I think its time that I contribute to the ‘Who Rock’d It Better’ posts being the big fashion junkie I am. I remember numerous times I’ve caught celebs rocking the same outfit.
Here’s one in particular that I remember, its an oldie but goodie. Once again Beyonce is first up wearing this gorgeous Valentino gown to the 2004 BET Awards. The following year, top model Eva Pigford wore the same dress to the 2005 Soul Train Music Awards. Who do you think rock’d it better?
I suggest Beyonce asks her Mom to make her dresses more often because girlfriend just can’t stay away from these posts lol.


of course it beyonce she rocks it the best and i love that women sooooooooo much so u already know what it is Beyonce if u read dis PLZ cal;l me 270 564 3412
Beyonce definatley rocked the hell out of this dress! I really can’t say too much about Eva at this point! She looks so bad next to Beyonce in that dress! But I do love Eva! I aint hatin on her I just think Beyonce looks a hell of alot better in the dress!
BEYONCE LOOKS BETTER IN IT CUZ SHE HAS A CURVY SHAPE.
I THINK THEY REPRESENT AFRICAN AMERICAN WOMEN GREAT IN THAT DRESS. THEY ARE BOTH VERY BEAUTIFUL. BEY HER WAY AND EVA HER WAY. AS LONG AS THEY KEEP IT REAL. BOTH OF THEM LOOK VERY CLASSY.
Go head beyonce you lookin real nice my role modle!!
I SAY EVA, A TIGHT DRESS TO SHOW UR CURVES DOESNT ALWAYS WORK ON EVERY DRESS.
WHAT!! no competittion im one to sya eva is pretty as hell, and usually i odnt even liek beyonce BUT SHE ROCKED THIS DRESS HARD!!!!! anyone who says eva looks better is just hatin on beyonce, she looks way better in the dress NO DOUBT! she got BODY! and EVA DONT!
WHAT ARE PEOPLE THINKING IM CONFUSED BEYONCE SO WON THIS ONE HOW CAN NO BODY LOOK BETTER THAN BODY! CURVES ARE ALL THE WAY MUCH BETTER FOR ANY DRESS
THE COLORS OF THE DRESS ARE DIFFERENT ANYWAY BUT BE STILL WINS THAT ONE EVA LOOKS TO OVER DONE IN THE MAKEUP DEPARTMENT. BE LOOKS MORE NATURAL
Beyonce won. They both look great, but the dress looks to big for Eva.
i thought the dress fit well but differently on both eva and b except i love beyonce a lot more than i care about eva she has a certain sense of elegance in it she’s got that “it”
IT’S A TIE THEY BOTH LOOK BEAUTIFUL WEARING THAT DRESS
Bwyonce looks much better in this Dress Hands down,
Eva is too skinny and does nothing for this Dress.
This is a very elegant dress. i think Eva very well pulled this off much better because she is not bursting out of the dress. It doesnt look like the dress is about to rip into a million peices. Sometimes big butts kind of takes the elegantness away from certain styles of clothing. enough said. Who agrees!
I think both of dem rocked it wit respect and wit what they got, but i gotta give it 2 Eva, bcuz she don’t have da same curve as Beyonce, but she ‘s on da same level as Beyonce in dat dress.
they both was hittin, but I gotta give it to B. She fills the shit better. I just wish they made it as long as Eva’s.
although beyonce fills up the gown more n has more curves to make it look very sexy n feminine, Eva is shining. She would have been noticed first had they worn it on the same day at the same place because her skin is glowing, her eyes r radiant and she is just exotic looking in this dress. a godess..
beyonce beyonce!
I would have to say Eva. Because her golden skiin tone makes the dress stand out. I agree that both of these women are equally beautiful but to me the dress just looks better on Eva. Absolutely stunning!!!
BEYONCE TAKES THE CROWN NO QUESTIONS ASKED
BEYONCES COMPLETES THE DRESS WITH HER CURVES
EVA DOESN’T REALLY HAVE THE BODY FOR THE DRESS
BEYONCE HAS THE PERFECT BODY AND CAN ROCK ANY DRESS
QUEEN B WINS THE TITLE
i think that beyonce wore it better than eva
i think that beyonce wore it better than eva
WOW dey both look beautiful but I think I wood hav 2 chose Beyonce sens shez my favorite & n e outfit lookz good on her n dos hipz but dey. Both r workn tha hell outta tha dress
B’s body, Eva’s skin tone and smile…I’m confused…they are both smashing.
Ugh, Beyonce did the dress better than the rat
I think beyonce wins this one and i dont agree with that one girl who said this dress was made for people without curves because beyonce she looked beautiful with her hips and thighs in my opion eva does not have curves and that dress looks dull on her.
I think Bey looks good and stakalisious in the dress. Bey got one of the BADDEST shapes I eva seen.
YALL ALREADY NO BEYONCE KNOWLES ROCKED DAT DRESS AND QUIT HATIN OFF OF HER EVA ASS 2 SKINNY FOR DAT DRESS SHE LOOK ASHAME
Where can you buy this dress. I really want it!