespretty said:
——————————————————————————–

I have always liked Mariah. When you are mixed you mostly relate to the person who raised you, which was her mother. That’s why she might have related more to white people. When she became of age she decided to learn more about herself, and I respect that.
——-

I agree and there’s NOTHING wrong with that. Like the Jews, I believe that ‘heritage’ is passed through the mother.

If you’re mother is White, then you are white (no matter how you look) and if your mother is black, then you are black ( no matter how you look).

The mother is usually the one that raises the child, so the child is going to adopt the mother’s culture. It makes sense.

52.

baddestchick

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I didnt know you could turn being black on and off. I didnt know that you had to wear a poster on your head saying Im black. Just because she came out one way does that mean she cant change. Everybody that is biracial dont have to “keep it real” to impress “us” the black folks. If she didnt grow up being around black culture then that is not who she is. She grew up with a white mother. Youll cannot point the finger at Mariah, because some of us “pure black folks” dont even do enough for our race to uplift it. And if Mariah Carey grew up with this type of attitude from black people, if she is denying that side of her then I dont blame her.

53.

huh?

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

@ GG Boo

Another one of Nelly’s songs is “Fly Like A Bird” so I knew who she was BEFORE her new song. Which I love by the way.

54.

GG Boo

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

@huh?
Yes, that is why in my post I pointed out that some of you MAY know other hits, It wasn’t an across-the-board statement. But I honestly believe she took the hip-hop angle this time around because she WILL get more notoriety with this. The other Nelly song (I can’t think of the name) was the one she had with Missy Elliott. But, either way, do you think more people know the song you mention or Promiscuous Girl? It’s just business that’s all.

That being said, (I don’t know if you are black or not, but for this point it doesn’t matter and this comment is not directed at you) I appreciate you for saying that because it lends to the point of how different we all are concerning everything from tastes in music to skin color. There is no such thing as “acting black” and it is just sad to see that written after all black people have gone through to break into so many things.

55.

pittbboi

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Hold on, I have to call this mess out:

#49
“Being black includes all of the following: having black DNA, growing up in the culture, and having a black state of mind.

Mariah is missing two of the above.”

Exactly what in the hell is black culture, and what about it qualifies us as black people? There’s a different answer to this question in whatever country you’re in, and America is unique in the fact that when the slaves were brought here they were stripped of their culture and identity. So tell me, what is black culture? Is it food? Music? Because, if you ask me, Mariah subscribes to all of those things that people like to consider “black” when they are, in fact, not.

And don’t get me started on what the hell a “black state of mind” is supposed to be.

Face it: In the United States black people have very few things that they can call “culture” if they have anything at all. We were stripped of it coming here. Does that suck? Yes. But there’s nothing we can do about it but move on. Saying someone isn’t black because they don’t subscribe to a culture that doesn’t fully represent black people and is only a list of negative stereotypes and constructs is foolish. If Mariah has black blood in her she’s part black. Period. It doesn’t matter what she looks or acts like. And just because she’s part black doesn’t mean that everything she puts out has to be Jazz, Rap, R&B or Gospel. But that’s a different argument all together.

The shackles were unlocked a long time ago, but some black people just refuse to take them off…

56.

GG Boo

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

correction: *the other Nelly song that I remember was with Missy, not Fly-Bird*

57.

MakingFaces

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

So let me get this right…white folks are getting too “comfortable” talking about race — but it’s perfectly fine to call Sandra Berhard a dyke. That hypocrite kool-aid must taste mighty fine.

Sandra comes from a long line of social/political humorists — i.e. Paul Mooney and Margaret Cho. She speaks the truth and is often funny. Apparently the art of satire is lost on many these days.

Talent aside Mariah Carey IS a straight-up wack job. Her bizarre insecurities cause her to do some rather strange things. I mean, she ONLY wants to filmed from one side of her face. If you watch that ridiculous Pepsi commercial she is ALWAYS facing the same direction. She always glares to the right. Even when that motorcycle is leaping left, her damn face is pointed right. What about all those hilariously staged “candid shots”. Poor little rich girl with glittery psychosis. To not mock her is a crime.

Also — Star Jones can take a flying leap…if she can even get those tittays off the ground. She was combative for the entire interview — just looking for a fight. Apparently in some alternate universe somebody told Star she looked cute. Up is down and ugly is cute. The fact that anybody would defend such an abomination of a woman is beyond me. She is a grotesque self-referential snakey opportunist with no shame.

Star should really be nicer to Sandra, they have so much in common — they both got big mouths and they are both in gay marriages.

58.

GG Boo

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

*applauding pittbboi* Very well put, please take a bow.

Ok yall have a great day I better do some work… Remember self-love and respect, and much love to all (ALL) of you!

59.

SARCASTIC SID SAYS:

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

everyday the same fuckin’ arguments…WILL GOD KILL US ALREADY AND START ANEW???….now maybe you m/f’s will get along, when you agree how ignorant that statement was.

60.

Real Talk

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

#43 HAHAHA….u are DEAD WRONG for that. LMAO!!!!!!!!!!

First of all, let me start by makin it clear that Mariah has ALWAYS been an RnB artist. Her debut single, “Vision of Love”, was #1 on the RnB charts b4 it was #1 on the pop charts. and btw, the only difference between a pop song and an RnB song is the voice on it….put Mariah’s voice on a Britney-type joint and it becomes RnB. I think it is ignorant of the general public to say she was tryna be “black” simply because of collabos with rappers….i mean she did collaborate with Luther Vandross in ‘94….why wasnt she black then?

Also, what the FUCK is a black state of mind??^^^…..havin a cheap as weave in ur head?….no wait, it must be havin 5 kids before the age of 20…..puh-fuckin-lease….it is sad that such words are even spoken.

Like someone said^^, if halle and alicia are considered black, then why not Mariah??

61.

what?

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

#52 “huh?”…..it’s “I’m Like A Bird”…..”Fly Like A Bird” is track 14 of Mariah’s LP….lol, u must be a fan

62.

what?

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

#52 “huh?”…..it’s “I’m Like A Bird”…..”Fly Like A Bird” is track 14 of Mariah’s LP….lol, u must be a fan

63.

littlemamajtb

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

#2 why would Mariah have to dye her hair to look white? if she had dark hair, she would still look bi racial. Mariah have neva given me the impression that she wanted to be either or, she is simply Mariah. Not once have I heard Mariah cater her songs to whites, most of her songs caters to black people. Even though we know all races of people love her music. This is what I can’t understand about some folks, why wouldn’t Mariah, Halle or any other bi racial celebrity or singer not date white or act partially white, they are half and half, right?

64.

cutdashit79

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I do not think we will ever know what Mariah’s true race is, but I do not think she wants to be labeled as any one thing, that why she says she is “bi-racial”. And she damn sure don’t want to be labeled as Black(only).

65.

DLady06

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

#56 What’s your point. Stay on the subject. Your are right that hypocrite kool-aid is being drunk a lot. But you must tell me how it taste. You probably chose the flavor. This whole I agree with Sandra bull is just siding with the ignorant. And if that’s you why would anybody take your statements seriously? Mariah is Mariah and I respect her black or not.

66.

hmmm

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

It wasn’t that bad. Star calls it like she sees it. She has relationships and conversations with celebrities that the everyday person does not have access to - who is to say Mariah has not been forthcoming about her background in everyday life? It was her management, husband/spin doctor who kept her ethnicity under wraps.

Now the exchange between Sandra and Elizabeth was quite entertaining. Joy needs to sit down.

Everybody has issues. I like Star. I’m not mad at her.

67.

SixTwo

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

dat sandra bitch is ugg

68.

Chi-Chi

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I could really care whut Mariah is…it dont matter…..the fact is the gurl can SSSAAANNNGGG!!!

69.

gizmo

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

First of all I think that sometimes you people over-do it with your slanderous language, calling someone a dyke is mean rude and uncalled for, even if Sandra Bernhard is gay what does that have to do with being a bitch. (I love Sandra she’s hilarious, take the stick out your ass and giggle) I think people’s true colors show when they open their mouths. Its 2006 get with the gay shit. Damn.

I love Mariah but there are two sides to this coin.

I must say Mariah looks good blonde. Her natural color doesnt give her that speaker phone look. I think Mariah may be a little insecure about her good side because she has a grill issue on the other side(arent we all a lil insecure). So fuckin what? Why does someone have to be uncomfortable with being black just because they dont have their natural hair color or natural hair. Does she have to have dreads just to be down too?

If thats the case all of the famous broads your frends and family and alot of the chicks that frequent this site are all playing themselves because they are using chemicals to straighten their hair. And no, relaxers dont make your hair more manageable, it makes it fall out faster.

On the other side I know people who have met Mariah and said that she is waaay over the top with that vivacious “Darling” shit. Kinda annoying im sure. But underneath all that playing she’s doing is a baad intelligent bitch (read her lyrics, most of us can’t spell the shit she’s writing.)

If Mariah really is mixed then im sure she had a hard time growing up in Long Island, NY which to this day is one of the most racist places to live in NY. Therefore no I dont knock her if she is a lil kooky either.

70.

kat25

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I don’t think Mariah tries to “act black” at all, but she definitley leaned on black folks when white folks didn’t want her ass no more…. Like Sandra said…

I’m not a fan of Sandra or Mariah, but damnit Sandra made a good point, and yes Mariah is a hellava singer, but as far as her public persona, well it seems mighty damn fake to me, but oh well…

And I don’t think Sandra is going to far, or even white folks in general… Black comedians crack on white people all the time, but when they speak on us we get all sensitive, but then we want to be treated equally in this society…. I like people who speak freely and say how they really feel more than I like people who pretend to be down or all racially sensitive and then go home and call us niggers to their friends **coughs Eminem** cough…

71.

Ebz

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Im sorry..but was I the only one that was blinded by the catastrophic GAP [ ] between them teeth. I couldn’t focus on what she was saying..All i kept thinkin is DAMN THIS IS ONE UGLY AZZ WOMAN.
Whoever called her Fishlips was ON POINT

72.

gizmo

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

And another thing, just because your black doesnt mean you can tell another black person they are not black enough. Alot of blk people who are interested in what we do but were not introduced to those things growing up are afraid or dejected because our brothers and sisters shunned them.

Just because someone else is into something you or your friends were never introduced to, it doesnt make them less blk, thats just their flow. We aren’t carbon copies. Then blk women wonder why good black men run off with a perky white woman. Expand your mind, and love each other because we are, not because of who we are.

73.

MrsDawsondn

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Pittboi said:
Face it: In the United States black people have very few things that they can call “culture” if they have anything at all. We were stripped of it coming here. Does that suck? Yes. But there’s nothing we can do about it but move on. Saying someone isn’t black because they don’t subscribe to a culture that doesn’t fully represent black people and is only a list of negative stereotypes and constructs is foolish. If Mariah has black blood in her she’s part black. Period. It doesn’t matter what she looks or acts like. And just because she’s part black doesn’t mean that everything she puts out has to be Jazz, Rap, R&B or Gospel. But that’s a different argument all together.

The shackles were unlocked a long time ago, but some black people just refuse to take them off…

Very well put **claps**

74.

tdotlady

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

sandra has alot of nerve, she doesnt know what the hell shes talkin about. mariahs always made r&b and soul music from vision of love and emotions, mariahs record labal wanted to mold her when she first came out, into a woman that was always coverd up and the inocent type and i heard in a interveiw that mariah always loved rap and from the begining wanted to work with rappers but her record label didnt want her to because they thought it wouldnt be right for image they wanted her to hav, so when she broke out she started workin with rappers which she always wanted to do and dressin more of her own taste. Sandra is so stupid why the hell is she talkin about someone she knows nothin about.

75.

lea

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

snadra is right about mariah in tha beginning she didnt want to have any thing to do wit blacks and married tommy motola when he left her ass she stated singing wit bones thugs and harmony like she was useng them for back up to protect her next it was puffy and so on so sandra is right go sandra for putting it out there so star needs to shut her anerexic lukn ass up and concentrat on dat faggot ass husband of hers just my opinion lol

76.

lexi_baby

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

How the hell is Star Jones gonna defend anybody about being black. When the bitch ain’t even black her damn self! She act as bougee and as white as they come. She always got her nasty ass nose turned up at somebody. She ain’t shit. Come on, I mean seriously, what REAL black person do ya’ll know that would be on the god damn VIEW? Point exactly.

77.

Megan

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

40. Strictly stickly; so I’m very sweet!

78.

jewel13

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Sandra was right on with a lot of her comments. So #73 you think she’s always wanted to work with rappers? You can’t believe everything you read. Mariah has used her “blackness” when it was convenient for her , she’s frequently used rappers on her remixes. In her “Dreamlover” days, she was a white chick, the only thing black about her back then was the dancers in her video. She’s talented, so don’t start ya’ll, no hate here.

79.

DLady06

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

#75 I would never conversate with you about anything when you use the lord’s name in vain. Just to be a hater. Go MC. Yes you are black.

80.

lexi_baby

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

#78 I didn’t ask you to conversate with me now did I? no. And how the hell is that hating. by saying she ain’t black. Oh right. i’m hating on Star Jones. lmao!

81.

Craig

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I cosign Pittboi, sounds intelligent and reasonable to me

82.

Siobhan

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

How does a person act white? For that matter, how does a person act black? People say “Oh he acts white.” Or “Oh look she’s acting black.” How does one act like that of a particular race?

83.

Megan

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

81. When people say “act” or “looK black or white, I think they are referring to what a group of people emulate culturally.

In reality, there is a way that is or sounds Black. Like if you were talking on the phone with someone, you can tell that they are Black no matter how proper they talk, you can tell that person is Black.

But these days, since everybody wants to be us, you can’t really tell sometimes.

84.

pittbboi

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

#75 That made absolutely zero sense. I know lots of BLACK people who love The View, and plenty of black people have been on it.

And if Star isn’t a REAL black person, is she fake? Does she wake up every morning and take a bath in some brown dye or something? Because that’s the only way someone could be fake black.

There’s no such thing as a REAL black person or fake black person. If you’re black you’re black. That’s all there is to it. Stop basing it on petty, temporary things that don’t really matter at the end of the day.

And if you don’t think black people can act bougie…

85.

wowfactor

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

The field niggas love talking about house niggas.. lets focus this hate on that white dyke and not Star

86.

huh?

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

# 61 you’re right. my fault. and I am a fan of hers. I was happy when she came back out. I like different types of music.

@ GG Boo I’m actually a black female, but I don’t let race define what type of music I listen too. I love the Dixie Chicks, Alanis Morrisette, Jewel, Tamia,etc. I’m not a big rap fan but that’s because of the cursing. I do understand what you’re saying though. I hate the race card being played though.

87.

ZV

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Well, to us guys ALL them chicks are yentas. Mariah certainly does not look black, so I understand her ambivalence. She is an opportunist and uses Blacks when it suites her, I guess like most other artists and Blacks OURSELVES use other Blacks. ALL those chicks got personal issues so I guess it’s easier to fault somebody else.

88.

tijarah08

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Oh one more thing the girl who was tearing off Sandra’s head about Laura Bush being an advocate for better education is a load of bull. If she was so for education why would she let her husband cut over a billion dollars in scholarships and grants to fund higher education for students who cannot necessarily afford it. I am an elementary education major in college and I plan on working in the inner city schools. Education in the inner city is such a joke many of the students don’t have the same opportunities that are afforded to their middle class or upper middle class associates. How dare this women try to protect Laura Bush when so many of our young black students are not recieving a proper education because they have cut funding, that really pisses me off!!!

89.

Asentha

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I don’t like Sandra as a comedian, but she was on point about Mariah!! Hell, Star may as well argue that Al-ice isn’t gay while she’s at it!! LOL!!

90.

Gizmo

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

That bitch do look high on sumthin..fuck is it valium? My boy got a bottle full, maybe i should pop one and see if I can budget myself much less the country’s education program.

91.

ohmylord

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

lexi_baby said:
——————————————————————————–

How the hell is Star Jones gonna defend anybody about being black. When the bitch ain’t even black her damn self! She act as bougee and as white as they come. She always got her nasty ass nose turned up at somebody. She ain’t shit. Come on, I mean seriously, what REAL black person do ya’ll know that would be on the god damn VIEW? Point exactly

*************************************************

Congratulations! that is just about the most ignorant comment i have seen on CL yet. Now, tell me…when did being black have anythin to do with how u act??

black people, I AM BEGGING YOU, read books….we cannot afford to be this ignorant. For the record, being black means u belong to the negroid race. It has absolutely NOTHING to do with how bougee u act or dont. And also for the record, a race is a biological division of human beings….for fuck sake

92.

Mister G

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

wowfactor, i feel u!!

93.

HERO POLI SOKOLATA

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

SANDRA BERNHARDT IS RIGHT!!!
I HAVE BEEN SAYING IT FOR YEARS. WHEN MARIAH FIRST STARTED OUT, SHE LOOKED BLACK. THEN WHEN SHE WAS REALLY HAPPENING, SHE STARTED TALKING ABOUT HOW HARD IT WAS FOR HER BEING MIXED… (BULL SHIT)
THEN SHE WAS IRISH/VENEZUELAN, THEN WHEN PEOPLE STEPPED ON HER, IT BECAME (IRISH/AFRICAN AMERICA/VENEZUELAN).
MIMI HAD HERSELF A NOSE JOB, DYED HER HAIR AND STRAIGHTENED IT. WE HAVEN’T SEEN MARIAH’S CURLY HAIR SINCE WAY BACK WHEN?

AFTER THE NERVOUS BREAKDOWN AND THE ONLY PEOPLE STANDING WITH HER ASS IS BLACK PEOPLE/THE REST OF THE DIASPORA, NOW MARIAH IS BLACK.
BETTER LATE THAN NEVER, AT LEAST SHE FIGURED IT OUT AT SOME POINT!!!

ELIZABETH HASSLEBECK IS THE BIGGEST PUCCEE ON THIS SIDE OF THE MISSISSIPPI!
SHE TALKS SHIT, SHE LOOKS LIKE SHIT!!!
IF ELIZABETH WERE BLACK AND TALKING SUCH CRAP ON THE AIR ON A DAILY BASIS, THE MEDIA WOULD HAVE DONE SAID SHE GOT THE JOB BECAUSE OF AFFIRMATIVE ACTION…
I CAN’T STAND STAR’S FROG EYES, BUT AT LEAST SHE SOUNDS SMARTER THAT ELIZABETH.

THE MOST PRACTICAL AND SEEMINGLY OBJECTIVE PERSON ON THAT SHOW IS JOY, AND LET’S NOT FORGET BARBARA!!

94.

Susie

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

@lexibaby

are you joking or are you really that ignorant and ghetto?

In my lifetime, I have NEVER heard such ignorance, don’t expect a good job, house or any of the finer things in life

YOU DON’T DESERVE IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

95.

craig

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I co-sign anyone that goes at lexi baby..that kind of ignorance and illiteracy is UNACCEPTABLE.

96.

SitDown

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

#93 HERO POLI SOKOLATA ….when next ur gonna go on a mindless rant, pls be sure to get ur facts straight.
Mariah NEVER had a nose job. it looks narrow in videos due to technological alteration - for lack of a better term.

Oh and straight hair means ur not black??…then i guess 85% of the black women in America must be white.

as far as i remember, Mariah has ALWAYS claimed her black heritage. I definitely remember her sayin so on Oprah at least 14 years ago.

and about dying her hair….why not call out beyonce….or half of the black women in the industry

Plus, i think Mariah looks blacker now than she ever did.

97.

Helena

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I know this is about Mariah but someone mentioned the VIEW being some sort of high class show which is not “black”. I hve to speak about that because I want black ppl to understand that the world is about putting ur best foot forward. You don’t see trailer trash addicts that are not eloquent on these shows…and they make up the majority of america right now. So why should blacks put the worst in front of the camera???
BTW it wouldn’t hurt if Star spoke a little more eloquently…I know she’s a lawyer so she can def speak better.

98.

SitDown

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Real Talk:

“First of all, let me start by makin it clear that Mariah has ALWAYS been an RnB artist. Her debut single, “Vision of Love”, was #1 on the RnB charts b4 it was #1 on the pop charts. and btw, the only difference between a pop song and an RnB song is the voice on it….put Mariah’s voice on a Britney-type joint and it becomes RnB. I think it is ignorant of the general public to say she was tryna be “black” simply because of collabos with rappers….i mean she did collaborate with Luther Vandross in ‘94….why wasnt she black then?

Also, what the FUCK is a black state of mind??^^^…..havin a cheap as weave in ur head?….no wait, it must be havin 5 kids before the age of 20…..puh-fuckin-lease….it is sad that such words are even spoken.

Like someone said^^, if halle and alicia are considered black, then why not Mariah??”

CHUUUUCCCCHHH!!!!!!!!!

99.

putitinyomouth

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

preach, Helena.

100.

jajasjor

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

star is defending mariah….wtf for?…..she better defend why she married a doo-doo chaser

101.

wowfactor

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I like Star and … and hell if you know your going to get fired go out with a bang.. I would cuss all those white bitches out on my way out the door.. that should get her off the d list and win her black fans back..

102.

Amber

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Yosay, you are a damn mess. My Mom is white and I wasn’t raised to identify more with whites. She taught me I was black and should be damn proud of that from the jump. If it were slaves times, all our asses would be picking cotton and/or making Massa’s supper. I don’t care if you look lilly white, if one of your parents are black, so are you.
Siohban, or however you spell your name. You live in a fantasy! Those kids can mark other, green, or Caublinasian, but they are still black and minorities at the end of the day. Teaching kids they are “grey” helps nobody.

103.

Amber

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Oh, #63, how and the hell do you act “partially white”??? You are a dummy.
Mariah is black! She’s finally come to that realization too. Its everybody else who’s still arguing over it because she doesn’t fit everybody’s definition of what a sister looks like.

104.

jaime del rio

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

sandra bernhard is a crazy bitch dun listen to nuthin she says lol she was funny on roseanne though

105.

Amber

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Hey, #93! I love you!

106.

reborn

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

pls everybody, read pittboi’s posts. it makes too much sense…

it’shigh time we stopped going by the one drop rule and accept ppl’s multi-ethnicities.

107.

Yosay

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

pittbboi said:
——————————————————————————–

Hold on, I have to call this mess out:

#49
“Being black includes all of the following: having black DNA, growing up in the culture, and having a black state of mind.

Mariah is missing two of the above.”

Exactly what in the hell is black culture, and what about it qualifies us as black people? There’s a different answer to this question in whatever country you’re in, and America is unique in the fact that when the slaves were brought here they were stripped of their culture and identity. So tell me, what is black culture? Is it food? Music? Because, if you ask me, Mariah subscribes to all of those things that people like to consider “black” when they are, in fact, not.

SOUNDS LIKE YOU NEED TO READ A FEW HISTORY BOOKS AND BECOME AWARE OF THE WORLD YOU LIVE IN. AMERICAN CULTURE IS BLACK CULTURE. EVERYTHING FROM MUSIC TO FASHION, TO SLANG LANGUAGE (THAT EVEN WHITES AND OTHER RACES USE IN THIS COUNTRY) TO FOOD IS ALL BLACK CULTURE. WHEN BLACKS WERE BROUGHT TO THIS COUNTRY WE WERE STRIPPED OF OUR NAMES OUR LANGUAGE AND SOME OF OUR AFRICAN CULTURE BUT SOME OF THE CULTURE WAS RETAINED AND STILL LIVES ON IN OUR MUSIC AND AND DANCE WHICH HAS BEEN CO-OPED AND EXPLOITED.

BTW, ALL AFRICANS THAT WERE KIDNAPPED WERE STRIPPED OF SOME OF THEIR NAMES, LANGUAGE AND CULTURE BUT WERE CREATIVE ENOUGH TO CREATE NEW CULTURES BASED ON THEIR AFRICAN CULTURE…ETC BRAZIL, THE CARIBBEAN AND THE FUJI ISLANDS!

And don’t get me started on what the hell a “black state of mind” is supposed to be.

Face it: In the United States black people have very few things that they can call “culture”

VERY INGORNANT STATMENT. SEE THE ABOVE RESPONSE. YOU ARE WHAT YOU ACCUSE ME OF BEING.

if they have anything at all. We were stripped of it coming here. Does that suck? Yes. But there’s nothing we can do about it but move on. Saying someone isn’t black because they don’t subscribe to a culture that doesn’t fully represent black people and is only a list of negative stereotypes and constructs is foolish. If Mariah has black blood in her she’s part black. Period.

THERE ARE ALOT OF PEOPLE WITH BLACK BLOOD WHO ARE TECHINICALLY BLACK YES! LATINOS, JEWS, SICILIANS, “BLACK IRISH”, BUT THEY DON’T ACKNOWLEGDE. THAT ACKNOWLEDGING PART IS VERY IMPORTANT. LOL!

It doesn’t matter what she looks or acts like. And just because she’s part black doesn’t mean that everything she puts out has to be Jazz, Rap, R&B or Gospel. But that’s a different argument all together.

WHAT YOU FAIL TO UNDERSTAND THAT EVEN THE ORIGINS OF POP MUSIC,ROCK MUSIC, ROCK & ROLLS ALL STEMS FROM JAZZ, RAP, R&B AND YES EVEN GOSPEL!

SO NO MATTER WHAT SHE SINGS SHE WILL BE SINGING BLACK MUSIC.

BTW THE TYPE OF MUSIC SHE SINGS WASN’T EVEN SOMETHING I ADDRESSED.

The shackles were unlocked a long time ago, but some black people just refuse to take them off…

LOOKS LIKE THE SHACKLES ARE STILL LOCKED ON YOU BECAUSE YOU HAVEN’T EVEN BEGUN TO GRASPED THE INFLUENCE YOUR PEOPLE HAVE NOT ONLY MADE ON AMERICA BUT THE WORLD.

SO TAKE A LOOK IN THE MIRROR FIRST BEFORE YOU SPOUT OFF AT THE HIP!

——————————————————————————–

108.

Yosay

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Also to address the “Black State of Mind” issue. The terms means to 1. Have some understanding of Black World History. 2. To be PROUD of that history. 3. To be in solidarity with other Black people.
3. And to want to see if progress.

109.

Yosay

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Real Talk said:
——————————————————————————–

Also, what the FUCK is a black state of mind??^^^…..havin a cheap as weave in ur head?….no wait, it must be havin 5 kids before the age of 20…..puh-fuckin-lease….it is sad that such words are even spoken.

It’s said that someone who reference a Black State of Mind to such negative things such as: “having a cheap Weave” Or having “5 Kinds before age of 20.”

Sounds, like you are buying into your own stereotype. Now that’s sad!

Like someone said^^, if halle and alicia are considered black, then why not Mariah??

My Question is why can’t all of the above be considered WHITE? Since they all have White Mother’s.

110.

Siobhan

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Amber - no one is teaching those children to be grey. They were just taught to be proud of both of their racial heritages. Why is that if your half black then you can’t claim the white side, according to you and some others on this site? I read that story and thought those were some seriously well adjusted children.

First and foremost, I am a woman. Secondly, I am a biracial woman. I don’t claim either side soley and why should I? Who made up the rules that I have to claim one or the other? Or according to some of the logic on this site just the black side? I proudly represent both sides and no one can change that.

111.

Yosay

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Siobhan said:
——————————————————————————–

Amber - no one is teaching those children to be grey. They were just taught to be proud of both of their racial heritages. Why is that if your half black then you can’t claim the white side, according to you and some others on this site? I read that story and thought those were some seriously well adjusted children.

First and foremost, I am a woman. Secondly, I am a biracial woman. I don’t claim either side soley and why should I? Who made up the rules that I have to claim one or the other? Or according to some of the logic on this site just the black side? I proudly represent both sides and no one can change that.
——

Very well put!

112.

dru d.

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I think Sandra B. was full of disrespect. if she wants to rant and boast like that she needs her own damn show, you don’t come start drama on someone else’s show, I just thought she was disrespectful. real snappy against the panel, showing them no respect - no matter how biased they can be to their own views.

what does it matter if she claims to be this or that. the fact she doesn’t have curly hair, doesn’t mean she wants to be something else. it’s just hair, you can do whatever you want to, people change up their looks all the time, so do we attribute this to wanting a race change? NO! I know people get perms all the times and die their hair and that does not consitute them as “playing” roles. I love the new look, old look and whats to become. all this started off was a joke, FUNNY! ha - people laughed and moved on. sandra is just trying to get back into the game, she was gone for along time (like mariah)

113.

Siobhan

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

And let me add just one more thing: if you’re born to a black parent and a white parent and you choose to identify more with the black side no one judges you. However, if a child is born to a black parent and a white parent and chooses to identify with just the white side or claims both sides why are people so quick to condemn them or the parents?

What makes the former so much more acceptable than the latter?

114.

armanei_718

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Listen, this Sandra chick might have a point but we sure dont need her white ass saying it!! We all know that Mariah cashes in on us black folk when she need some record sales. I think Star was just speaking out for Mariah because she realized quick that Sandra was just trying to tell another “nigger” joke to get some laughs from all them crackers that make up the majority of the audience. Because whether Mariah wants to accept it or not, she IS half black and no matter how much bleach she puts in her hair, or how much money she makes she STILL gonna be black. Thats how white america feels and thats why Sandra felt so comfortable saying a “joke” like that in front of a black woman in the year 2006. No respect…She knew Star would say some thing, she just wanted to get a rise out of her. Im glad Star told her that she was “too cute to go off on her!” (Even though that might not be entirely true, lol)

115.

pittbboi

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

YOSAY

Here we go…I apologize to everyone in advance for how long this post is going to be…

Let’s break this down…

“SOUNDS LIKE YOU NEED TO READ A FEW HISTORY BOOKS AND BECOME AWARE OF THE WORLD YOU LIVE IN. AMERICAN CULTURE IS BLACK CULTURE. EVERYTHING FROM MUSIC TO FASHION, TO SLANG LANGUAGE (THAT EVEN WHITES AND OTHER RACES USE IN THIS COUNTRY) TO FOOD IS ALL BLACK CULTURE. WHEN BLACKS WERE BROUGHT TO THIS COUNTRY WE WERE STRIPPED OF OUR NAMES OUR LANGUAGE AND SOME OF OUR AFRICAN CULTURE BUT SOME OF THE CULTURE WAS RETAINED AND STILL LIVES ON IN OUR MUSIC AND AND DANCE WHICH HAS BEEN CO-OPED AND EXPLOITED.
BTW, ALL AFRICANS THAT WERE KIDNAPPED WERE STRIPPED OF SOME OF THEIR NAMES, LANGUAGE AND CULTURE BUT WERE CREATIVE ENOUGH TO CREATE NEW CULTURES BASED ON THEIR AFRICAN CULTURE…ETC BRAZIL, THE CARIBBEAN AND THE FUJI ISLANDS!

If this isn’t some mess…

Where in my post did I say that African Americans did not contribute to the melting pot that is America’s cultural fabric? Read my post again and get your facts straight. When I asked the question “what is black culture?” I wasn’t denying these things. Rather, I was asking you to acknowledge them. I will not go as far as to say that American Culture IS “black culture,” because American culture is comprised of every group of people that found their way (forcefully or not) to this country. I will say, however, that black culture is something that has been emulated by other races. why? Because it can be. It doesn’t take much to eat a piece of fried chicken or listen to rap music, but how easy it to emulate Asian American culture? Native American culture? African’s had the specifics of their culture taken from them when they came here. Sure, we can listen to “black” music, use “black” slang and eat soul food. But how many of us can trace our roots back to the original African tribes that we were bartered and taken from? Not too many. People tend to forget that Africa is a CONTINENT, composed of many different countries which are composed of many different tribes that contain many different cultures. It was this complexity that was lost when we were brought here. All we have is this petty little thing we call “African”. THAT’s what I was referring to when I said black people had their culture stripped. And, I don’t know about you, but I would rather live my life in this country and be apart of its culture as a whole.

I’m not going to talk about Brazil, the Caribbean or Fuji because those are different places and the black experience there is completely different.

“VERY INGORNANT STATMENT. SEE THE ABOVE RESPONSE. YOU ARE WHAT YOU ACCUSE ME OF BEING.”

That’s not good enough. Again, examine the cultures of people who willingly came here or were already here. You will find that their cultures (beliefs and traditions) are a lot more extensive and blatant than ours. Again, it’s not something to be proud of, but it’s the truth, and all we can do is move on from that and continue to make our mark on society, not shun people because they don’t constrict to our stringent and inaccurate conception of what it means to be black. If you’re black, you’re black. That’s really all that should matter.

“THERE ARE ALOT OF PEOPLE WITH BLACK BLOOD WHO ARE TECHINICALLY BLACK YES! LATINOS, JEWS, SICILIANS, “BLACK IRISH”, BUT THEY DON’T ACKNOWLEGDE. THAT ACKNOWLEDGING PART IS VERY IMPORTANT. LOL!”

Erm…are you trying to say that Mariah doesn’t admit her heritage? And as for the other groups you mentioned…I understand what you were saying, but it doesn’t apply, because most of those groups have to go be countless generations to find the “black” in them. Mariah, on the other hand, has a parent who is half black.

“WHAT YOU FAIL TO UNDERSTAND THAT EVEN THE ORIGINS OF POP MUSIC,ROCK MUSIC, ROCK & ROLLS ALL STEMS FROM JAZZ, RAP, R&B AND YES EVEN GOSPEL!
SO NO MATTER WHAT SHE SINGS SHE WILL BE SINGING BLACK MUSIC.
BTW THE TYPE OF MUSIC SHE SINGS WASN’T EVEN SOMETHING I ADDRESSED.

Correction: I don’t ‘fail’ to understand anything. You’re bringing up things that are immaterial and not even being debated. The origins of rock and pop music are not being disputed. Did they originate from African traditions? Sure. Again, nobody ever said they didn’t. However, there’s no denying that these genres of music are partially classified by the groups of people that largely represent them (i.e. blacks with rap, whites with rock). It’s a system that probably causes more harm than good, but that’s the way it is at the time I write this. So, in other words: what’s your point?

“LOOKS LIKE THE SHACKLES ARE STILL LOCKED ON YOU BECAUSE YOU HAVEN’T EVEN BEGUN TO GRASPED THE INFLUENCE YOUR PEOPLE HAVE NOT ONLY MADE ON AMERICA BUT THE WORLD.
SO TAKE A LOOK IN THE MIRROR FIRST BEFORE YOU SPOUT OFF AT THE HIP!

Shackles are the last thing I’d have on. I am not denying our race. Black people have survived a world that has largely been against them until very recently. But we did not survive unscathed. All this talk about “black culture” is only beating around the bush of the real argument—that some people believe that you can’t just be black or bi-racial to be black. That, somehow, you have to be black and follow certain beliefs. People, that just cheapens us.

“Also to address the “Black State of Mind” issue. The terms means to 1. Have some understanding of Black World History. 2. To be PROUD of that history. 3. To be in solidarity with other Black people.
3. And to want to see if progress.”

As for 1 and 2: how can you accuse Mariah of this, when more than half the black people in the US don’t have an understanding of the history of our people? And yet you know what? They’re still black. It would be great if everyone had a thorough understanding of their history, but our ethnicities shouldn’t be and aren’t dependent on this. It’s not just a problem facing black people, either. EVERYONE needs to know more about history in an effort to ensure that it doesn’t get repeated. As for 3….that just makes no sense. We may all be black, but we all have different opinions and beliefs. It’s impossible to stand in solidarity on everything.

Here’s an article from –1991—where Mariah address a man who called her “another white girl trying to sing black.” I don’t think anybody says it better than she does.
http://www.findarticles.c...077/is_n5_v46/ai_10405332

116.

tianni

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I agree with SANDRA to an extent.

When Mariah first came onto the scene (single: Vision of Love)Everyone knew her more or less as the WHITE GIRL with the PIPES okay…her vocal range back then was BANANAS!

By the time she ended up DIVORCED from whats his name TOMMY MATOLA (sure it is mispelled–The rich white dude that is “HEAVY” in the RECORD BIZ–they married, he changed her entire image, hair became BLONDE/CLOTHING SEXIER-starting rocking the STILETTO heels/got her BREASTS done/put a PHAT ROCK on her finger/ & she got to live in his enormous mansion I think the world got to see it in her “HONEY” video) She was still a white lady–HONEY was produced by JD as well.

She started seeing that making music with the RAPPERS & BIG HIP HOP NAMES sold her more albums. Next thing you know she DIVORCED TOMMY…& was coming forth on OPRAH about her FATHER being half AFRICAN AMERICAN & Portuguise. She was saying it in magazine articles,interviews..she let the WORLD know she was PART BLACK. But only “AFTER” she started making calaborations with the RAP stars & HIP HOP producers & after DIVORCING Tommy.

So Sandra Bernhard- isn’t TOO FAR off from the TRUTH about Mariah Carey.

& STAR JONES….PLEASE GIRL!…PLEASE–(she is such a H.A.M. in every since of the word).

117.

Original Sindee

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I don’t know about y’all, but Mariah looks a lot more black to me now than when she first came out, even with the blond hair. I know a girl who saw Mariah in concert or signing autographs or something and she said that in person, Mariah doesn’t look as white as in the media. She just looks like a light skinned black person…

118.

Real Talk

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Yosay said:
——————————————————————————–

Also to address the “Black State of Mind” issue. The terms means to 1. Have some understanding of Black World History. 2. To be PROUD of that history. 3. To be in solidarity with other Black people.
3. And to want to see if progress.
******************************************************

If having a black state of mind is necessary to be black, and that is your definition of the black state of mind, then the vast majority of African Americans aren’t black….What? You think Tyrone and Shaniqua know a thing or give a shit about their history (other than slavery of course)??….no, they are too busy having children they cannot afford to take care of.

Real Talk.

119.

dg1234

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Sandra needs to shut her ugly, dyke ass up. She was very rude and disrespectful someone should have put a leash on that dog and lead her off the stage. She is the type of white person who thinks she can say anything to anybody and it’s ok…when she said to Star you can understand about the lips…come on!!! That bitch was outta line. Fuck her..her rudeness and nasty ass attitude make her opinion(which on some things may be valid) lost!! All you see is a rude, bitch who needs a cork stuck in that big ass gap in her mouth so she can shet the fuck up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

120.

Big L

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

mariah is black, if you take in to consideration the one drop rule. mariah is alright with me she can sing, and has always delivered beautiful songs from the jump. Mariah struggles enough with her own identity, it’s so apparent that she has issues. I am so glad that she got herself together enough to deliver another hot album just for all you haters who are obviously hoping for her demise.

She has absolutely nothing to gain by saying her father is black and he wasn’t apart of her life. Many white artists collaborate with black producers etc. and make hit songs, they have been doing this forever, so she doesn’t need to create a story about her nationality to jump on the ole bandwagon.

That white/black (whatever) bit** is bad, you can’t even hate on her. Her skills are unquestionable. When you are that good, color doesn’t matter-she obviously appeals to the masses-check those record sales!!!!!!

Co-sign!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

121.

aziajs

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I like Sandra Bernhard. I always have. She keeps it real. What she said is what we all have been saying for years. Star and Elizabeth Hasslebeck are jokes.

122.

YESPLEASE

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

pittboi, u speak the truth.

tianni, Honey was produced by Diddy, Stevie J, and Mariah herself.

and to all who do not know, Mariah’s father is 75% black, 25% latino.

Original Sindee, i agree with you. for some reason she looks more white with darker her….plus, if u ever actually paid attention to Mariah’s facial bone structure and her nose, i think it would be obvious that she isn’t all white.

123.

Amber

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Siobhan,I”m not going there with you.
You’re black. I don’t care if you call yourself the middle or not. If the police pull you over for DWB, are they only going to half whoop your ass??? A biracial woman???? What the hell is that?? A new life form?? American blacks have been mixed with white blood for years and you are nothing new or special. To answer your question though, to be mixed and identify with the white side totally is ultimate craziness. First of all because of black’s history with whites. Second, because you are a minority. You can never be white. I don’t care how bad I can tell you want to be that.

Oh and by the way, Sandra and Star are both right. Sandra is right because in the beginning of her career, Mariah called herself everything in the world except black. After leaving Tommy, she did surround herself with rappers. Star is right in the sense that Mariah does now know she’s black. She may have always known it and the record company just created this image for her.

124.

Kandee

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

YESPLEASE, Mariah isn’t 25% Latino. Latino isn’t a race, its a culture. Her father was a black man who’s family was Venezuelan. People of African descent. Stop with the cookie mixture please. She’s black!
Also, its obvious that M.C. has had plastic surgery. Go back and look at her circa 1990. Looks like a totally different woman.

125.

I'mSmarter

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

ATTENTION: Mariah’s collabos with rappers has NOT helped her sales….she sold more before the collabos.

I understand hip hop is very popular but you have to understand that the best-selling artists are WHITE.

If Mariah really wanted to sell, trust me, i am pretty sure she’s been in the industry to kno exactly who to collabo with…..why do people find it hard to believe that this woman truly loves hip hop….it’s not that deep.

126.

TNT

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Amber, why so harsh??…lmao

127.

YESPLEASE

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Kandee, Latino IS some type of race….what are they, white?…come one….however, i know what u’re sayin about mariah lookin different…..it’s called age and dramatic weight gain.

Plus, i agree….Mariah IS Black….people are jus gonna have to deal with it.

128.

concretestone

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

Sandra’s pretty on point. I think some on here are in denial

As for Elizabeth..*sigh* I really cannot stand this woman. She’s a dribbling idiot. Not to mention a sanctimonious, self-righteous b*tch

129.

shimmy shimmy ya

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I don’t care if Mariah Carey is black or white, the trick is awkward-looking…

130.

jchill

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

That video is too funny. I think Sandra needs some penis to calm her crazy ass down.

131.

GG Boo

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

@ #86 huh? - this is not being said in a fecetious manner at all, but if you read my entire post, you will see that the very point you make about not letting race define the music you listen to is EXACTLY what I just said. Believe you me, I can go down the list of people I like (Hall & Oates, Lionel Richie, Kenny Rogers, Ginuine, R. Kelly, etc…) and the mix of people you will see is just as vast as yours. Here is the connection — I actually was applauding the fact that you proved that very point, that doing (or in this case listening to) whay some may consider “typically black” is stupid because we are all so different, hence, Mariah Carey not “acting black” was a silly thing for someone to have said.
P.S. I had Nelly Furtado’s CD, too…

132.

Megan

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

130.

My thoughts exactly. A penis deprived chick is a confused chick.

133.

DaReal

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

^^LMAO!!!^^

134.

LadyMahogany

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I think she has a tendency to not claim her heritage, I’m not saying go around saying I’m black I’m black!But
I remember someone telling me that Mariah sais she was Mexican or something and now she just calls herself biracial,but she was black when it came time to honor African American’s at the Legends Ball,pick one dmanit.

I personally don’t give a damn what she is her ass could be blue for all I care as long as I don’t have to hear the songs Don’t Forget About Us and We Belong Together for a long long time if ever.

135.

FanOfMusic

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

#125 U are on Point!!!

When Mariah started to do more urban music and started working with rappers her sales DECLINED. Most white people didnt wanna hear that. She didnt care cause she started doing the music she wanted to do. Alcica keys and Halle dont get this backlash because they look like light-skinned black women. Alot of sistas have talked bad about Mariah for whatever reason. Women are always knockin the next woman. SMH

136.

Missthang

Monday, June 19, 2006 /

I DON’T LIKE HER BECOS SHE HAS THAT GUUD HAIR

137.

wonderful8

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

It’s because Mariah goes back and forth too much. First she’s White, then she’s Black…confusing. Just like J-Lo. Pick a color/heritage and stop flip-flopping at your convenience! Mariah does nothing to promote her ‘blackness’ except lap dance for rappers when she think she needs street fame. Please stop spending so much time on Mariah, she is not worth it. Keep it moving…

138.

NAT

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

well sandra is a comedian, and her job is to make jokes, and this one went bad. if you knew her past, she was raised with a white mother in a white environment, so how black could she be ?

139.

TS

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

wonderful8:
“It’s because Mariah goes back and forth too much. First she’s White, then she’s Black”

WHEN HAS MARIAH SAID SHE’S WHITE….WHAT THE FUCK….IF U DONT LIKE HER THAT’S FINE…BUT U DONT HAVE TO LIE TO MAKE YOUR POINT…AND THE SIMPLY FACT THAT SHE DIDNT COLLOBORATE WITH RAPPERS OUT THE GATE DOESNT MAKE HER WHITE….GGODNESS GRACIOUS….BLACK PEOPLE, YOU ARE SMARTER THAN THIS!

140.

Megan

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

Wasn’t Mariah’s first single soulful? Hell she was “blacker” than Whitney was when she first came out.

141.

Missthang

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

I DON’T LIKE MARIAH BECOS SHE GOT THAT LIGHT SKIN

SHE’S ONE HIGH YELLA BITCH

YUP…I DON SAID IT..WHATCHU GONNA DO?

142.

grillz

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

Missthang….u r the hood personified….have a seat.

143.

Tianna

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

Wow…Star said she is too cute to go off on Sandra…

*crickets*

144.

Tianna

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

And where was the catfight? It wasn’t even that serious to me lol…

145.

ShoNuff

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

lol^^

146.

Megan

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

142. grillz

Don’t let stuff like that fool you.

147.

UdontKno

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

Mariah is WHITE. Look at Nicole Richie that has a slight tan and then look at Mariah. She is a WHITE woman that “CLAIMS” She is mixed if you go back to all of her old interviews then you will read that she NEVER said she was mixed with black!

148.

sophia

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

how does one “act” black, just curious!

149.

ShoNuff

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

UDontKNo….GET A CLUE….Mariah has talked about being black on many occasions dating back to the very beginning of her career

150.

NotDrunkAssLauraBush

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

Mariah is Fake and do try to act black when she needs to sell albums to make money. Laura Bush is heavily medicated, high on Cocaine and also a fucking drunk. Everytime I see that dumb ass Bitch Laura Bush my nerve snap because she talks so annoying and country. She is a dumb ass drunk and will probably run over somebody again and kill them like she did when she was younger. Elizbeth is kissing ass because she wants to be something else than the white trailor trash she is, look how the slut dress, cheap slut, she probably wants to lick Laura Bush pussy while Laura pop pills and gets drunk.

151.

natalia

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

Tianna said:
——————————————————————————–

Wow…Star said she is too cute to go off on Sandra…

*crickets*

I was thinking the same thing. *cringes*

Sandra’s right though, Mariah did exploit her “black” side.

152.

lihalee

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

I am not a great fan of Mariah but I don’t understand why black Americans get so worked up over her. I am black but not American (never lived or visited America) so I don’t really get the statement she doesn’t “act black” How does one “act black”?

153.

bored@work

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

Sandra is fuuny as hell!!!

Star Jones looks like Meathead from Meatballs II.

154.

algie

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

ignorance is bliss

155.

FoReal

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

^^ditto^^

156.

Amber

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

Who’s being harsh??? Not I. Truth is what its called Dear.

Lihalee (very pretty name by the way), you are right, there is no one way to “act black”. What I think people really mean is that as black people we usually have a certain swagger and cool style. When another black person is missing that coolness, we tend to accuse one another of “acting white” or not being down. It really makes no sense because its all about the environment you grew up in. It doesn’t make you any less black though.

157.

Kstar

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

Mariah knows that R&b sels better then pop..
Star act like she know MARIAH or something!
and
FISHLIPS !!!! LOL, that was funny as HEEEEEEEEEEEEEEELLL !

158.

Glue

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

^u dont have to know a person to know they are mixed…..get a brain

and btw, pop generally sells better than rnb.

159.

Nanz

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

In response to one of the comments above, since when is Latino a race? Only in America is it claimed to be thus. It is an ETHNICITY. Huuuuge difference. You have white Latinos, black Latinos, and every damn thing in between. Trust, I know this for a FACT, when you’re in certain places in South America, they won’t just call themselves Latino. They’re white, black, “other” etc. etc. Can someone explain this whole Latino as a “race” thing to me?

160.

lea

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

#79 git yo numbers right i didnt mention the lords name so u stop hatn aight #75

161.

Slovely

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

This white trash need to go back to the trailor park.

162.

Gin

Tuesday, June 20, 2006 /

Sandra is what’s hot in the streets.

163.

Amani

Wednesday, June 21, 2006 /

LMAO 143-Tianna

Wow…Star said she is too cute to go off on Sandra…

*crickets*

164.

MegansUgly

Wednesday, June 21, 2006 /

Yo Megan I thought You was an Ugly dude at first than you started talking about dick I thought you was a gay dude . Now I see you are just one Ugly Ass Bitch . You must be blind wearing them sunglasses because you wouldn’y put out a pic like that for us to see. Damn You FUCKING UGLY . I feel sorry for the fool who fucks you . wait its probably just a dildo because no man would touch you I sure wouldn’t

165.

MegansUgly

Wednesday, June 21, 2006 /

megan you look like a alien with shades on

166.

LaMorenaEnKobe

Wednesday, June 21, 2006 /

Sandra Bernhart has NO authority to be talking about blackness and defining who is allegedly exploiting their blackness or not. Fuck her.

Mariah is of mixed heritage. Latino is NOT a race. Latinos are of mixed heritage, of african, european, and native american descent. Depending on the country, and region, their might be more of a particular race. Mariah’s dad was a BLACK man with roots from a spanish speaking country. Her mom is white. Look at pics of Mariah’s father and her nephew and her brother and sister and tell me she doesn’t have black in her.

Stop hatin’ on Mariah. She makes great music and is doing the damn thing. Fuck Sandra. Bitch needs to get her grill fixed before she starts talking shit about other people.

167.

Slovely

Wednesday, June 21, 2006 /

MegansUgly said:
——————————————————————————–

Yo Megan I thought You was an Ugly dude at first than you started talking about dick I thought you was a gay dude . Now I see you are just one Ugly Ass Bitch . You must be blind wearing them sunglasses because you wouldn’y put out a pic like that for us to see. Damn You FUCKING UGLY . I feel sorry for the fool who fucks you . wait its probably just a dildo because no man would touch you I sure wouldn’t
^^^^^^^^

DAAAAAAAAYYYYYYUUUUMMMMMM!!!! She playin herself, Someone call a therapist! Nah yall need to chill it aint that serious lol.

168.

DUKE

Wednesday, June 21, 2006 /

I REALLY DON’T THINK MARIAH IS PART BLACK OR WHATEVER SHE CLAIMS. I’VE SEEN A PICTURE OF HER AND HER ALLEDGED FATHER POSING TOGETHER WHEN HE WAS SICK AND IT’S NO DOUBT THAT HE’S BLACK OR BLACK/MIXED. I THINK MARIAH HAS BEEN USING THIS AS A CREDIBILITY STEP TO GAIN ACCEPTANCE IN THE HIP-HOP WORLD. SHE’S SO FAKE. WHICH A CHARACTERISTIC THAT MOST WHITE GIRLS TEND TO HAVE. I THINK THE GUY SHE CLAIMS IS HER FATHER WAS NOTHING MORE THAN HER MOTHER’S BEST FRIEND. I DON’T BLAME SANDRA FOR MAKING THOSE COMMENTS.

169.

SAY WHAT :0

Thursday, June 22, 2006 /

@43: finally,now i found someone i can agree wit. I mean there was just so many opinions that i agreed to that i just couldn’t find one number to give their props. and u sortof round all of them up together and made it into one simple opinion.

I too think she shouldn’t choose what side she should be on. Some of u are just referring to Mariah as just a black and white woman and forgetting all about her hispanic side.(referring to my mixed friends) If u are bi-racial it really does not matter what side u pick u’re still and always going to be mixed. And i don’t care if Mariah claims her white side because she wasn’t raised by a black influence or she only use it around other black folk, i will still support my half fellow sista.

170.

Glue

Thursday, June 22, 2006 /

LATINO/HISPANICS ARE A RACE OF THEIR OWN….yes, there are white and black people of spanish descent….but there are those other people who arent black nor white…so what race are they??…..exactly.

171.

cah_03

Thursday, June 22, 2006 /

White folks putting freedom of speech into good use these days, yet they be the ones getting their asses kicked at the end.

We all know that Mariah has a mixed heritage. Why repeat it over & over again?

172.

warrior princess

Thursday, June 22, 2006 /

LATINO/HISPANICS ARE A RACE OF THEIR OWN….yes, there are white and black people of spanish descent….but there are those other people who arent black nor white…so what race are they??…..exactly.

They’re just mixed Latinos? lol Stop trying to sound intelligent and read this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afro-Latin_American

It will do you all some good =)

173.

LE-LE

Thursday, June 22, 2006 /

MARIAH IS WHITE AND THAT’S IT. SHE HAS NEVER OPENLY DATED ANY BLACK GUY THAT I CAN THINK OF. SHE’LL DO A LITTLE HIP-HOP WITH US BUT THAT IS AS FAR AS IT GOES. WHEN JENNFIER LOPEZ WAS HOT AND MARIAH WAS IN A SLUMP, SHE REPORTEDLY WANTED TO CHANGE HER LAST NAME TO HER SO-CALLED FATHER’S BIRTH NAME. WHICH WAS NUNEZ. MARIAH NUNEZ. SHE’LL DO ANYTHING TO FIT IN FOR THE MOMENT.

174.

Glue

Friday, June 23, 2006 /

warrior princess….i’m not tryna sound smart…i AM smart. lol….asshole

LE-LE….u sound STUPID…and Mariah NEVER wanted to change er last name….btw, Nunes is her dad’s mom’s maiden last name….so pls get ur facts straight b4 u u say anythin….and she isn’t white…when u have a black parent, that is technically impossible…u can die now

175.

LE-LE

Friday, June 23, 2006 /

GLUE,YOU MIGHT BE USING TOO MUCH OF THAT IN YOUR WEAVE. MARIAH IS A WHITE GIRL AND THAT’S THE END OF IT. SHE’S WHITE. HELL, HER SISTER IS THE ONE THAT LOOKS LIKE SHE GOT SOME BLACK IN HER. BUT MARIAH IS PURE WHITE. DEAL WITH IT. U CAN GO TO HELL AND DIE NOW !

176.

Glue

Friday, June 23, 2006 /

” U CAN GO TO HELL AND DIE NOW !”….how original

i can see that u’re intent on beliveing somethin that is not true…that’s ur prerogative…i must say i think it is very stupid of u to say she is white simply because of how she looks…anyways whatever

oh btw sweetie, i dont wear weaves.

177.

jay

Saturday, July 22, 2006 /

mariah is part black ok i think this whole thing

about is just claiming where her talent comes

from “she got it from the black people”, ’she got it

from the white people” it dont matter that girl got

the voice of an angel* now if she sound like paris

hilton or someone ya’ll would’nt be have this

conversation…. NO MATTER WHAT YA’LL SAY SHE WILL

ALWAYS BE PART BLACK AND PART WHITE…. done…

178.

DDRE

Saturday, December 30, 2006 /

when someone is mixed, how come they only go with JUST the black side? are they scared of being humiliated? it would cause so much controversy if someone just talked about them being white. just picture mariah carey talking about being a white woman.