♫ WHO SANG IT BETTER: KILEY DEAN VS. BRANDY ♫

June 14th, 2008

Years ago, during Timbaland’s short-lived reign with his first label, Beat Club Records, he signed a girl by the name of Kiley Dean, who actually was a former back-up singer for Britney Spears. Although she failed to release her first album, Simple Girl, which was in large part produced by Timbaland, she continued to pursue music and record songs. “Escape” was recorded years ago, but recently a version of the song Brandy recorded has leaked. The leaking of all this old Brandy stuff, I think, has a lot to do with the fact that she’s working on a follow-up to 2004′s underrated Afrodisiac.

[poll=105]

  1. 1.
    J. Peezy

    Kiley does really connect with the song… I prefer her version, but Brandy has more colorful adlibs. Great stuff… Brian, you should do a post on some of Kiley’s new music!

    Reply /0
  2. 2.
    Tasia

    Wow! Who is this Kiley chick? This is the first time I’m hearing her and her sound is banging! That girl has a nice voice, forreal. I’m going to have to go with her on this one. Sorry Brandy. Brian, post more Kiley! I want to hear more stuff from her.

    Reply /0
  3. 3.
    sexsee

    brandy all the way!

    Reply /0
  4. I think we all know it’s Brandy on this one! I miss my girl I hope she comes back strong…we’re waiting 4u girlie!

    Reply /0
  5. 5.
    Whytry?

    I like them both, but it sounds like a “Brandy” track. I thought Kiley was going to make it back then but she’s still grinding.

    Reply /0
  6. 6.
    DeShawn

    i give it to Brandy on this one.. because you can tell that it was recorded by her first. Kiely does a WONDERFUL job on the song.. but its clear *at least to me* that Kiely rerecorded it after brandy as it was probably a reference track for kiely. So there are alot of “brandy-ism’s” in Kiely’s Version..

    However Kiely did her thing.. Kiely got Pipes.. i actually have her “Simple Girl” album.. and her second CD “Changes” both were GREAT.. she just didnt get the pub she needed..

    but i love her!
    *and of course i love my Brandy… oooooohhhh yes!! cant wait for album to drop!”

    Reply /0
  7. 7.
    punnkfresh

    The song just SOUNDS like Brandy, so her voice flows over it better.
    & I’m pretty sure I can hear Brandy’s vocals in the background of Kiley’s.

    However, Kiley’s voice is decent and it was a good effort.

    Reply /0
  8. 8.
    ND

    The song has BRANDY written all over it, although Kiley Dean version is v.good!

    Reply /0
  9. 9.
    I LOVE HIM? YES I REALLY DO!!!

    I’m with my girl BRANDY on this one…Can’t wait for her to come out with something new. The last album was crazy!!

    Reply /0
  10. 10.
    BRANDYSOURCE.NET

    CALLING ALL BRANDY FANS!
    CLICK THE LINK TO GO TO HER BIGGEST FANBOARD!
    http://brandysource.net/board

    Reply /0
  11. 11.
    After Midnite

    #16. This song was a demo that Brandy did and Brandy is in the background.

    Kiley’s version is nice, however Brandy’s version is better.

    Reply /0
  12. 12.
    Mizphit

    BRANDY!! Kiley could never, LMAO!!

    Reply /0
  13. 13.
    Cupid_Valentino3989

    There is no comparison. I don’t like the song for either of them though. But Brandy’s was a demo, that wasn’t finished. Kiley’s is a HQ finished track. It’s not fair to Brandy to compare the two. But I clearly say Bran sings better.

    Reply /0
  14. 14.
    Siiren

    BRANDY… no one is touching her vocally. lol

    Reply /0
  15. 15.
    Cerone

    DeShawn, hit me up ‘Simple Girl’ please

    Reply /0
  16. Brandy……and I didn’t even listen to the songs…..yeah, I know I’m prejudice.

    Reply /0
  17. 18.
    BrandyIsGOD

    Brandy!

    Reply /0
  18. 19.
    DOB

    I like both versions, but I prefer Brandy’s. It just sounds like a “Brandy track.” She had a more artistic approach to the song. Her adlibs and tone color add to the song. Kiley’s version is cool tho.

    Reply /0
  19. 20.
    Nick

    I LOVE BRANDY sooooo MUCH, so I may be a lil biased here, BUT the other girl has her sound 2 me, its cute on bth parts, BUT BRANDY is jst sooo und-errated!!!!!!!! :) LUV BRANDY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Reply /0
  20. 21.
    Sharonda

    @24 just type in a google search you can find it.I have both of her unreleased material, I personally think Simple Girl is much more better.

    Reply /0
  21. 22.

    kiley’s album was sick with it. I loved simple girl.

    Reply /0
  22. 23.
    David

    I mean is that Brandy or T-Pain? I guess the fact that it’s a demo takes away from it a lot. I give it to Kiley on this one, but I do love me some Brandy.

    Reply /0
  23. 24.
    Zuzu

    Like there is any hope of Kiley out doing Brandy in any way.

    Brandy is a musical genius, she does things no girl can replicate.

    And hands down she murders this track.

    Reply /0
  24. 25.
    VOGUE

    I LIKE BRANDY…

    BUT KILEY’S VOICE IS WAYYYYYYYY STRONGER!!!

    Reply /0
  25. 26.
    Kellz

    Can’t vote because I honestly didn’t like either version since I don’t like the song period. Its not really about the artist if I can’t feel the song and this another example to prove that theory. So thanks Brian! LOL

    Reply /0
  26. 27.
    Rake

    Kiley has a better voice than Brandy…I heard her sing “Crazy on You” and I couldn’t believe how good she sounded. Brandy should do something else…what about getting into the movie biz? Her last album wasn’t “underrated” it was underwhelming, unfinished, irrelevant, garbage!!

    Reply /0
  27. 28.
    Keke

    Yeah this is mad old brandy actually wrote and recorded it around late 2002 so i give it brandy even thou kiely did her thang on it

    Reply /0
  28. 29.
    erik

    brocka kilt it ,she can do know wrong with her voice

    Reply /0
  29. 30.
    _Hottness_

    i like both version of the song but since brandy wrote & recorded the first i’ll give it to her

    Reply /0
  30. 31.
    Kieshia

    Why is it like brandy speaking directly to me it like i fill dat shytt deep in my soul

    Reply /0
  31. 32.
    Zeinabou

    BRANDY hands down i love that girl!

    Reply /0
  32. 33.
    UMMMM...

    Brandy did her thing!!! I am the BIGGEST Brandy fan there is & anythign she puts her voice on is theraputic. And thanks Brian for stating that Afrodisiac was underrated b/c it definitely was. That album is still in heavy rotation w/ me

    Reply /0
  33. 34.
    Thatsuperstar

    i love anything Brandy touches she makes it her own. i have all of her unreleased tracks. I ready for the new album.

    Reply /0
  34. 35.
    TRUTHFULLYCUTE08

    KILEY! SORRY BRANDY U SOUND LIKE UR HOARSE

    Reply /0
  35. 36.
    TR!LLA

    BRANDY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    BRANDY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    BRANDY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    BRANDY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    BRANDY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    BRANDY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Reply /0
  36. 37.
    dominique

    OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!,Kno Brandy didn’t go in kilt that song like that,cant nobody fuck wit brandy

    Reply /0
  37. 38.
    ashia

    Brandy….BRandY…. bRaNDy hands down

    Reply /0
  38. 39.
    shawn

    Damn!!! B’Rocka did her thang

    Reply /0
  39. 40.
    True

    This is truly a BRANDY song. I like Kiley’s voice very much on it but there is no messing with a song once Brandy has done her thing on it.

    #36: It is apparent that you either have not heard the Afrodisiac album or you just don’t know good music. That album really was very underrated and it was one of the best female R&B albums to come out in recent years. The songs on that album are CLASSIC!

    Reply /0
  40. 41.
    Dee

    Kiley stomped all over Brandy version. I love Brandy but Kiley killed it.

    Reply /0
  41. 42.
    Sexxxy

    I wonder did brandy write this song cause of all snuff she’s been going threw cause if she did i can fill her plain……………………………….

    Reply /0
  42. 43.
    TheoSoul

    SOO WEIRD. IT SOUNDS LIKE A BRANDY SONG. LIKE WITH THE VOCALS AND MELODY EVEN IF I HEARD KILEY SINGING IT I WOULD’VE THOUGHT OF BRANDY. SOO WEIRD.

    Reply /0
  43. 44.
    Jaylin

    WoW this a though one cause it the same song in it totally different vocal wise,but brandy kills no matter whats so i’ll give to B

    Reply /0
  44. 45.
    SouthernN.E.R.D.Goddess

    i liked kiley’s version better…im over brandys breathy vocals

    Reply /0
  45. 46.
    Comptons Finest

    brandy..i didnt even have to hear the otha chick…

    Reply /0
  46. 47.
    Knuck

    It sounds like Brandy because she WROTE it. She sang it first and her vocals are still on the track. Brandy was working with Timb at that time and she arranged songs for kiley and sang vocals. If u watch the video for Kiley’s “Make me a song” it actually shows brandy coming to the studio to lay background vocs. Kiley is cool, but she’s bland.

    Reply /0
  47. 48.
    Dev

    I agree with no:5, i think Brandy needs to evolve and change her style, i’m a fan but am starting to think of late that all of her stuff is starting to sound the same also i think she was at her best when she was under Rodney Jerkings and Kayne as they seemed to push her vocals. I also cant wait for the new album

    Reply /0
  48. 49.
    imD0P3

    I like Brandy’s version better but Kiley has a good voice as well.

    Reply /0
  49. 50.
    TRUTH80

    The other chick has the better/stronger voice but this song is so Brandy. The vocals the melody, I think it fits Brandy better. I did like the Afrodisiac album. I like the unreleased track Nodding Off from the Afrodisiac sessions. I listen to it all the time.

    Reply /0
  50. 51.
    jase

    I’ll have to go with brandy on this one..even though Kiley did a great job on it but the lyrical content is most relevant to brandy….just my opinion,dont get it twisted now!

    Reply /0
  51. 52.
    Jules

    Kiley!
    Brandy’s voice is kinda week especially in the beginning…

    Reply /0
  52. 53.
    Cerone

    @30 ta for that. I’ve been following kiley dean for years like robin thicke, hoping she’d make it. She deserves it. Did you know she provided the vocals in flo rida’s tune elevator?

    Reply /0
  53. 54.
    Angelita

    I’m a huge Brandy fan but must say that Kiley got this one. I can’t wait for Brandy to release her album.

    Reply /0
  54. 55.
    Mya

    Some of you need to get your facts straight. Kiley Dean recorded this version first and Brandy DID NOT write this song. And Brandy is nowhere on Kiley’s version, not in the background, adlibs, nothing. And overall, Kiley’s version is much better than Brandy’s take with her computerized vocals. It seems that some of you just came in this thread biased because you’re already a Brandy fan.

    Reply /0
  55. 56.
    Alexis Moore

    @mya u are a damn lie brandy wrote in recorded this song first and she also wrote better dayz ,Confussed and a couple more songs for KD. so u get ur fact staight 4 u try to tell somebody else to

    Reply /0
  56. 57.
    Truthurt

    Brandy kilt it,n that all to it in everyone can see it that why she’s winning in the POLL,Lmao…yall hater need to stop it

    Reply /0
  57. 58.
    i just don't know" Helppppp

    That girl can sing to to b a white chick,but i got to give it to my girl brandy cause it so her
    i just think no one can do a brandy song better than brandy her self i remember j-lo tried to do it on Ryde or Die but brandy murdered that to,lol Kelly rowland did it on that song that B wrote “I hate that i love u” or “Love/Hate” in olivia did and okay job on that song that brandy wrote “Never to far”

    Reply /0
  58. 59.
    i just don't know" Helppppp

    @66.Truthurt

    U anit never lied

    Reply /0
  59. 60.
    Huh

    @mya………………….What da hell r u even talking about Kiely dean have said it before on youtube that brandy wrote the damn song.so that know question on who wrote it in who recorded it first, in on the video she talked about how it was a dream working with brandy in Timberland , and she was also saying how it was a dream come true to work wit them n how quick brandy is when recording…….Yall hater B killing me wit that shit

    Reply /0

Leave A Comment