mos def J-Hud
love ya girl

Jen rocked it wayyyyy better!

Jennifer is wearing the dress..and the dress is wearing Gwen. :/

NEITHER! I love both, but that dress is not cute. Gwyneth coulda looked better in the black. J Hud’s shoes are better for the dress than Gwyneth’s. J Hud would look better in the silver or maybe a red. J Hud’s hair is also better. The dress itself is not at all cute. It makes them both look bigger than they are.

Jennifer hands down!

Jennifer because she’s carrying herself in a better way. While Gwen is kinda just wearing it to be wearing it, she can still act though…

J-HUD!! =)

The black dress minus that bow foolishness on the shoulder looks cute on her, HUDSON that is.

JENNIFER IS DOING IT BIG IN 07 SHE DONE WON AN OSCAR THATS A GOOD LOOK

Jennifer all the way she looks hella Sexy and Gwenith doesnt even look like she wants to be there…

neither.

bad look for both. but worse for Gwenyth.

Jennifer looks like a diva in the dress while Gwenyth looks hella plain.

j-hud

JENNIFER RADIATES IN ALL OF HER PHOTOS-
SHE’S GLOWING ALL THE TIME.

IS IT JUST ME OR DOES SHE REMIND ANYONE OF A YOUNGER MARY J BLIGE A LITTLE?

BLACK IS DEFINATELY A BEAUTIFUL COLOR ON HER SKIN TONE.

SHE’S DEFINATELY REPRESENTING FOR THE YOUNG BLACK WOMEN OF TODAY.

AND

SPEAKS WITH CHARISMA AND ALWAYS LOOKS PLEASANT AND JOYFUL.

I’M VERY HAPPY FOR HER.

Beautiful Jennifer, hands down!!!

JENNIFER HUDSON LOOKS BETTER!!! GWENYTH’S SHOES WITH THAT DRESS LOOKS OFF. HER SHOES MAKE HER ANKELS LOOK FAT. HER SHOES ARE TOO DARK AND CHUNKY.

Honestly…neither one…because that is a frumpy dress. It makes both of them look wide.

J-Hud! She just looks so fabulous in that dress.

Definitely Jennifer.

hate the dress but if had to choose j.hud

Jennifer Hudson Hands down…Gweneth Looks so freakin fugly in the face on this pic ugh! J-Hud is rocking this dress. Her figure is very volumptuous, which gives this dress personality…something it desperately needs! Gweneth on the other hand, looks Frumpy, so now the dress is lacking style. This dress needed someone to give it style and class, J-hud did it, while Gweneth did not!

JENNIFER

I like Gwyneth’s shoes, but not with her dress…so I must go with Jen on this one.

I love JHud no matter what she wears. She is so adorable. Just give her some time. She will grow into her own. Gwenneth has not wanted to go out since having a child. She said she felt really bad about how she looks and stated that she wants to get something done about it. From what I understand, she did not enjoy being pregnant. She used to be a stick. She just needs to embrace her curves now. Personally, I think she was too thin before and now is self concious about having something to work with.

Jennifer Hands down!

jennifer. she looks radiant. gwyn looks chalky, pasty…

Jennifer rock’d it!

JENNIFER HUDSON
The black just looks better and she has the purse to match.

j-hud got this one, she is just carrying herself better in it.

I have to agree with #4…NEITHER ONE. I don’t care for this type of style dress at all. But a since GWENNIE is a FASHION ICON, i’ll give her a break. And the same goes for JHUD, considering that she’s a FASHION NEWCOMER.

Jennifer Hudson looks 10x better than gwenyth.

J-Hud —–> NEXT

I think JHud looks good her make-up, her hair and shoes go just right with the dress. I just think paltrow coulda worn better shoes I have a pair of those (the real ones) and I woulda never worn them with that dress. Kudos to JHUD though!

jennifer. gwyneth’s hair is not complimenting the dress.

Definitely Jen! She always looks great to me. I don’t like Gwen’s black shoes with the white dress.

Jen wins. she looks radiant & stunning.

Gwen looks like she lacks personal style. what happened 2 her accesories?… and Gwen’s posture??? her shoes do not go with the dress. she looks frumpy. her hair would look better up in a french bun or something.
fix up.look sharp!

Jennifer wears it much better…agree with ppl concernin Gwen…

Jennifer Hudson, no doubt about it.

Neither!

J-Hud

You know our girl J-hud rock it the best!

Satin looks bad on anybody. Too shiney.

Jenninfer is my preference. It’s interesting, this dress wear well for both ladie’s figures, and that’s not always the case. Lot’s of designers create for a limited range of sizes, and the larger the woman, the garment looses it’s intented look/styling. But this looks like the exact same dress on 2 distinctly different figures.

Are you serious right now??? There is no contest!!! I think we ALL know who won this battle!!

(Hint: Dreamgirls : ) lol

LOTION @ Jen but she did rock it better.

J-hud looks like a younger version of Star Jones in that picture….she still looks better than gwyneth though

if i had to pick…..jennifer…..gwen looks like a servant girl

JENNIFER! I don’t know what it is about Gwyneth always looks slow and retarded! I shouldn’t say that but I did lol

Hmmm no contest. Jennifer Hudson all damn day long… Gwen looks okay, but she would’ve looked better with sexy stilettos and her hair off her shoulders…

I don’t like the dress, but I think it looks better in black so JHud wins by default.

JENNIFER FILLS THE DRESS OUT BETTER. I AM A BEYONCE FAN AND I AM GIVING JENNIFER PROPS..WTF?.. J/K… I LOVE THEM BOTH BUT JENNIFER ROCKED IT BETTER HANDS DOWN!

i’m sorry but that dress is wearing gwyenth! she looks washed out and pale and those clunky black shoes are a no-no!

jennifer my dear you can do no wrong! she looks great!

Niether, the dress id ugly. Still love J-Hud.

Who the hell knew Prada made plus sized clothes?
J Hud is working that dress!

Satin is so unforgiving. This isn’t my favorite of dresses, but Jennifer Hudson’s natural glow helps her pull it off. Gwyneth looks awkward and washed out in this photo, and I blame the color of the dress and the way her hair is styled. Love J Hud!

J-Hud’s got that one … Love her!

j hud. gwen’s shoes are way too chunky for this dress. and ivory-ish satin only looks good on wedding dresses or slimmer girls like eva the diva!

Gwyneth looks washed out… the blonde tresses are definitely working against her in this dress.

Jen looks beyond fab!

Neither. That dress is fugly.

I finally got to see Dreamgirls this Friday and it was great. I do believe that JHud is very powerful as Effie. The entire time I was watching the movie I was wondering what Effie was doing.

I think JHud fulls out the dress a bit more than Gwen. It could be the boobs and hips but JHud does do the dress justice.

Side Note: she has a lovely smile and the hair is looking great.

JHUDD, HANDS DOWN IS ROCKIN’ IT BETTER! WORK IT MOMMAS!!!

MY GIRL JHUD

Most definately J Hud.

My girl J.Hud!

I am not 100% feeling the dress but I have to say Jen rocked it better.

HA! NEITHER

I PREFER THE WHITE DRESS BUT GWEN NEEDS TO STICK TO WOOL COATS AND PONYTAILS…

Wow! J. Hud looks better in this. The shoes are prettier, her hair…
Gwen resembles a washed out white shadow–so boring.

Jennifer Hudson, no contest. Who is Gwyneth Paltrow?

J Hud I guess, but I like Gwyneth’s shoes better

It definately looks better on Jennifer Hudson. It fits her shape a lot better. The dress makes Gwen looks thicker than what she really is.

the blk chick did

I WILL HAVE TO GO WITH JENNIFER, CUZ I LIKE A SISTER WITH SOME CURVES.

I can’t believe you even asked this question….

The dress is not the best cut but Jennifer definitely rocked it! She fills it out and it compliments her curves. On G, the blonde hair and skin tone almost washes out that color. What was her stylist thinking? G is normally on the BEST dressed list but this lil number knocked her right off the radar!

Go Jennifer! You are stepping right into those SUPA STAR shoes girl!

Jennifer definitely!

Neither one of them look good…the dress is ugly.

Go Jennifer…b/c you ROCKED IT BETTER!!! She looked beautiful!

Jennifer!

Jennifer did. I think the dress falls right on her. On Gwynth it looks kind of like a potato sack. Jennifer has the right body for it in my opinion.

Jennifer looks great. Peolple.com poll where this came from also states that Jenn rocked it better. I voted the other day on this Who Rocked It Better over there. So JHud fans are really showing support..

Definitely J-Hud!

Jennifer because she put some accessories on and look like she spend a lot of time and patience to get the look together.

Jen.

that dress makes them both look BIG.
but im feelin it more on JHud, she got pretty shoes too

Ms. Jennifer Hudsom without a doubt! Do it, girl!

Jennfier looks fantastic…but I wish they would stop putting her in black outfits all the time. I know black is supposed to be slimming, but come on now…

Jen Hands down.

#55: Couture is custom made so they can cut the fabric to any specifications. Plus size or not it looks great on her.

Neither…. They look like old satin bedsheets. The dresses look homely and grandma-ish.

@87 she does wear a lot of black,i would love to see her switch it up

jen is WEARING and ROCKING it. gwyn’s posing is looking very humble. if she had a better pose/positioning, then maybe it would be a little different. gwyn’s shoes also look awkward with the dress.

J.Hud no doubt!

Jennifer Hands Down!!!

Although I am sick of her wearing all black…But then again it is slimming.

JEN SHE FILLED THE DRESS!

Jennifer looks better, Gwyneth looks frumpy with those big ol shoes

Jen wears it the best

bout time is right..i love who rocked it better…

i must say JHUD rocked it better this time…body is filling the dress better, her hair is onpoint and so are the shoes….

GWEN, love ya, but you lost points with:
- choosing a silver dress with that bleach blonde hair
when i look at this picture i have to keep blinking with the “DEER-EYE” cuz its so dang bright
- clunky black shoes…not with a silver dress hun..

MY GIRL J- HUD.. I LIKE THE WAY THE DRESS LOOKS ON

HER.

THEY HAIR HAS ALOT TO DO WITH IT TOO.. GWYNETH HAIR

LOOKS DEAD..

GOOD JOB J- HUD..

jennifer hudson look waaaaay better in the dress gwen looks like shes sick and wants to go home and rest

J-HUD DID IT!

Definitely J. Hud!

J all the way!!!

I think they both look nice, but of course I’m going to say I prefer Jennifer Hudson. There’s nothing better than a simple black dress.

Jennifer!!!!!

@67 I agree with your statement about Gwyneth.

Gwen just look like she came out of the closet and said “how do i look” and just went on.

I love these “who wore it better” things. JHUD!!!! Hands down.

JENNIFER HUDSON

white gurl looks a mess GO HEAD J-HUD!

Jennifer…the dress is CLEARLY for bigger girls

I don’t really like the dress, but JHud rock’d it better.

Gwen looks like the dress is swallowing her. Ugh!!

jennifer rocked it way better b/c her shoes pulled off the outfit just right and she looks
F-A-B-U-L-O-U-S

Gwenny.

jennifer

neither ..

I hate this dress but it does flow better on Jennifer.

J-hud rocked it best because Gwyenth needs a Tan & the dress washes her out.

I LIKE JENNIFER HUDSON’S DRESS BETTER BUT GWENYTH ROCKED THE DRESS BETTER. THE DRESS DOESN’T FIT JENNIFER WELL. BUT GWEN NEEDS TO TAKE THAT BLACK FEATHER OR WHATEVER THAT SHIT IS SUPPOSED TO BE OFF.

gwen’s hair sucks, but she can afford to make that mistake…

ok maybe it doesn’t suck, but it surely doesn’t suit that dress… it reminds me of the adaams family a lil bit!

jennifer wins this one by default b/c she looks odd from the knee area on down…

GO J HUD!!!!!

JENNIFER HUDSON HANDS DOWN!

Her name is Gwyneth, not GWEN!

I’d love to lift Jen’s dress above her waist! mmmm

Jennifer, definitely.

Gwyneth looks washed out and funny-looking. But I never was a fan of her style anyway.

nobody give a fuck what her real name is if we call her gwen its GWEN

J Hud has the curves and that skinny white chick doesn’t. Besides, her skin blends in too much with the dress.

JHUD

Wow. It’s not even a question - I think it’s unanimous. Jhud KILLED it. Gwyn looks homely, washed out, and disoriented. She needs to get it together. But my girl JHud? Loves it!

JENNIFER. her body looks waaaayyy more classy/sexy in it casue her full figure fills the dress out. Gwyneth just looks like a hillbiilly tyrin to look classy but didn’t even come near it.

JHud rocked it. Black is a powerful color.

LOL @ #121! Oh yeah, but who gives a $hit?

Ok I am fast becoming a huge Jennfier Hudson fan everytime i hear this woman sing i get chills but that is irrelevent right now ok so yeah Jennifer wins i to would like to see her in other colors but i think she looks fabulous in black….Go J-Hud (my garsh i sound like a stan) ehh oh well

J HUD that white washes out Gwen’s skin and makes her looks too pale!

Gwyneth needs to learn how to pose.
The attitude is half of the look.
And standing there with your shoulders hunched
would make any outfit look bland.

Okay this is a no brainer for me. Hands down, Jenny from the block (Hudson that is). Don’t get me wrong, I actually like Gwenyth. She played the hell out of that shy naive character in Seven. But that dress on her… aaaaaah no.

IMO, Anglo-Saxons this pale should never wear white that close to the skin… it’s just wrong. Gwenyth looks like something from a scary movie. In that pose, she kinda reminds me of Sissy Spaseck in Carrie. Remember when Carrie was at the prom and she was onstage and John Travolta dumped the pigs blood on her and everyone in the gym started laughing? And they had that voice over of her mother saying… “they’re all gonna laugh at you!”

Well Gwen looks like Carrie on her prom night. And Gwen, your mom was right… we are laughing at you. NEXT IF YOU PLEASE.

Def Jen! Gwyn just looks washed out, her hair clashes with that dress.

Jennifer

Her hair and accessories pull it off

Jennifer looks absolutely stunning. She feels the dress out completely.

JeN WoRe iT BeTTeR. GwEn LooKs LiKe sHe CaMe oUt oF ReHaB….KeeP DoiN’ iT JeN! WoRk yO wAy 2 tHe tOp!

jennifer hudson rocked the dress better

i think alot of you are saying JENNIFER wore it better because ya’ll like her(hell i do too) but the fit of the dress looks alot better on GWEN but i like the black version better but i am sick of jennifer wearing black she has nice skin tone she should do like red or dark pink or something….PEACE

of course jen. Gwen looks washed out

what a competition!!

jennifer who?? Gwyneth Paltrow rock’d it!!

WOOWWW!!!

I never thought I’d see a day when Gweneth was FAT!!! She lookes almost the same size as JHUD!!! WTF happened to her eating brown rice and drinking grass root tea to stay thin?

He husband kinda cute too in that scruffy-lookin’ white boy way, and we all know how VERY AGGRESSIVE young white women are, so she better drop the pounds and watch her back cuz a white man will drop his woman over weight in a HEART BEAT lol!!!!

But JHUD looks better in that UGLY ass dress!!! It looks like something a little fat 11 year old girl would wear to a music recital or something, not something a beautiful, sophisticated young woman should wear and be taken seriously!!!!

My girl Jennifer Hudson, no doubt!

gwen looks like like a ghost off a damn horror flick and she needs some sun..hudson looks better

hands down jennifer rock’d it…gwen looks kinda dead in her gid-up

@ 130 4 real!

COME ON NOW. JEN LOOKS WAY BETTE

new bad bitch: J-HUD!!!

I say J hud but the only prob I have with it is that her chee chee’s are lop sides even them thangs out lil momma

hudson

MY GIRL JENNY DID THAT!!!!!!!!

j-hud got this one - gwen looks frumpy…

its a tie. they look eaqually good in their different capacities n skin tones.

I am going to have to say J-Hud cause Gwen looks like a trashy ass mess. Go J-Hud.

jenifer rocked it better! because gwen is so pale she’s looks dead with that white dress. 1 time for jennifer actually putting on a bra and what have you. she IS NOT BUILT LIKE BEYONCE and everything does not need to be skin tight and naked! she’s so whack for most of her dress choices!