I like the original better but this one sounds cool too

uuummm, not hating at all. WHAT are yall listening to??? There is nothing special about this! i like the original version better.

I already loved this song and Beyonce gave it an extra something. I loved her voice on this and she should sing more things that showcase her vocal abilities b/c Bday was some hot garbage to me w/the exception of some songs. But this right here brought my faith back in Bey

I liked the originl version better but it was ok.

Why work with Justin, Bee why? Damn I can’t stand that guy!!

And I expected vocals ala “Suga Mama” the way people talked about it. She didn’t do that much. This doesn’t top what she does in “Suga Mama”. It’s laid back.

Lol, am I da only one who liked Bday? Lol

#81.. I believe so.. lol

LMAO @ the haters trying the hardest to give constructive criticism , to avoid showing their true hateful feelings. interesting how some folks claimming to have love the original and how bee doesn’t add anything to it,PLEASE, im sure if justin timberlake felt like that,then he wouldn’t have asked her to be on it. bottomline she murdered the remix(in a good way for the slow folks), just give props where it due.

sidenote : ” alrighh-hi-hi-hiiiight!” be climbing the vocal scales with that sick run

#81 — Naw, boo, you got at least 4 million people keeping you company, LOL!

@81

i loved bday actually i think alot of people didnt like it cus it was different from dangerously in love and some people dont like change but who cares it still sold a hella lot of records but anyway i like the remix better with beyonce on it especially that lil run she did at 2:36 k……………PEACE

Lmaoooo@82, i have always been an outkast so I’m used 2 it, i got kitty kat on my voicemail which my mama been beggin me 2 take off!

totally cosign with 69. This is booty. YUCK, BOOOOO, NEXT……….

69 and 71 hit it on the head for me. It’s ok, but it would have been better without the oversinging. This is a laid back groove and the diva warbling wasn’t required. I like the original better, and I’m not really a fan of either. Had she just sang it straighht with some feeling behind it, it might have been a bit better. I couldn’t get into her vocal until the breakdown.

Uhhh…..it’s alright. This is one of my favorite songs on this album, and he kills it at the end, you folks would have heard it if BEYONCE wasn’t singing over him like she always do (I don’t care who get mad at that). LOL! But both versions sound nice…. the song was fine the way it was though.

One more thing…. is this BEYONCE singing or MARIAH CAREY? Because the way some folks are taking (if I wouldn’t have listened to the song first before reading the post) I would have thought this was the best vocal performance of all time. LOL! I mean it’s BEYONCE…. i mean she sound nice, but nothing new. :shrugs: SMH

BEE KILT IT!

Loved the original….love this one even more. She did her thang!!!

#86.. LOL.. H.A.M. with that on your voicemail!! LOL..

@81, naw, 6mil people WW love it too and i’m one of them. hell, check out the sold out dates on the tour.

btw, i love this remix and it’s been in constant rotation since it debuted on beyonceworld.

funny how SOME people claiming they loved the original all along when they hate justin and probably ain’t even heard the song before.

lol at some people saying she thinks just cause she got on the track, it would be a hit……….hello, justin asked her to

JT knows what up! He wanted some more heat, so he went to the only chick who could bring it!

89.

JANEE
Wednesday, September 26, 2007
Uhhh…..it’s alright. This is one of my favorite songs on this album, and he kills it at the end, you folks would have heard it if BEYONCE wasn’t singing over him like she always do

_______________________________________________________________________

UMM……..maybe you don’t get the memo that’s jt’s song so guess what? HE EDITS the damn thing. if he want her singing over him, he should have taken that part out. you people give the girl entirely TOO much credit! from the way some of ya’ll think, it sounds like you think she has control over someone else’s song!

LMFAOOOOOOOOOOOOO, Bee got the haters out full force ONCE AGAIN LOL!!!! Yall know the song is HOT, Bee Killed it!!!

Sounds like typical Beyonce to me…. I like the original.
*waits for hundred Beyaki stans to come and call me a hater (rolls eyes)*

Wow that bitch killed that. I’m not really a Beyonce fan, but I gotta give it to her.

@ 93

PREECH!!!!

ALL THESE DAMN HYPORCRITES,LOL. WHAT HAPPENED TO HATING AND DISLIKING JUSTIN’S GUTS???? ALL OF A SUDDEN SOME OF Y’ALL CLAIMING TO LIKE HIS MUSIC,LOL!

Lmao@92, I had dat for a year now and I neva changed it, my ex name was Craig and dat song described us 2 da T, i wanted him 2 hear it wen he called, U Ain’t got 2 lie craig…..lmao, he is so done now!

#84 &88.. I guess we are in the minority on this and will be branded haters for not liking it.. I like JT as a singer, but even his voice ain’t all that..same as Beyonce.. she has an ok voice and puts out good songs, HOWEVER, she is definitely overrated ! Granted she may be the prettiest and hardworking entertainer out at the present time, but to me that’s all she’s got right..

Waiting for Maxwell to come out show JT a real falsetto without gimmicks and James Brown moves

Get Em Bey’……………. here come the Hatas! Bey’ did the Damn thing! Stand Back, because the Queen Bee is about to Sting !

This song was great before it got blessings from Beyoncé, however JT reminds me too much of Jon B. He was the reallest, all the others are copycats, from Justin to Robin Thicke etc. HOLLA

#100.. LOLOLOL.. Now I got ol girl in my head from Friday..

“Ya think ya slick askin me for sum money..well ask DAT bitch for sum money”!! She had the Honda in the wind with a neckroll. LOL..

@101, you think she’s overrated cause you ain’t heard her live at one of her concerts. check the reviewes, all the reviewers could rave about was her voice and how half of em ain’t know she could sing that good. IN MY OPINION, she’s underrated as a vocalists cause she shows her vocal abilities live rather than on tracks

Damn some of you are suck f*cking HATERS! . Bee u killed the vocals and the run you did..GO GIRL F THEM HATERS THEY ALWAYS TALK SH!T..Cant wait for you and J.T. do it up BIG and release a video to go along with it. Keep Doing Ya thing Mama

LAWD this makes me appreciate her so much more. No more of them damn up tempo beats! She sounds really good.

————————-

Jordan
Wednesday, September 26, 2007

she did not add a damn thing, to this song, at all…. should have left it alone, its funny to me, how she thinks when she adds her voice that is going to be more flavorful..Her voice isn’t even that strong.. I mean if he wanted to really make the song better, he could have put his favorite singer of our generation Christina Aguilera.. Beyonce is so overated:) Will the real singers please stand up!!!!

^^Yea, but Xtina would’ve out sung him something serious! lol

Soft vocals are better on a song like this. Like B’s song “Kitty Kat”; no need to yell on it.

And yea, her voice isn’t the strongest, but it’s certainly strong enough for this joint. I repeat, Xtina would’ve blown J out of the water if she got on this track.

Plus B is the hotness right now. He coulda put Rhianna on it and ppl would be feeling it bcuz she’s popular too.

nice song

tight work !!!! I love it I can really say this was a great collab!! I enjoyed it

Y DA HELL SHE GOTTA GO MESSIN UP A PERFECTLY GOOD SONG… DAM SHE DOIN WAY 2 MUCH IN DA SONG.. WACK!!!!!

#105.. you’re right, I haven’t been to any of her concerts and probably won’t.. It’s just my opinion that folks make this big fuss about her music and when you don’t agree then you are self-loathing, ugly, broke ass hater or bitch.. lol.. Now, I do think she did a good job on Listen and Dangerously in Love and I would be a hypocrit to say that I didn’t like some of her songs, but I just don’t think her voice is that strong and thats when the warbling, over sanging and unneccessary runs come in..

Hell I feel the same about Christina Aguilera.. love her voice, but she oversangs..

I Knew they were coming, Everytime Bey’ stings you all (haters) rush in to rain on her parade, Beyonce got ya’ll runnin scared ! LMAO, she got you envious ! Keep Killin Em’ Bey !

sandra rose is that u?

damn that song is fiyah…bee killed it…her voice sounds amazing…..

Can there ever be a post where people aren’t calling each other haters or an arguement doesn’t break out? I think we take these posts a little too seriously.

I’ve always liked this song and I’m glad that Bey added just enough to it and wasn’t doing a lot of runs and stuff. It was nice. Me likey.

* getting out my raid spray for the hating azz roaches*

LMAO @ the idea of puttin rihanna/ christina on this remix .Now thats laughable. thank god justin timberlake the sense to ask one of the most versatile,talented vocalist of this generation to be on it.

in Kanye West voice “haters start your engines up i can hear you gearing up”

nice song!!!

quick question, how come NO ONE on here was admitting to liking this song until bee got on it and now all of a sudden, you’ve always liked the original? hmmmmm…..

beyonces great but i like it better with just justin.

I’m so glad that beyonce killed that fake ass on his own track!

she showed out on dis … i’m liking this remix

Go Beyonce!!! You keep proving these haters wrong. This girl is amazing, no other chick can top her. You haters can say what you want but this chick is fire. I really think there is more to come, so haters get ready because Ms. Beyonce is going no where.

Beyonce irks me in many ways, but her remix on this track is cute. I already liked the song before and with her addition, it doesnt mess up the song to me. No complaints really. It didnt move me much. It wasnt really awe-inspiring. Just cute.

and uh..people–its a remix (for those saying the ” B’s vocals are just layed over the original track”)..umm..ok….let’s educate…usually its a 50/50 chance that the original artist and the remix artist actually comes in to re-record the track–you have to remember there is so much production work and time that goes into it…not to mention deals b/w management if the artists happen to be on different labels…sometimes remixes are planned in advance, sometimes they’re not. it depends on many different variables.

But none of that matters, really because music is made by sprinkling cinnamon toast crunch pieces over a blank CD, while rubbing copies of each artists albums together, and MAAAAGICALLY a song appears–right?

CL ADMINISTRATORS: I’m going to need y’all to NOT do anymore posts with Beyonce in it. People get out of hand and call anyone who doesn’t think she is the best thing ever a hater. Bey brings out the worst in these CL bloggers.

BEYONCE’ is so amazing! I miss her voice on slow tracks. She is the most talented artist out there now!

@ #95 “B ALL THE WAY” (d@mn ya’ll don’t even try to hide being a STAN huh?)….

Whatever you say guy/chick. I’m not going to argue with you over this girl (I already had an disagreement today with a “crazy” in another post about something else and am NOT in the mood for another one, LMAO)….. I said BEYONCE sounds nice, is that NOT good enough for you? If I liked JUSTINS ending better, then I liked it better. PERIOD (and I will politely listen to that version). Don’t know what else to tell you…. the only people that give that girl too much credit is you “special fans”…. you act like it was ARETHA FRANKLIN that was singing this song or something. LOL, SMH. Are you going to read through everyones post and argue with everyone that doesn’t worship BEYONCE? SMH **looking at the screen crazy**

P.S I wish people would stop calling BEYONCE “BEE/BE/BEY” like they know her. Didn’t she tell ya’ll on 106 & Park that she would prefer for people not to call her that, because that’s what her friends and family calls her when they are out in public (so the STANS won’t hear her name and come a runnin’)? SMH, I feel sorry for her that she has followers like some of you people on the Internet….it’s one thing to be a FAN, but d@mn. Some of you take it overboard, that is scary….. anyways, NEXT!!

LMAOOOO @ # 97 :MJ:

Don’t worry, folks have their STANNING SKILLS on lock tonight. I said that the song was nice and I am still getting questioned! Just a shame. LMAO!!

LMAO at rihanna even being mentioned on somebodys damn song. I bet Justin would get a good laugh outta that bullshit. Beyonce you did your thing girl. I am a confident woman that can give another fly ass chick a compliment and I’m telling you that you took that shit to a whole other level. Damn her voice is the business on this yall ,just admit. You know what Bey if you didn’t have haters what would that say about your talent. For you to say her voice isn’t strong you lying to yourself. Some of yall are funny as hell. Hating is a sickness..Get help.I wonder do Bey and JAy think about the haters when they check their account balances. LOL HELL NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Standing Ovation for Janee!! LOL.. well put.. especially the part about calling her B.. she said y’all don’t know her like that and that’s for family and friends.. which the stans are neither!! LOL.. it’s just a shame to see folks worshipping this chick when she could probably careless about you and don’t want you to ask her to sign that re-released B-Day that y’all paid bout $20 for!! Oh, wait would she turn into Sasha and tell you get the f**k outta her face!! LOL

JANEE
Wednesday, September 26, 2007
@ #95 “B ALL THE WAY” (d@mn ya’ll don’t even try to hide being a STAN huh?)….

Whatever you say guy/chick. I’m not going to argue with you over this girl (I already had an disagreement today with a “crazy” in another post about something else and am NOT in the mood for another one, LMAO)….. I said BEYONCE sounds nice, is that NOT good enough for you? If I liked JUSTINS ending better, then I liked it better. PERIOD (and I will politely listen to that version). Don’t know what else to tell you…. the only people that give that girl too much credit is you “special fans”…. you act like it was ARETHA FRANKLIN that was singing this song or something. LOL, SMH. Are you going to read through everyones post and argue with everyone that doesn’t worship BEYONCE? SMH **looking at the screen crazy**

P.S I wish people would stop calling BEYONCE “BEE/BE/BEY” like they know her. Didn’t she tell ya’ll on 106 & Park that she would prefer for people not to call her that, because that’s what her friends and family calls her when they are out in public (so the STANS won’t hear her name and come a runnin’)? SMH, I feel sorry for her that she has followers like some of you people on the Internet….it’s one thing to be a FAN, but d@mn. Some of you take it overboard, that is scary….. anyways, NEXT!!

***************************************************************************************************

ahhhhh the typical hater. it don’t matter what you think cause guess what? it’s gone be a hit anyways.

thank you for giving me the attention and typing all that tho.

Justin is such a Prince swagger jacker . Damn, he might as well just remake all of his songs . The song is fine with or without Beyonce …

I WORSHIP BEYONCE’ KNOWLES! She is the Best!

I LOOOOOOVED IT. SHE ROCKS ON THIS

@119

thats an interesting question. notice how the haters are gonna avoid the question,lol. come on now haters,think of something creative to say. the whole overated and oversinging lame excuses are so tired and old.

haters my ass…it is what it is she spoiled this song period..less is better

those who like the song are just music whores and those who can see right through..well the wackness that it is are music connoisseur’s

let that marinate

Note to the Stans. Aguilera shits on Beyonce’s vocal anyday, Beyonce is more of Diana Ross and Tina Turner in a away, shes like because she’s gorgeous , while Diana was/is like for her hair/costumes and Tina because of her body/legs. But i do love like Beyonce but she gets hate a lot.

I love Beyonce and Justin but the instrumental is so sick I believe if Kermit the frog sang on this track it would be hot….

SMH @ all the haters in here…It kills yall to give Bee her props huh? She did the damn thang on the song, the song was hot before but now it’s pure FIRE..Her voice is soulful, it adds soo much to the song..

And for yall saying you don;t like the song and it’s just your opinion, fine..BUT is it Necessary to write a damn ESSAY on why yall don’t like it? Just keep it moving, if you really don’t care..But Beyonce just keeps yall coming back for more lol…Go bee, keep doing your thing!!

DAMN! some of ya’ll sound like teen fans on here getting mad at people for voicing their opinion. I really do hope ya’ll are teens cause if not, being 18 or older and getting mad cause someone doesn’t like what your favorite artist did is pathetic. Now, I see why my girl don’t be checking for this site no more… I’m going back over to KING!

119 said:

“quick question, how come NO ONE on here was admitting to liking this song until bee got on it and now all of a sudden, you’ve always liked the original”? hmmmmm…..

Uhhhh maybe because this is a BLACK BLOG SITE and CL didn’t post any JT songs to discuss…. that could be it. LMAOOOOO!!!!

….And LMAOOOO @ clicking on one of the STANS names (because I always wonder what a STAN looks like) and instead of a myspace page BEYONCE’S site pops up. LMAOOOOO!! I’m too though.

This is why I never post in a post about her…. the IGNORANCE is over the top. SMH

It’s OK, like the original better.

Maybe she will add this to B’Day and re-release it again…

It could be the “I CAN STILL SING SLOW SONGS, BUSTED MY ASS AND GOT BACK UP WHIPPING MY HAIR LIKE I WAS HAVING A SEIZURE, BUY HOUSE OF DEREON..PLEASE(NO ONE ELSE IS) KNEW KELLY WASN’T GOING TO SELL” version.

#139..So true.. I’m still trying to figure out how is it hating when you don’t like something or express an opinion.. this is not the I Heart ( Beyonce, Rhianna,etc) Fan Club..

LILI ..I totally agree with you, Christina would have murked Justin on his on track. the only reasonn why i said her name, is because Justin always braggs that Christina is the best singer of or generation., Bottom line, the point i’m trying to make is, she doesn’t do any justice to the track… and oh my GOD Rhianna would have totally ruined it, with that nasal twang:)!!

Can someone PLEEEEASE tell me how to find this on zshare or supload…I can’t sleep til I have it…I LOOOVE THIS TRACK OMG!!!!!

Can people define “hater” to me? Because it’s so overused I’m not even sure I know what it means anymore.

I love the song very relaxing and chill, Beyonce is usually known for her up beat songs but this is actually nice Justin’s voice is alright. reading comments i don’t think people realize how much Christina Aguilera influences up and coming young singers these days.Her riffs are fucking insane and i don’t think many people realize how amazing and how much control she has of her voice, i think she’s going for a particular sound which makes it a signature, but you best believe when you hear her voice you definitely know its her.

@ 139 Okay, I agree 1000% …. I mean damn , the last few days for me on this blog has been pure pathetic with these crazy ass people running around here . You can’t say nothing about nobody(even if it’s the god honest truth ) or you are a “hater” …Angel needs to have bloggers take a mental evaluation packet before being allowed to post , alot of poster are not built up to accept other opinions. .. It’s getting rather ridiculous!

so it’s okay for people who don’t like her to voice their opinion but not ok for fans? interesting analysis. once again, funny how this post is about to hit 200 in less than 15min and it was just posted a couple hours ago. compare this to the posts posted today and say to yourselves, “if i think bee is overrated, it might be better for me to stop talking about her ALL together.” she’ll get the memo then. it’s too much energy to spend time on a person you don’t like, why do you think her so called “overexposure” keeps increasing? ahhhhh, it’s cause folks who don’t like and despise her can’t seem to stop talking about her and coming in her threads making her have 300 comments!

funny how this a song from BOTH jt and bee and here this has become a conversation ONLY about bee. this is one bad ass chick!

let the blatant hating continue………….plus why do beyonce(obessive) haters, always result to comparing her to other artists,that nothin to do with the topic at hand???? don’t blame beyonce for being vocal talented and being on her grind.blame your favourite artist for not stepping up their game.

B all the way should get payed for her defense wow lol