I love both of these ladies, love both of their versions, both of their voices, but I voted for Miss Thang. So I’m downloading the version with both of their vocals! Love their true 90s sounds. I miss those times.

Mo’s is better.

Fantasia did too much. I think she could record it better, though.

I don’t like the song, and I’m tired of Missy screaming all over the track. All you can remember is Missy’s screams. She’s gotta do a better job of stamping her productions.

I actually liked both different verisons of their songs. I feel that the both of them are talented and wonderful artists. But if I had to pick one it would have to be Monica’s voice because I feel as though her voice fit the song and her voice goes along with the rhythm and the melody of the song. It’s not unbalanced or anything like that. Fanstaisa’s voice was great on this track as well and I like her voice. But I would have to say Monica.

Actually i have changed my mind i prefer monica’s subtle mellow tones fantasia on the other hand murdered the song with her over-the-top vocal acrobatics.

I have to ride with Fantasia on this one.

Although, I like Monica as an artist more…. Fantasia clearly took her shine on this song.

Ohhhhh. You’ll put 2 of my favorite artists up against each other? Dayuummm this is going to be hard. Ok. I think both of them did a dayum good job but Tasia has a totally different vibe than Monica. I would like to hear the version of these two together on the song b/c I know it is straight FIYAH! My vote…I really don’t know. LOL

I like both, but I prefer Monica’s version better. Her voice just so smooth and sensual, and I think it fits the track better.

MONICA HANDS DOWN….WITH TASIA EVERY SONG HAS A CHUCRH CHOIR FEELING TO IT.

Foxxy, I downloaded the version with both of them, because I couldn’t decide.

Miss Tasia got this one!

Fantasia sounds better singing it but it was clearly written by Missy for Monica and based on a demo sang by Monica. The vocal arrangements are Monica (not even Missy as normally happens) all over.

@RNB, how was that version? I didn’t even see that CL had the version with both of them. Did they just add it? Well, I’m going to listen to it now. Thanks!

Fantasia all the way!!!!!

Man both of them did the damn thing on this song but really you can’t even compare these two artist. They both have different sounds and really its all gonna boil down to who’s sound do you like better. Cuz to me no one sang this song better than the other. They just sang it differently from each other.

I love and support these ladies the same. They both have beautiful unique voices but, I liked Fantasia’s version better. Most definately hot!

I got to give it up for Fantasia… Monica is doing her thing but Fantasia is in a different league. The girl is tight, hands down!!!! With that said she gets my vote…

i love both versions. but i’m gonna ride with my girl fantasia on this one. i don’t know what it is about her voice but she can get it from me anytime. i’ll blow her back out. my bad, gettin a little carried away over here. peace

I like em both…But Fantasia is my girl she is sooo emotive!! she can interpret the hell outta some lyrics!! Although I think the song fits Monica’s voice better….but she only sounds as good as the material and the song isn’t all that hot…Fanny on the other hand could make the damn phone book sound hott!!

Ii’s very good, Foxxy. I am putting it on my iPod before I go to my history class.

They should make it a duet, they both sound good on it.

hmm i dont really like the song but tastia brought more than monica

luv the song and both girls did their thing

so right. DUET!!!

I am going with monica she is hot no matter what nobody say.

I love them both but I have to go with Fantasia On this one she put more feeling into it Monica was basically just singing the song just to sing it!

I like the one with both of them

Tasia, got this one hands down!!!!!!!!

Both versions were good but as someelse said the song fit Monica better. i like Fantasia first verse part of the song and the end doin her vocal runs. Missy’s joints is the business she’s a genius and underrated. Too bad Monica’s “A Dozen Roses” by Missy wasn’t a hit. Thought it was a good song. The public just don’t like her new hood image

Forget those two singers!!! I know exactly what sound Missy is trying to get…and she needs Brandy or Mya’s vocals on that joint!

both of em are really good and talented, but i hafta give it to Monica! she is so beautiful too, not that that has nething to do with it..just wanted to throw that in there. lol

fantasia sounds better for sure i had to listen twice

Fantasia did that! Her version is way better. I’m fans of the both of them but, Fantasia’s voice is alittle stronger on that one.

damn i dont even like mantasia but ive gotta say she did a much better job on this one.

MONICa sounds better…her voices fits it perfectly!

i’m gonna have to go with fantasia because monica’s kind of bored me, even though i love her voice too. tasia’s just has that special edge for me

Tasia put her foot in it!!!!

I love the fantasia version, half way through the monica version i was bored

Monica and Fani Both did that shit forl!!!!!
But I gotta go wit mo, she sexy n her voice is flawless

Fantasia all the way, baby!

Okay Monica kept it cool and she put it down, BUT Fantasia snatched this one up!

FANTASIA HANDS DOWN! MONICA IS BORING

They are both wonderful woman with lovely voices but I love Monica’s version…her voice is so melodic…..the song has a feel good feel to it…makes you want to go to a cook out with your family and jus dance the day away!

FANTASIA

Fantasia killed it! Sorry Monica Fantasia OWNED you on this song!!

MONICA….I don’t need to hear Tasia’s version…B/c when I first heard Monica’s version a while back, I fell in love with it….But I am going to peep Fantasia’s version, but I don’t like a lot of Tasia’s material…..Not saying I don’t like her or her singing…B/c I do….

I liked them both.

FANTASIA B. GOT THIS ONE, SHE BRINGS THAT EMOTION AND EDGE TO IT, MONICA VERSION WAS HOTT DONT’ GET ME WRONG HER VERSION WAS MELLOW AND SOULFUL. WITH FANTASIA BROUGHT EMOTION AND RAW SOUL TO IT!!!!!

SO FANTASIA SHOULD DEF GET IT, BUT I CAN LISTEN TO BOTH!!!

I LIKE BOTH OF THEM, & MISSY KILLED THE BEAT. BUT I WOULD HAVE TO SAY THAT MONICAS IS BETTER, THE SONG FITS HER VOICE, I DONT KNOW WHY IT WASNT ON HER ALBUM.
BUT IF SHES SAVING IT FOR SOMEONE I WOULD SAY BRANDY, SHE COULD PULL OFF A SONG LIKE THAT. IF AALIYAH WAS STILL ALIVE SHE WOULDVE TORE IT UP THOUGH, CUZ IT DOES HAVE AN AALIYAH FEEL TO IT DONT YOU THINK? ESPECIALLY AT THE CHORUS, SHE WOULDVE KILLED IT.

R.I.P BABY GIRL

Love Fannie, but I gotta give this one to Monica…Monica and Missy have kinda trademarked that sound, so it doesn’t translate well to Fantasia.

Still love, ‘Tasia, though.

Fantasia easily better, she rocked the F%&k OUTTA THAT JOINT, wow fantasia has done it again, one of the best voices the whole has to offer

my vote goes to my babymama fantasia

fantasty can sing to me any night, fantasia fo sho, monica is still good though

I HAVE TO SAY MONICA’S VERSION BECAUSE THIS SONG GIVES A MELLOW VIBE WHICH SHOWS OFF MONICA’S VOCALS. TASIA IS DOING TOO MANY ADLIBS AND TAKES AWAY FROM THE SONG. WHICH I MUST SAY IS A GOOD BALLROOM SONG

I liked both..got to give it to Tasia…

TASIA

they both do it well….They should just the song together and shut this R&B game down!!!!!!!

Again it looks like everyone wants a competition. I believe that Missy intended to drop the song with them singing together….not against each other. How can you judge two very different styles? They sound nice and make the song complete when it is sync’d together. Missy is a genuis and knows very well what she is doing!
One Love
Queen

FANTASIA, FANATSIA, FANTASIA

I think Fantasia sounds better.

MS. Tasia’s version is better. Monica gave a good song but not great.

well, if i can be brutally honest. Fantasia is just superb while Monica bores me to tears.

I liked Fantasia’s ……gives it more character, but I think they both couldve pulled it off!!

I got to give it up for Fanny, she doing it up. No disrespect to Monica, but I think Fanny killed this song. Just like she killing them with “When I See U”… Big things are happening for Fantasia in 2007. I still respect Monica, though.

Ms. Juicy Lips, gets my vote. With her sexy ass.

Monica, you know I love you right. And you know I will never do anything to hurt you(intentionally) But I’ve met someone new. Yeah, you know her she the one with the big ass booty down the street. Yeah one more thing I’m voting for Fantasia. Peace. Ay, Fantasia make a brotha a sandwich.

fantasia wuz better

tasia hands down

I like both ladies but it’s obvious that Fantasia song it better. She put her soul into everything she sing. You can feel every emotion when she sing. She just got the voice that makes the hair on the back of your neck stand up.

Two of the realest sisters in the game. Dang this is hard!

I voted for Fantasia but, I think Monica’s version is cool.

So maybe I will vote for them both—is that cheating??

I don’t know but, they both did well.

Ms. Lady Tasia is #1. Chocolate and thick what more can you ask for.

I would groove to Monica’s version in the bedroom, and bump Tasia’s version in the Lex

…but if I had to make a choice it would be MONICA because i’m in a mellow type mood right now. else, it would be TASIA all the way!

FANTASIA tore that shit up for real! I was bored in the middle of Monica’s so I started cleaning out my keyboard. Fantasia got it I was doing my two step!

TASIA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Both artists have exceptional talent. I love them both and usually never go against Monica 4 nobody cause she got that real dirty south flava. But I must say Tasia got this one.