WHO ROCK’D IT BETTER?: KIM OR DAWN
Monday, August 25, 2008

( Photos: Wireimage/Filmmagic )
For this edition of Who Rock’d It Better we have socialite Kim Kardashian and Danity Kane’s Dawn Richard wearing the same Black Halo One Shoulder Jackie-O Dress.
Kim wore the dress with Black & White Louboutins at Monte Carlo Television Festival back in June. Dawn wore the dress recently in New York at MTV’s “Making the Band 4″ Premiere. Take your pick…








68 Comments
1.
Jen
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Kim wore it better.I love Dawn but I’m not really feeling the shoes, and Kim just fills the dress out better.
2.
faith1991
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
kim is a betta figure..so she roked it betta..
why wud u wear blak shoes..i noe blak matches wid errrrrrrthang..buh cumm on,,man cha..!
3.
candygirl
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Neither one looks terrible in it but ill have to give Kim this one only cuz she fills it out better
4.
Nothing But Love
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Not feeling the dress..
5.
Ladyssolady
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
As much as I tire of seeing Kim in these dresses, her body is made for them. I’m still finding it hard to believe that she is the size 2 she claims…
6.
nevergiveup
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
I hate to say this bc I like Kim… shes my girl… but im going to have to give it to Dawn ..the dress looks better on a flat ass titty body… and the color pops out against Dawn’s skin ….
7.
the_one
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Just based on the shoes alone I have to give it to Dawn, plus Kim Fakeassian needs a tan and her shoes were ugly but I will say the upper torso area of the dress looks better on Dawn. I just wish she and Aubrey would get to a dermotologist and drink much more water because their skin is so much older then they are, its sad.
8.
RobinNCALI
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Have to give this one to Kim. I like the longer length on her, it gives the dress a classier look. Plus she does have the better body…..however Dawn’s skin looks gorgeous against the pretty yellow color
9.
math
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Both ladies’ shoes are atrocious so I’m just focusing on the dress. And imo it looks a lot better on Kim.
10.
Fine-N-Mellow
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
The dress looks better on Kim but hate that she wore those black shoes with it.
11.
yomama
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
something about kims body seems sloppy and dirty she looks like she smells so i go with dawn
12.
Vee1
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
I hate to say it, but Kim rocked it better because she is more shapely. Those shoes, she could have done without.
13.
iamwhatiam
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Kim actually looks presentable for once. She looks sexy but still classy. I like her hair with the dress, even though she rocks that same hair do every time I see her. Dawn looks like a crackwhore! She is so bonny and looks like Mr. Ed. I’ve never seen Dawn look nice in an outfit.
14.
Bee
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Kim wore it best. The length on Kim’s dress is better than Dawn’s. Dawn’s version of the dress is too short.
15.
Dame(The real singers are back)
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Kim
16.
philly
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
__KIM___LOOKS LIKE JAY LENO__SHE ALSO JUST GOT A NOSE JOB RECENTLY…BUT SHE HAS A JAY LENO FACE SHE IS NOT PRETTY…
HER LIL’ SISTER IS PRETTY TO ME.
17.
dukesman2000
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Kim killed it
18.
Phillyfashionista
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Kim rocked it better HOWEVER, she should have worn some other foot wear…those black shoes are ugly and umm they’re Black!!
P.S. I LOVE the pic of Aaliyah in the backgroud CL!! I miss her so much!!
19.
WhatIThinkIs
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Why does Dawn stay wearing other peoples clothes?
20.
Ladee
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Kim feels it out better, but her shoes messed it all up.
21.
kaykay
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
it’s not cute. i don’t like it on either. nor the shoe choices. the Aaliyah backdrop is the bomb!
22.
Aries
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Kims Shoes dont go, so im giving it to Dawn
23.
toya1
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Kim wore it better. Kim is more shapely and does the dress justice. I love Dawn and DK, but those girls have no sense of style and Dawn’s skin is sooooo oily!
24.
sowhat123456
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Can anyone just admit that Dawn is butt ugly! If none of you want to admit it than I will!
CL keeps comparing Dawn to other women in the industry and she’s lost every single time!
Shit, Mo’nique would win against Dawn at this rate!
25.
TETE
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Those shoes Kim has on gotta go….. but all in all… the dress looks better on her (even though I’d hate to say it, because i can’t stand her!!!)
Nothing Dawn wears she “rocks”… she needs a new stylist… and someone to help her pick out things that will flatter her….. and not make her look soo manish
26.
DVYNEDVA
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
ok..first…i lyk Kim but both of her big toes r sitn on top of her other toes…that shud have been the first sign not to wear those shoes…
I lyk the color of the dress better on Dawns skin…Kim does have a nyc shape but i think the dress sort of luks nyc with Dawns shape 2…ok…so i wont have to think so hard…imma just say Dawn…
neither one of them did the dress perfect but….Dawn just pops more…
27.
Tealeaf
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Kim wore it better, but she looks Chubby next to Dawn
28.
TRUTHEE SHOULD BE MY NAME
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
The dress isn’t great but on Kim it actually looks like a designer creation…but boy is Kim a fat ass. No wonder she’s all in the media talking about working to lose weight…I knew she was “thick” but she’s chubby!
29.
fashionrocks
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Why are you even posting about Kim K - she is racist against black women and such an attention seeker!
30.
♫ Lola AM ©
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
I ♥ Dawn, dislike Kim….but her body looks better in the dress. I like her shoes too
31.
♫ Lola AM ©
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
@ Sowhat123456
Wrong…..but funny. Dawn seems so sweet though
32.
DEEDEE***
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Kim…Dawn is starting to appear very unattractive to me…
33.
complexndope
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
I heard (read) Dawn & Que (from Day26) are engaged. Peep the ring ya’ll.
34.
SEABREEZE (networking)
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
I can’t even really judge because I can’t get past Dawn’s face. Anyhoo, the question is who looks better not who do we like better. Kim’s body looks waaay better and she just fills out the dress waaaaay better (lol)! Go KIM!
35.
daisy
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
dawn makes the dress look okay, kim makes the dress look beautiful, i cant believe believe dawn got over 1000 votes for this dress
36.
Toodles
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
OMG why keep putting Dawn up against attractive women?? Dawn looks like a bobble head Jay Z twin with lipstick and a wig! Please stop asking us who rocked it betta because Dawn will NEVER win…she is TOO DAMN UGLY!!!!!!!!!!!
Kim K wins of course..and she looks stank. So you know what that says about Dawn..she can’t win, po’ thang. that is all.
37.
Tealeaf
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
In the face Kim is not attractive, she has a long trannyface…
Cher Meets Elvira
38.
MAP
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
dawn has no body
39.
Trey
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
@ sowhat123456 & Toodles I know both of you broads must be ugly and very self conscious. Beautiful women with high self-esteem never have to put down others in order to feel better about themselves. Its one thing to criticize someone, but to just be plain nasty and call them names is another.
Please email your pictures to Angel so we can all criticize you. The way you guys speak, you have a dude thinking you look like Lauren London or Cassie. Damn!
40.
Dev
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
I have to agree with 6 but both pairs of shoes are horrid!
41.
Dev
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
24 & 46! Lol!!!! Lol!!! I nearly wet my pants laughing.
42.
Ajah
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
I think it looks a million times better on Dawn.
The color goes great with her skin tone, and it fits better; the dress looks like it’s struggling to get over Kim’s curves.
43.
Kellz
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
This is a prime example of “not for a big(ger) girl” type clothes. Kim looks a hot mess in that dress and her curves aren’t appealing to the eye in it either. I think this is just one of those outfits where a person of a smaller size looks better in it because Damn looks nicer.
44.
tiff
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
i would care if a pitbul had that dress on, i would have picked the dog before kim. i can’t stand a women that makes a living off a being hoe, them kind gets no respect.
45.
Kena-smilez all day
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
num 33 I know right they are so cute together I WISH I COULD FIND LOVE LIKE THAT! they all engaged and he under age jk jk lmao, they said it on mtb what?!….. 4 5 or 6 that he wanted to marry dawn thats so SWEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEET!
46.
callmewhatever81
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Well I have to vote for Dawn here easily. I know slimmer girls will automatically say Dawn looks better and thicker girls will automatically say Kim looks better. I think my body is in between them both so I dont have a biased opinion. Kim is more attractive but not in this outfit. Some outfits were meant for cute petite bodies like Daw’sn while some were made for more of an extra curvy body like Kim’s. This dress was clearly made for a more petite cute body. I personally think they both have beautiful bodies since im not one to think everyone should look the exact same way or have the same shape since that would be boring but personally I think Kim has a little too much of everything to me cause how can anyone ever concentrate on her face or who she is on the inside. Even Jlo doesn’t have all that. Kim has huge hips, huge boobs and huge ass. Whe she has a baby, I think her body will just explode. In the long term, Dawn’s body will hold up better as in her body can only get better while Kim’s can only get worse down the road but thats just my opinion.
47.
Cornbread706
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
CL never gets a good picture of Dawn. I swear, I’ve seen better pics of her in many of the outfits you’ve compared her to others with. It’s like you guys are deliberately wanting her to lose.
48.
cindy
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Dawn wore it better! it fits her body better. this short dress does not look right on kims body.. shes too thick for it. its more for a thinner frame like dawns. also, it looks better on dawns skin vs. kims skin.
49.
Toodles
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
@39, fool please. I don’t need to prove anything to you. My man is happy so that is all that matters. I look one helluva lot better than dawn.. lmao!
Anyway…stop acting brand new. This site everyone gives their opinions. if its too rough for you then bounce your ass on up out of here >>> man up niccra!
50.
Toodles
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Another thing Trey…you must be Q from day 26…because truly he is the only person who thinks she is fine..and he is gay so………..
51.
nelly
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
I think dawn wins this one.. Her petite body looks better in the dress and it pops against her beautiful ” REAL” brown colored skin.. Kim slutdashian is ugly.. Her body looks nasty in alot of the dresses she wears.. That’s why she stays in herve leger dresses because there skintight And hold in all her blubber.. She’s fake as hell .. Her breast are fake, her obvious numerous nose jobs, her fake bottom lip, and last but not least that fake ASS of hers!!! She needs to sit down somewhere I’m tired of seeing her long tranny looking horse face self .. Go away.. Dawn seems to be a very nice person while slutdashian thinks the world revolves around her and she thinks shes the cutest thing since sliced bread and is glad she was rewareded for being an amateur porn star who was pissed on by ray- j LMBAO.. Nasty skank.. White folks are a joke and out of control with these butt implants there so happy was made for there flat bootys.. LMBAO.. Whoever up top said how kim’s body will look lime crap in a few years after she has a child is correct while dawn has a better chance to bounce back after having children.. Kim’s whole family is fake!!! Her Mom Bruce chloe with her breast implants and only god knows what else she’s had done.. There are one plastic family ..
52.
Natasha1
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Well, dawn is not the best looking thing now is she? Thanks CL for driving that point home one more time. sheesh.
Kim K wins hands down.
53.
shannon
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
ok..stop doing this to dawn
54.
A&E
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
The dress is better on a curvy lady, so Kim wins. BUT I totally think that the color yellow looks very good on a darker tone like Dawn’s.
55.
yomama
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
am i the only one who dosnt think dawn is ugly..?
i think she has nice eyes and she seems like a positive person
there is nothing wrong with her body! she looks nice
56.
RocketGirl
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
Dawn wore it better. It was something flabby about Kim.
57.
No Ma'am
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
How can you even vote for Kim with those black ass shoes on?!
58.
Classy
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
I say Dawn overall. Kim has a nice figure, but she looks like she has a pouch in that photo. Kim would have won if she had invested in some spanx.
59.
Cee
Monday, August 25, 2008 /
I think both ladies looked great but I had to go with Dawn. Although Kim’s body is amazing in the dress, her black shoes killed it for me. Dawn’s stappy silver sandels were more fitting and her legs look great.
60.
Cory
Tuesday, August 26, 2008 /
this is the second or third time dawn has been in a who rock’d it better section she needs to be original
61.
DIAMOND
Tuesday, August 26, 2008 /
DAWN : BECAUSE I LIKE HER IN DK, KIM LOOK PRETTY AND CURVY AS WELL.
62.
king
Tuesday, August 26, 2008 /
She is my favorite. I love her. I saw her profile on milllionaire personals site “”"”"”"”"W e a l t h y L o v e s.co m”"”"”"”"” yesterday. It is said she is in relationship with a young handsome guy on that site now. Is she single again?
63.
ballers wife
Tuesday, August 26, 2008 /
kim needs a tan she looks too white in that dress
64.
THEQUEEN
Wednesday, August 27, 2008 /
Kim looks better in the dress but why did she wear them black shoes?
65.
L.A.
Saturday, August 30, 2008 /
Kim hands down cause thats my baby jawn!
66.
kiera08
Saturday, August 30, 2008 /
i wish dawn would get a new hair do
67.
NISHA
Saturday, August 30, 2008 /
KIM K JUS LOOKS 2 DAMN BIG IN DAT DRESS IT LOOKS 2 SMALL 4 HER I LIKE IT BETTA ON DAWN BECAUSE IT FITS HER WELL DEY BOTH LOOK NICE BUT IF ONLY KIM HADNT WORN A SMALLER SIZE DEY BOTH WOULD HAVE ROCKED IT BUT NOW ITS ALL BOUT DAWN
68.
Cara
Tuesday, September 2, 2008 /
Dawn for sure.
Kim looks fat in my opinion…not even thick…she just looks a lil chunky.
And Kim’s shoes are hideous with that dress.