WHO ROCK’D IT BETTER: GOLDEN BROOKS vs. MELODY THORTON

gbmtrb.jpg
( Photos by: Wireimage )

For this edition of ‘Who Rock’d It Better’ we have actress, Golden Brooks (left) and Pussy Cat Dolls member, Melody Thorton (right). Both ladies rock’d the same Herve Leger bandage dress at recent events. Big thanx to CL Reader Shantel from sending this one in.

Melody rock’d the dress first at a VMA after party in Las Vegas on September 9th. Golden, on the other hand, wore it at a Emmy after party on Sunday. Who Rock’d It Better?

Posted in ROCK'D IT BETTER
Golden Brooks - Zap2it
Golden Brooks - Motorola 9th Annual Anniversary Party - Arrivals
Golden Brooks Photo
Golden Brooks & Her Darling Dakota
Golden Brooks and her 2-year-old daughter Dakota were spotted at a farmer's market in Los Angeles, Calif. on Sunday (January 29). Brooks - best known as her role as Maya in the CW sitcom Girlfriends - carried her little girl as she walked around ...
Albert Brooks reacts to Oscar snub: I got robbed
Brooks, who was nominated for a Golden Globe for the role wrote, "I got ROBBED. I don't mean the Oscars, I mean literally. My pants and shoes have been stolen." "And to the Academy: 'You don't like me. You really don't like me,'" the comedic actor added.

94 Responses to WHO ROCK’D IT BETTER: GOLDEN BROOKS vs. MELODY THORTON

  1. natural mystique

    Golden has a boyish shape.
    The other chick has a bloated tummy.
    Neither.

  2. UMMM GOLDEN??? SORRY YALL FIRST!!

  3. passion21

    Golden Brooks all the way. Melody need to stop posing so hard, she look like she ate a big lunch.

  4. DAMN U NATURAL MYSTIC!! LUV YA ANYWAYS GIRL!!! AND I THOUGHT THEY KICKED MELODY OUT OF PCD?? AM I WRONG?

  5. TOSH

    ummmmmmmmm y is she standing like that????

  6. Im at a loss for words and Golden’s shoes and for Melody’s pudge!

  7. Stacy H

    Those shoes that Golden Brooks has on are not cute. but they both are about the same

  8. KI KI

    I’LL JUST GIVE IT TO THEM BOTH FOR TRYING.

  9. DCTRINIGYAL

    melondy look cuter…pudge or not. she rocking the dress

  10. lovlypeach

    Thisis the first time I’ve seen Golden (H.A.M) Brooks look decent, so I have to go with her.

  11. ugh

    neither.

    melody looks like she just ate and she has scoleosis of the stomach
    golden looks like she could used some hips and thighs. basically she needs to trade her boy shape for a girl’s.

  12. natural mystique

    Sorry Bashy. Boredom at work here.:-)

  13. i think golden been readin cl cuz she has improved!

  14. Damn, I like Melody’s hair because Mya didn’t do hers. But Melody’s pose just threw it off for me. Mya she looks better than previous pictures I have seen her in and I dont like neither shoes so I have to vote for me :o ) and I am not wearing the dress today…

  15. lashawn

    BOTH ARE ABOUT THE SAME AS FAR AS THE DRESS GOES…SO I’LL GO WITH MELODY SINCE HER SHOES ARE NICER.

  16. dee dee

    These dresses are all over the place, everybody has one.

  17. DINAJONES

    golden im not del not feeling. and melody is gorgeoues.. she got my vote for sure!! but i think its so hard to wear clothes when you are a female with not a female shape so i feel where golden is coming from with that no shape body.. not that i have no shape but i know girls who have a shape like that.

  18. jmms529

    Golden’s body looks better in the dress. But I like Melody’s shoes and hair better. I think they’re equal on this look. Damn Golden – why you always gotta wear those big brogan shoes? You could have won this one.

  19. NayeNaye

    Shame they should do a dress like this. They call her Golden Ham brooks for a reason. looks like someone drank a lil too much koolaid when they decided the shoes. melody gets points offf for that tummy stickin out but i like the shoes. i pick melody

  20. Golden rocked it better because that other chick’s hairstyle doesn’t go with the dress.

  21. yes

    i didnt need to see the picture to know melody won

  22. YA’LL ARE WRONG. YA’LL VOTED MELODY B/C YOU’RE USED TO SEEING GOLDEN LOOK JACKED UP. LOOK AT MELODY’S UGLY ASS LEGS. SHE DOESN’T LOOK CUTE AT ALL…FOR THE FIRST TIME, OLD GOLDIE WON THIS!

  23. Surprisingly enough…Golden worked it out in this outfit. This is the best she’s looked in awhile…although I just want to burn all these damn dresses…every chick in the industry got one…only a few do it any real justice.

  24. mena

    Melonie looks better..

    Golden is ashy as hell and just busted.. I’ve seen crackheads that look better

  25. D.Vida

    Melody definitely looks like she ate a little too much at the VMA’s.

  26. Donnie

    They both look a little “crackish” to me. So I think the dress hanging up by itself wins.

  27. bailey

    I CAN’T WAIT FOR THIS FAD TO BE OVER

    STRETCH LYCRA ALL OVER-EWWWW!

    I’VE ALWAYS HAD A RULE IF IT’S TIGHT IT CAN’T BE SHORT TOO-IT SCREAMS HOOCHIE IN MY OPINION,

    I WOULD RATHER ROCK SOMETHING THAT WAS MORE SOFT FLOWING AND SHORT AND DEFINITELY IN A DIFFERENT MATERIAL-SUMMER SWING DRESS BUT THIS UH, UH

    THIS IS DEFINITELY A THROW BACK STYLE, WHEN I USE TO GO OUT FIVE YEARS AGO CLINGY,TIGHT, LYCRA, STRETCH DRESSES WERE IN, BUT THIS IS TAKING ME TOO FAR BACK I SWEAR -AND I HAVE THE BODY FOR IT BUT THIS I WOULD CONSIDER A BIT TOO REVEALING, IT LEAVES LITTLE TO THE IMAGINATION.

  28. Only because we have the same name =]

  29. Rep Da D

    Melody Thorton can GET IT FROM ME ANY DAY! ANY TIME!

    Golden Brook is a H.A.M. as usual.

    Its a shame everytime CL post a Golden Brooks PIC SHE ALWAYS LOOKS A h.a.m.

    CL save her the embarrassment and humiliation and retire all her pics….cuz its a damn shame.

  30. Greatestloveofall

    Golden over Melody and her funny lookin self.

  31. LADYBUG

    NEITHER! This dress does not flatter either one of their figures, sorry.

  32. Mallato

    NEITHER !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YUK

  33. msweb

    melody looks better
    Golden Brooks looks way better on Girlfriends than she does on red carpets
    why is that?????

  34. Girl Stop

    Melody.

    Them dresses make your stomach look awkward

  35. Blackstallion

    I agree with #1 also. Neither of them have the body to wear this dress!!!!

  36. natural mystique

    #40- It’s because she is one of those women who can’t make the right clothing, hair and makeup choices on her own.
    She doesn’t know what look flatters her, and consistently wears the wrong shade of cheap makeup and plastic hair.
    Basically she needs those stylists from the show.
    I hope she reads CL.

  37. TT

    Neither….I’m sorry but they are both shaped kinda odd. Melody could have been caught in a bad pose but regardless they both need a little help.

  38. AJ

    what is up with this? everytime I see Golden on girlfriends she looks so cute. the hair is right, the make-up, outfits etc. i remember one episode where i saw her and i thought she was so beautiful….then we have her red carpet appearances and her photo shoots which are a whole notha story cuz she be lookin straight BUSTED like she just walked out of a crackhouse and threw on some heels and lipstick

  39. *******SOMEONE’S EXPECTING******* =/

  40. charlee

    This goes to show….. NOT EVERYBODY CAN ROCK THAT DRESS

  41. Shan Shan

    Kimora rocked it better, she wore the same dress a couple of months ago.

  42. FashionChix

    That’s not a Herve. It’s a replica that can be found at Bebe.

  43. Tlo

    Its fitting Melody so much better, but her stomach is sticking out. But if she would of sucked it in, I know she would of won hands down. Better shoes and everything.
    Melody. Cuz Golden just look like a bum that put on a nice dress. She need a samich.

  44. dee dee

    #1, I hate to say this about Maya, but I could swear she’s a man! She is shapped like a tranny!

  45. they both were on equal ground at first glance…

    but after a little review Golden’s shoes seem a lil fug–so the vote goes to Melody.

    *yawns*

  46. TRUTHHURTS

    Melody Thornton of the Pussycat Dolls rocked it, she is way better looking than Golden Brooks even with her hair in a ponytail. She does not have a stomach however the way she is standing kind of causes that effect. I think she rocked it she is prettier than Golden Brooks not to mention made better and yes even with her hair up in a ponytail she still looks better and more naturally beautiful. Melody gets this one.

  47. Melody is super hot!!!

    What a voice.

  48. DO THE POCKET-KNIFE

    Golden looks a luke-warm mess…she’s not quite a hot-mess.

    That other chick looks like she has worms or something…whats up with that “Feed the Children” belly? You cant tell me she dont remind you of one of those kids from the 700 club…all she’s missing is the fly on her nose, lol.

    I’m thru for today, lmao!

  49. So in love with my boo...

    So sick of those Herve Leger (or whatever he calls himself now) dresses. So I’mma have to say neither. NEXT!

  50. So in love with my boo...

    LOL @ # 31
    Dress hanging by itself? LOL!

  51. slimredchick

    MELODY LOOKS LIKE SHE’S ABOUT 2 MONTHS PREGNANT

    AND GOLDEN….UMM YEAH

    —————————————–>>>>>NEXT

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

If you comment on this site that means you have read the comment rules

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>