my vote is for amerie.

LOVE amerie!

Brookes version is better to me, I think alot of ppl will end up saying Amerie because her sounds comes out the Loudest and Clearest through my speakers - that makes a big difference. I had to turn up the volume for the other ones

LMAO is that girls name really leche? As in the spanish word for milk?

Amerie….hands down

With all the gossip and celebrity rumours swirling around the cyberspace..

…and we get a post with Amerie and BROKE Valentine.

CL done fell off..

Brooke all the way!!!

AMERIE AMERIE AMERIE!!! I loved her Because I Love It cd. That was one of my favorite songs off of that album. Her voice is very well suited for that whole go-go live instrument sound! The others were ok but Amerie got this one!

amerie did the thang!! her’s was the most original, and i always love how layered her vocal arrangements are, so i gotta go with Ms. A. That’s mah girl!!

Amerie has a better voice over the others as it meshes well with the beat of the song and the others are just singing over the track and Amerie is with the track…

Amerie

I think the Friday nigh theme with Brooke Valentine definitely put me in the mood to party! I wanted to go out for real! ameries became background music for me. She needs to evolve! Le’ches’ version was hot too.!

Agree with No3
Brokke’s version is funky but i love more the Amerie’s

I’m sorry….but Amerie and Brooke’s version can’t hold a candle to Leche’s version. Her vocals are better, the melody is better….she killed it. And this is coming from an Amerie fan, lmao.

I love all the versions. I always loved Amerie’s so I thought I’d be biased, but they all put their own spin on the track. I’d put them in this order:

Amerie
Le’Che
Brooke

But they all sound good! I have a hard time deciding which is better.

#14, I have always been partial to le’che’s version too - I think maybe because it was the first one that I heard.

Love amerie on this track!

Wooooooowwww….that sure is her (le’che martin), thas kinda crazy. But anywho, her track reminds me of a Brandy track, which isnt a bad thing- just not orginial. I happen to love Amerie’s last album so I am definitely partial to her song out of the 3. Brooke Valentine-Ga-bage.

LeCHE….

vocally stronger than the rest DIDDY is an idiot.

Valentine needs to sing about something more mature… the club scene.. NEXT it has been done… and her vocals are dry and scratchy.

Amerie… needs to get away from any more tracks that are gogo… she is over doing it… move on to some ballads … maybe even a futuristic track…go ask Kanye for one…

For the record. Amerie’s version had a better sound quality… but that isnt due to Amerie. I guess louder equates to better nowadays.

It is a sad day when vocal ability is chosen behind track quality.

Amerie vocals, especially live are so shaky and weak.. she NEEDS tracks.

Everybody sounds great. But, I love Amerie’s voice cause its so sassy & sophisticated,

Leche’s is a little bit better than Amerie’s. But, I think Amerie, and Leche’s are the top 2.

Is there a lack of songwriters out there?

This is to many people singing the same track.

Yeah Amerie for sure the sound production is much better even though I would like something different from Amerie other than the Baltimore beat your feet heavy drums in the background trumpets blasting beat

No doubt Amerie has the best song with tha same beat.

Why are they all using tha same beat tho

I like amerie but leche i s better i like

AMERIE OWNS IT!
HANDS DOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Leche is the biz.

Lets judge vocal ability here people! This is not a who’s more established or who do we think is the sexiest contest! Le’che is kill’n both of these chick vocally and I don’t even know who she is!(but I’m going to her myspace to find out!) Her vocals are sick and I’m an Amerie fan! Sorry Amerie, you lost this round!

Amerie is like the worst singer ever! The only thing she has going for her is her looks

neither

http://www.Shop-Luscious.com
http://www.Shop-Luscious.com
http://www.Shop-Luscious.com
http://www.Shop-Luscious.com

Amerie has the most emotion which I appreciate. Also Amerie’s background layering is CRAZY! Le’che was aight tho kinda boring. Brooke Valentine’s is well written I just don’t like her for some reason.

LeChe all the way!!!

Holddddd on. The only version that would ever get any real play is Le’Che’s version. She killed it hands down. The other two are WACK. But since Amerie has been around longer, it’s biased. And we know Brooke from her single “Girlfight.” But Le’Che still murdered them both. Amerie can NOT sing what so ever. Le’Che’s vocals are better and she used the track way better. So in order it goes:

Le’Che
Brooke
Amerie

Amerie, Is the BEST singer in the WORLD.

Amerie is da best Hands Down who da fuck is the other 2…………….. Amerie is the best in da world!!!!!!!!!!!

brooke and amerie look alike 2 me