( Photos: Wireimage/Beyonceworld.net )
For this edition of Who Rock’d It Better we have Jennifer Lopez and Beyonce Knowles wearing the same Roland Mouret Pigalle dress, except in two different colors.
Jennifer wore the white version at the Spring 2009 Marc Jacobs runway show last week during New York Fashion Week. Beyonce wore the dress in a grey color Tuesday night at the New Yorkers For Children Fall Gala. Take your pick…
WHO ROCK’D IT BETTER?: J.LO OR BEYONCE
- BEYONCE (41%, 4,218 Votes)
- JENNIFER (35%, 3,666 Votes)
- BOTH ROCK’D IT (18%, 1,835 Votes)
- NEITHER ROCK’D IT (6%, 624 Votes)
Total Voters: 10,343
Loading …
umm…I’ma go out on a limb here and say JLo????
The dress is just BAD all together!!!! Neither rock’d it and Beyonce’s shoes look a mess!
I like J.Lo length better
Bee color of her dress and the jewerly is better and shoes
Hate that purse strap J.Lo
it is a tie for me
Bee rocked it…Her shoes are hot! Not feeling the way J Lo’s legs look. It’s kind of awkward.
Bey should never wear something a 40yr is wearing. Point Blank
i Feel Yall .. i Dun Think Dat Dress is Hot At Yall Srry None Of Dem Rocked it Really & i Love B & J Lo So Sit Down Yall Cuz Dht Dress Ugly
Bey did that. The shoes and bracelets did it for me.
Okay cute dress but I am truly diggin Bey’s shoes. Can you put those shoes out there as to name and where they can be purchased?
YALL KNOW BEYONCE LOOK CRAZY AS HLL WITH ALL THOSE ACCESSORIES ON! HUH?? TOO MUCH TOO MUCH AS ALWAYS!!! THAT DRESS WAS MEANT TO BE UNDERSTATED. THE SHOES AND THE DRESS PAIRED WITH THE SHOES, MAYBE A SIMPLE BRACELET AND STUD EARRINGS, HAIR PULLED UP IN A BUN OF SOME SORT.
LUV HER BUT IS SHE AINT IN A BALL GOWN OR LOOKING LIKE VANNA WHITE SHE DOING THIS, PLEASE B, ITS TOO MANY HOT STYLISTS OUT HERE.
INSTEAD OF WHO ROCKED IT BETTER HOW ABOUT WE EACH REGISTER AT LEAST FIVE PEOPLE TO VOTE ON NOV 4..read this and see why its important.
* If you grow up in Hawaii, raised by your grandparents, you’re ‘exotic, different.’
* Grow up in Alaska eating mooseburgers, a quintessential American story.
* If your name is Barack you’re a radical, unpatriotic Muslim.
* Name your kids Willow, Trig and Track, you’re a maverick.
* Graduate Magna Cum Laude from Columbia and you’re the “darling of affirmative action”.
* Graduate from Harvard law School and you are unstable.
* Attend 5 different small colleges before graduating, you’re well grounded.
* If you spend 3 years as a brilliant community organizer, become the first black President of the Harvard Law Review, create a voter registration drive that registers 150,000 new voters, spend 12 years as a Constitutional Law professor, spend 8 years as a State
Senator representing a district with over 750,000 people, become chairman of the state Senate’s Health and Human Services committee, spend 4 years in the United States Senate representing a state of 13 million people while sponsoring 131 bills and serving on the Foreign Affairs, Environment and Public Works and Veteran’s Affairs committees, you don’t have any real leadership experience.
* If your total resume is: local weather girl, 4 years on the city council and 6 years as the mayor of a town with less than 5,600
people, 20 months as the governor of a state with only 650,000 people, then you’re qualified to become the country’s second highest ranking executive.
* If you have been married to the same woman for 19 years while raising 2 beautiful daughters, all within Protestant churches, you’re not a real Christian.
* If you cheated on your first wife with a rich heiress, and left your disfigured wife and married the heiress the next month, you’re a Christian.
* If you teach responsible, age appropriate sex education, including the proper use of birth control, you are eroding the
fiber of society.
* If , while governor, you staunchly advocate abstinence only, with no other option in sex education in your state’s school system while your unwed teen daughter ends up pregnant , you’re very responsible.
* If your wife is a Harvard graduate lawyer who gave up a position in a prestigious law firm to work for the betterment of her inner city community, then gave that up to raise a family, your family’s values don’t represent America’s.
* If you’re husband is nicknamed ‘First Dude’, with at least one DWI conviction and no college education, who didn’t register to vote until age 25 and once was a member of a group that advocated the secession of Alaska from the USA, your family is extremely admirable.
both ladies need to toss the purses and find better earings and both ladies would be on point, but since it is what it is and b shoes and square braclet is bangin’ b is the winner.
Those shoes that Bey are wearing aren’t for a dress that style. The shoes are cute though. J.Lo done got back since having them twins.
tie………Beyonce’s shoes are fire.
Heidi Klum wore it in white and she had the better look, though J LO certainly chose a pump that was very similar to Heidi’s shoe. I think Beyonce looks out of shape in the dress…and all the accessories in your face this way seem a bit overboard…but that’s consistent and expected tackiness from her, I’m afraid. So, I’d say Heidi did it best, J LO looked great and comes in second and Beyonce looks not so good…
They both rocked it bout, they both gave the dress a different look. J-lo made it more conservative and grown up with the accessor and shoes, but beyonce made it more youthful and fashionable, love the shoes and the color of the shoes and the bags and bangles, and the hair and jay-z complimented it.
All of you who said bee isn’t rocking this is probably jealous that she can afford this dress and you can’t… Not to mention she looks fierce in it.. The accessories and the shoes go perfect with it..You haters of B would find anything wrong with it… J.Lo looks nice but plain..
So b is the winner!!
#10 I LOVE YOUR POST AND COMPLETELY AGREE. LETS FOCUS ON POLITICS FOR THE NEXT 48 DAYS!!!!
OBAMA/BIDEN 08
It’s a tie.. Beyonce shoes don’t go well with that dress.but .I like the color of Beyonce dress better..
Beyonce hands down the white/tan color jlo is wearing appears very boring and plain. I like the grey it does the dress some justice. Bee’s shoes are also off tha chain i am really feeling them pair of shoes.
#10 thank you for the educated political post!!!! OBAMA 08′
I’m gonna say Beyonce..although the shoes are not the business!! I like the clutch, the bangles and the earrings
I say J.lo- Bee has too many accezories going on that it destracts the dress itself
The length of JLo’s is better. I hate that shoulder bag. But I like the simple jewelry and the simple shoes.
Bey has cute accessories but the shoes are too hip for that dress. A pair of manolo blaniks would have killed it! And the bracelets are cool with the shoes but not the dress.
I gotta go with Jenny from the Block!
#10 great post. It shows the biased and downright prejudice that is this years election Obama 2008!! ***And I have gotten my finacee and three cousins all regstered in the last few months***
I gotta go with Bey on this one!
J-lo looks dull!
Jenny!
I like B’s shoes but just not w/ that dress and I’m not feeling her choice of accessories
Beyonce hands down!
Love her shoes.
#21
J LO’s shoulder bag is an odd choice…I’m thinking either she was trying to bring the dress down a bit, make it more casual OR (and this is the one that’s most likely) make it seem as if she’s so stylish that she wears such high end stuff so casually like her best friend victoria… But you know there’s always the third option – she knew that she chose those avant-garde pumps that were very very similar to the pumps/booties Heidi wore with the SAME DRESS a few weeks ago so she tried to switch it up by pairing the dress with a shoulder bag as opposed to what would be the obvious choice (and was Heidi’s), the clutch.
I had to give it to J.Lo…
Love Bee but she had too much going on. The shoes, the clutch, & the accessories are clashing BIG TIME
Like most of what Beyonce does, the excessive accessories and shoes are too over the top. She should’ve kept the simple, but elegant ensemble minimum by just sporting that fabulous 5-carat diamond of hers and those earrings. I’m going with Jennifer on this one.
well its a pretty ugly dress im guessing it looked better on the skeltons walking the runway? but i think J.Lo rocked it better, that grey is just hideous
Also, isn’t this a BENEFIT dinner? The last thing you want to do, is show up at a charity event overly flashy, unless you’re type of celebrity that craves the spotlight…………..
I know B borrowed those accessories from Solo!lol
but they dont go with the dress.
Jennifer looks effortless.Beyonce,not so much.the whole look is confuzing.too much going on there.
The dress is fugly but Bey won this cos of her gorgeous shoes.
The best accessory is the wedding ring BEY is rockin’. Peep the benefit dinner pix with her hubby rockin his ring too. I love them.
Both rock’d it but they should’ve switched colors.Other than that they’re both beautiful!!
I’ll give it to J-Lo hands down. Her look is elegant, sophisticated, and simple. B just went over the top with the accessories. Her shoes are different, but definitely doesn’t belong with that dress.
I like Bey’s length and she accessorized it better. The length and shoulder bag killed it for JLO
Thank you #2 Bey’s shoes are ugly. No, they just don’t go with this style of dress. I thought it was just me. But I see it’s a New York thang. The dress is not cute. I hate to do this..but If I had to choose it would be Jlo.
Okay Bees shoes are hot for this season no doubt / however they didn’t compliment that dress. JLo had the finess wth that dress.
i voted for they both rock’d it…..boring that is lol…its a boring rich wife dress…and seeing as how they are both rich wives….it fits….beyonce is my bitch though and i like her hair more then j-lo and her shoes are kinda cute…..but like i said it looks the same on both of them to me.
my beyonce
bey bey
To be honest b killed it
NEITHER! that dress is fugly. Both women are beautiful, but that dress is not the business.
Wow! I see ya’ll took my advice! LOL! Anywhoo…Like I said before, JLO Killed it!!!!
Beyonce!!!!
Yall full of it if yall said Beyonce. Look at them shoes she rocking. *sigh* JLo looks classic.
Jlo.
She is the epitome of style. This woman can do no wrong, when it comes to fashion.
Beyonce.
Darling you’re trying too hard. And it shows.
J.Lo and Beyonce both put their own spin on the ensemble – they both rocked it.
It appears that dress is seriously unflattering to the arms on anybody.
JLO all day! She actually has more a waist in the dress…beyonce waist almost same length as her hips, and them shoes, ugly, and her legs, dented and spotted all up..
BEYOONCEEEEEEEEE!! ALLL THE WAYY!!
JLo looks old as hell and plain as hell.NO.
Beyonce looks very cute, I’m especially loving the shoes. (Her shoe game is on point). Her accessories are very hawt, probably a little much but they add to that plain ol’ dress. If I saw Jlo rock that I wouldn’t dare to say I loved not even liked that shitty shit, but BEYONCE makes me go “Hmmmmmm, that is actually kind of cute”. It fits her well.
On second look, why does beyonce’s beat up body look like a body that belongs to a older woman? I’m confused, didn’t Jlo have the twins…yet her arms look firmer.
Beyonce’s whole look here is confusing…she’s wearing a ghetto ponytail, with a structured after 5 dress, with a bunch of s&m accessories, ballet shoes that clearly don’t work here, and legs that look like somebody been hittin em with rocks.
JLo just look put together and more classy, though i wish she had a different handbag, but overall i’m sticking with JLo.
@JSCENE
Hun, why bother commenting? We all know whatever the hell you type is something against Beyonce. All your comments summed up say “Hey Look at Me, I hate Beyonce”.Pathetic. No matter what subject it is you’re always finding a way to swing hateful Beyonce comments into it. And granted this is about Beyonce but in previous posts you do. By the status of your comments, I think that you were a HUGE Beyonce fan a while back but you were one of those die hard Beyonce fans that waiting 4 hours for an autograph when she departed from her building but she ended up walking right by, gaurded by her sexy ass body gaurd. I know you were disappointed but things happen. I say this because no normal human will constantly find a such hateful comments about a person and continue spewing them out if they reall were JUST “not a fan”.
You don’t have to like Beyonce of course, we all have opinions. But you really hate the bitch. I mean you’re holding a grudge against her for some reason. WHAT THE HELL DO YOU NEED OFF YOUR CHEST?? Seriously. People who just “aren’t” fans DO NOT behave in such a childish manner as you do.
@JSCENE
You sound foolish. Every woman’s body isn’t built the same, incase you didn’t notice or know. That’s why some woman gain tons of lbs when they’re pregnant yet some dont gain any. Just because JLo LOOKS like she has firmer arms than Beyonce, says nothing. They weren’t born to the same families..so what is your point. I would truly love to see your body because if someone has the nerve to talk so much shit about Beyonce’s body then they must be up to Halle’s status.
Undeniable that B is a very pretty fashionable young lady….but I’m going to to have to go with Ms. Jenny from the Block on this one. B, looking like a BOBBLEHEAD right about now. She has lost way too much weight. Pity for those women that think being a size 3 is it. And no I am not fat!!!!!
#39 and #2 — it must be a New York thing because her shoes are horrendous. They remind me of the 90s for some reason.
JLO always looks so fly. She looks very classic here and I love the dress length. I feel like if the dress was tighter on B and she took away all those clashing bangles and the fugly shoes… maybe it would have worked lol They’re both gorgeous ladies so they always look good…the dress ain’t all that anyway.
J-Lo. Because Beyonce ruined it w/ those shoes, that bag, and that jewlery. She has like 3 different looks going on & none of it is cohesive. U can tell she dressed herself that night
hands down b. j needs to go to church with her husband in baby in that dress. don’t get mad at b she has it on lock. she can wear that dress with some j’s on in she will rock it. j looks nice but she is 40 almost she cannot hang with a 20 something beautiful classy young woman as b. you go b. obama 08 lmao!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I like Beyonce i do. But she always messes it up, always! she has to much going on!!