WHO ROCK’D IT BETTER: CHRISTINA, BEYONCE, or BARBIE?
Thursday, December 7, 2006

Finally, another edition of Who Rock’d It better. I have to give a special shoutout to Carrington L. for submitting this to CL. I would have never caught this one. haha.
Anyway, Christina Aguilera rock’d this dress back in ‘03 for the 2003-2004 Versace advertisment campaign. She looks bleached out, but that dress fits well. Beyonce also wore this dress back in ‘03, but she rocked it at the MTV Movie Awards. This of course was back when she was “bootylicious.”
I don’t even know when Barbie decided to rock Versace, but I say she is wearing the hell out of that dress. Get um girl.
VOTE ON THE POLL AFTER THE JUMP








270 Comments
COMMENT PAGES: [1] 2 3 4 » Show All
1.
BashyBoo
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
BARBIE HANDS DOWN !!!!!!!!!!!
2.
R&B Fan 4 Life
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Beyonce baby! Christina A. *shudders* She looks like a ghost. Barbie, I hate that fake ass doll.
3.
mika...
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Barbie of course…ha ha! I miss the old Be, she looks totally different now.
4.
Impossible06
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Beyonce rocked it better of course. I remember when she wore the dress, she was just starting to blow up as a solo artist. And yes “BACK THEN” she was extremely bootylicious. Yup that dress fit her perfectly, the shoes, the hair, the makeup, and her skin was flawless.
5.
Marquita
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Is this evena serious question???? Beyonce!!!!
6.
Martinique_fr
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Definitely Beyonce … Curves are ALWAYS better!
7.
bWHITE
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
MY GIRL B ROCKED IT THE BEST. THAT LOOK LIKE A CRACKHEAD SHOT FOR CHRISTIAN.
8.
Impossible06
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
As for Christina A… She looks like a girl interrupted.. Not a good look.
And Barbie.. Ill take a bratz doll over her any day! Fake ass white hoe.
9.
jewel13
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
I say whoever rocked it first, rocked it best. From the neck up she’s a mess, but I say Christina.
10.
poeticblue
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
I actually like the way Christina A. looks in the dress… its an art form… she’s not accidently looking like that … cmon.. haha…
11.
Jessica
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Bey
12.
wifey
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
ROFLMAO @ this one…LOL
13.
Dymediva25
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Barbie hands down… LOL
but I am feeling Bey’s shoes!
14.
wifey
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
@ #8 “And Barbie.. Ill take a bratz doll over her any day! Fake ass white hoe.”
——————
^^^^^You stupid!!!! LOL
15.
Htown
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
It fits them all well, yes even Barbie! Even though Christian looks a mess in the face, the dress looks cute on her.
16.
777-9311
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
@Mika i just realized that I miss that beyonce a little too. But I still think that B rocked it better. I loved that dress when I first saw it.
I wonder if beyonce would give me her hand me downs. Hmmmm.
17.
b all the way
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
is this even a competition. beyonce of course
18.
Why Lawd
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
I hated the ghost look they gave Christina for her Versace shoots, but the dresses always looked good on her.
The dress looks great on all three, but I’ma have to give it to barbie, because I love how much longer it is with all the pretty ruffles. And because she’s just a doll lol. I need to find a black version of that doll and add it to my collection.
19.
Tyra
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Christina looks a HAM!!!!! Ughhhh….not a good look for her….
Beyonce killed it….cant even believe that was a question…..
20.
girl
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
I like barbies dress better its longer and has more ruffles.
I think she l;ooks the best
21.
Khris
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Barbie, guRL…
Barbie.
22.
R&B Fan 4 Life
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Christina looks like that girl from THE RING movies.
23.
Kita bka
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
CTFU @ the Title!!!
Christine looks sickly…she is too pale and that dress doesn’t help her.
Barbie is BLAH—-but she prob. orginated the style, but she looks plastic to me (*boos the corny joke).
Beyonce looks fierce!!!! The thigh action, the hair (I like that understated style and the hue), the smoky eyed and the makeup……she is workin the hell outta that dress…..hands down, she wins this one.
F-A-B-Ulous! Go Bee!
24.
babyx
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
CHRISTINA LOOKS SICK
BEYONCE DEFINITELY TOOK THIS ONE
BARBIE’S DRESS CUT IS BETTER THOUGH
25.
fashiongurl
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Barbie!
It’s all about the full package and I’m not sure if I’m liking the cut of the dress and the hairstyle on Bey as much as Barbie’s!
26.
first time
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
am i wrong for saying Barbie??? LOL…. beyonce looks nice and christina is supposed to look pale cuz it’s a high fashion shoot… it’s not meant to look like everyday pretty seventeen magazine pictures.
i still think Barbie did it better.
27.
barbie is a bad bad bitch
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
omg barbie is working it.. barbie been in the game a long ass time and still showing these heffas how it is done.. and not to mention barbie is mult-talented.. shes done everything and still making it look hot.. work it barbie..
28.
first time
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
beyonce look uncomfortable in that pic… like she tryna suck it in and smile… plus her boob is falling out from between the criss cross ribbon. LOL. her shoes are really cute tho.
29.
ms_mac1
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Xtina wins the “Out of the Box” award
Barbie wins for “Living in a Box” and
Bey wins for “Staying inside the Box and never venturing out”
30.
POBOI
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
I’m just glad they are all different colors. So tacky to rock “someone else’s” dress.
I didn’t know Barbie had it like that!
B WINS, as usual.
31.
melisus
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Barbie looks the best.
32.
stylishlibra
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
The color looks nice on B’s skin, Christina’s dress fits nicely and I won’t put her down for the bleached look cause that was an artistic choice by Versace’s advertisement peeps. BARBIE wins hands down! Although I don’t like the image Barbie sets for young girls and the color’s too close to the doll’s “skin-tone”, the dress fits her perfectly.
33.
Clearminded
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
The length the dress on Barbie is the best (can’t believe I’m talking about a doll) but other than that B killed it. Christina needs CPR.
34.
Qtpie1978
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Beyonce….. Christina is given’ me the creeps, she looks like something out of “Night of the Living Dead”
35.
DINAD82
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
BEYONCE hands down!
That doesnt even look like Christina…ewww!
36.
Barbie
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
BARBIE-TOTALLY PUT “TOGETHER”!!
37.
bill
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Carrington L & Angel.la is crazy as hell for comparing Beyonce & Barbie…
As a Man I really don’t give a F_ck….
I’m looking forward to reading PittBoi’s Fashion Commentary later on though….
38.
Meatloaf
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Is that lacefront?
39.
NEWORLEANS_FINEST_CANDI
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
BEYONCE PRETTY ASS, LOL
40.
Kells
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Beyonce baby! All the way. Fugg Barbie’s skinny food deprived behind!
41.
Ne-Ho for Ne-Yo
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
BARBIE IS ROCKIN THAT SHIT! SHOW THE BRATZ YOU STILL GOT IT BARB!!!
BEYONCE IS RUNNER UP.
42.
DINAJONES
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
hmmmm THIS IS A HARD ONE//// LMFAO….HMMM I THINK BEYONCE OF COURSE WORE IT BETTER..AND SO DID BARBIE…THIS IS DEF A TIE…BETWEEN THE B’S….
WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO CHRISTINA??? SHE LOOKS UNREAL…FAKE AND LIKE A GHOST….WELL THATS EXPECTED OF HER
OH BUT DID ANYONE SEE THE VIDEO WITH HER AND PDIDDY…SHE IS BANGIN HANDS DOWN FOR THAT VIDEO…
I FEEL THAT WHOEVER PUT THOSE EXTENTIONS IN FOR HER AND DID HER MAKEUP NEEDS TO TAKE A PERSONAL VISIT TO MY HOUSE…NOW THATS HANDS DOWN!!! LOL
DINA JONES
43.
DMV the Future
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Angel La - You are a TRIP LOL. Puttin Barbie as a choice.
Great post haha
44.
candeegurl
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Beyonce looks great in the dress, but Barbie’s dress is cut better….she killing ‘em. Now talk about someone giving these twenty something girls a run for there money…BARBIE is 47 years old and she still got it!!! I ain’t mad at cha Barbie. Don’t hurt ‘em.
45.
shorty spice
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
I always liked that dress on Xtina but Barbie is rocking it. I never thought that it looked that good on Bee. Barbie’s dress looks better.
46.
candeegurl
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
^^^^I’m soooo not serious.
47.
Natural Mystic
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
I miss the REAL Versace–GIANNI Versace. He was so much more talented than his sister. His gear was FIERCE!
48.
NewAgePrep
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Gwentina rocked it better. Skinny women always wear clothes better than thick women, let me rephrase, they wear clothes the way the designer meant them to be worn. The designer didnt make the dress for the average woman, size 2 and below, is who it was made for.
49.
Meatloaf
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Christina wore it laced under her titties, Beyonce wore her lace criss-cross her tattas, but Barbie wore it lacefront proper!
Beyonce’ rocked the best accessories!
Barbie rocked the best hair!
Christina looks white washed!
50.
bill
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
I have a question for the Caucasian Ladies on CL: Why do WHITE magazines, Like Vogue & Elle (I don’t read them..My wife GLANCES at them) ALWAYS use MORTICIAN’s MAKEUP for White Woman ????
Why do Caucasians Think it’s Cool/Pretty to apply makeup on White Woman (Like Christina Milan) in that manner ???
Not trying to be funny or disrespectful..I’m just trying to understand white woman….
Thanks.
51.
SAFFIRE IN NEW YORK
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Beyonce wins, hands down boo.Go head Barbie but it would look fiercer on a black doll ( forgive me for being bias).
Love,Peace,&&Honeyy
52.
hehe
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
christina aka barbie
53.
Natural Mystic
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Oh yeah, the dress looks better on Christina b/c she’s skinny, though you can’t really tell b/c of the odd hair and makeup and pale photography. On B, it seems a little too tight, her accesories are also overdone. The dress is elaborate- she should’ve toned it down and tanned more to compliment it.
54.
AngelEyes
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Barbie looks fab! lol
Everyones been chasing Barbie’s style ever since the begining of time. lol
Hell Barbie is the reason for all of the body dismorphia in Hollywood. lol
Beyonce has that pose down.
55.
bill
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
candeegurl, I have a Question….
Is that Avatar a picture of your puppy ????
What is your Puppy so pissed off about ???
Cute Pup…He looks like he just pee peed on the carpet, and got caught though…
56.
AngelEyes
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Christina looks like Barbie gone wild!
57.
bill
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
on Thursday, December 7, 2006 @ 10:59 am
AngelEyes said:
——————————————————————————–
Barbie looks fab! lol
Hell Barbie is the reason for all of the body dismorphia in Hollywood. lol
Bill Said:
AngelEyes is showing off this morning using words I never heard of before….
I HAD to look up the definition of DISMORPHIA
Angeleyes thinks she’s cute…

lol
One of the most common psychological conditions associated with cosmetic surgery is a condition commonly referred to as Body Dysmorphic Disorder (BDD). BDD is a distressing body image condition that involves excessive preoccupation with physical appearance in a ‘normal’ appearing person. This condition is often associated with intrusive thoughts of body dissatisfaction, avoidance of exposure to body images situations, such as mirrors in public places, and excessive body checking and comparisons with others. Thus, in its extreme form it can be quite debilitating and cause a great deal of anxiety and dis-satisfaction
58.
candeegurl
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
@Bill, not mine. I received this in an e-mail tittled “Sorry”. I have this tiled on my desktop as well cause I think it’s so cute.
You’re right whatever the little puppy did, he got caught and is really really sorry for it. Poor thing. LOL
59.
Why Lawd
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
@ Bill, are you sure you’re referring to the right Christina? Because that’s Christina Aguilera up there.
As for your mortician’s makeup, I’m black myself, but I think that question has to be directed towards a high fashion/coture fashionista rather than the average white chick. The average white chicks I’ve seen like to be tan.
60.
R-Jae
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
I know a lot of people are going to disagree but I think Christina rock it best. The Vesace gown is a Couture piece, hence the pale make-up I think Christina carries it off well.
61.
candeegurl
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
I can see one of those ads for BDD right now.
“If you feel you have any of these symptoms, please see Monique and she will definitely tell you how skinny you are and to get over yourself.”
62.
EnJoi
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
I’m Team Barbie
63.
blk dds
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
I like the dress on Christina.
Still love Bey though.
Barbie, well, she’s a white girl…..
64.
bill
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
on Thursday, December 7, 2006 @ 11:04 am
Why Lawd said:
——————————————————————————–
@ Bill, are you sure you’re referring to the right Christina? Because that’s Christina Aguilera up there.
As for your mortician’s makeup, I’m black myself, but I think that question has to be directed towards a high fashion/coture fashionista rather than the average white chick. The average white chicks I’ve seen like to be tan.
Bill Said:
Christina Aguilera, Christina Milan….What’s the differance ???

lol….Just Kidding…
I’m a Man..I don’t have a clue as to who’s who…I just repeat what you ladies tell me….
Thanks for your response. I work with a few real cool white girls, and they are always going to the Tanning salon, and asking the sister for makeup tips…
There’s one white girl in my office who wears MAC Makeup…She trying to be down with the Sisters in our workgroup..I think that’s cool..
65.
bill
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
on Thursday, December 7, 2006 @ 11:07 am
candeegurl said:
——————————————————————————–
I can see one of those ads for BDD right now.
“If you feel you have any of these symptoms, please see Monique and she will definitely tell you how skinny you are and to get over yourself.”
Bill Said:
That’s Funny !!!!
Your avatar of the Puppy who is really sorry for peeing on the rug is a great photo !!!
66.
Beautiful
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Bee!
Damn, Barbie looks good but no curves so I say Bee..lol
67.
AngelEyes
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
57@Bill,
Women know what Body Dismorphia is. LOL
I THINK BARBIE HAS GONE UNDER THE KNIFE.
BREAST AUGMENTATION AKA BOOB JOB
FACE LIFE because you know she is old as dirt.
RHINOPLASTY
HAIR EXTENTIONS AKA WEAVE
HAIR LIGHTENING AKA BLEAH
RIB REMOVED….UH MAYBE TWO RIBS
LIPO
BUT SHE LOOKS LIKE SHE HAS A LITTLE BUT ON HER;
MAYBE SHES HAD THE BUT IMPLANT OR FAT TRANSFER. LOL
Let me know if I missed something. lol
68.
AngelEyes
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
oops sorry I meant FACE LIFT AND BLEACH
69.
archuletachick
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Barbie got this one.
Cause I hate Christina and something about Bee’s cleavage don’t look right.
70.
DIVA
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
CHRISTINA WINS THIS ROUND - BARBIE, C’MON….
BEYONCE LOOKS LIKE JAY WAS JUSTFONDLING HER BOOBS AND SHE GOT OUTTA THE CAR WITHOUT FIXING HERSELF…
CHRISTINA WORE IT BEST… ROCKED IT PERFECTLY!!!
71.
JASSIE FAI
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Ugh i hate to admit it but barbie got this. They shoulda gave that dress to a Bratz doll cause I can support them hoes! 4real yall my sister got a collection of them, and I be mad that they be lookin fresher than i do lol! I swear i would jack them bitches cloths if they wasnt 5 inches long!
72.
blk dds
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
#27 said:
Barbie been in the game a long ass time and still showing these heffas how it is done……
AND
#47 said:
BARBIE is 47 years old and she still got it!!!
_______________________________________________
Yeah the bitch been in the game a long ass time. She just got a job as a substitute teacher and a doctors assistant a few years ago.
Bitch kept a Corvette, a house in Malibu and she stayed up on her workout regimen and her gear game was on point - hence the Versace gown.
Now how you gone have all that and not have a job. That’s showing heffa’s how it’s done.
She even had Ken’s gay ass questioning his damn self.
Barbie is a slut! lol j/k
73.
LaVonna
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
THe dress looks too small for bey…her underarm is bulging out of the side and one breast looks like its about to push its way through the criss cross….but anywho…i dont really care for the dress on any of them to be honest. but i will say thick bey is better than skinny bey.
74.
pittbboi
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
Well…Barbie IS putting both these bitches in their place. That’s right Barbie! They don’t want it!
LOL–on to the two real people though. I’m surprised that I’m actually going to have to give this to Beyonce. I remember when she wore this dress and how fabulous I thought it looked on her. This is one of those rare occasions where the dress is actually her size! The fabric is tight and form fitting, but unlike with most other dresses she wears you don’t see signs that the fabric is struggling to fit around her curves like wrinkles and bulges. And the ponytail just sets it off.
Christina does look nice though. Even though she would probably look better (though not as good as Beyonce) in real life as opposed to a magazine shoot where they’re purposely make her look and pose so weird.
But Barbie handed it to both these broads…lol
75.
bill
Thursday, December 7, 2006 /
on Thursday, December 7, 2006 @ 11:18 am
AngelEyes said:
——————————————————————————–
57@Bill,
Women know what Body Dismorphia is. LOL
Bill Said:
Uh, okay…I didn’t know what the heck you were talking about…I had to go look up the definition..
lol
COMMENT PAGES: [1] 2 3 4 » Show All