GAB

Garcelle but I love kellys shoes

WELL I DONT KNOW THEY BOTH LOOK GREAT IN IT

I think Garcelle Beauvais-Nilon Rocked it better…she fills it out nicely

i think Kelly is absolutely gorgeous. she has come a long way and i am very proud of her and her achievements!

Gab! She is chilling in that! I swear everytime I see Kelly it looks like her breath is kicking or she has body odor! I like her but God help her, I don’t know what it is lol !

NO I’LL GO WITH GARCELLE,,,BUT I AGREE#2 I LOVE KELLYS SHOES..

I’m not to sure which ne wore it best there is something about the shoes I’m not to thrilled with on both the ladies.

But I think I like Kelly the best.

Kelly.

Where in the hell do the stars shop. Shouldn’t the designer, let their stylist know that somebody has already purchased that “same” item b4 the other star stylist buys it?

Kelly looks damn good. Garcelle looks like she just came in from a swim.

Kelly looks simple in that dress but Garcelle make the same dress look elegant.

OK everyone Her name is Garcelle not Gabriel

i think that Garcelle rock it best, she fills it out better

kelly hands down!

I think Kelly.

LOL@Kitten

Garcelle

What are you people looking at…Gar does not look good in that dress, she looks a mess! The dress almost looks to small for her, her hips are poking out under the dress & damn shoes do not go with that dress - ARE YOU KIDDIN ME!

A dress like that has to flow & Kelly does that hands down. She looks toned, her make-up is nice, not to keen on the hair,she should have worn it pulled away from her face but the shoes are great! Kelly is my girl & she is doing it!

Kelly’s shoes are so ewwww….Garcelle’s shoes look way better

who cares if celebrities rocking the same dress or shirt is it that serious I know you walked down the shirt and seen someone wearing something you had it happens…

I have ti go with Garcelle, but Kelly looks nice as well.

MY VOTE GOES TO GAB…LOOKING ALL HOT AND TEMPTING!!

Kelly.

Garcelle sure do rock a lot of the same stuff other celbs do. Is she borrowing it or what?

And before anybody says something ignorant I know she rocked it first. It was a JOKE! I was clowning because we just saw her in another recent post about this.

KELLY
GARCIELLE(OR WHATEVER HER NAME IS)KNOWS SHE’S WRONG!THE HAIR, GOD AWFUL ACCESSORIES, AND TACKY SHOES!YOU WRONG GARCIELLE, JUST PLAIN WRONG!!!!!!!!!!!!

Is it me or is everyone shopping out of Garcelle’s closet these days?

WHO ARE THESE CHICKS?…..LOL J/K. I’MA GO WITH KELLY SHE SEXY AS FUCK…

Gab look a little “grandmaish” ( I know that not a word - but u feel me!) it’s just not a good look on her. Kelly looks cute in the dress…but someone please tell me WHY GAB is ALWAYS on CL edition of who rocked it better??? I know these type of things happen in hollywood, but damn she is ALWAYS doing this (and I know she wore it first this time ,but still) Not being mean but she is going to have to expand her horizons in the wardrobe dept foreal, who ever is picking out her clothes aren’t looking too far

GABBY GAB GOT THAT BOO.

excuse me “Garcelle” not Gab

IM SORRY I MEANT GARCELLE. DAMN I ALWAYS GET MIXED UP WITH HER AND GABRIELLE UNION.

i gotta go with garcelle and i also think her shoes look better than kelly’s

The color of the dress if different. If Kelly had on the Kelly of Garcelle’s it would look better and vice versa. They both look nice. Garcelle’s face looks odd though.

Garcelle

I think Kelly looks better.

Garcelle

Garcelle HANDS DOWN!!! If Kelly had a little more up top and a better hair do she would have easily pulled this off. But Garcelle feels out the dress nicely and I love her necklace. I love me some Kelly but I had to be real Garcelle does the dress justice.

Kelly…she looks like that dress was made for her!!!

it is NOT that flattering on either lady, but they both look equally chic in it

i agree wit number 26 . Kelly rocked it WAYY better

Garcelle looks a little thick in the dress. Kelly worked it!

Garcelle. She looks a bit swollen but I don’t like Kelly’s hair.

Kelly, it matches her skin tone better. Garcelle looking a lil weird in the face and arms.

kelly rocked it better hands down. But it looks like the dresses are two different colors? Kelly’s dress compliments her compexion better.

Who knew ol’ garcelle had a tat on her ankle.

Tryna be all riské lol

kelly looks fresh and clean therefore she wins

Kellie.

Gab look a little “grandmaish” ( I know that not a word - but u feel me!) it’s just not a good look on her. Kelly looks cute in the dress…but someone please tell me WHY GAB is ALWAYS on CL edition of who rocked it better??? I know these type of things happen in hollywood, but damn she is ALWAYS doing this (and I know she wore it first this time ,but still) Not being mean but she is going to have to expand her horizons in the wardrobe dept foreal, who ever is picking out her clothes aren’t looking too far

^^^^^

Sorry to point this out to you, BUT in all 3 of the posts w/ her in it …SHE ROCKED IT FIRST….so it wud seem that other more mainstream celebs and celeb gf’s (ie: Kim Kardashan)…are STEALING HER STYLE!

Just wanted to point that out…give credit where its due…her stylist is an innovator of sorts!

THEY BOTH LOOK GREAT BUT I LOVE IT WHEN PEOPLE DO SOMETHING OTHER THAN THE SIMPLE BLACK OR WHITE SHOE, SO I WILL GO W/ GAB

Garcelle.

Kelly looks classy in the outfit
garcelle looks hot and sweaty

so Kelly…although garcelle shoes are better

Kelly.

Gab won Kelly nice but gab body looks better!

I like the dress on both of them.

kelly

Kelly, because her whole outfit works, while Garcelle’s shoes don’t work.

Kelly KILLED it - she is SO naturally beautiful to me.
http://celebggm.blogspot.com

#21 She rock the dress before Kelly…Lets pay attention to the detail that is given please

kelly’s shoes look better & her hair… i like the subdued look!

soooooooooooo I didn’t read #22

Kelly Rocked the whole look. her image always make a statement..

kelly most def.
she has more style then garcelle in this outfit…garcelle looks like she just threw it on and added random accessories.

If Garcelle wasn’t standing there like a doofus, she would look better in it. Kelly is the winner by default.

I think Kelly looks so beautiful so she wins hands down. She carries it off really well and looks classy.

kelly

Is it just me or is Garcelle in EVERY FREAKIN who rocked it better post?!?!

They both looked nice in the their body shape is pretty much the same to me-but Kelly shoes looks better.

U KNOW MY GIRL KELLY IS HOLDING IT DWN, SHE LUK GUD IN ANYTING UNKIKE THT UGLY BIACH NXT 2 HER HAHAHAH ! KELLY KEEP DOIN WT U DO GIRL KUZ UR MESSING IT UP !

Kelly, hands down!

@Caff I agree. Her stance is a bit awkward and not her usual poised self.

Kelly rocked it better.

Both women look nice, howver Kelly peep toes helps the dress out alot better. So I will say Kelly, and actually they could have traded accessories to.

KELLY…

IM GONNA GET TECHNICAL LIKE THE MAGAZINES, THEY BOTH LOOSE! THESE NECKLACES COMPLETELY DROWN THIS DRESS. WITH THIS KIND OF PLUNGE DRESS A NECKLACE SHOULD BE OBSOLETE! BUT KELLY SCORES WHEN IT COMES TO THE SHOES! LOL

Garcelle!

But Kelly looks beautiful as well. Garcelle fills out it a little bit better and makes it look more feminine.

Kelly!

KELLY hands down. Garcelle’s doesnt even fit!

Kelly hands down

Kelly got that dress looking like $1MILLION

I say kelly on this one. But I must also say that I love love love BCBG.

Kelly for sure.

i like it on kelly.

love her shoes.

I WOULD SAY KELLY! SHE LOOK REALLY NICE!

I must say both are lovely and the colors compliment both ladies skin tones. Garcelle is a true fashionista. Girlfriend comes up first in rocking her wear and the others follow along. Go’on girl!

I like it better on Garcelle…but dang how embarrassing… luckily they were at different times but thats like wearing the same prom dress as your enemy.

MISS ROWLAND IS ROCKIN THE HELL OUT OF THAT DRESS. HER ACCESSORIES AND SHOES LOOK BETTER WITH IT TOO. KELS HANDS DOWN!

GARCELLE LOOKS FAB..BUT KELLY IS MY VOTE.

I think I like it better on Kelly then on Garcelle she was just the first to jump out at me

I’m with #11. I like Kelly’s hairstyle better with it, but I love Garcelle.

It is not GAB!!!!

why is it garcelle is always in these type of posts,lol

Haven’t been here in a grip, what up!

Neither. But if i had pick someone ill pick garcelle

MY BOO KELLY HANDS DOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!

garcelle must shop a lot cause she always wears the outfit first

Kelly’s killing ‘em softly right now. It’s definitely her time to shine.

Kelly’s killing ‘em softly right now. It’s her time to shine.

i think they both look good in the dress but if i have to choose ill go with Garcelle but i agree with #2 I LOVE kellys shoes.

Garcelle looks good, but GraceKellyRowland iz rulin.

i have to give this one to kelly she is looking good

Kelly makes the outfit young and fresh, the epitome of hollywood ‘it’ girl. Garcelle gives it a grown and sexy vibe.

Why is everyone calling Garcelle “Gab”????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

Dumb asses….

ROFLMAO

I think that it’s refreshing to know that celebs style are not out of reach, & that us regular John & Jane Doe’s can rock these fits just as well.

Who rocked it best? Well Garcelle (as Fab as she want’s to be) wins big points for the unconventional use of animal print shoes. What a risk! A good risk at that. But… Kelly is rocking this style & it say’s “Classic Chic” all over the place.
Kelly Rowland wins!!!!

Kelly fa sho… thats my girl. Garcelle can’t even compete with her on this one.

Who the fuck is Gab? Her name is Garcelle. And she rocked it better, just not the shoes.

Kelly looks better in the dress hands down.

I think Kelly looks beautiful. I definately think she rocked this outfit.

KELLY

It looks sweet on her

And i like her shoes

KELLY HAND DOWN!!!

#100 I meant Garcelle lol my fault and she looks wayyyyy better than Kelly even though I think Kelly’s shoes are cool they are just average I can find those anywhere. Maybe not for the same price she paid of course but they are average!

I think Garcelle shoes are banging! I think she rocked it head to toe!

LOL @ #6. That is soo wrong.

I’m gonna have to say Kelly rock’s the dress better. It flatters her shape more.

Garcelle

Kelly.

And another thing I didn’t not come on here to be politcally correct Gab or Gar who gives a hoot you know who the heck I’m talking about!

And don’t these folks have fashion designers make one of a kind dresses and whatever else they want? There are too many posts with “Who Rocked It Better”. Makes it look like handmedowns!

Kelly , hands down, and the shoes go perfectly with the dress.Her hair and makeup are also on point, and her skin looks phenomena.

I luv them both but Kelly looks better in the dress.

I have a question. What does Garcelle do? I mean, is she on a television series that I know nothing of? Is she a socialite? I mean she is always out, what the hell does she do for a living?

KELLY

Garcelle rocked it betta cuz she fills it out but Kelly’s accersories look better with the dress. So I say they rocked it equally.

Kelly

@ms_mac1

I was thinking the samething. Garcelle needs to tell her stylist to stop putting her in the same sh#@ as everyone else.

But I think Kelly is gorgeous. She definitely did her thang….

Garcelle wore it last year so her stylist doesn’t need to fuss, its the other celebrity stylist that might need to keep an eye on who wore what. Leave the girl alone.

I think the outfit looks better on Kelly only cos I don’t like Garcelle’s shoes and necklace with that dress…but props to her stylist

Neither!

kellz wig isn’t cool

KELLY!

kelly wins but her hair is flat and boring.

i gotta give it up to my girl kelly, even tho i’m feeling Garcelle’s shoes.

Kelly wins.
But her hair is a little flat. She look like one of those girls who try to wear a flat-wrap, but don’t pull it off quit well because their hair is thin.

Even though Garcelle wore it first, her accessories aren’t appropriate for the dress. Kelly’s peep-toes are the right style and color for the dress and her earrings keep it young. I don’t really like the too-long necklace distracting from the dress’ bodice but Kelly’s look wins

Gabs definitely. They both have cankles but at least Gabs is representin for us busty gals.

Oh, and I know her name isn’t Gabrielle, but I just like saying Gabs. Sorry if it offends anyone.

I THINK BOTH LOOK VERY NICE BUT I LOVE KELLY SHOES THEY MATCH THE DRESS WELL SO I’MMA GO WIT KELLY

kelly looks fab, the whole outfit works, the hair and shoes are perfect. great taste

garcelle fills it out at the top tho

kelly!… whats wrong with garcelle legs? ugh, like she had on too tight scks or something..

I think it’s a tie. and for some people who think its ridiculous that celebs end up gettin the same outfit, why is it so bad? regular people walk around and be wearin the same thing as another person ALL THE TIME maybe Kelly liked the dress and so did Gab. so they both got it. **sighs**

Kelly looks precious…..Garcelle just ummm hmmmm….not doin’ it

kelly alldamnday!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

kelly but they both look good in it.

Kelly most def.

IM SICK OF PEOPLE COMING ON HERE AND NOT KNOWING HOW TO SPELL THE MOST COMMON OF WORDS AND MISPELLING CELEB’S NAME’S WRONG.

RISQUE NOT RISKE’…WTF.

TYPOS OK BUT NOT JUST OVER AND OVER AND OVER AGAIN.

kelly kelly kelly

garcelle!!

Get ‘em Kelly!
Ms Rowland has my vote.

Kelly, the dress fits her better

Garcelle looks waaaaaaaay better in that dress. sorry kelly.

Definitely Kels

KELLY

WHAT no BEYONCE comparison.I’m SHOCKED.but her girl KELLY took it WIT THOSE accessories.

it’s the f*ckin same. i like fancy pants shoes better. their accessories suck ass.

Garcelle wins. No comp. Kelly needs to quit with that necklace and that awful wig/weave…whatever the hell it is. I love that Garcelle is the leader of the pack! Have these other celebs been digging through her dirty laundry or what? Way to rock unique accessories w/ the dress. The necklace and shoes match the accents in Garcelle’s dress and Kelly looks boring, like the average girl next door. This pose is not about GArcelle’s awkward pose, but who rocked it better…Mrs. Beauvais-Nilon.

Garcie got this one. Although kelly looks nice too

kelly hers looks darker! like the band i prefer the black to the lighter brown!

Two of my favorite ladies. I give it to both of them, both are beautiful and both look good in that dress.

@#113

I’m not sure what else Garcelle is in, but she plays Forest Whitaker’s wife in his new feature film American Gun, it’s new in South Africa anyway.

KELLY…hands down! She looks Classy Gabs feet look Ashy..lol

Kelly! CL 1 yr and counting…..:} I freaking love this Blog! A, B, T keep up the good work!

FYI…
Garcelle is a ‘fashionista.’ That is why she is CONSISTENTLY invited to sit front row at the top fashion shows of the top designers. Also, she is one of the few women in Hollywood who can afford to BUY the dresses and not BORROW them!

(If you do not know abot the Nilon name, do your homework…homegirl married OLD money)

Garcelle fills the dress out more with her curves!

Kell

Its funny that everyone loves Kelly’s shoes, but thinks Garcelle rocked it better. I think Garcelle had the better shoes, but Kelly rocked the dress better and had a better hairdo. DAMN Garcelle is always going out somewhere… I’ve seen her on like 200 of these “Who Rocked It Better” posts!

I like Kelly better but Garcelle looks nice.

KELLY!

I did a quick tally of the votes and Kelly wins!

Kelly.

Actually, #154, the majority of the comments say Kelly rocked it better.

Kelly!! She just has an aura around her in that dress. she looks gorgeous in the dress.

Garcella looks sweaty

Wow garcelle is featured in this column a lot.
It’s interesting how they went with a different approach with the same dress, kinda ethnic with Garcelle and sleek 5o with Kelly. I like Kelly better.

I think Kelly rocked it better.

For those of you giving the celebs a hard time for rocking the same outfits, let me just make a few quick points (1) if you’ve noticed, in these segments, the women are always wearing a dress. not too many of them are balling enough to just call up Donatella Versace or Tom Ford and have them to create them a 250 dress wardrobe? Damn, when was the last time you bought a dress that was an original design? Every woman in the world has a dress that another woman also has. (2) only once have i seen the celebrities wearing the same dress at the same event (ya’ll remember when Oprah’s bff Gayle and Alfre Woodard both had on the same loud ass orange dress). that’s the real tragedy. so it’s not that big a deal when celebs wear the same dress at different times to different events. hell i have a little black dress from bebe circa 1999 that i’m still rocking the hell out of at least once every other year. new shoes, new accesories, NEW DRESS! i know another chick probably has it too. i ain’t mad!

Umm Kelly all day, Garcelle is beautiful but I think she’s a bigger size than she wants to admit and that’s why her clothes always look not properly fitted for her body.

KELLY IS DOING THE DAM THING I LIKE ALWAYS CLASSY

I think the dress looks like a throwback gown on Fancy but more expensive on Kelly

i think kelly did…Garcielle looks kindly manly to me…maybe its the way shes standing…but that dress looks young and flirty and kelly looks the best IMO.

They both loose…the dress is ugly!

KELLY, ALL DAY ANY DAY

Kelly. Garcelle is normally very lovely, but not here. That dress looks like it was made for Kelly’s body type. Kelly looks great in it.

GARCELLE LOOKS NICE BUT, KELLY MAKES THE DRESS LOOK CRISP AND NEAT gARCELLE LOOKS LIKE SHE’S GOING TO A PARTY AND KELLY LOOKS LIKE SHE’S HEADED TO A BENEFIT. BUT OPVERALL I GIVE IT TO KELLY.

kelly - thumbs up!!!

i love garcelle but kelly killed that gown she looks oh so fab

Kelly

Kelly

Garcelle and her shoes are fierce.

Kelly’s accessories look better with the dress, but Garcelle looks amazing in that dress. I love her shoes, but they don’t really go.

THEY BOTH LOOK CUTE BUT GARCELLE LOOKS BETTA!

Kelly is a bad bitch!!! She hittin. KELLY GOT IT!!

Garcelle never lets me down..she has this one in the bag!!

G DID BUT THEY BOTH LOOK CUTE