the first one

THE 1ST DRESS WITH THE 2ND PICS SHOES………

n/m not the first one but the one in july maybe its the makeup and heels

Ummm #2 its the same dress lol

the second picc. and iz it jus me or does her dress look a little less brite on da july pic??hmmmmmmm…………………….

Neither

i think she rocked it better in may, i guess b/c she accessoried more.. and i’m not feeling her current hairstyle

May.

the second pic

Recycling clothes…uh uh uh…..

Is..Ashanti. a broke Broke

Even I dont wear articles of clothing TWICE!! WTF?

she rocked it better in may..the second one!

LOL, I KNOW TIANNA, SHE ROCKED IT BETTA IN THE FIRST DRESS (LONG HAIR IS CUTE W/ IT), SHE COULD HAVE ROCKED IT BETTA WITH DA 2ND PICS SHOES, JUST PUTTIN MYFASHION SENSE IN DEH, OH AND LOSE DA BRACELETS IN DA 1ST DRESS….UGHHHHH

DAMN AFTA MY CACULATIONS THAT LEAVES DA SECOND DRESS JUST W/O THE LONG HAIR, GOSH ITS LATE, IM GOIN 2 BED, LOL

The 2nd pic.

I like the second pic

YUCK to both.

I guess she looked a LITTLE less wack in the second picture. That print should of stayed in the 60’s, H.A.M.

She looked sexy in July.

I preferred it in May, she gave a very vintage feel reminiscent of DC3’s Independent Women video circa 2000…BUT, let the record show

I don’t particularly care for the dress

May ‘07!

She can’t rock the same outfit on camera. She “famous”….they can wear it again in the comfort of their own home but not out on the town..Twice!

Definitely MAY

She should of never rock’d it in the first place. But if I had to choose May.

never

The second picture. She looks real cute there. The hairstyle works with the outfit. Some styles just don’t match with certain clothes knamean…

She NEVER rocked it better. That dress loooks like a patio table cover from the sixties. Now if only it came with a hood that she could zip up! LOL. Just kidding…

why can’t someone famous wear an outfit more than once in public??? y’all trippin!

The second pic is much cuter; the make-up and hair coordinate well with the dress.

@ ladyloza, I totally agree. There is no way I’m gonna be a celebrity; spend like $800 dollars on a dress and only wear it once, no matter how rich I am. That just isn’t practical; at least not in my book.

Homegirl must be running a little low on funds. She must REALLY like that dress. Even I wouldn’t wear it that often.

Ashanti Figured Cuz She Was In A Different Zone at the time - Nobody Would Catch That LOL - I’ll say the Bahamas joint though!

4 sure LEA, ain’t that the truth. lol

May

well second one because the hair style is 60 ish with the head band just like the style of dress and shoes are cute

Why do people find it so outthere for celebs to wear the same clothes twice wdf
yalll all know yall g0t days where yall wear da same damn things more than twice
money dont fall from the tree where i am from im not saying i wear my shit over over and over but damn its clothes if im rockin the same thing i tend to switch it up something most of these celebs do just because your a celeb dont make you any less human
and if you wanna wear the same damn thing then hell wear it so it doesnt matter which looks better to me cl0thes is fkn clothes leave it at that

May 07 her hair was nice.

In May…i don’t know she looks glowing & colourful n…. pretty shoes. i like her hair on the 2nd pic too.

she rocked much better in may 2007

She didn’t wear the same dress to an event wok king on the red carper she was just wok king on vehicle and a photographer took her some pick. I don’t no why some of you are tripping Ashanti never wear the same dress on the red carpet

Both scenarios with that dress are cute

Both wrong

The second pic. She just looked more together.

Please……….. and she aint the first or last celbrity to recylce clothes, but I say the first pic beacuse of the theme of the party & the heels, either way she looks cute. Some of you love to hate…….lmao & @ #10 “you dont wear articles of clothing twice” well WTF do you do for a living.hmmmmmmm you must get paid to be on CL & make stupid ass comments like that. lol .Be for real…..carry on kids…

Shanti rocked it better in May 2007. The hair shoes and accessories all looked better.

I like Both but she could have switched up some things like the bracelets and the shoes. But it’s a cute outfit.

July hands down. In may she looks like she’s wearing a costume.

Ashanti showing that she can dress it down and some what up. I like the dress down version better (July). The dress is cute.

#10, why you always calling them a broke broke?! LOL

May, she made it sexier with the shoes. She’s a cute girl.

oh just saw #5’s comment, I think it’s the lighting. Pic 1- candid off the street, Pic 2 on the red carpet- there’s more camera flashes and lighting.

She rock it better in may 2007 cauze her was looking good, she was wearing good shoes to go with the dress, her make up was poppin and those basket ball hoops gave it her own style!!

She rock’d it better in July…. It looks better dressed down .

It’s one thing to wear the same dress like a couple years a part but to be a celebrity n wear it jus two months within each other….thats tacky

Neither time and why is her mouth wide open in that last pic? She lookin like a reject extra from Hairspray.

maybe she just like the dress too much but I think she rocked it better back in MAY..

Definitely July cuz she looks a hot mess back in May. Her hair & makeup artist’s need to be fired after that one.

I like the picuture in May 07. She brings a hippie look to this dress. Do it Ashanti!

I think she rocked it better the second time around but they say 3 times is a charm so I guess when she is wearing the outfit every two months so say we check back again in Sept when she wears it again before the summer ends. I’m sorry but Ashanti is a has been.. Aww poor baby! SHE IS WACK!!!!! BITCH GO AHEAD AND HAND ME OVER TO THE SIDE! I want to go to the amusement park and ride on the rollercoaster!!

*SINGING* I aint got take my panties off, just move them to the side, i want to ride on that rollercoaster, come on and let me ride… HAHAHAHA.. naw im just joking.

Neither look is doing it for me. She needs to retire that dress.

I’m sorry but I WAS TELLING ASHANTI TO GO AHEAD AND HAND ME OVER NELLY!! i LOVE HIM!!

JULY 2007!

the old pic in May she looks a hot pink, teenage mess.

I like the May 07 look better….hair, makeup, shoes look better then. I like her bracelets better in the other pic though.

I wouldn’t look at either of them separately and think WTF? So I’m going to have to say it’s a tie. Ashanti never disappoints in her dressing.

In May (before it started fading) lol

Ashanti looks a hot ass mess in both! That outfit is straight up ugly. WTF is up wih her boy looking body? I personally think she wore it twice because she is low on money, just like Mya and Meagan Good. Plus she hasn’t been styling in the latest fashion for a while now. Some people think it’s not cool to wear same article of clothing and some people do. Who cares everybody got a different opinion. Some of ya’ll need to realize that.

I like the May 07 look, but both of them arent too bad.

I’m really not feeling the outfit but I will say she rocked in better in MAY just for the Hair tye, make-up and shoes sake..

@ all the haters. She’s gorgeous no matter what she’s wearing. With that face it doesn’t even matter whether she’s a has been, a broke broke or has a boy body (which she definitely doesn’t ).

dang girl wear the same stuff the same year just a couple a months a part but i go wit the one from july and the shoes from may

I think Ashanti is pretty, the dress is ugly. I’m gonna say less is more she rocked it
better in July 2007.

Damn some of yall act like she is the only celeb who rocks the same shit twice. Beyonce did it B4 and so did Megan Good. That does NOT mean she is broke. Dumb asses. Anyway I say the 2nd pic cause I like her shoes and the pink headband.

Luv u shanti!

First pic looks like she’s hanging out on the town and the paparazzi happened to snap a shot. Second pic is a themed red carpet event where there are millions of cameras flashing and that makes her skin and the dress look brighter. She looks good in both. It must be great being a celebrity and having millions of people, including myself critique, judge, and make assupmtions about their financial and personal lives.lol Obviously it just comes with their careers.
@ # 10 not tryna bash you are nething but be realistic. Everyone wears articles of clothing more than once. It’s just called accessorizing and switching up outfits with different peices. We all need to go to hell for wearing our clothes more than once…C’mon yall let’s keep it real!!!

In May

People hate on Ashanti but in all actuality she is a very nice down to earth woman…i met her on 2 occasions and both times she was mad chill…as for the outfits…i don’t like how she looks in either…the dress looks better with heels however, black peeptoe pumps would have been fine…too much goin on with the bangles…loop earings are fine with the curls to the side…long hair looks good on her but you dont want to cover the front of the dress like that… eye makeup should be colorful but a lil more subtle…

NEITHER!!

2 nd pic. may 07