( Photos: Wireimage/Wenn )
For this edition of Who Rock’d It Better we have Cheetah Girl and 3LW member Kiely Williams and singer Rihanna wearing the same Betsey Johnson Evening Show Lace Ruffled dress.
Kiely wore the dress at the premiere of the film “Hancock” in June. Rihanna wore the dress that same month while performing at Thisday in Africa. Take your pick…
WHO ROCK’D IT BETTER?: KIELY OR RIHANNA
- RIHANNA (51%, 5,323 Votes)
- KIELY (32%, 3,305 Votes)
- BOTH ROCK’D IT (12%, 1,295 Votes)
- NEITHER ROCK’D IT (5%, 502 Votes)
Total Voters: 10,425
Loading …
The white shoes ruined it!!
I’d have to say Rhianna has this one. The white shoes killed it for me as well. Although both are rocking the simple look the patent leather belt made the dress pop for me.
Rihannas face is throwin me off on this one.. but they both did ok…
I think the reason Keily was wearin white shoes was to somewhat match the rest of the group since they were all wearin mix match black and white…
i cannot stand kiely, and i love rihanna, but i have to say kiely looks better…the white shoes did it for me. rihanna is still my homie though…and i still do not like kiely lol
Ehhhh……..not really vibin’ with the white Crocs, Kiely. I suppose I would pick RiRi…….since I HAVE to chose
The white shoes ruined the outfit and plus they are the wrong type of pump for the classy dress.
lollll i liked the white shoes …. haha….
Rhianna hands down.
Keily made it tacky with those white porno shop hooker pumps. You’re at a movie premiere, not playing nurse in the bedroom with your boyfriend.
I like how Rhianna broke it up with the thin black belt. Her shoes couldve been better too.
imma give it to Robyn..even tho she holdn herself lyk her blatter is abt to explode and she cudnt w8 4 tht song 2 b over so she cud go p…the belt made the dress pop more…
keily luks nyc and pretty also..but if i had to chuz (lyk which fit wud i wear) I wud go with rihanna…
and even tho adrienne is supposed to be a blur…she luks pretty 2…lol…
oh words… i got kiely`s shoes. they are so high its unbelievable. i love them though. cost me a fortune. both grils looked hot. pretty chicks.
CL love what you did with kielys photo love it when there black and white vs colour contrast is used. – i know its off the point but – credit given when due.
I give Rhianna the edge just by the way she has her legs open. It is sexier…hahaha
That dress is hot! The dressed draped both bodies well, but why did Keily have to wear white shoes with it? That just took away from the hotness of the dress. So i’d say Rhianna rocked it better.
thats a ugly black curtain wedding dress lookin table cloth
rihanna rocked it better but its still ugly
Kiely wore the dress better, but the shoes f**ked up the whole outfit.
Rhianna should have dismissed the belt.
Soooo….Imma have to say neither.
The White shoes were hideous. They look to big for her feet.
They BOTH look good in the dress but I give it to Rhianna bcuz of the Larger Belt and I dont like those White shoes Keily wore with it.
LOL! It kills me when people start thinking thier fashion experts in shyt. haha! But anyways I like how Kiley wore hers it look’d cute The shoe were cute for me too! She like me got that different color shoe thing going on. Rihanna looks okay she looks sick ass shyt in this picture though; the way she’s hold her stomach, then her leggs look sick, and someone said it’s sexier the way she opens her leggs. That shyt ain’t sexy at all! And how old is them damn belts around your waist. GET THE FUCK OUT OF HERE! LOL WHO ROCKS THAT SHYT ANYMORE. oH YEA JUS A THOUGHT THERE BOTH AT DIFFERENT EVENTS 1′S PERFORMING SEX APPEAL CAUSE SHE CAN’T SING THE OTHER CAN’T SING EITHER BUT HAS THAT SWEET GIRL THING GOING ON!
AND ONE LAST THING I THINK PEOPLE BE ON RIHANNA DICK CAUSE IF THEY WOULD HAVE SWITCH OUTFITS THEN THEY WOULD HAVE STILL CHOOSE RIHANNA.
BUT NYWAYS PPEACE!
WHEN I MEAN SICK I MEAN IN A NASTY WAY NOT CUTE.
AND ALSO IF PEOPLE CAN LET RIHANNA DO HER WHY NOT LET KEILY DO HER. JUST A THOUGHT
PPEACE!
Does Rihanna own every piece of fabric sewn into an outfit EVER? She is in a who rocked it post every week.
@19, I 100% agree.
That belt just killed Rihaliens dress, nobody wears those shits anymore. Her long ass legs don’t look right either, just like her face. The white shoes gives it a little more flavor, and I like that. I’m not a huge fan of the shoes but I still feel like they gave the dress pop. Rihanna’s only winning because her stans couldn’t stand to see her lose.
*gave
*made the dress pop
I have those Heels in Orange!
But it doesnt go! Sorry!
Cheetah Girl!
Jeeze!
White shoes? Hell naw!
IDK
I like the dress better on Kiely because I dont like the belt Rhianna has on but Kiely shoes are HORRIBLE. So I just dont know.
Kiely looks better in the dress b/c she fill it out. I ‘m not feeling the color of the shoes !
rihanna looks like a boy in a dress
rihanna looks like a boy in a dress
rihann looks like a boy in a dress
Rihanna I hate the white shoes
RIHANNA AIN’T LOOKIN RIGHT..
i said neither, neither one of them have the legs to completely pull that dress off,thats a tina turner dress right there you gotta have the right legs,not just long but pretty lol….may i add that i really dont care for either one of them so that made it worse lol
rihanna of course no doubt about it
Rihanna face looks kinda ugly, I think.
Non of them wore that dress great.
Whats with the…
“Rihanna’s face threw me off” and “why is she holding herself” comments?? HELLO!!! It’s a performance shot, her picture is in motion! She probably only held that pose for .50 seconds! Yall are acting like she stayed like that for 5 minutes!
Okay now that I got that out the way back to what’s really at hand, The Outfit. I’m a big fan of accessories and Kiely has on NONE, so it goes to Robyn.
Who the hell is Robyn?
I agree with #19 too. The belt is soo overated. I like the shoes to. Big and clunky is in for the upcoming season!!!
Rihanna looks like she’s enjoying the dress more…especially with her right hand on her Ella, Ella, Ella!
keily, theres nothing wrong with the white shoes. im so tired of ri in all that boring black like she attend funerals every day, give that dress to solo and watch how she splash color with it, she work it like me.
BOO!!! HEYY CL FAM!!!!
KEILY IS AND WILL ALWAYS BE A MESS!!
# 34
I think people know she was performing but she still had an ugly face shot which took away from others judging the dress… and they are right
Keliy looks better
@ 35 Camille
Wow, you don’t know?
“Google it” baby
Robyn was performing and Im sick of her a lil bit,but do yo thang gurl. The dress ok,but yeah she cud’ve done witout them dam bulky white shoes..lol
Definately Kiely!
The pig face girl on the left rocked it better. But why did she wear those white shoes???
Ri-Ri is performing. People can’t always look pretty while singing. She looks striking in that dress. Kiely adds no personality to that dress.
Rihanna wore it better although you could’ve got a better picture. 3rd LW was never a good look, she always seems to look cheap.
Oh, Robyn is Rihanna’s first name.
I say Rihanna won… she looks sexier.
Kiely…but she’s actually got style…unlike the other unfortunate two in that group, she’s always quite chic.
Is iT JUsT Me…… Or is CL ONLY POST (This BS) FOR TODAY WWWAAAACCCKKKK!!!!!!!!!!!!
@ #19
I totally agree… if the outfits were flip… they would have said Rhi, b/c she changed it up with the white shoes!!!!! Rhi is cute but does she actually own any of these outfits she wears to events, i doubt it……. designers are just using her as a human manikin….. She needs to just get a modeling job, b/c singing ain’t paying (not her…$20k in the bank.. ha ha ha ha hahahaha ha ha ha ha!
Rihanna only got the higher vote because people ”like her”, and please remember, give credit to rihanna’a stylist…..coz it sure ain’t her whose dressing herself.
I think it is pretty messed up that concrete loop hasnt had the decency to post Dr Dre lost his 20 year old son last Saturday!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BOO CONCRETE LOOP SHAME ON YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I MEAN WHO GIVES A SH#$ ABOUT WHO WORE IT BEST. SMDH
@49
I know huh? I just knew there were going to be alot of posts today. Like the photos of Bey&Jay eating out (again) and the news about Dr. Dre’s son passing Saturday. I don’t know whats up either.
I don’t think the white shoes ruined the outfit. And Rihanna has made a fashion faute de gout by wearing Black shoes with Navy !! But ya’ll don’t know anything about fashion so …
The white shoes are more appropriate with navy for a nautical Look.
Kiely wore it better.
Rihanna’s legs look scary
to all those hating on Rihanna , if u haven’t noticed every “who rocked it better” has been compared with Rihanna…why ?? Because rihanna wears it first … She’s the only one u always see shopping in candid pics. So it’s not being on Rihannas dick it’s called give props to a trend setter when u see one. Ps everything rihanna is rocking this year u’ll be running to the store to get next yr. So stop hating
rihanna must pay cl really good. I havent been to this site for a while due to the fact of the sickening rihanna post. rihanna is like word vomit to these wack ass blogs/site.
Oh lord. We got a ugly person up set at other ppls opinion again. If you want to talk about sick(nasty), you should check 3lw’s history. Everybody should know that the reason they put the dark skinned girl out the group was because Kiley and the other hoe wanted her to join them in sexual acts or favors with the members of The St Lounatics in oder to get a collab back in the day. She refused to, so she got dropped. Now thats “sick”. And you just sound ignorant ( yall dumb) or what ever you call yourself because for somebody that has no talent has made quite a name for herself in her own way. You say she took the slut roll in this pick when really she did the complete opposite in this pic and with her whole career. When some one is trying to be sexy or slutty they would not cut their hair. They would get the longest ghetto tracks they could find in order to get attention. Please b*tch, Rih is the definition of class. And you hollering about ppl thinking they are fashion experts, well everyone is entitled to an oppinon if they are an expert or not, and to let you know b*tch Iam an expert, Im in college now for Journalism and Professional writing, what do you do with your life??? ANd for the record, what im doing now is not proffesional at all. I just had to type it so a person of your standards and from your life style could understand. I hope i typed it to your liking.
Wow, kind of got off track dissing this no body. Trying to get info for my new letter and ended up shutting somebodys pointless life down. Go back to wal-mart, or what ever call center you work at.
Anyway, Rih(my girl) Got this in the bag.
Anya Cheri signing out.
AWWWW!! And even if it is navy she has the black belt stupid. U match shoes with belts and purses. Who the F**k matches their acctual outfit with there shoes. I bet you shop at body shop. OMG YOU are all idiots F**k!!!!!!!!!!
Anya Cheri signing out for real this time. Yall done pissed me off.
Every time I try to leave something keeps holding me back LOL(nice quote)
Ok fool. SO Rih doesnt own the out fit… if she doesnt the Kiley deffinatly does not with her disney channel a**. Somebody that couldnt hack it in the real music business couldnt possible affor it, nor would designers throw her the rope to even try it on. Hell that might be knock off ish lol. And no. if rih would have wore the white shoes I would have been like, Rih what the f**k are you doing. but the reality is Rih wouldnt wear the white shoes fool!!! Duh!
Um. Kiely rocked the dress better for me. I think I would have gone with a strappy shoe for that dress in a red to add some color. I love the white shoes, just not with this dress. I hate the belt Rih wore with it and feel like her shoes were a bit too much as well.