i’m first..i’m first!!!..imma have to roll with Ashanti on this 1 hands down

I think nessa’ rocked it better!

Ashanti rocked it better, she has a better shape. Vanessa still looks nice though.

That dress is not really that hot but Ashanti rocked it better.Vanessa is box shaped and has chicken legs not a good look I might add.

Uh…. Vanessa

Vanessa, only because I don’t think the dress would fit at a Fashion Week event.

Vanessa M. did it better! Ashanti, sorry boo.

uhm i think vanessa

Ashanti rocked it better. But Vanessa’s shoes are cuter.

Niether one! That DRESS is FUGLY as HELL!

It’s February…why are chicks still running around dressed like Thanksgiving turkeys…? I am just asking…

definitly ashanti
her skin looks good with the color

I agree about Vanessa’s body…she anit got no body and She has shoulder’s of a man…Her upper body is wider than her lower body…ewww

Ashanti looks much better in that dress.

Ashanti-all the way

OMG FOR ONCE ASHANTI LOOKS GOOD AS HELL AND SHE ROCKED IT WAYYYYYYYY BETTER THEN VANESSA…GO ASHANTI YOU SHALL SHINE IN DIS POST FOR A CHANGE LOL

ashanti

Ashanti rocked it!! She has more curves. It looks like a sheet of paper on that chick that go with Jessica Simpson’s left overs.

Ashanti

Vanessa all the way…I wanna fuck the shit outta her
besides Ashanti always likes so hairy

I would say Ashanti, because she has more curves to fill out the dress.

I have to go with Ashanti

i have to give this one to ashanti she win this hands down they are both beautiful celebs but ashanti got her in this one!

This is pretty damn close to a tie for me. I like Vanessa’s shoes a little better but Imma still go with my gurl Ashanti.

vannesa all the way , i’am stil mad at ashantie for Stilling sexy ass nelly from me .

this is a hard one….we all know that Ashanti IS phat!

ASHANTI!

The dress is nice and it looks nice on both, but Ashanti rocked it better with her curves.

Ashanti rocked it better, But vanessa shoes were alot better ashantis shoes looks really cheap like she got them from BIG T bazzar…LOL

Ashanti–she’s got better curves and better accesories.

Ashanti looks better just becaus she has a coke shape were as Vannessa is more boxed shaped. But both look great, big ups to the women of color doing it!!

Ashanti gets 2 thumbs up. Her hairstyle compliments the dress perfectly & she’s wearing just the right amount of accessories (love the bracelet) to make the outfit complete. Unfortunately Vanessa’s body type (no hips) makes this dress look shapeless but her shoes are the better choice for this outfit.

All you people choosing Vanessa ought to be ASHAMED!!! I mean, she looks a hot mess in that!

I really don’t do Ashanti. . . but she is working that dress. . . and KILLING Vanessa!

Ashanti has the hips to wear form-fitted dresses; all the dress does on Vanessa is emphasize the fact that her bottom half has no shape–not cute.

Ashanti rocked it better, but Vanessa stilettos look better.

I doo like Vanessa’s shoes better…but she still looks horrible in that dress…It’s like I want to inflate her hips or something

You can’t be serious? Assanti non talented a$$ rocked it better. The other chick ain’t even built right!

Gotta go with Ashanti. Vanessa’s a pretty girl, but she always manages to look tacky somehow.

Ashanti. She has a curvier body. What is a VJ?

Ashanti.

Ashanti looks better, yet Vanessa has better shoes…the only reason I couldn’t pick Vanessa is because of the boy hips, not a good look ma…

I think Ashanti rocked it better! Vanessa should’ve picked better shoes

ashanti. she’s got better curves than vanessa

@ whoever asked what a vj was- it’s a video jockey. same thing as DJ, except with videos

Ashanti.

ASHANTI ROCKED IT WAY BETTER IT LOOKS GRATE ON HER ND HER HAIR FITS B/C ITS NOT SO POOFY. ND PLEEEZ STOP WIT DAT SHE’S HAIRY SHYT IT’S GETTIN OLD!

DAMN..I THINK THIS IS LIKE THE FIRST TIME BOTH PEOPLE ROCKED IT WELL..ITS USUALLY EASY TO DECIDE..THEY BOTH LOOK GOOD

THEY BOTH ROCK’D IT
NEITHER ONE IS BETTER THAN THE OTHER…MY OPINION

Ashanti rocked it better but she should have had on Vanessa’s shoes.

I pick Ashanti. Those chickenhead legs are not looking good for Vanessa…at all!

ASHANTI ROCK THIS WAY BETTER

Gotta be Shantiii

Defintely Ashanti. She has lost a few pounds, so this dress works for her and it compliments her shape well. Vanessa looks alright in it, but I’ve seen better from her…

UHM…..ASHANTI!!!VANESSA HAS NO SHAPE!!!!

Defintely Ashanti. She has lost a few pounds, so this dress works for her and it compliments her shape well. Vanessa looks alright in it, but I’ve seen better from her…

I think the dress is cute. I also think Ashanti rocked it better. She has more curves to fill up that dress and it goes well with her skintone. I like Vanessa’s shoes better but that dress looks like it’s going to fall off of her.

Ashanti all day.

ima say ashanti, but vanessas shoes look better..

Vanessa has better shoes….Ashanti wore the dress better.

Ashanti hands down my boo is sexy

Vanessa has better shoes…but Ashanti wore it better.

I’m gonna have to give this honor to Ashanti!!

Of course Ashanti! She filled out the dress better. U gotta have body to work a dress like that.

ashanti has the best shape in the dress.

vanessa’s shoes are cuter.

Vanessa, her shoes look better too.

I’ma have to say “Shanti.” It’s not often, but she definitely ROCKED IT!

Sorry homegirl!

vanessa

ASHANTI. HANDS DOWN!
It look like she can’t breathe..
but that girl Vannessa body is bad! (awful, funny shaped, horrid) That kind of bad. Those broad shoulders. ugh!

Ashanti! She just compliments the dress better. But Vannessa is always flawless.

they look about the same

i think ashanti has a lil more curve in the hip, but i like vanessa’s shoes better

hmm…it’s a tie

VANESSA

Ashanti

AHANTI hands down

Ashanti for SURE.

SHANTI!

SHANTI!

I know that’s the angle Ashanti took the photo, but she looks like she got one arm. She rocked the dress better though.

This dress is ugly as heck. I said that when I saw Vanessa in it at the awards BUT Ashanti does look better in it. She fills it out nicely.

Ashanti to me she is rocking it better with the curves that dress gives vanessa no body shape at all her shoes are cuter than ashanti’s though lol

I know that’s the angle Ashanti took photo, but she looks like she has one arm. She rocked the dress better though.

I’m not usually impressed by Ashanti, but she won, hands down.

Definitely my girl Ashanti rocked it better.

Vanessa has a swimmers body…not a good look in this dress.

I THINK ASHANTI ROCK’D IT BETTER. SHE HAS MORE CURVES TO FILL OUT THE DRESS MORE AND HER JEWELRY IS BOMB!!

Asanti rocked it better. Angel La, when posting pics to compare who looks best, it’s always better to show pics facing towards the camera. This allows everyone to analyze and judge better.

Vanessa

Ashanti rocked it better

Ashanti rocked it better.

Cut Ashitties neck off, and she wins. Her body is bangin!

This dress looks better on Ashanti. It compliments her skin tone and she fill it out well. Vanessa does not have the body

Ashanti, she actually fills out the dress.

Id go with Ashanti cause she fills it out better.

Id go with Ashanti cause she fills the dress out better.

Ashanti hands down!

Ashanti although Vanessa’s shoes are cuter.

ASHANTI…(YEAH BABE), LMAO!!

They both look really cute. I’d go with Vanessa.

ASHANTI OF COURSE.

Hey you guys are hurting my feelings cuz i have a bod like vanessa :-

my girl ashanti looked way better get it girl

if Vanessa Williams ever had a long lost love child it would be Vanessa Minnillo!She look just like Vanessa W in Ugly Betty. All orange & fine looking

btw Ashanti rocked it better with her thickums

GO HEAD

ashanti

^^^ Well now you know what not to wear.

Accentuate the positive and not the negative…

ashanti looks better in the dress and vanessa has better shoes.

Shani rocked this one real good. I love her shoes.

ASHANTI WORKED IT

Both look really great.

I like Ashantis shape better in the dress. But the dress isnt that cute.

Ashanti baby!!

Is it just me, or is it a tie on this one?

They both look mad good to me wearing that dress

ashanti’s shape fills it out better, but vanessa looks good too! but not better than ashanti in this dress

Ashanti looks much better Vanessa has no shape.Her body goes straight down not a curve seen anywhere.Ashanti is thick and has hips.She looks like a woman in the dress while Vanessa looks like a boy with hair.

Oh damn! Ashanti!

Ashanti…all day!

ASHANTI all the way. Vanessa looks like a stick.

ASHANTI all the way. Vanessa looks like a stick.

I think Ashanti wears the dress better because she fills it out better but Vanessa looks very pretty as well.

I say Ashanti cause she fills the dress out more they both look nice though.

I MISS CL CHAT……..

Ashanti..she has better shoes and I like the bracelet.

vanessa rocked it better

shanti look bettah evn though her expression is kinda fucked

ASHANTI

they both look nice but it fits ashanti better. I have small hips too so vanessa should shift her weight to one side more so it will put more empahsis on her hips.

Well this is easy umm Ashanti! Vanessa doesn’t have the bottom to hold that dress up sorry.

OOOOh baby….OOOOOOH BABY
OOOOOOO BABY!!!!!

Ashanti most def

ashanti for sure. vanessa looks like a pencil

i think ashanti looks better, simply beacuse of the fitting of the dress. she has the general body structure to make the dress look good. tho vanessa is pretty, she has a weird figure, no hips. Hips dont lie

Ashanti rocked that dress better, vanessa looks egghh in that dress.

ITS A TIE..

ashanti got the hips for the dress… she rocked it better…

This isn’t even fair, Ashanti all day! You can’t even compare the two, I mean seriously!

Ashanti rocked it better .Ashanti has a shape and Vanessa has no hips:) I do agree that Vanessas shoes are better ,and well Ashanti maybe should have purchased a shoe size bigger and a better shoe to really set off that gorgeous dress the right way!

ASHANTI ALL THE WAY AND SHE CAN NEVA B HAIRY ANYMORE AND SHE IS GOING 2 RULE “07″ SO THE HATERS CAN SUCK MA D%CK

Vanessa rock’d it better, but Ashanti looks nice,too.

Vanessa!!!…you guys think Ashanti got more curves maybe by the way the photographer photographed her in a different position. Sorry Vanessa is hot!

They both killed it but Ashanti got a slight edge.

Ashanti No Doubt

Ashanti!

‘Shanti

Ashanti!

ashanti….

Ashanti has the better shape, Vanessa has the better shoes.
Final Answer: Ashanti

Imma Say My Baby Ashanti Rocked It Better She Looks Hott!!! Vanessa Look nice but ashanti lookz better!!

Ashanti got this

Ashanti All Day!!!

07 will Be INCredible

Ashanti hands down……….she fit the dress better!! look @ them curves

ashanti no doubt!

OK um, why is there even a comparision? Its Ashanti hands down! Dont get me wrong, Vanessa looks good too, BUT… we all know Ashanti got this on lock!

CANT WAIT TILL LATER THIS YEAR SHANY YOU GONNA BE DOING IT!

“ONLY YOU” CAN WEAR THIS DRESS!

Well my real name is Vanessa but I still gotta go with my dog Ashanti! Thats my DOG! (BARK BARK) Love that girl man! Ashanti got the body and everything. I even like her shoes even the Vanessa’s are alittle better, shany’s are nice too. Ashanti wore the dress first anyway. Just how when she wore that other goldish tanish dress first before Beyonce did. Seems like people like to dress like her. She always look good anyway.

ASHANTI!

kool

Ashanti rocked it better.

definately Ashanti..Vanessa’s figure and legs are horrible

The dress looks nice on both of them, but I’m going to have to go with Ashanti.

Ashanti, no question.

Ashanti definitely. Vanessa has no curves.

vanessa needs some hips… that dress is not flattering on her. ashanti got this one.

EQUAL=TYE

this is a very old pic of Ashanti, like two years old… so she not running around now with the dress on… Ashanti looks better, her legs and shape, but Vanessa looks nice too..

ashanti,but venessa looks good still

Ashanti rocked it Better. She feels the dress out more.

Olympus Fashion Week - Badgley Mishka (September 14, 2005)- Ashanti wore this two years ago, this pic is on her site…

http://gallery.ashantidai...s.php?album=11&page=1

see how old pic is for those that want to know why they wearing this is February

Ashanti’s got that one (womanly shape) … but Nessa looks good too.

For those who voted Vanessa…what is wrong your eyes?!

Vanessa is pretty and all, but that dress does not compliment her shape atal!!!

Hands down…Ashanti rocked it!

Ashanti

Ashanti looks better just because she got a blk girl shape …and im a sista…sooo…Ashanti all the way..
P.S the otha girl dont have a shape at all…

Most definitely Ashanti.

Ashanti- Hands down!

ashanti anyday!!!she got the curves which is just perfect for the dress…got nice legs too!!vanessa got a white ladys body and got chicken legs!!not soo sexy at all….next!!

ASHANTI: it complements her skintone and is a nice cut on her curvy body. The gold is too close to Vanessa’s tanned complexion and she doesn’t have enough curves for this type of dress. I do like her shoes better though.

it a tie they both look beautiful

both ladies are pretty, but Ashanti looks better in the dress b/c she has a nicer figure. Of course some cosmo magazine or the other would probably vote vanessa the better dressed, but what the f*** do they know.

Ashanti fills the dress out much better.

ASHANTI ROCKED THIS FIT!!!

ASHANTI, ASHANTI, ASHANTI!!! That other girl looks awful. Where are her hips?!

i know this is totally off topic but did anyone see the Ray J sex tape its on bossip.com !

Ma gal Ashanti all the way…the curves are there…cute shoes vannesa…

a gurl Ashanti all the way…the curves r there, nice shoes Vannesa…

It’s a tie both girls look smashing regardless of shape!

Ashanti

Ashanti has the better body for that dress. It does nothing for Vanessa and her skin looks the same color as the dress. Vanessa body looks deformed in that dress.

Ashanti won this one…Vanessa has stick legs. That is not a good look.

I think Ashanti rocked it better, but they both look pretty tho

Ya’ll might as well say my girl Ashanti won this round.

Ashanti!

Snanti!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ashanti…Her Body Suites It Better…Both Complexions Go Well….But Vannesa`s Shoes Are Better All In All=Ashanti.

I agree with those who say Ashanti rocked it bettery. She looks like a woman, Vanessa looks like a boy. She has no hip/waist definition and her legs don’t look good.

Ashanti wins this one.

I’m 26th, but who cares?? Ashanti gets my vote.

Oops! I mean 187! uh-oh

Ashanti

Ashanti!

Tie
They both look nice!

Why is Ashanti always caught wearing what someone else wwas/is wearing or vice versa? Where ever she shops…she better stop!

Ashanti takes this one by a land slide,Sorry nessa she just rock it betta

it’s a tie u both lose…. haha naw i’d sooner vote for andre leon talley or ms. jay than these to gyals haha

192 Ashanti wore it first & she wore the OTHER out-fit before Beyonce. So what are you talking about?

I’m not sure…I think they both suck in the dress…It looks too small on Ashanti and Vanessa doesn’t have the body for it…so if I HAVE to choose, I guess Ashanti.

ashanti

ASHANTii!!!

They both look horrible but if I had to choose it would def. be Ashanti cuz that another one realli IS box shaped :/

Vanessa - I liked her shoes more with the dress.

Ashanti looks much nicer.

No. 5 you hit it right on the nose.

Um, to #192, Ashanti was wearing the dress first you fool! Its Ashanti hands down!

Ashanti! Vanessa legs are soo damn skinny. EW

shauni def rocked it betta! I wonder when her cd is coming out.

Wow,

I looove that dress. Ashanti rocked it better. But I think that if Vannessa would have been standing at the same angle as Ashanti, it would look about the same on them.

Id Say Shanti,plus her shoes are cute!

I’ll have to go with Miss Asahnti, she tore that carpet up she did her thang look at her,just gorgeous

I’ll have to go with miss Ashanti on this one she posed better and have better lookin skin she atethat carpet up she did her thang on dis one sorry Vanessa

ashanti rock it better you wanna know y………..

none,that dress is horrific.

Ashanti looks beautiful, so does Vanessa…but Ashantis body wins in the dress hands down. Plus I don’t appreciate Vanessa dating Nick two seconds after he cheated on and divorced J. Simpson.

Hands down Ashanti rocked it better!

surprisingly, I’ma have to say Ashanti. She just fills the dress out better. But I agree with poster #10: it is fugly…

Vanessa, bc her toes aren’t hanging over the front of her shoes…and her shoes don’t look as bad either.

ASHANTI///IM FEELING THE SHOES BOO !!!!

I don’t like her that much, but Ashanti.

Ashanti!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Was the question a serious one?

I think thay ashanti rocked it better. Vanessa has no body what so ever. Ashanti has hip and but no 2 b gay or anything but sorry Vanessa u still pretty though

HEY PEEPS I GOTTA GIVE IT TO ASHANTI CUZ IM HER #1 FAN SHE THA SHIT BUT OLD GURL REALLY PRETTY IN THAT DRESS I THINK THA DRESS LOOK BETTER ON ASHANTI CUZ SHE’S THICKER THEN NICOLE

first of all i know thatn ashanti is not phat and i think ashanti is rocking that dress.