@ 13

yeah it’s because they switched places at one point…while you’re looking at Shakira who’s now in the back, Beyonce is in the front

they just switched places, that’s all.

Okay lemme post this link again of Beyonce with no makeup

http://www.beyonceworld.n...or/images/gladiator11.jpg

nooow look at that pic and tell me if she looks like Shakira? She doesn’t huh? Exactly she tries to look like her…because she wants to look like her

Cool video. But I dont think Bey looks like Shakira. It’s really the curly wig and make-up that helps her look “exotic”.

anyways if you copy and past this link below

http://www.beyonceworld.n...or/images/gladiator11.jpg

into your address box or url box you will see the pic that i’m trynna post..because it does work …it’s just isn’t working on this CL site

i meant they are just like closeted gay men

Just like the HATERS alway know more then the FANS… funny how that is.

IF YOU DON”T LIKE BEYONCE THAN WHY YOU THIS POST?

OMG@Jscene you are absolutely rigt about everything you said on #75….applaud this memeber*

Man haters just don’t give up! LOL The video is hott I must say. Why can’t people be happy that there is a powerful black woman doing her thing and out selling all the other female artists instead of being jealous. Beyonce doesn’t copy Shakira shes herself and thats all. The girl works hard and even a hater can’t deny that.

Beat to “WE FLY HIGH”
WE HATE ON,B.K.,YOU KNOW WE, HATAZ!
SHE GOT ALL, THE CURVES AND THE PAPA!(PAPER)

Stacey, if you are trying to prove a point, why try so hard? if you think that then fine but stop wasting your time nobody cares…

Am I really the only person who thought the song AND video was wack as hell???!

People just get it out now. By the time the Upgrade U post comes up, the haters/jealousBGKlovers will be too tired out to say anything else.

DOPE VIDEO-DIDNT OVERDO IT-NOT FLASHY-GOOD LOOK

DAYUUUUUUM! This is the hotness rite now! AMAZING! They look exactly alike! Go head B with ya bad self! Show these pretenders trying to take ur throne who the real Queen B is!

First let me state I love Beyoncé before ya’ll put me in the hate train. I like the concept, its so 80s, thanks for everything Michael Jackson.

Why can’t people state what they see.

Nobody is hating, there was a glitch in the editing, I saw it too, so Shakira appears in two spots in one shot. And I was watching closely cause I was getting confused, not looking for imperfection so that I may feel better about myself.
Just because you didn’t see it, doesn’t mean its not there it happens all the time in editing.

Yo Gezzy (post #13), r u serious??? LMAO. That was not digitally enhanced. it’s obviously done like that on purpose cuz they’r supposed to look alike. Why u gotta say bout the part when they show both of their faces and hips shaking. I knew somebody would have something negative to say about it. Hot video. Jus leave it at that.

I like dis i think this is koo between the two of them

#88 funny….. Hate take years off your life too.

Quote from Upgrade U “WHAt You Think they all MAD at me for?”… priceless

GO BEY GO SHAKIRA GO JENNIFER GO FANTASIA GO CIARA GO MJB GO NORAH ……..

I so love the video. I was like in the ending, “who is who?”. But you can tell which is which because the different body types. Haters are in denial. Its alright. When Beyonce first came out, she looked like herself (excuse me) but when she puts on the curly bush, then she looks like Shakira. I hate it when haters always try to convince you about something like they really know it all, Negro please.

Love,Peace,&&Honeyy

That was really HOT! It never fails…Bee can do basically ANYTHING she puts her mind to. I’ve always admired Shakira’s dancing. Now I will learn all the words in the next 5 minutes and dance to it in my mirror. Yay!!!

By the way, did anyone else notice “The Boy Is Mine” kinda concept behind the song? Love it!!!

I WANNA KNOW Y PEOPLE KEEP SAYING THAT BEYONCE IS COPYING ARTISTS OR SHAKIRA. IF SHE IS THEN SHE IS OBVIOUSLY DOIN A HELLA BETTER JOB WITH IT CUZ I AINT SEEN N E FEMALE ARTIST THAT PEOPLE DROWL OVER OTHER THAN BEYONCE. AND HOW CAN BEYONCE BE COPYING SHAKIRA WHEN BEYONCE CAME OUT WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY B-4 SHAKIRA DID? PEPES IS LOVIN BEYONCE A LOT MORE CUZ Y R THEY PHENEN OFF OF BEYONCE DOIN THE BOOTY THING AND NOT SHAKIRA, THINK ABOUT IT.IT COULD BE THE OTHER WAY AROUND.

to 85)sweetjazz21

LOL, i know, it so sad, the poor girl is obsessed with proving her point, what the hell was the point again?

that negative energy she is wasting, she could have spent checking out her favourite artist and be enjoying that, instead of wasting precious time.

poor thing needs to go to rehab to get bee out of her system.LOL

This song is ohkay and the video was ohkay and newsflash Shakira didnt come up with the booty bouncing belly wiggling whatever you wanna call it dance moves. So apparently Beyonce aint really jocking her style…but any hoot.

i never realized it until i read some comments on here but her style IS so much like shakira.wow.

i love the video because i llllove shakira.its hot cant knock beyonce for this one.she knows how to make money,i mean her daddy does but i didnt buy the cd the first time and wont buy it this time.

if u look closely at the end it’s really shakira’s body doing the winding up and not really Bee , they digitally enhanced it to look like bee that’s why when the hip action was going you didn’t see bee’s face but you could see shakiras . Then bee was in front but then auto-matically in back when the full shot appears . look closely before calling me a hater please .

——————————————————————————–
it was beyonce on an old mtv on the diary show beyonce did that dance her hip can pop out or some shit like dat a nice video though

BEYONCE…YOU NEED TO GET SOME NEW STUFF…SAME OLD DANCES.. SAME OLD MOVES..AND SAME OLD SOUND..I DON’T WHAT YOU GUYS LIKE ABOUT THIS VIDEO, BUT IT’S NOTING NEW (OH SHAKIRA IS IN.. THAT NICE). WHAT OTHER VIDEO CAN BEYONCE DO, BUT SEXY VIDEOS. BEYONCE TAKE MY ADVISE, CHECK OUT CIERA’S NEW VIEDO (LIKE A BOY) AND GET SOMETHING NEW AND CREATIVE.

These 2 yella skanks are annoyance personified. Both at the same time singing the same song in the same video is enough to make me want to cut ‘em low!

To STACEY AND JSCENE: Shakira has changed her look over the years too.. She use to have RED HAIR like Joss Stone has now. also her hair used to be BLEACHED BLONDE too. So I guess you haven’t done your homework so you don’t get your after school snack.

You are correct #13 your not a hater you can notice shakira in the back and front they switched postions although B is shaking also. They blended it.

why do beyonce posts always have to turn into a STOP HATIING thing.and then her die hard fans get all heated and want to i-murder somebody.man this is sad i think beyonce posts SHOULD HAVE COMMENTS DISABLED to end so much bs

The beginning reminded me of one of those videos they used to do on In Livin’ Color…like “Rhymthless Nation” but other than that, the video was hot.

Upgrade!

to 101) LOL

em, wtf? ciara? ciara has been dancing like a boy since she came out, nothing has changed. she just had the sense to make a song about it.

now speaking of copying, she copied janet and micheal, nothing new.

she also copied that lesbian segment that have been wanting to be a boy. so what is new.

this video is hot
unlikely collabo but it works
i like the concept of not being able to tell them apart with the similar styling and cuts to them dancing.
i remember when concreteloop first posted this without shakira and people said that beyonce was copying shakira, not knowing that it was designed to be a duet with her.
hahahahahaha people on here crack me up

to 101) LOL

just say you hate beyonce already and stop looking for excuses

All the hataz could just stay off of Beyonce’s shit damn! It’s funny how almost half the people commenting on BEYONCE are hataz. Dont like her then STAY OFF HER SHIT!If you really don’t like Beyonce then you wouldn’t have click on the video, or even comment 4 the most part.cuz I know I hate Rhianna and I dont know a damn thang bout her but yall”hataz” are over here writing FACTS about Beyonce that i dont even know and I like her.You know you like Beyonce, it ain that hard 2 addmit.#58, I 100% agree.

The video is not enhanced. I slowed it down on my TiVo. Why do people have to tear people down for no reason? If you don’t like it, say you don’t like it. Don’t go trying to make up shit.

Then Stacey. Why did you have to post 20 times to prove just how much you don’t like Beyonce. Damn, we knew the first 5 times. BTW your links don’t work. & turn that TV off and do your homework.

Anyway, i like the song, and the video is def. hot. Good career move.

Beyonce and Shakuria don’t look shyt alike, u foolz would say a roach and a turd resemble because they’re both brown, lawdy.

they both look a like i wonder how they got together in created the song knowing their styles is different but they both were hitting their hips U GO GIRLS

#106 Enjoi:

LOL - I remember that. It does start like that. Somebody could easily do a parody of this video. It’s hot though.

#110 agree. If people don’t like her fine, then say “I DON”T LIKE THE B$TCH!” then move on. The fans only get upset when someone comes on here and try to knock her down by saying she copying, she fake, she can’t sing, she ghetto, she can’t dance, she always looks the same, her father paid for it, she this she that. Haters spend too much time picking out things you would think Beyonce hit their puppy then back up twice then hit it again. Get over it already.

Shakira doesnsn’t seem to mind so why are you people on Bee’s shit. BACK UP!

Check out this article…

http://i44.photobucket.co...ssboss82/seeingdouble.jpg

#107, i agree

#29 that was the whole idea of making the song together and singing with Shakira to try and outdo her in the video and song. Shakira has more sex appeal as far as how she moves and dances! Beyonce’s trying to get like her and I’m not buying it! That girl is wack I swear!

to 111)

LOLOL

i like the part “… and do your homework”

one more thing, i know people have already said this but it amazes me why if you hate someone you could stand watching their stuff, learn everything about them so you can argue with us “stans” and then waste your time commenting.

i have no feelings (note i don’t like or hate) for rihanna, ciara. so i don’t waste my time going into their post, what is my business with them, and even if i go there, i only comment IF i like the stuff i see there because i don’t have precious time to give to them.

@96

Umm…she copied Kelis’ “Caught Out There” with that wack ass “Ring The Alarm”

This SONG IS GARBAGE!!!! What the f*ck is she talking about with a “Beautiful Liar” I could barely make out them stupid ass lyrics. The video is boring as hell with them low productions, she must’ve spent all her money on those other boring videos cause this looks like it was done in the back of a wal-mart. Call me a hater (but the ones that call people haters for voicing their opinion, are STANS!!!)all you damn well want but this is the type of sh!t that is ruining r&b.

hmmmm….i like Beyonce (i thought her & jhud were great at the Oscars although most on CL did not) i like Shakira (& yea usually she has more passion and fire when singing in Spanish, but i guess she gotta get that crossover money) BUT i am NOT feelin this video. maybe it’ll grow on me though i doubt it

Maybe its just me. I mean I love my light skinned sisters & I have a light skinned sister but damn a WHOLE video with this “WOW! Dont I look like Shakira” concept was a little annoying for me.

wtf i need to be confused watchin a video tryna guess is that Bey or Shakira. When i watch a Beyonce video I wanna know its her even on a collabo, shyt!

i dont need 3 minutes of a black woman seemin sooooo damn giddy to pass for somethin other than black. maybe i’m tripping but it is still Black History Month Dammit!

Loved the video. GO Beyonce and Shakira. They should have performed this at the Grammy’s together.

to 119)
let’s assume that beyonce ONLY invited shakira for a dance off and only sang with jennifer at the oscar also for a dance off.

at least she is smart enough to fight with talented dancer and singer instead of some lousy dancer and singer.

that is why i like beyonce she goes for the difficult.

BUT, people are so dumb not to realise that shakira is very big in europe and south america, so she is trying to appeal to that area. they are looking at personal issues. B is trying to make more money, who has time to be fighting.

Vari, the video is more of a smoke and mirrors, are you really seeing what seeing type concept video. I dont think it really was all about race and skin color. #101, please literally cut the BS.

Love,Peace,&&Honeyy

HOW FAR UP ARE YALL?….WHAT FLOOR?….CUS BEE IS USING YALL HATERS AS “ELEVATORS”…MAD CUS SHE’S STYLIN ON YA? LMAO…CHECK!

Yesssssssssss! Work Out B!!!! Fuck what ya heard, this hoe could be clappin here hands thru the whole fuckin video and still give me LIFE!! I love it……. Now can you leak the rest of the videos??

I agree with 124. I mean really. Stop being desperate in trying to find fault.

Love,Peace,&&Honeyy

^^^ and u say u not a hater how can u say ciara has been doin the same dances ciara dances are not the same she can do do all types of dancing from gyrating her hips like shakira 2 more choreographic dancing like janet so please

I NOTICE BEYONCE TRYING BELLY DANCE LIKE SHAKIRA, NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.I THINK BEYONCE WORKED WITH HER BECAUSE SHE IS TRYING TO TRAMPLE HER, THANK GOD SHAKIRA DID NOT LET THAT HAPPEN, THE VIDEO WAS O.K , SHAKIRA DID HER THING. SAME THING AT THE OSCARS WHEN BEYONCE WAS TRYING TO OVER JENIFER HUDSON, JENIFER DID NOT LET THAT HAPPEN.

DIS VIDEO IS DA BANG BANG
MA GAWD DEY BOTH LOOK SO CHOONG
DAMN

aND ONE MORE THING : BEYONCE WHY DON’T U DO THEM BELLY DANCES FOR JAY-Z SO HE WON’T LEAVE UR ASS, HE IS ALREADY LEAVIN IT.

to 129) Ms.D

you are the one who came to BEYOnce’s post to use ciara as an example, i am only pointing out that EVERYBODY copies everybody, EVEN MICHEAL COPIED JAMES BROWN(i know it is hard for you to believe,LOL)

i bet james brown copied someone from the streets he was leaving it. it is called INSPIRATION.

i don’e like ciara so i would not comment on her segment, BUT i have the sense to acknowledge that she is the best in cherographed dances since janet(which she got inspiration from), but beyonce is spontanous, you can’t beat that.

ok i love ciara’s popping.LOL

don’t like the song or the 80’s lookin video

You people are so desperate you make me laugh. I swear people need to really give it a rest.*Cough,cough* #130,131.

Love,Peace,&&Honeyy

They do look alike…but this video is GARBAGE!

ive been saying for YEARS that they look alike and you can really tell in this video.

the song is garbage but nice video.

Personally, I don’t see what the hype is all about. The video is okay, a little boring, and the song is boring. It’ll only make it high on the charts because it’s Beyonce and Shakira. Nothing spectacular. My opinion.

I expected something out of this world the way majority of the people here are talking.

DAMNNNN B GON DUN IT AGAINNNNNNN!!!! that video was FIYAHHHHHHHHHHHH!! Shakira n B were workin it like crazyy.. has anyone got anymore leaks?…. L

to 139. An

now, this is an example of commenting, he/she stated clearly hi/her feelings about the video without bringing beyonce’s personal business about whether beyonce hates shakira, or mama and papa knowles.

damn beyonces got one phat azz. show me more

to 139. An

now, this is an example of commenting, he/she stated clearly hi/her feelings about the video without bringing beyonce’s personal business about whether beyonce hates shakira, or mama and papa knowles.

Okay why all the look alike comments, they don’t look a like at all each lady has their own unique features. The song is okay and theirs a small dancing part that from the comments I thought was going to really be something spectacular but it was okay and the video was decent. I think that they each do better in their own video because when they are together they kind of cancel each other out.

El Chico is Mine, II.

Somebody produced the phuuuuuuugggggggggg out of that video! Is it Hype Williams?????

johnosahon1 said:
——————————————————

to 139. An

now, this is an example of commenting, he/she stated clearly hi/her feelings about the video without bringing beyonce’s personal business about whether beyonce hates shakira, or mama and papa knowles

I agree too! If you like, love it, or hate it just keep it moving, the whole family speculation is old and tired now!

didn’t like the song or the cheap looking beyonce

papa knowles had to tame shakira down for this. can’t have her outdance the h*ll outta beyonce

in the little dance break, they used shakira’s body twice to make up for bey’s inability to move her hips. i saw frozen shots of this on the net. lol!

they both look lovely though

LOL at bey trying to pop out her booty at the time. dang girl…nothing’s there. accept it and move on!

Damn watching this video I could’nt tell them apart…

Too many of y’all are simple. Beyonce’s manager doesn’t have as much pull as y’all give him. If he wasn’t Beyonce’s father, y’all wouldn’t know his name.

Clearly, this video was produced so that the two would be “mirror images” of each other. Beyonce is on top her game, Shakira is on top of her game - sounds like a SMART MOVE to me. Making history, and this will cross both of them over. $$$$$$$$$$$$$

Are there still intellectually gifted people of color, or did they stop being born after 1979?

pure hate. No one ever copied shakira. Why would she want to copy someone who can’t sing? lol….beyonce’s voice is in a whole nother level. She actually released a solo version of “Beautiful LIar:” without shakira on it. And she says BEYONCE BEYONCE is SASHA is SASHA! that is a baaad bitch lol. She blows the track up, and for the shakira version she had to actually tone her vocals down so it wouldn’t look like she was upstaging her. Ya’ll need to get ur shit together. beyonce’s the queen