WHICH SONG IS BETTER? LE’CHE VS. AMERIE
Monday, May 7, 2007

You may remember a while back (and I do mean a while - this may be for the throwback CL’ers!), I posted a song by Le’Che Martin, of Making the Band 3 fame. She was a contestant that didn’t get to the finals, but she’s been working her way through the industry, writing and selling songs. Last summer, she collaborated with Rich Harrison and Rico Love with the song, “Get Away,” which was featured on the CL Summer Mixtape. I absolutely loved the song and fell immediately for Le’Che’s delivery. I was under the impression that the song was to be sold. However, when previewing the Amerie album, I noticed that the same Rich Harrison track had been recycled, and the lyrics changed. Immediately, I was turned off because I was so used to Le’Che’s version, however, that’s not to say that I didn’t think Amerie’s song wasn’t a good song… I was a little surprised, considering I remember reading somewhere that Amerie wouldn’t be working with Rich Harrison this time around - and technically, she didn’t, ’cause this track’s been done. Which song do you prefer?
Le’Che Martin feat. Rico Love - Get Away (full) - download
Amerie - Hate2LoveU (full) - download
Make sure you check out Le’Che Martin’s MySpace page, and show her some love. Tell her Brian from CL sent you. Also, Amerie’s album, “Because I Love It” is due out May 15, according to Amazon.com.








64 Comments
1.
L. Datz it
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
amerie..
2.
andrea
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
i’d say amerie
3.
lashonda
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
err NUMBER 1 she only jus put this story up like a second ago so how can u tell. LMAOOOOOOO
4.
lashonda
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
oh i meant “he”. sorry Brian
5.
andrea
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
i’m listening to it still and i’m starting to lean towards le’chie. i’m a little silly i didn’t realize they would have the same beats and i heard amerie’s first but i like le’chie’s vocal work over thr track a lot better.
6.
jewel13
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
#3 you mean he put it up.
But I’ll say Le’che since she did it first and has a lot more vocal strength than Amerie.
7.
DreDre
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
I think my boo Amerie should leave this one alone. it sounds like sometin she did in the past. Let shawty have it. I would like to see amerie hook up with pharrell for some beats. Timmy makes good beats too.
8.
L. Datz it
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
heard it b4. number 3
9.
NEWORLEANS_FINEST_CANDI
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
AMERIE FA SHO! SHE IS SOOOOOOOOO PRETTY! CANT WAIT FOR THE NEW ALBUM, BECAUSE I LOVE IT…….ALREADY!
10.
LikeThatYall
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
Le’Che looks like a man.
11.
Josh R
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
THey both sound horrible. Le Cha no no, and Amerie HELL no.
12.
Bella
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
Ok I loves me some Amerie but this doesnt seem right, I mean wasnt it the other girls’s song?
13.
compton_chick23
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
Brian The Clutch wrote Amerie’s version.
I like Le’Che’s version better. But I do like Amerie’s too. They’re both good.
14.
Nyland Kanku
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
I like them both.
15.
Stone
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
Damn, I sorta like the Amerie version better cause of the production quality. Either way, I’m lovin’ that beat.
16.
Brian
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
yeah, I know the clutch wrote amerie’s version.
17.
hood_shit
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
They’re both lame and why dude on the Le’Che song is trying his best to out-beat Kanye at being Kanye?
18.
sarcasm
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
is it just me or are a lot of Amerie’s songs recycled from other artists or songs from artists that were given the boot or didn’t do too well? Why does she get so many leftovers?
19.
M E RENEGADE
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
FIRST OF ALL THIS HAS NOTHING TO DO W/ WHAT THESE GIRLS LOOK LIKE…
ARE YA’LL SERIOUS? WE KNOW LE’CHE IS NOT A CELEBRITY AND ALL BUT YA’LL KNOW SHE AND HER VERSION SOUNDS 100 TIMES BETTER THAN AMERIE.
AMERIE DOES WHAT SHE DOES, BUT SHE DOES NOT HAVE A GOOD VOICE…
BTW RICO LOVE IS MY HOMEBOY! YA’LL STOP HATING!!!
20.
Brian
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
honestly, I like both versions - I have listened to amerie’s and I really like it, I guess I was just taken aback a little bit because I was so in love with le’che’s version too.
21.
Sassycat
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
GO AMERIE THEY CANT TAKE YOUR SWAGGER MA’
22.
LadyCole
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
I like both versions but im feeln le’che’s version more.
23.
Mz. Juicee
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
It said who’s version is betta not who looks betta!
I like Le’che’s version
24.
wendy's student
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
i like amerie’s better bcuz that guy is not on the song talking every second. le’che’s vocals are a bit stronger but that guy is too annoying. However it does sound like something amerie has done in the past.
25.
new yorker
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
i like the chorus for the other girl’s song better
26.
Afan
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
THIS SONG WAS PRODUCED BY ONE UP ENTERTAINMENT OUT OF BALTIMORE. COME ON, IF YOU GONNA BE STARTING A POST MAKE SURE THE FACTS ARE CORRECT. THIS SONG HAS NO CONNECTION WITH RICH HARRISSON. AMERIE’S TRACK IS HOT, THE LYRICS, HOOK, HARMONIES….NO COMPARISON. FYI SHE MEANT WHAT SHE SAID AND DID NOT PUT ANY RICH HARRISSON ON THIS ALBUM.
27.
j tuck
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
Le’Che is killin’ her vocally!!! Amerie can’t compare. I’m assuming Le’Che is not sign, but as crazy as she’s going on this record, A&R’s need to wake up and get some money off of this girl!!!
28.
D.J. Boogie B
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
Yo I’m rockin’ the shorty Che’s version in the clubs!!! The arrangement is bananas!!!!
29.
RNB^MJ
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
Can’t really hear, but they probably both sound good.
30.
Zam Zhinga
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
I listened to both tracks thoroughly. I like the addition of Rico Love on the LE’Che version, but AMERIE hands down delivers it better in my opinion. Right out the gate Amerie commands the song, due in part to the fact that she really knows how to sing over a RICH Harris track–she’s had alot of experience with this guy. Le’ Che is strong as well… BUT I THINK AMERIE took this round by split decision….. 3 to 1… like MAYWEATHER
31.
Lisa Smith
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
I am a big Amerie fan, but Le’Che’s version is more believeable to me. Her voice sends chills down my arms. I like Amerie’s version too but I’m in love with Le’Che’s version.
32.
Tha Gift
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
I’ve been hearing a lot about Le’Che this past year. I’m feeling Amerie, but let’s be honest the underdog is much better. People are so use to image and not talent anymore. I would rather hear Le’Che singing acapella than Amerie anyday! That’s a sign of true talent to me. My vote would have to go with Le’Che! Amerie can’t keep up.
33.
shan
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
why does amerie always end up on these who sang it better posts? she needs do some original sh*t
34.
Miko
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
I met Le’Che in Atlanta about a month again. She was a very humble sista. I though she was a song writer not an artist. I like both records. I got to show some love to Amerie too. I like Le’Che’s version better though. She is a beast on them vocals.
35.
Monique
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
I like both versions. I do have to admit that Le’Che’s voice is “richer” and more “softer” than Amerie’s voice. Amerie sounds as if she’s trying too hard. Nevertheless, they both did an o.k. job in their own unique way.
36.
coolierasta
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
leche. although the harmonies on ameries sound better
37.
Kawaii
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
it realy annoys me how people automatically side the better looking artist automatically. amerie endlessly copies other people’s stuff, then moans when SWSNBN copies her.
the girl cant really sing, and i think its really sad that people are so gullible that they would buy a cd from an artist who cant sing well just cus there “good-looking.”-ignorance is bliss.
38.
Keisha
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
Some people are so damn ignorant! Nobody asked who should be America’s Next Top Model! The question here is about vocal talent and Le’che is winning hands down. I think Amerie is gorgeous as well, but VOCALLY she’s been defeated by the underdog this round. FYI…I checked out Le’che’s myspace page and this isn’t her most flattering picture. She is far from looking like a man!
39.
Beyonce's Girl
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
it baffles me how some of you can say amerie can’t sing. her sound is unique and she riffs and can harmonize like it’s noone’s business! anyway, i say amerie.
40.
Bed-Stuy
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
I’VE SAID THIS BEFORE AND I’M SAYING IT AGAIN….
I DON’T HAVE RESPECT FOR AMERIE BECAUSE SHE KNOCKS OTHER ARTISTS THAT ARE DOING BETTER THAN HER AND SHE’S NOTORIOUS FOR STEALING LYRICS AND TRACKS AND LABELING THEM “HERS” OR “HER SOUND.” SHE’S A JOKE. SHE STOLE TWICE FROM THAT CHICK IN LONDON, ONCE FROM GWEN STEFANI, BEYONCE AND NOW LECHE.
AMERIE’S WHACK AND WILL ALWAYS BE WHACK THAT WHY SHE DOESN’T RISE ANY HIGHER.
NEXT!!!
41.
Bigbumpaa
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
amerie..
42.
Pstone
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
Le’Che is the winner to me. She got some crazy joints on her myspace too. She could put Milwaukee on the map with that voice. Thanks for putting me on this future star concreteloop. Amerie is not for me!! Though i wish her much luck and success.
43.
Nikki
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
Amerie all the way.
44.
RNB^MJ
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
40. Bed-Stuy said:
——————————————————————————–
I’VE SAID THIS BEFORE AND I’M SAYING IT AGAIN….
I DON’T HAVE RESPECT FOR AMERIE BECAUSE SHE KNOCKS OTHER ARTISTS THAT ARE DOING BETTER THAN HER AND SHE’S NOTORIOUS FOR STEALING LYRICS AND TRACKS AND LABELING THEM “HERS” OR “HER SOUND.” SHE’S A JOKE. SHE STOLE TWICE FROM THAT CHICK IN LONDON, ONCE FROM GWEN STEFANI, BEYONCE AND NOW LECHE.
AMERIE’S WHACK AND WILL ALWAYS BE WHACK THAT WHY SHE DOESN’T RISE ANY HIGHER.
NEXT!!!
^ Uh.. when did she steal from Beyonce, and what did she steal? A college education and intellegence? You just want Beyonce’s name in a post.
Remember, Beyonce stole from Des’ree and Ne-Yo, and Mary J., and Diana.
45.
billionheiress
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
i LOVE le’che’s version.
46.
loves2speakhermind
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
Being an Amerie fan since her first album from 2002, I have to say that this beat most definitely is hers. Amerie has been having this type of go-go R&B vibe since 2002 and her voice is so unique and beautiful, it makes the song come even more alive. Le’ Che sounds nice as well but like I have always said, Amerie has the most unique and different voice in R&B music and this track sounds like it was originally made for her. Amerie can so sing, not just sing but sang. She has natural raspiness in her voice that needs to be controlled at times, but she still has powerful and amazing vocals. Amerie is not only beautiful, she is also very talented. I do wish she would stop recycling tracks from rising artists because she can be original on her own.
47.
yes
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
ppl record songs everyday and they end up on someone else’s album, sometimes the song is just not right for the direction they want to go in or they didn’t use the song in a certain period and it went up for grabs, that’s just the way things go
anyway i’ll listen later…
48.
Kenny
Monday, May 7, 2007 /
there is also another version of the song on this page too >>>http://www.myspace.com/danalee03
leche’s was the best to me
49.
atreyou
Tuesday, May 8, 2007 /
I like both versions. VOCALLY, LE Che is better. Amerie can sing to me, she just has a unique voice. She’s so freaking adorable. Hopefully, this album is hot and it sells.
50.
Bouga
Tuesday, May 8, 2007 /
Vocally Le’Che takes it. But the production on Amerie’s is funky.
51.
C-Note (Vocal Producer)
Tuesday, May 8, 2007 /
I’m the vocal producer of Le’Che’s record “Get Away”. Brian thanks for the love you’ve been show us man!!! We appreciate the good and bad comments. We shouldn’t hate on either lady. They both have their own style and talent. To speak on Le’Che’s record. Rico wrote the record for placement. Le’Che and I cut the record in 2 hours as a demo. So it not Le’Che’s song. We were trying to make money off the song, not keep it. We have been blessed to work with some of the industries finest. Le’Che is an artist but has stepped back for a second to get the writer checks. Brian are in L.A. right now homie, but we’ll be flying in to Atlanta on Friday. Holla at us. If you want to hear more of what we are doing go to Le’Che’s myspace or mine at http://www.myspace.com/chadcroper. Le’Che, Rico and I wish Amerie nothing but love and success. Hopefully, we will catch her on her next album. Be Blessed!!!!
52.
Ashley
Tuesday, May 8, 2007 /
to #33, Amerie does create her own $hit and does have original $hit. listen to the new album. she is creating her own lane and separating herself from other female artist….so get ur facts straight before u make a comment.
to #37, u need to shut the fuck up because Amerie is a VERY good singer and is talented and thats why people buy her music. not just because she’s pretty.
to #40, she stole from wat chick in London?? She didnt steal from NOBODY. If ur talkin about Tori, well CEE-LO sold the track to Amerie and Amerie changed it so shut the fuck up.
When did she steal from Gwen Stefani?? When? From what I kno, she was gonna sell her song Some Like It to Fergie.
When did she steal from Beyonce? If anything Beyonce was copying her style. So u need to shut the fuck up.
I like Amerie’s version better not just because I am her fan but just because I like her vocals better and her harmonies and background vocals. I DEFINATELY will be buying her album and will be supporting her to the fullest
AMERIE STAND UP AND BRUSH THEM HATERS OFF!!!!!
53.
UH HO
Tuesday, May 8, 2007 /
Amerie’s is alot better
54.
HOLLA@CHABOY
Thursday, May 31, 2007 /
Her vocals sound very Brandy-ish, her runs are VERY MUCH BRANDY’S SIGNRATURE STYLE. I like Amerie but the other chick is better
55.
phillygirl
Saturday, June 2, 2007 /
WHO THE FUCK IS LE’CHE??????????? AMERIE ALL DAY!!!!
56.
Who Cares
Friday, June 8, 2007 /
Amerie need manager help. That guy Len can’t book Amerie any magazines, shows or products. We dogged Kelly Rowland manager (Kelly looks real good rigth now). It’s time to dogg Amerie’s manager. Where is Rich Harrison.
57.
Bainta
Monday, July 2, 2007 /
Le’che Martin’s version. And she sounds better than Amerie!!!!
58.
dream_kidd
Wednesday, July 4, 2007 /
amerie is better
59.
mylov481
Wednesday, July 25, 2007 /
They both suck
60.
jazz
Monday, July 30, 2007 /
Le’che does have nice voice but this style of music belongs to Amerie. People in London and Asia have been bumping Amerie’s version for months now. Stop hating!
61.
bearrr
Tuesday, July 31, 2007 /
READ COMMENT 51 & WEEP - LE’CHE RECORDED THE “DEMO” TRACK TO GET THE DAMN THANG SOLD.
62.
Jermaine Tha Producer
Thursday, August 30, 2007 /
Apparently none of you have what it takes to spot out talent. Vocals are better in Leche’s version. Production is better in Amerie’s version. Why? Because it was being released on her album. Which means better Production and Engineering. Like a lot of people said, the post wasn’t asking who looks better or who’s more of a celebrity. Stick to the topic and please just be honest with yourself and get past “Celebrityism”. (I know i just made that word up… Lol) These are the reasons why music is being destroyed, because we have to look nice for people’s approval. Leche would be Amerie singing any day. Amerie is a better version of Cassie….
63.
ZAM ZHINGA
Thursday, July 24, 2008 /
I think AMERIE killed it !!! She’s a good artist. The other chick held her own toom but I prefere the Amerie version better.
64.
Remiyah
Monday, September 15, 2008 /
Amerie Iz Tha BEST!!!!! Dats All I Gotta Say!!!