♫ ALBUM REVIEW: BEYONCE - I AM… SASHA FIERCE ♫
Monday, November 17, 2008

Beyonce gets a little conceptual and reveals a little bit of both sides on her third studio album, I Am… Sasha Fierce, which hits stores and online tomorrow, November 18th.
I Am… Sasha Fierce is probably some of Beyonce’s most impressive work to date. Much different from her previous releases, 2006’s B’Day or her acclaimed 2003 debut, Dangerously In Love, Beyonce explores uncharted territories, especially on the ballad-heavy, pop-driven I Am… side.
With the leaking of her first singles, “♫ If I Were A Boy” and “♫ Single Ladies,” bloggers, fans, stans and haters alike knew that it would be time for the Beyonce media blitz.
Collaborating with the likes of Ryan Tedder, (responsible for OneRepublic and Timbaland’s huge hit, “Apologzie,” as well as Leona Lewis’s “Bleeding Love”) on the second single, “Halo,” as well as Toby Cad, Amanda Ghost, and the production team known as Stargate, Beyonce really delivers some of her most straight-forward vocal performances ever, over beautifully produced tracks. Stand-out tracks from the I Am… side include the Tricky Stewart & The Dream-assisted “Smash Into You,” the airy and eerie “Satellites,” the huge popera, “Halo,” and the very understated beauty of “Disappear.”
Sasha Fierce was a little hard for me to get into at first. When Beyonce announced that this would be a more “dance”-driven side, I assumed Sasha would be offering up a flurry of bombastic, techno-driven Europop sounds much like the leak, “Beautiful Nightmare,” which was retooled and renamed “Sweet Dreams” for the album.
Instead, Beyonce taps into her more edgy, urban side on tracks like the Bangladesh-produced, Sean Garrett-penned “Diva,” her stab at Lil’ Wayne’s boast and gloat, “A Millie.” She chants: “Na-na-na, diva is a female version of a hustlaaaa…” and raps lines like, “Fifty million ’round the world and they say that I couldn’t get it/I done got so sick and filthy with Benjis, I can’t spend it!” as well as “Video Phone.” The high points on this side of the album, for me, however, lie in the techno-synth ode, “Radio,” the confidently pleading, “Hello,” and the Jim Jonsin/Rico Love knocker, “Sweet Dreams.”
All in all, I’m glad that Beyonce stepped it up and stepped out her shell a little bit for the album. She definitely put something on there for everyone, from your pop ballads, to your hood anthems and dance numbers. I Am… Sasha Fierce seems like it will turn out to be my favorite Beyonce effort yet.
Preview the whole album on Beyonce’s MySpace and make sure you pick up your copy of I Am… Sasha Fierce tomorrow, November 18th!








322 Comments
1.
TESSA
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
GONNA GO # 1 BABY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! QUEEN BEE THE BEST HATER DONT COME UP SAYIN THAT ISSH!
2.
JLINZ
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
DAMN THA PICTUER IS FIRE!! BEEE BEE BEEE
3.
queen tee
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Beyonce cover is okay!
4.
JAX
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I CANT WAIT FO TOMARROW
5.
------- Jazzo--------
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I am excited to see what is to come from this album. She been so predictable, so hopefully this album creatively will be the best yet.
6.
se7en
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I agree “Disappear” is VERY beautiful and ..I think it’s her best ballad..she sings with such tenderness..i LOVE it.
7.
Be The Best YOU There Is...
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
The cover is hot, love the way they accenuated the color of her eyes and the gold accessory it just pops against the black and white.. of course I’m getting her cd…
8.
Be The Best YOU There Is...
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
accentuated
9.
ProducedByiQ
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Very interesting concept album… did enjoy the bulk of it… well see how the sales go!
10.
DEB
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I ALREADY GOT THA ALBUM ON MY IPOP N BUMMPIN N MY CAR FO LIE THA PAST 2 WEEKSZ THIS ALBUM BEEN GOT LEAKED OUT DID SHE KNOW THAT??? NO MONEY FO ME TO SPEND WIT THIS MONEY CRISIS GONNA ON
11.
*****Dame (IT'S OBAMA TIME)
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I LOVE LOVE LOVE the CD I know a lot of people won’t like it but it is EXCELLENT better than DIL and B’Day IMO.
Brian I totally agree with everyting you said but I don’t like Diva or Radio other than that the cd is perfect and Video Phone (altough it is childish) that beat is sick and I can see myself dancing to it in the club.
I can’t wait for the tour
12.
Bey/MJB'S MAN!
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
i cant waiiiiittttttt! thIs cd is gonna bve big for her! Get it Beeeeyyyyyy! Hey its BEE SEASON YALL!
13.
Monique
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I bet it is nothing different or creative. Most of her stuff is taken from others, so I don’t give her credit anymore.
Even the glove she rocks now is taken from an old George Michael video
everything about Bey is so contrived and fake to me, no matter how hard she tries to be deep and act like she creates things.
She will still sell regardless, and these days, that is all that matters!
14.
09 CHICK
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
ONLY 3 SONG I DONT LIKE ON HER ALBUM
VIDEO PHONE
CRASH INTO YOU
HELLO
BUT THA REST IS GOOD LOVE IT GOO BEE
15.
Lovinlyfe757
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I like “single ladies” but really not feelin’ anything else right now….its gonna have to grow on me I guess
16.
uugggg
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Cover is fierce … beyonce time needs to be over sick of seeing her .. somebody new please
17.
PeterReTroKidd
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Im so In luv with this cd i can wait till it drop in store. i luv every song on the album..
Key songs:
broken-hearted_girl (Good story)
ave_maria (Good Vocal)
radio (Good Dance Track)
diva (Hood chicks new anthem)
hello (Just luv this song)
Ps luv me so Riri. i;m a die hard fan…but the queen has return..
18.
Travis
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Dissapear and Ave Maria are great songs. These songs showcase her true talent and her beatiful voice. Beyonce is back to take the throne!
19.
Lady
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
“bloggers, fans, stans and haters alike?” -Brian
You are a professional, right?
I mean we all know Concreteloop is a BLOG dressed up in professional, editorial garment, and is the one BLOG that doesn’t feel like a blog at all.
Please maintain the professionalism of the site and keep your bias talk to your personal round circle.
And my apologies for the repetition, but I couldn’t stress the word PROFESSIONALism enough and attempted to incorporate in my comment what your piece lacked.
It’s still possible to express your feelings on the subject in which you choose to write of without sounding as gaudy.
Subtle shots- if need be.
Awesome blog, Angel. I’ve been here since 2006 =]
And I think this album will be great as well.
So far, I love a couple of tracks off her myspace; and I’m not a fan but I’m far from what you’d call a “hater”.
20.
UB
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
150 MILLONS ALBUMS SOLD
10X GRAMMY WINNER
4 NUMBER 1 HITS
GOLDEN GLOB NOD
FORB LIST 82 MILLON WOMEN
ICON
TRUE ARTIST
I LOVE THIS WOMEN !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
21.
ALINA
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I THA WORDS OF YOUNG JOC ITZ GOIN DOWN!!!!!!!!!!!! TOMARROW!!
GETTIN MINE LOVE THA ABLUM
22.
The Good Girl...
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
my fave songs are DIVA, Halo, and Radio. HEAT.
and i mean…it’s gonna be number one regardless, so…let the hate begin!
23.
TEANA
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
BEE LOOK HOT N THA PIC YO SOO MUCH HYPE BOUT DIZ ALBUM SOO BUYIN DIZ!!
24.
GINNA
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I SOO LOVE HALO!!! i love this album much betta tha b’day can wait !
25.
GANLEIYY
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
will be buyin OF couses!! it freakin beyonce!!
26.
JEA
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
BEEE THA QUEEN SHE BACK TO RECLAIM HER THRON!!!!! d
die rhianna die rihanna!
27.
kmniles
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
This post will self destruct in five…four…three…two…one….KABOOM!
28.
Katherine
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Honestly, I think this is some of her worst work to date..In my opinoin Beyonce’s music has gotten worse with each solo album. Lately all her songs sound the same and I think people keep her relevant just for the sake of who she is not for her body of work. There are far better artists out right now..and I think if another artist was to come out with some of the stuff Beyonce has been doing lately it, people wouldn’t think anything of it, but because she’s Beyonce people automatically jump on it.
No i’m not a hater, like I said before I used to really enjoy Beyonce’s music and I do appreciate her work ethic. But this is poor quality music and I will only be buying 2 or 3 songs off of Itunes tomorrow.
29.
JEA
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@ 28 u go do that tha album is still gonna goo # 1 on billboard next week i predict is gonna bush 7,000,000 or more!!! platnium n a week mabye!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i would love to see that!!!
30.
annie
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
lol @29!!!!! naw i think itz gonna push like 8000,000 copies tha first week
31.
LINN
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
haterz FALL BACK RHINNA FANS FALLL BACK THA QUEEN IS BACK
32.
MISSBROWN
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I LIKE Halo nice
33.
Katherine
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@ 28 I think you meant to put 700,000, not 7 million…
34.
Katherine
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Beyonce may sell 7 million total, but I doubt in a first week as no artist has ever done that..I do think Beyonce will sell well, but I just won’t be one of those people buying the record..
35.
kmniles
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Ok Katherine…we understand…thanks for letting us know…mm humm….
36.
BRIAN
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
#19′ I wasn’t trying to take shots at anyone, I was merely trying to get the point across that it seems like with beyonce, people assume you’re either one or the other. and that’s just not the case.
thanks for helping prove my point.
37.
KSH
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I guess I’m in the minority. She just had too much ish going on - the “Ava Marie” & “DIVA” threw me for a loop. There are quite a few other songs that dragged on forever. I think she is going backwards. her lyrics are kinda child playish. I LOVED DIL - but I am just a consumer and I will be buying 1 single so far. “Disappear”
38.
sassydancer
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
“Halo” is the BOMB!!!!!!!! her vocals are madd crazed!!!! go get them girl!!!!
39.
Inspired by Change
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Even though there are times where I don’t understand some of the decisions Beyonce makes as far as her career is concerned I can appreciate them as well as her. It is her dream to be a legend, internation icon, and shes working towards that. Whether you like her or not, think she’s vain, you have to respect her hustle. I like the album and the direction she is headed right now. I do think that there is a little bit of beyonce over saturation going on right now but again respect the hustle. Go Big or go home.
40.
Toriano
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I agree with #19…you clearly are coming from my perspective…
Brian,
I agree with the person who took a moment to check you on the lack of objectivity and professionalism in your posts.
Since all of the information on this site is directed as supplying information, that is what needs to be communicated here.
HOWEVER….I love to visit the site daily to make sure I am on top of the latest and greatest. I don’t mean to be offensive at all. I just wanted to offer constructive criticism.
That being said, here is my opinion of the album:
Who is Sasha Fierce? More importantly, who is Beyonce Knowles-Carter? Music listeners worldwide are more interested in the latter; more curious about divulging into the mind and psyche of Beyonce, the newly married, former lead singer of super girl group Destiny’s Child.
But with her third solo album, widely publicized as her most personal project to date, does Beyonce really give insight into what life is like behind the celebrity trappings?
I Am…Sasha Fierce is exactly what was forecasted: a disjointed package of two sounds and ambiences. In what is described as an album illustrating two sides of the vocal powerhouse diva’s persona: Beyonce’, the artists vulnerable, emotional (sincere) side, and alter ego Sasha Fierce, the domineering, attention capturing diva; the two disc set straddles current music trends of pop on the former, and edgy, street-wise R&B/dance on the latter.
First disc, entitled, I Am, is an adventure in pop sounds and phrasings for the most part. In the grand scheme of this conceptual project, I Am is more rewarding and convincing.
Listening to the twenty-seven-year-old sing about her lover’s angelic qualities on “Halo” and pondering her actions as the opposite sex on “If I Were A Boy” is actually a bit refreshing. An abundance of acoustic elements (piano, guitar) and soaring restrained vocals reveal a distinctively new approach to music for the Houston native, famous for cramming more syllables and words into a single breath than her other female counterparts.
Even here, however, the attempts to incite a certain intimacy are futile. Most notably is “Ave Maria”, which may have been a decent song without the interpolation of the operatic standard into what is an overly ambitious, under-executed filler track. Conclusively, there is no doubt Mrs. Knowles-Carter has the chords to sing just about anything, and I Am, while pleasant, is almost too easy.
Thankfully, disc two, Sasha Fierce, finds Beyonce channeling her familiar, sure-footed sexiness. It’s inevitable that most will skip through a couple of tracks on disc one before they trade it in for Fierce.
With alter-ego in full effect, “Single Ladies (Put A Ring On It)” immediately signals the change of pace and prepares listeners to break out in a sweat. “Single Ladies” is about as synonymous with sophomore album single “Get Me Bodied” as any song could be without being an exact carbon copy. Down to the snappy hand claps and steady foot stomping beat —both songs even have accompanying dance routines—”Single Ladies” may sound eerily familiar, but it is among Bey’s catchiest songs to date.
“Radio” and “Sweet Dreams” are clear attempts to capitalize on the techno craze sweeping airplay as of late. “Radio” finds the singer stepping into Rihanna territory, relying on overemphasis of vowels ‘o’ and ‘a’ while in the midst of lyrics that sound like they were written for a teenager . On the other hand, Beyonce owns “Sweet Dreams”, embodying the song’s irony in her vocal delivery against the bass-thumping, rousing synths and sparkling piano. “Dreams”, a clear gem, was unfortunately leaked to radio and dance floors in the early part of 2008.
After listening to I Am…Sasha Fierce, one will realize that Beyonce’s work with Destiny’s Child on their farewell album, Destiny Fulfilled, is the closest we have gotten (or may ever get) to calling an album by Sasha Fierce herself, personal and probing.
Speaking of the Destiny Fulfilled album, the final track on second disc Fierce, “Video Phone”, borrows a lot from “Soldier” off of the DC3 project. Hustlers swagger and pants sagging low are the catalysts for Beyonce to offer a private “video phone” sex tape. “Video Phone” is rather frank.
We appreciate the notion of trying to present a candid, stripped down Beyonce to the world through music, but this is not it. There are interesting surprises, but this double-disc album package is a lot less compelling than it could have been. Given a recording process that stretched over a year, and a goldmine of seventy songs from which these eleven were selected, it’s hard to determine whether the album’s concept diminished the intended introspective feel or if the concept saved the songs from the project’s lapse in cohesiveness.
Beyonce’s voice is there. She sings effortlessly. A few good songs are there. Top 40 radio will eat up the catch phrases. But where is the evidence of the singer turned actress and wife blossoming into womanhood and relishing in the bliss of married life?
If Beyonce fights the inevitable, at worst she could end up like Usher; playing catch up by the time she is thirty. If she reinvents herself, she may never need to live her personal life on stage. Instead she can follow in the footsteps of Madonna or Tina Turner and “Sasha” all the way into her fifties and sixties.
41.
DIAMOND
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Im from the UK and I got the album 2day.I love it!!
42.
politicallyincorrect
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I heard many of the tracks and I think Bey and her people said lets do a song that sounds like a hit song from last year. She saw how popular Alicias pop album As I Am was and she thought let me drop this hood routine and make some pop records. She got a song thats a little Rihannaish too.
That said the songs are horrible, I don’t think the album is focused. The alter ego thing is not working either.
43.
BlahBlahBlah
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
wow Toriano, that was long….
44.
jamie
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
STAND OUT TRACKS:
HELLO
HALO
DISAPPEAR
VIDEO PHONE
SWEET DREAMS
RADIO
AVE MARIA
All very different. Something for everyone!
45.
Ladyssolady
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
The only songs I like are ‘If I Were a Boy’ & ‘Single Ladies’. All the rest are depressing or just too much, like forced.
46.
SALI
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Beyonce and Sasha Fierce are Desparate. She will end up like Usher.
47.
SALI
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
The only difference between Beyonce and Usher will be that he didn’t try to drag his sibling along.
48.
Shardae
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I will be listening to Bey’s album in full on Rhapsody tomorrow before I decide to purchase! I hope I like it though…
49.
M* of SUnriseSundown.BLogspot.com
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
im so glad they changed the name of BEAUTIFUL NIGHTMARE to SWEET DREAMS
cuz that track is nice to be having a bootleg title!!!!!
peace & thankz brian
50.
Toriano
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@ #43….Lol. It was long. I actually posted an objective, far reaching review of the album and the impact it will have on Beyonce’s career, long-term. Sorry
51.
SALI
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@Toriano
So after all that reading, I couldn’t tell if you liked the album or not?
52.
kmniles
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
#19 and #40
This is a blog and you do not have to maintain a sense of professionalism, though at times it’s much appreciated. I understand you all recognize this place as raising the bar in the blog game but to be honest, one could take the saturation of beyonce posts here as clear bias by Angel but nobody complains about that. So although I might not always agree with Brian I can respect his opinion, which is fair game on a blog.
53.
IgetamnesiawhenI'mstandingnexttoyou
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
This album had me at “Hello” (My Favorite Song).
54.
M* of SUnriseSundown.BLogspot.com
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
SALI :The only difference between Beyonce and Usher will be that he didn’t try to drag his sibling along.
M: Shady. smirk
55.
Getem
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Ummmmmmm I downloaded most of her album like a week ago. Sorry Bee can’t get the album this time. But I’m loving it.
56.
Toriano-URBANSOPHISTIC.BLOGSPOT.COM
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
to SALI
I thought that it was noble of Beyonce to try something new on the first cd. Halo, Dissappear and If I Were A Boy are pretty nice. But they come across as forced.
On the second she just shoved a bunch of sub-par, get you shaking your booty tunes.
I think some of the songs were catchy, but they don’t show a lot of growth.
I am mixed about the entire album. I would give it 3 out of 5 stars, or maybe 2.75 stars.
57.
Mrs.Sk8board P
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Everyone who LOVES beyonce…get that album…it’s crazy and we gotta SUPPORT REAL TALENT..not that other SHIT..REAL talent…come on BK we going NUMBER 1..
58.
Lili
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Why the hell is #19 freaking. I dont see the big deal of Brians comments. Beyonce has fans, stans and haters, as most artist do.
Anyway…beyonce has out done herself with this one…If ppl dnt like this album then they will never like anything beyonce will ever do becuz beyonce gave everyone something with this album. This is really a remarkable efford from her and her team…I mean I am not even a big fan of slow contemparary songs and I find myself listening to the whole side of I am…
I really think beyonce can hit a Million in the first week with this. Her and lil wayne is prolly the only artist out there that can do this. I have a feeling its gonna be some where between 500,000-700,000 but I think it deserves to go a mill becuz the team has really been going al out for this album, and the quality lives up to the hype.
59.
K
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Sorry
But I am still not feeling this album. And her camp takes promotion to a different level, it feels like they stalking me to buy the album. With her camp, the pictures and the videos, this album could not stand on its on. #1 first week duh, her fans got “BNA” in them, they were born to buy this.
SWEET DREAMS IS MY ISH though!
60.
Elegance1981
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I agree with # 28. She can write nusery rhymes and people will love it. There are better artists than her. That DIVA song sounds like Jay-Z has rubbed off on her now. She’s seems as if she is very cocky and self-centered as if the world revolves around her music only. There are many great singers that came before her and are here now. I believe here audience is made up of mostly people under the age of 23.
I wonder what is going to happen when she reaches the age of 31. I won’t be spending my hard earned money on that album.
61.
jamie
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
if you go into listening to this album with an expectation of what you think a beyonce album should be, you will be disappointed. This is not Dangerously in Love Part II or Bday part II. However, this project stands on its own as a good album. She stepped outside the box for her, and as such made herself more vulnerable to scrutiny. But at this point in her career, she can do what she wants. Bravo B.
62.
Getem
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
The songs that I like are Halo, Ego, Dissapear. Diva is ok and single ladies I like because I’ve heard it so damn many times it’s like I have to like it. Now sweet dreams I love that song but she could have left that turn the lights on off the song. It’s doing too much. I know she likes to have that catchy phrase in all her upbeat songs, but she could have left that out. The song was fine the way it was. And one last thing. Though I love a couple of songs on the album she could have done much better. And I’m sorry but most people that sing about the personal things in there lives write their own songs.
63.
☆ Lola A♏ ★
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I will be getting the deluxe edition. My fave tracks are Scared of Lonely, Halo, IIWAB, Single Ladies, Sweet Dreams, Disappear, Broken Hearted Girl, Ava Maria
64.
Intrigue216
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I can’t wait to get my copy from the library and burn it to my computer, lol. Kidding, I might get her album. I like the video phone song, sounds like a club banger.
65.
Beyonce Forever
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@14 09Chick……….REALLY…I Love “Hello”. LOL. Anywho, I absolutely love this album…Imma buy 4 copies. So proud of Beyonce. Can’t wait til she does a video for Ego
66.
Greatestloveofall
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
If Halo gets released as a single, it’s guaranteed to be the biggest hit off the album. Just like Irreplaceable on B’Day that track’s GOTTA be a single. How can it not be, best solo Bey track ever IMO.
67.
☆ Lola A♏ ★
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@ 66 GreatestLoveofAll
Halo and Ego are her next singles
68.
whatsgoingon
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I liked Bey best when she was with Destiny’s Child. She’s apparently a snob and has produced rehashed, borrowed garbage for her fans. Her passion seems to be gone- it seems as if she’s all about stacking chips.
She said on the Oprah show last week, she’s traveling and revealing things to promote her album. Straight out of her own mouth. STANS recognize the game!
69.
SALI
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@Lili
You compare her to lil Wayne but his single at least went #1 on the Billboards before his album dropped. That showed the people were interested. Beyonce singles (2) surfaced 4 or 5 weeks ago and has yet to break into the Billboards #1 spot. Even Usher’s “Love in the Club” went #1 before he flopped.
I think she should be grateful that she can chant in a song about making 50 million worldwide, because she won’t have a repeat performance (and by the way, she is going to need the majority of that to push Solange). She should also realize that TRUE LEGENDS have never bragged about their accomplishments. They let other people do that for them. She must have gotten that from Jayz before his bottom fell out.
P.S. Not a hater just keeping it real!
70.
A FAN!
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I LOVE THE NEW DIRECTION…JUST SOMETHING DIFFERENT AND I AM FEELING IT BEE! I WILL SUPPORT. THE BALLADS ARE SO FABULOUS AND HER VOCAL RANGE IS SICK! THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN HER AND RIHANNA AND CIARA AND THE REST. MARAIH WILL ALWAYS BE GREAT BUT HER VOCALS ARE SLIPPIN LIVE. BEE IS MOVING IN A GOOD DIRECTION….
I AM….SASHA FIERCE AND I WILL…..BE GETING IT 11/18/08!
71.
Jamie872006
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
To me her CD is not all that it’s okay
72.
SALI
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I am starting to think Beyonce fans have to have low I.Q.’s.
73.
Greatestloveofall
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@67, Thanks. Smart move by her camp.
I really hope they start selling replicas of her metal claw/glove she rocks as Sasha its fierce.
74.
Greatestloveofall
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@46, She wont fall off like Usher. Beyonce never married a tranny like he did, didn’t fall out with the media over the said marriage and didn’t fire any parents as her manager
75.
UPTOWN
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
her album is horrible. beyonce is probably the most overrated artist on the face of the earth. her stans should jump off a cliff and land on one of her heels.
76.
CW
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Love the album. will cop a few copies for my car, my office and my lab. This is what happens when a Bee album drops. I been listening to that girl blow since I was 12 years old, now Im 23, in medical school and she is one of my biggest inspirations. Say what you want about it. Im doing okay for myself. People say she is arrogant and cocky, well she’s not, but even if she was, she can CAN be. She is a 27 year old legend whose voice alone makes her a gift to her fans. She inspires, is a great role model, classy and sexy all in one. She really is the women with everything; loved throughout the world and highly respected. Im proud of her and all of her accomplishments and even prouder to be a fan. Go B. ***Med Students for Beyonce*** a group of us will be gettin the album tomorow after class.
77.
TRILLA
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I WISH THE ALBUM WOULD LIVE UP TO THE HYPE.
SHE WENT ALTERNATIVE ON THE FIRST DISC & GHETTO HOOD RAT ANTHEMS ON THE 2ND. THIS HAS TO BE THE WORST ALBUM THIS YEAR.
78.
Knowledge
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I normally do not comment on these types of post but I want to leave a comment for the buyers
How many of you guys live on your own? How many of you guys have a job? How many have kids or other responsibilities? I remember when the president elect in his speech in Tha Go said “Don’t just rely on your government to bail the economy out of this rut, you also have to do your part, be more frugal with your money if the need doesn’t match the means than you really don’t need it you just want it”
So, when you go to your favorite fast-food drive thru, Best Buy or Sears ask yourself one question: Do I recall NEED this or do I just WANT if so, can it wait ‘til later?
Not trying to knock Beyonce, Ludda or any other artist with albums coming out but ya’ll live the good life $20.00 bucks is going to hurt me more…
79.
tsagrednerp
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I love when people get so defensive about things. Brian said ‘haters’ he didn’t say ‘haters (I’m talking about Lady)”. HAHAHA! Hilarious. Continue. SMH
I actually like “Video Phone” somethiong about the song has me moving.
“Disappear” is sweet, cute a little too Destiny’s Child for me but I guess people will like it. I like most of what I’ve heard so far and I am excited about hearing the rest of her stuff. I think she gets better and better with each album.
80.
tsagrednerp
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I also love when people say “No I’m not a hater” That ish is funny to me…Ok hon you not a hater. I believe.
*raised brow*
81.
SALI
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@74
But she did marry a drug dealer.
82.
Beyonce Forever
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
“You had me at hello….hello…” I f-in love dat song. She did the damn thang. Beyonce is the queen. I was watching the 2003-2004 Grammy’s I recored (yeah I kno I’m lame)…and I couldnt help be smile when babyface referred to Beyonce as Our New Queen. He knew then what I know now. Beyonce has raised the bar.
83.
mzcapricorn
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
honestly im not really feeling the slow songs that much except for “hello” but i love ego and radio
84.
Piper
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Can someone explain to me why Single Ladies wasn’t released as a single on iTunes? The video was, but not the song.
I’m going to support Bey and buy the album tomorrow when it comes out. However, I wasn’t really feeling what I heard so far. It will have to grow on me I guess.
I’m extremely disappointed that Sweet Dreams/Beautiful Nightmare was leaked a long time ago. It’s old by now but I guess it’s been reworked and I’ll have to listen to it. I loved it then and I hope a different version doesn’t ruin it for me.
85.
samplethis
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I personally love “Halo” and for some reason even though I really don’t like the track for the past week I ve caught myself repeating ” diva is a female version of a hustla.” “Scared of Lonely” is sweet and tragic at the same time. Especially for me, my baby is getting ready to head to europe for 6 months and I am already feeling that sense of impending detachment. I have to give her her props for trying to develop her sound for today’s listeners without losing one’s identity. I like this better than the bullish women anthem’s of B-day this gives me more of the Dangerously in Love vibe. Congrats Mrs. Knowles- Fierce-Carter ow wateva!!
86.
sit down
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
havnt we been previewing the beyonce album for over a month now,,,
get off beyonces nuts concrete loop
87.
New _Orleans Finest
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I understand #19. Afetr reading tha one statement about the “fans and HATERS…” . What happened to the word “Critics”? Some of do have valuable discrepancies and even just mere opinions about Beyonce`, B, Bee, B. Miss Knowles, Mrs. Carter’s music (that’s for all the obsessed people- who go BEYOND the call of the “diehard” fan duty). Hell, people critiqued Mrs. Obama from head-to-toe, with no resolve, and you don’t see the secret service coming to hail bullets at their asses! Back down, bulldogs LMAO
I just had to laugh
Good luck, Beyonce`, knock ‘em dead, Girlfriend
88.
BEYFAN008
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I WILL BE BUYING MULTIPLE COPIES OF THIS SET TOMMOROW!
89.
lovelovek
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
So i listened on myspace and i’m LOVIN:
-Halo
-Dissappear
-Ave Maria
-Broken Hearted Girl
-Radio
-Ego
Hell, i love/like most of the album! Might as well cop it!…
90.
shana
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I’ve had the cd for about a week now and it’s just not doing anything for me. I only like Sweet Dreams. I’m kind of disappointed. Also, why do people need multiple copies? That’s just odd to me. Why not buy one and burn another on a blank disk?
91.
TooMuch
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Haters fall back!!! Just stop it at some point, enough is enough!!!!
92.
Miss J
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I LOVE THE NEW DIRECTION MY FILR IS GOING AND CAN’T WAIT TO GO GET THE ALBUM TOMORROW
93.
whatsgoingon
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
People are saying they will buy multiple CD’s to sound like they are legal, law abiding ciizens (RIGHT). In the US it is against the law to copy songs from CD’s, but people do it all day long. They call it bootlegging, or pirating.
94.
peacekeeper00
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
lol, I think Music World have people on here posting reviews.
95.
YaChi
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I only like Halo. I think she will do aight, nothing like what she’s done in the past though. And of course they will say it’s do to the economy. That may be true, but for the most part the album is sub-par.
Single Ladies sounds like Upgrade You, Smash Into You is actually SMACK Into You by Jon McLaughlin, If I Was A Boy is from BC Jeans. Diva uses A Milli by Lil Wayne. How is this innovative, creative, stepping it up, out doing herself, others need to fall back, icon, legend Queen Bee material?!?!?!?!
It’s recycled bullshit and that’s MY opinion.
96.
kaykay
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
aww Brian you are too cute-love your long thesis! i like 3 of her songs so far all i can say is i wish the neptunes could have done at least ONE track! but i’m happy it’s Bey Season-she shut it down on SNL…
97.
SALI
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Bloggers keep posting the phrase “I love the direction she is going with her music”? The was the same phrase they used when Solange’s album came out. What direction is that. It they mean the same thing they said with Solange this album should be a total bust.
Why are they not promoting her new movie? It will be out in a couple of weeks.
98.
Feedback
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I like beyonce but Im sorry!!!! From what i heard on this cd…This cd is TRASH it is horrible!!!!!
99.
UrbanChic
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Beyonce killed it on SNL. She not only performed well, but her skit was cute.
100.
*****Dame (IT'S OBAMA TIME)
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@ 72
what makes you think that because I like the cd?
Actually the cd is very good the lyrics are personal on most songs and she stepped outside the box and made a great cd. People complained they were tried of the “booty shaking Bey” All the songs on I Am beyonce are good and heartfelt and her voice is beautiful. Now sometimes I love to dance and that where Single Ladies and Video Phone comes in. I love Ego because everyone feels like that at times. Hello is just the truth.
101.
FlyOne
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Beyonce singing in “pop style” is like Aretha Franklin sing “Baby Hit Me One More time”. Yuck!!!
102.
*****Dame (IT'S OBAMA TIME)
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@ Piper
I have the video for SL off of Itunes and the song is also listed in the songs part like I purchased it. I am not sure why she did it like that but IIWAB is # 1 again and so the SL video Get Em Bey
103.
whatsgoingon
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I just heard Maxwell perform live. That MAN CAN SANG to me anyday, non stop. CL, could you all post more about Maxwell. Bey is cool and all, but ya’ll wore the heck out of post about Bey and I’m sick of it!!!! Please mix up your posts about other artists. Bey is not the Music Industry. I wanna see more info on Maxwell and some other fine male artists out here. Thanx in advance.
104.
ChocolateBeauty
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
love, love, love bey. love, love, love the album. ill be first in line to cop the DELUXE EDITION 2morrow. Go head Bey. The baddest chick in the game will reclaim what is hers. Ri Ri…..no competition.
105.
truthfully
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
That picture up there is the business, that’s the best pic I’ve seen of “Sasha Fierce” so far….
But I had the album like a week ago, its pretty go0d! I like Halo and Ego, but the song where she trynna rap we coulda did without
106.
politicallyincorrect
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@90, I don’t know who these fools are that buy multiple CDs. Even before CD burners were invented I wouldn’t do that. I mean why not put the CD in the case and throw it in your purse. If you do leave your CD at work are you gonna die?
Like who is trying to buy 3 CDs when any normal personal computer in 2008 has a CD burner?
107.
StarzU
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I just listened to Britney’s album and it is FIRE! I really think Britney will give Beyonce a run for her money with records sales. White people will eat this new Britney up…..listening right now and people are like this is hot.
108.
StarzU
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Beyonce is making money from her fans not her non fans, so to tell “haters” she is made $80 million last year, she is a diva…..this is because of her fans, so fans should feel stupid that she is taken your money because you choose to purchase multiple albums which is retarded because you are taking money from your pockets. Her haters may spend time on a blog talking about her but there is no money being given.
109.
Sophie
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Halo was meant for Leona, but she was busy so it was given to Bee-Honestly, Leona would have sung it better.
110.
Janet
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I don’t like neither of them songs, she needs to stop sounding ghetto in her music and start singing with songs that have messages like ( politics, having a good relationship ( not all the time break up songs)
111.
61
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
As far as diva you know jay-z ghost wrote that for her. She sound just like him but she beyonce. Come on people they way she sound like she reading from a paper.
112.
Wendell
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Halo is INCREDIBLE! Easily one of the best songs she’s ever done.
113.
GOLDEN
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Beyonce’s album is fire!! There are multiple standout tracks on the album, and I feel she has really grown. Her vocals are even better, and I love that she recorded different types of sounds for this record. She excels whether she is on a ballad “Ave Maria”, “Broken Hearted Girl”, “Halo”, or a dance number “Radio” “Sweet Dreams”. Beyonce also does a lot of great midtempos on the album, I loved “Hello”, “Scared of Lonely”, as well as “Ego”. To me her whole album is standout, and I agree with Brian for the most part. Also her live performances this era are top notch, and above the rest. She gives her all, and if she is giving this much in performances of her first singles IIWAB and SL then I know the second and third singles will be amazing. Her artisty is undeniable this time around. I love everything about how the vision and execution of this project. Beyonce is an all around great artist, and I will definitely be picking up the album on tomorrow!
Also LOL @ people getting mad at Brian’s review because it is positive. He gave a review of the album based on his perception of it. I guess some people just hate seeing anything positive about an artist and their work. This is his review, put on his blog. I think it is very reflective of the work that Beyonce put out.
114.
Solizzay
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I listened to the cd. I don’t know if I can properly judge it yet, but on my first listen - I didnt even make it through all of it because it got a little boring for me. I like alot of different types of music and I like that Bey is trying to go in a different direction and please her fans that like the more pop side vs. the urban side..but Idk. Its like I’m so damn tired of her that I can’t even enjoy the song. For example the song smash into you, is a beautiful ballad and I know if someone else was singing it I’d probably be more into it because it’d be a new tone for my ear. So in a sense, I am saying that maybe I dislike her album because I’m tired of her. Not only that but alot of her songs sound like they couldve been rejects from Bday for instance Diva which reminds me of upgrade you pt 2. and single ladies which reminds me of get me bodied (in which let me say i LOVE the video & the dancing)… I think vocally, the album is beyond on point but alot of it sounds like or like her previous work…but whatever. Nothing will top her DIL album.
115.
Butterpecan
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
GREAT REVIEW BRIAN. DEFINITELY PICKING UP SEVERAL COPIES TOMORROW!
116.
toni
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I’m sorry, but all these songs are str8t TRASH….I’ve tried my hardest to like them, but it’s not happenin. Bey gotta do waaaay better than this if she wants my money. Jennifer Hudson, Jazmine Sullivan, and Robin Thicke albums are bangin!
117.
ANEWSPIRIT
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I listened to it today. A coworker bought on Saturday. I think the cd is okay.. It is not the best cd yet this year. I think there are a couple of songs that are standouts but it does sound like she is trying to hard to be a pop or white singer. Some of these Lisa Loeb Alanis Morrisette songs don’t work for Beyonce. I am still on the fence about buying it. Cos, it seems like a cd that I will have listen to more than once to get into.
118.
BEYONCE FAN@
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
LETS MAKE IT # 1 BEYONCE FANS!!!!!!
119.
Minx
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
*********SHE TURNING INTO MICHAEL JACKSON YALL!!!!
120.
tara
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
It’s funny how some people are trying to “make” themselves like this album by listening to it over and over again lol. With me, It’s either I like it or I don’t. I don’t have to listen to something 5 or 6 times to see if it will “grow” on me lol! This album is boring as hell no matter who the singer is.
121.
Lili
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Beyonce gave yall majority ballads in DIL, people cried out there was not enough uptempo songs.
So she gave yall all up tempo in Bday, ppl cried out it was too urban and lact substance
Now beyonce is giving yall pop songs, urban bangers, and ALOT of meaningful material and people calling it boring? Like seriously, what the fuk do yall want. I would appreciate it if ppl just say hey I dont like beyonce so I would never like anything she does, as suppose to downing the album and calling it trash, because god knows this new album has songs that are at the top of the pack in terms of production and writing.
122.
CALICARMELHOTTIE
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I LOVE BE TO DEATH SINGLE LADIES IS COOL LIKE A BOY IS COOL BUT I JUST AIENT FEELING THE WHOLE ALBUM. ITS OK I THOUGHT BE WAS GOING TO COME HARDER. STILL LOVE HER THO…..
I HOPE SHE COMES BACK LIKE NAUGHTY GIRL…… HITS NEXT TIME
LOVE YA B
123.
SALI
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@ChocolateBeauty
I’m sure there will not be a line when you go to pick up your copy.
All the people talking about picking up several copies work for Beyonce and all they have to do is swing around in their chairs and get them off the table. I’m sure they are free for employees. Well maybe not (especially with the Knowles). But I’m sure they can at least get them for half price or buy one get one free.
124.
TheEliteJustin
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I love Beyoncé don’t get me wrong. She can sing and she’s amazing… BUT… BUT… BUT… This album is 100% shit… It’s total junk and isn’t worth a value meal at McDonalds… This time I feel she just fooled out… 2008 has been the year of flops. From Janet, to Usher, to even Mariah (although she went platinum). With this below mediocre crap she’s singing… She’s next :[
125.
mellowyel
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
you know, i’m not in love with it. i acknowledge the fact that she’s trying something different, but I’m just not feeling it. It feels like she just amplified “Irreplaceable” to make the “I Am” side, and (insert pop track from B’Day here) to create the “Sasha Fierce” side. to me, it’s nothing new - i’ve heard it all before. I won’t be buying this one, unfortunately (or fortunately).
126.
SALI
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@TheEliteJustin
PREACH!!!!!!
127.
Curtis
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
It amazes me how the things that happens whenever Beyonce knowles-Carter is discussed. You have peeps posting for fans to jump off a cliff and that they should get their IQ checked. Whether a person think Beyonce is doing great music, the truth is, good music is subjective so please don’t be condescending. This goes both Bey fans too. Anyway, this is going to be long so bare with me.
Here is what I think of the double album: My viewpoint is that Contemporary R&B needs more variety as far as adding genres to progress it and this album will do it. Bey don’t have the “prototypical” R&B voice so this is the kind of album that fits best with her voice. A lil bit of this, a lil of that. She’s so versatile she can sing the phone book and give a vocal clinic. Ave Maria is great in that it shows off her classical training. Halo is so passsionate and intense especially for a ballad. I love Smash into you. Learn to be Lonely is also intense like Halo but with a different sound. Still love it. Broken Hearted is a strong song also. The only song that don’t grab me on the Beyoncé side is Satelites. However, it is still very high quality. 4.5 out of 5
As for the Sasha CD, the thing that surprises me is that it is not as Uptempo as I expected it to be. Diva is an ear catcher, and Single Ladies is also an ear-catcher and the lyrics are deeper than you think(Listen to the Bridge). Ego is great. I love the Wordplay(It’s too big, it’s too wide, it’s too strong, it’s tough, it won’t fit, cause he got a big ego). Not to mention, since the Beyonce CD has Halo, it is the song that promotes the devilish, egotistical side of Bey’s performing alter ego which is what the Sasha CD is all about. Video Phone, I could take it or leave it. Sweet Dreams, I don’t like that song. I didn’t like it when it was a demo and I thought that if they were going to put it on the album, at least change the production. They didn’t. Don’t like it. It seem Bey was trying to hold her voice back to fit the weakness of the production. Other than that, the CD is good but not as good as the Beyonce CD. I give it 4 out of 5 which means, overall it is a 4.25 out of 5.
One last thing, anyone who wanted a “deep autobiographical” effort, is not going to get it. The closest we will get is Ave Maria, song dedictate to Jay and their love. But I get the concept: Show that I am a normal woman, maybe even a lil boring away from the stage while a laced-front, ball of energy on the stage. So for that alone, I appreciate it. It is good music, but the kind of album like B’day, those who love it will love and those who hate it, will hate it.
128.
H-Town Chic***
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I’ll be getting the album despite what the haters say LOL!!!!
129.
DONTFEEDTHEHATERS
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
LOVE BEYONCE. stay on the rise B. COPPIN THE CD THIS WEEKEND.
130.
fum
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
This album is actually really good, the ballads are amazin, disappear, ave maria, halo, just beautiful…. this is the new diection, you would never see her in the past recording songs like if i were a boy, satellites or smash into you, or more pop international sound like radio or sweet dreams.
The up-mid tempos, ego, the part when she is singin with the piano is BEAUTIFUL radio, sweet drems, video phone…. all nice! Its different from her previous work and the lyrics are great too.
I am buying it.
Now, this week, If I were a boy will be number one in the BILLBOARD HOT 100, I am telling you this, from what I saw on itunes, its obvious, next week is a takeover.
Now concerning Single ladies, they release it on tuesday so expect Beyoncé to have a number 1 album, 2 singles in the top 10 for the next week. I saw Dangerously in love too, is re-selling really good and is in the top 10 amazingly!
Brian, the ‘haters’ comment is funny lol you’re seem to be such a Beyoncé stan lol but I thank concreteloop for the posivity in the blog and the hype around Beyoncé, you guys are doing the damn thing to promote the Knowles!
I wish her and yall the best.
131.
iknowdasrite
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
This is the first album of hers that has had to grow on me. I remember when I heard B’Day for the first time I couldnt stop listening to it, it blew me away! lol. IMO I think is was her best signature sound so far, still outshining this. magnum opus ish!
This album sounds like it was set up for her and Bey just threw on her lacefront rolled up and did her vocals in day and scrammed. It is severely underproduced, IT sounds like it took two weeks to do, and B’Day sounds like it took as long this. I remember her saying she wanted to be an icon and not just follow the crowd, but this sounds like a complete 180 from what she wanted! I apprecaite her doing some new stuff though “Diva” is that tune! but overall im still a little confused. I know she wasnt ready for quiet storm, and I hope she doesnt go there for another 20 years! Keep shakin girl
3/5 stars from me! lol
132.
iknowdasrite
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
And I can hear Jscene and Asia crackin their knuckles for their keyboards from here! lol
Haters CL will be saturated with Bey for the next month, you better get on board!
133.
Beyonce Forever
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
The reason I’m buying multiple copies is because Imma Bee fan. I’ve do this with all artist I love. I’ll buy 2 or 3 copies and either use them as stocking stuffers, or b-day gifts.
Now, on to my sweet Beyonce…This woman put her heart into this album. She has proven to me why she is so admired around the world.How can someone call this album boring, but listen to Jennifer Hudson’s album and say it’s entertaining. And the ppl that are callin the 2nd disc ‘ghetto trash”…it’s for the club. When I go to the clubs I dont wanna hear no freakin slow ass song. I wanna dance. And thats when they played Diva everyone started moving..it was crunk. And so what she used some of the “A Milli” beat…..no one said anything about Lil Wayne using Beyonce’s Irreplacable pattern in “Comfortable”……
134.
HOT yeah NOT!
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Its okay at best. I will say HALO IS MY JAAAMMM!!!!!
Im really feeling Disappear and Radio. Everything else is on skip. SO yeah not buying this CD, just utubing those three songs till I feel like Downloading them!
135.
Slanted
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
video phone is the shyt, along with Halo, Hello, if i were a boy, diva and a few more i cant remember……normally it takes me a long time to get used to her songs but not this time…..
136.
Don't Be Churlish....
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@121..
THANK YOU! I’ve been saying this for ages. And they do the same thing with her pictures. When she gets all glammed up they consider it gaudy, overdone, or drag queen-ish. But when she gets less dresssed and made up they say she’s boring as hell and has no flavor. WTF? Beyonce can never, ever, win with some people. No matter what she does she will never get an approval from them. Beyonce has done almost everything in the damn book to put a smile on these haters faces but she can still never win. The only option she has left is to whip out a banjo and call it a day. There’s nothing left for her to accomplish to make these ‘nonbelievers’ complement her.
Anywho, I will be getting the album no doubt. Some of the songs still have to grow on me but overall I would rate the cd an 8/10. I already got the whole thing on my iPod and in my car. Limewire is very useful.
BTW: She looks FABULOUS!
137.
norinomo
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
“her album is horrible. beyonce is probably the most overrated artist on the face of the earth. her stans should jump off a cliff and land on one of her heels.”
^^^^^^^^^
ROFL. haha i don’t think they should, but that was pretty funny….
ok i’m not a fan, stan, hater…or whatever else. so here’s my review of the album….i feel that the album is definitely above average, but i was expecting a classic album…and i think this album missed the mark when it comes to that…if a new artist came with this album it would be a good album, but since it’s beyonce, we hold her at a higher standard and rightfully so. i personally don’t care for IIWAB but SL is definitely growing on me after seeing the video…standouts include halo, sweet dreams, and disappear. she was clearly trying to cater to many audiences with this album and i think she did, but i don’t think this is an album we will be talking about many years from now. overall i give the album 3.8/5 stars.
138.
Beyonce Forever
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Last thing….I love beyonce’s sounds, I love Jazzy’s sound, I love Brandy’s sound….This are all different artist, why would we want them to sound the same or sing about the same thing. “Real music” (whatever that is) she expand beyond ‘Love and pain. I mean damn….can some music jus be fun. That’s why I love beyonce, she knows that her fans like to have fun. When she puts ona concert, her fan are on their feet dancing and excited.
I like so many artist, but if they all sang about the same thing, I would be soooo bored. Oh BTW my faves are
1) Ego
Stop Signs (dont think it made the album)
2) Hello
3) Halo
4) Why Don’t You Love Me
5) Single Ladies
6) Scared of Lonely
7) Diva
9) Sweet Dreams
Ok the whole damn album….but esp like Ego and Hello
139.
Maurice
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I don’t care what nobody says (fans,stans,haters,or whoever) this album suckz azz. And if that makes me a hater then so be it.
140.
d
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
it’s been clear he stans for beyonce and keri hilson in part because his friend works for them. what else would you expect from a review. on the other hand i can gaurantee no matter what ciara has on her album he won’t like it. put 100 on it
141.
Darius writes songssss
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I actually think that Brian’s “I Am…Sasha Fierce” album review was pretty informative and overall a very well written piece. I don’t think it was biased or unprofessional at all. In making the “stans & haters” comment, it just acknowledged that fact that people are just generally checkin’ for Beyonce. Furthermore, the statement only reinerated the influence of her two current singles, “If I Were A Boy” & “Single Ladies”. He didn’t run-on with his own opinions, he simply stated the obvious.
Just my thoughts.
142.
jayla06
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I get so tired of people calling others “haters” because they give their personal opinions. Some of you guy’s really need to grow up and stop acting like you’re 12. I swear some of you act as if Beyonce’s paying your mortgage or something. It’s either you like this album or you don’t…I DON’T (nothing else needed to say)!
143.
Sammaji
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I just LOOOOOOOOVE me some RADIO!!!! But thats about it lol.
144.
Me again
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
My fav song sso far is “Hello”, “Halo” & “Ego”. Love Love Love!
145.
FoxyAfroChic
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
HATER: Never points out the STRENGTHS of the album
STAN: Never points out the WEAKNESSES of the album
Fan: Believes in Beyonce no matter how many mistakes she makes
Not a Fan: Doesn’t like Beyonce and never will
Critic: objectively reviews the album and notes strengths AS WELL as weaknesses
So if you have NOTHING good to say about Beyonce, I’m sorry to crush your bubble but that means you are a HATER.
146.
The Truth
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Queen Bey returns the a vengance! I love the picture too! Stunning!
147.
bambino
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
i don’t really agree with this review while the album is good i dnt think its her best work the best tracks for me are broken hearted girl from the i am side and diva from the sasha side although the best song is scared of lonely from the deluxe edition but for me her best album is dangerously in love she can’t top that.
148.
chelly samuell
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Its bullshit to say she doesnt have passion. Who the hell wouldnt go out and make money for it. The things she does, you have to have passion for because if she didnt she wouldnt be lasting as long as she did. Anyways i like the i am mellow side better than the sasha fierce side. im loving dissappear!
149.
DC Glam Examiner
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I heart Beyonce and I LOVE the CD but thus far my favorites are:
Hello
Diva
Ego
Single Ladies
Dissapear
150.
JAZZY
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
DAMN CONCRETELOOP IS ALL ON BEYONCE’S NUTS!!!!! CAN SHE BREATHE??!!!
151.
complexndope
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
#145.
That’s a crock of bullshit. Nice try though. What if someone genuinely feels there are NO strengths to the album?
Does this apply for every artist or is this the list that is drawn up by “Beyonce Standards”
152.
Ego
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
HA! B to the HATERS….I walk like this cause I can back it up!
153.
Jazz
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
ALBUM IS WACK. THE ONLY GOOD SONGS ARE “EGO”, “HALO”, “HELLO”, “RADIO”, AND “DIVA”, WHICH I ALREADY GOT OFF OF LIMEWIRE. DON’T WASTE YOUR MONEY YALL.
154.
yaishay
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Please e-mail comment #40 to Beyonce!
155.
Jazz
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
AND I AGREE WITH #19 AND #40, YOUR SO CALLED “ALBUM REVIEWS” ARE PRETTY WACK TOO.
156.
Jazz
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
…PROBABLY SELL OVER 500,000 COPIES, EVEN THOUGH IT’S WACK.
157.
MIMI
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
This record is just straight genius, the concept (or marketing gimmic) of spliting the record into two entitities gives Beyonce’ the chance to reach out to a broader audience (not that her 300 million strong millitia of supporters need any more help)
Beyonce’ is no longer just a woman, she’s a form of success. in the dictionary it should say : SUCCESS, also known as Beyonce.
SASHA FIERCE AND JAY Z ROCK. SHOUT OUTS TO THEIR DAUGHTER, RIHANNA TOO.
WHEN ARE BEYONCE’ AND SHAWN GONNA POP OUT SOME KIDS?! IVE ALREADY SAVED UP TO BUY THE BABIES RECORD.
158.
Great
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
The album is great. vocals are amazing. Sista can sang. straight up
159.
sexyredd
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I work 40+ hours a week in the hellified BANKING industry. I live alonge and pay my own bills to pay with only me to take care of…and each week I treat myself to something to feel like I’m not just working to live. My treat this week will be the Beyonce CD …I’ve liked everything I’ve heard….
Isn’t an album review sort of an opinion, basically kind of biased? So why yall getting on Brian’s Review?! He states his opinion and so why he got to be biased because he likes it. Are those who don’t like the CD not biased as well? I enjoy his album reviews, so Brian - I appreciate you!
Surely with so much going on, people want to get away from everything and have some fun - and some people find that get away by listening to music…Who really wants to hear a song about politics or message songs all the time??? Seriously, sometimes people want to forget about all that and just have fun…
160.
mzlee
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I used to love me some Bey but she is so darn watered down and fake to me it aint funny she has no originality or creativeness about herself everything she is doing she swagger jacked from some1 else even with the concept of her putn out a double album who she think she is TI vs TIP! she really need to gone somewhere cuz she got about as much personality as a sponge and 4 her to b a married women she was all but naked on the Single Ladies video that was totally outta order,,,,, like i say i use to love me some Bey but with the lies the facade and the fact she think she can do no wrong i am threw with her and i’m sure the cd will sell just cuz she Beyonce not cuz of the creativeness or talent cuz if every1 was honest they know that Single Ladies is just a horrible redention of Get Me Bodied and its hella wack! maybe she should take time out to do what she became on 04/04/08 w freakn WIFE and possible mother and spare us the boredom and let these other ladies get some shine,,,, hell i like Solange better then Bey rite about now and that is not a good thing
161.
Maya T.
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I heard this album for the first time today, and i gotta say it’s not good at all ” i’m very dissapointed!” No offense to anyone here, but I couldn’t even make it through all the songs, it was just that bad. The ballads are DRY and BORING, and the sasha side is GHETTO,GENERIC, and GARBAGE! I’m a HUGE Beyonce fan, but i gotta keep it real this go around. If this is her true album out of over 70 songs she recorded, then their is a problem somewhere.
162.
MYTIMENOTYOURS
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Love Halo, Sweet Dreams, If I were a Boy, Broken heared girl, Diva, Single Ladies, Ego…..Beyonce is BACKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
Whoever says she sounds like Rihanna should go get a slap. Simple.
163.
Tha Boss
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
LOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE THIS ALBUMMMMMMMM!
Its Different, But sooooooo creative! There aint nothin that Bee can’t pull off and we know this!!!!!
164.
JAZZY
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
AGAIN……IS BEYONCE PAYING CONCRETELOOP A LITTLE EXTRA MONEY ON THE SIDE TO PROMOTE HER OR SOMETHING???? I MEAN YOU ALL ARE REALLY ON HER NUT SACK!!! I LIKE BEY AND EVERYTHING, BUT SOMETIMES PEOPLE ACT AS IF SHE’S THE NEXT MESIAH! RHIANNA IS JUST AS GOOD IF NOT BETTER THAN BEYONCE! I MEAN THERE ARE OTHER ARTIST OUT THERE WHO ARE EXCELLENT AND HAVE NOT GOTTEN HALF AS MUCH ATTENTION. IM NOT HATING ON BEY BECAUSE BY ALL MEANS SHE IS A GREAT ENTERAINER, BUT THERE ARE OTHER GREAT ARTIST AS WELL AND YOU ALL DO NOT GIVE THEM THERE PROPS! AT LEAST NOT LIKE THIS!!!!!
165.
leslie arnelle
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Okay I just listened to her myspace page and Im adding
“That’s Why Youre Beautiful” to my list of why I really like this CD! It channels Prince and I heart Prince!
166.
Asia
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Why must we continue to insist that it may even be possible for there to be substance anywhere in the releases of the so-called “artists” who dominate our society’s ring-tone driven, style-saturated, gossip maven-oriented muzak? There are so many reasons not to mention the records released by the Brtineys, Madonnas, Beyonces, and other rank and file image monsters and boy bands of the world. Sure, people want to know what they wore to the latest premiere, but are those people finding any real depth, beauty, or soul in the morass of overproduced studio-created blips and bleeps of audio to which these people attach their names? There is real music out there. Music with soul, integrity, and uncompromising beauty.
167.
MYTIMENOTYOURS
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
^ JAZZY
Just stop with your moaning and let Beyonce do her thing. Rihanna had her 15 minutes of irrelevant fame. Rihanna just as overrated as Beyonce, so at least mention someone who is underrated and more talented than Rihanna AT LEAST…
168.
bombay
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
she will sell 800,000 her first week
I cant wait for the tour
169.
ANGELIQUE
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
favourites =
video phone
hello
radio
infact i like most of the sasha side
I Am is good but i’m finding it harder to get into
170.
Monnie
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
AOL Sessions are out! She kills it!
http://uk.youtube.com/user/iSTAN4BEYONCE
171.
nick
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I LOVE IT, I dnt see y people hate, NOBODY IS PERFECT, BEYONCE LIVE IS A BEAST — AINT NO ARGUMENT there, here music is NOT ALL THAT, I ADORE HER, BUT LIVE IS WEN U WIN ME OVER, THE BIt&H is FIERCE, im sorry!!!
172.
scorpio
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Let the hate COME! LMFAO!
173.
beyonces true fan
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
look at these fools yall can hate all yall want nomatter what shes da best …y is erbody comparin her to rhirhi she good but not as bad as be…neways u know im goin to cop d delux and i love all the songs on thereesp the following:
halo ave maria if i were a boy single ladies videophone(how is it childish she jus havin fun wit her vocals hatas) neways back 2 wat i was sayin hello disappear smah into ..basically like thea said her whole album .love u b the hatas make u who u r nomatter u still gone sell
174.
curtis
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Yeah, she did@ Monnie. She is really growing as a vocalist IMO. I feel that she is actually three years away from the beginning of the her vocal prime as her voice becomes fuller and more mature. It is not there yet, but it is great all the same and not to mention, the things she can do with her voice is crazy.
175.
Ant$
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
the album wasn’t very good…honestly…
176.
OrangeSharpie
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
“I am starting to think Beyonce fans have to have low I.Q.’s.” ROFL!!!! Sali, your crazy.
177.
OrangeSharpie
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
but yeah Beyonce’s CD is not great at all.
178.
ANONYMOUS
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Halo sounded pretty good, but I had to stop it to see Rhianna’s Gucci film. Lol! Not a Rhianna stan or Beyonce hater, but I actually happy to see Rhianna after all the Beyonce posts.
And that was wrong whoever compared Beyonce to Prince. Prince is a mothaf%ck’n artist. You think Beyonce does it all. Prince can put on a concert by himself. He can play the guitar, piano, drums, sing, wirte his own songs, and can act. He’s prettier too (joke)!
179.
malolm
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
my favorites are
smash into you
broken hearted girl
Ava Maria- this is the song she use in her wedding to walk down the isle
dissapear
satalites
halo
180.
crunkpoet
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
the cd is boring…sorry yall
181.
angela
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I personally think that this is beyonce’s best album simply because from her previous albums, there were songs which i definately could do without i.e.listened to them once and was done with them.
I really like both sides but the ballad heavy side I Am….is perhaps the better side. I liked the way she goes all soft on Ave Maria, to being the fierceness that she is in Diva.
Favourite songs;
If i were a boy
Halo
Broken hearted Girl,
Smash into you
Radio
Video phone
Hello
Scared of lonely
Single Ladies
Ave Maria
182.
HCIG
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
THE HCIG IS BACK!!!!
HATERS DON’T UNDERSTAND IT BECAUSE THEY’RE LIMITED IN SEEING THE QUEEN EXPAND.
THIS ALBUM IS FIRE AND I’M GLAD IT’S GETTING GOOD REVIEWS.
WE’VE BEEN FORCED TO SUPPORT SINGERS THAT DON’T SING AND ARE JUST PRETTY FACES IN FLY CLOTHES AND THAT JOKE HAS GOT TO STOP.
BEYONCE IS A TRUE ARTIST. SHE’S ALWAYS GIVEN DIFFERENT SOUNDS WITH HER CHOICES AND TRIED TO UPGRADE HER MUSIC. SHE ALSO SINGS WELL IN DIFFERENT VOICES WHICH IS THE WORK OF A TRUE TALENT.
HATERS ARE NEITHER DESIRED NOR REQUIRED!!!
183.
thebabysitter
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
HALO me!!! I love it!!!
184.
BEYONCE FAN@
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
WAT IS RIHANNA BETTER THEN BEYONCE AT TELL ME PLEASE?!!!!! SHE CANT SING WELL LET SAY THIS SHE CANT SING BETTER THEN BEYONCE SHE CANT DANCE WAT IS IT SHE DONT HAVE MORE MONEY THEN BEYONCE HER ALBUM DONT SALE LIKE BEYONCES SHE DONT HAVE MORE GRAMMYS THEN BEYONCE DONT HAVE MORE AWARDS THEN BEYONCES WAT IS IT PLEASE TELL ME WAT IS RIHANNA BETTER THEN BEYONCE AT? LOL
185.
Whew
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
You guys are stupid for purchasing multiple albums, I laugh at you because no money or nothing is going back into your pockets. Beyonce is laughing at all you stans to the bank, she knows you guys will sale yourself out for anything she puts out. I feel sorry for some of you guys, I bet your monthly bills arent paid but your buying trash.
186.
Whew
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
BRITNEY SPEARS ALBUM WILL OUT SALE BEYONCE.
THE TRUE QUEEN B IS BACK, AND BEYONCE WILL SEE THIS.
I TOO HEARD BRITNEY’S ALBUM AND IT IS HOOOOTTTTT
187.
Jay
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
OK so I just love all music in general….there were a couple of stand out songs and I do like Disappear, but honestly Beyonce could have done better. I don’t think this cd is up to her full potential. With money being tight, a cd these days have to be just absolutely great…but I just don’t really like a lot of the songs on here. To me DIL was her best cd, and with my favorite artists I can truly say that they always make great albums, but each one gets better. I can’t say that with Bey cuz it’s like she really doesn’t grow much as an artist…. But on the songs she sounded great I mean she’s a great singer so that’s definitely not the case.
No disrespect to the fans…not trying to argue with anyone on here…..just my opinion
188.
Rebel
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Smash Into You is CRAZY!!!!
189.
NO ID
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I love Beyonce and her work ethic and drive are off the chain. But…but…I just don’t love this CD. I tried to like it…but I can’t say I do. I feel like lesser talented chicks who can’t sing and need to lean pop for sales would have done better. The songs aren’t bad…just pop radio garbage that sound like they’ve already been out in one way shape or form already. I was expecting Beyonce to take soul/R&B into a new direction….or at least deeper into the one she established already. Or I would have hoped that she could go there. This just doesn’t move me at all…..
190.
Whew
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Basically Sasha Fierce the black album is ghetto, while the Beyonce white album is nice and beautiful.
I really like Halo and Disappear but everything else is boring and ghetto. For Beyonce to be a multi millionaire she should be releasing better stuff than this. Why is she not working with writers/producers like David Foster or Diane Warren to get that grown up feel? I figured it out, Beyonce only works with writers who will give her writing credit. Rodney Jerkins wrote Scared of Lonely and this is the only song where Beyonce is not listed as a writer, Rodney doesnt play that.
I just feel like she tried to hard to do something different and its coming off fake and forced and also sounding like she is trying to sound like you know who, trying to really cross over.
191.
ahsatar
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I love this album and my favs are Hello and Dissappear. I have to say that the pic is fierceeeee (like tyra wld say)!!!! And Im not even a Beyonce fan but damn her she got me this time and Im feeling the music.
192.
Ms. AKA
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Sorry but majority of songs is garbage. This is not Beyonce. she trying to mainstream in the Leona market. Yes her vocals are beautiful. This album seemed so pushed …fake for her… almost forced…I know they tell her to go out of the box but this is not her style. As if she is not enjoying this…I really like Beyonce but this CD will sell in the Pop community. As if she abondened her roots as in her Destiny Days… “Hello” is beautiful and Halo is angelic but the rest is just so sad and boring…
193.
Ms. AKA
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
190 I have written the same thing and I swear I did not read your post…Yes It is a segregated album a white pop side and a black ghetto side. SMH… Not a good look …I will not spend a dime on this flop…
194.
Jazz
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@186- I LOVE BRITNEY SPEARS. I BET HER ALBUM IS BETTER THAN BEYONCE’S.
195.
D@ Pop3
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
TOMORROW,TOMORROW,I LOVE YA TOMORROW,TOMORROW’S JUST A DAY AWAY!!!!
I CANT WAIT!!!!
I’VE HEARD THE WHOLE ALBUM..AND I THINK ITS HER BEST CD YET!!
196.
Whew
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@Jazz
Honestly, Britney’s album is better. I know they are in two different lanes, but being that Beyonce decided to go pop on this album Britney has is on lock.
On Britney’s new album there are 6 songs that I like and on Beyonce’s there are two.
Check out Mannequin, Circus, Leather & Lace, Blur, Amnesia, Phonography, and Womanizer is catchy. I know Brit is crazy but she gives a great performance, and its interesting to see what her and Beyonce’s #’s will be because Beyonce has never gone up against Britney as a solo artist. People forget that Britney sold more records than Beyonce and DC by herself and white people are really waiting for her. Britney’s Blackout album sold as much as BDay without any promotion.
197.
Phresh
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
I am a big Beyonce’ fan and I am very open to all music but for some reason, I am not feeling this one at all. Of course I love “Single Ladies” and I recently discovered my love for “Radio” but that’s about it. I think she shows great range with the songs on the album but I just cannot get into it. I am not a fan of the ballads and the pop songs are just quite elementary. “Diva” and “Video Phone” have great beats but the lyrics are just plain dumb, there is no way around it. I challenge true fans to really examine the album and listen objectively and see if you will still sing her praises. As I said before I love her and I believe she is a vocal powerhouse, but I think her lyrics are quite, how do I say it…simple.
198.
bria
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@20 Stop believing everything the Knowles put out. Not her with DC nor her by herself have 150 million cd’s sold. Get real okay. And stop exaggerating what she has done. She does not need that she’s done pretty good for herself. But I don’t think this CD will sale alot. I think they are going to do just like they did with B-Day and repackage it and put it out again.
199.
Kellz
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
“Disappear” is a good song but I didn’t like the other two.
200.
Just Saying
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
U EITHER LIKE OR U DONT BUT EVERY NEGATIVE COMMENT ISN’T HATING SIMPLY AN OPINION ,REMEMBER PEOPLE THIS ISNT A FAMILY MEMEBER SHE JUST MILKING U FOR UR MONEY Y UR STRUGGLING TO PUT GAS N UR CAR LMAO GROUPIES!!!!!!!!!!!!!
201.
Spare_Me
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
CL must be on the Knowles payroll.
202.
Meka
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Love this album Broken Hearted Girl has been on repeat, but yes I’m going to go support this girl and buy the album.
203.
Tonia
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Comments that shouldn’t offend…
For the everyday “sistas”: Bey looks like she needs a touch-up in that first photo.
For the “au natural” sistas: Bey looks like she needs a hot comb in that first photo.
204.
Aliesha
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Beyonce is to me the best performer/singer alive in the music industry…..Now a days you can’t name too many singers that have the gift that Beyonce has. So please don’t hate, give her credit. As you can see, she is in the music industry for the love of music, not for the money like many other artists seem to be….If you don’t have anything nice to say (KICK ROCKS) you are not entitled to your opinion if it’s negative
205.
natalie
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
i really think nothing is wrong with this music or the album. I believe that just because its beyonce she should stick o r&b. She flipped the script and did it well. The album is good. and her best work work to date.
DIL was good but her vocal were not as good and most of the songs were based on sex.
B’day was very angry and catered mostly to the females but was good. some of the lyrics and subject matter was not substantial but the instrumentation on the album was crazy.
Review
growth 9/10
vocals 8.5/10
arrangements 9.5/10
lyrics 8.9/10
total 89.75 approx 90
A-
206.
CHERYLINMIAMI
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
190.
Whew
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Basically Sasha Fierce the black album is ghetto, while the Beyonce white album is nice and beautiful.
I really like Halo and Disappear but everything else is boring and ghetto. For Beyonce to be a multi millionaire she should be releasing better stuff than this. Why is she not working with writers/producers like David Foster or Diane Warren to get that grown up feel? I figured it out, Beyonce only works with writers who will give her writing credit. Rodney Jerkins wrote Scared of Lonely and this is the only song where Beyonce is not listed as a writer, Rodney doesnt play that.
I just feel like she tried to hard to do something different and its coming off fake and forced and also sounding like she is trying to sound like you know who, trying to really cross over.
—————————————————————————————————————-
DO YOU KNOW HOW MANY SONGS BEYONCE AND RODNEY HAVE DONE? DO YOU KNOW HOW LONG SHE HAS BEEN WORKING WITH HIM? RODNEY AND BEYONCE HAVE BEEN WORKING TOGETHER SINCE DESTINY’S CHILD…..DOES SAY MY NAME RING A BELL?
207.
Luvbug
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
Sasha Fierce,lmao, that shyt sounds so tranny……………….is she packin nutz.
208.
Whew
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
@206
Oh that video where the other members of the group learned that they were out the group by watching the video on BET? Yes, I remember Say My Name it was released in 2000 recorded in 99 it was when Rodney Jerkins was just starting out because he was mainly writing and producing for Brandy. Bets believe Rodney learned how the Knowles do it and how they take royalties for adding one word, he is not having it. If your going to make an example come with something that is recent and not 8yrs ago when someone is just starting out and learning how shady people work.
209.
Angel
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
some of the songs …like Video Phone….sound REALLLY cheap, rushed and forced…but I must say the songs on the Beyonce side are absolutely beautiful..and you can tell THOSE are her personal songs…and the songs on Sasha seem so far fetched…they were more hard to believe….
Overall I dont think she is going to do as well as BDAY did, but She will DEFINITELY be #1…
+ she cusses a few times…lol…
I think she should have named the album…
Mrs. Carter
210.
Pink
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
You know when beyonce is desperate?
when she start doing aol sessions
things she never did before
211.
sit down
Monday, November 17, 2008 /
sit down hoe this album is str8 shit…beyonce a ghetto mess who would have ever thought this was the same chick who sang me myself and i
212.
Greatestloveofall
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
@196, I thought Blackout was her lowest selling record. Just less than a million.
B’Day outsold it.
213.
HELP
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
Help i think i caught the beyonce flu
i cant stop patting my weave !!!! ahhh help
214.
HELP
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
lol greatest love bey didnt even hit number 1 with her new singles she sucks!
215.
yes
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
she coulda left beautiful nightmare alone
216.
greateststanofall
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I will give up a kidney for beyonce
fall back haters
the bee is stinging
bzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
217.
Meka
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
@
210
How does that make her desperate doing AOL sessions lots of popular artist have Alicia Keys, Mary J Blige has done AOL sessions. I guess they are desperate too.
218.
Whew
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
@212
Blackout sold about a Million, but keep in mind that this was out any promotion and no deluxe releases she was going crazy at the time. Beyonce release Bday, Bday Deluxe, Video Anthology, and Bday in Spanish and sold more but not that much for the energy put in.
219.
SOUL
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
DIVA IS A DAMN LIE, SHE AIN’T THE BEST! THERE ARE MANY OTHER PEOPLE WHO ACTUALLY PUT OUT BODIES OF WORK. This whole album just seems so fake to me. I mean, she tried something new, but i don’t feel anything in it. And i don’t care if Beyonce sold ass on the side, Rihanna will NEVER be better than her! If you want to compare Bey with someone, try Alicia, Jennifer, or someone who can actually sing and are talented…
But i feel Bey has some soul searching to do, pull some realness in her music. IIWAB is great to me, cause i feel something in that, but the rest are tired ass songs. I love Bey, shes a great artist, but i feel this album IS NOT better than Dangerously in love!
220.
bombdiggity
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
Like ive been saying for weeks this cd is not good at all, I will give her disappear though thats been on repeat when I sleep. Everything else just seems forced to me, like it took her two weeks to record(which some people do). im sorry I dnt blow up people’s ego like beyonce, rihanna, etc im to grown for that. To be honest I would love to hear Leona Lewis sing Halo anyway I think her version would have been more soul full. Halo aint that good like people are blowing it up to be.
Like people have been saying 2008 hasn’t been a good year for artist, everyone has flopped, or been to hyped up for nothing. All this promoting and we get wack cds. I wont even download beyonce’s cd, as a matter of fact i cant even remember the last cd i bought. No i do TREY DAY YESSS and that still gets bumped lol
221.
HELP
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
Kanye - Rihanna Was The Best Thing To Happen To Beyonce
November 12th, 2008
During an album listening session, Kanye played his new album ‘808’s & Heartbreak’ for selected media and guests.
After hearing listening to the album, Kanye took a Q&A session.
When asked about his single ‘Love Lockdown’, Kanye explains why he chose to make the single.
‘This is a wakeup call … people in music get comfortable … Rappers get comfortable’.
Kanye said this was the case with Beyonce.
‘Rihanna was the best thing to happen to Beyonce’, referring to Rihanna’s rise to stardom suggesting Beyonce had to set the musical bar higher.
Kanye believed that Beyonce did this with her new video ‘Single Ladies (Put A Ring On It)’. He expressed his respect and love for it, while saying it was a concept that he never would have come up with.
hahahahahhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahahhahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahhahahahaha
222.
heelp
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
Kanye - Rihanna Was The Best Thing To Happen To Beyonce
November 12th, 2008
During an album listening session, Kanye played his new album ‘808’s & Heartbreak’ for selected media and guests.
After hearing listening to the album, Kanye took a Q&A session.
When asked about his single ‘Love Lockdown’, Kanye explains why he chose to make the single.
‘This is a wakeup call … people in music get comfortable … Rappers get comfortable’.
Kanye said this was the case with Beyonce.
‘Rihanna was the best thing to happen to Beyonce’, referring to Rihanna’s rise to stardom suggesting Beyonce had to set the musical bar higher.
Kanye believed that Beyonce did this with her new video ‘Single Ladies (Put A Ring On It)’. He expressed his respect and love for it, while saying it was a concept that he never would have come up with.
223.
heelp
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
hahahah kayne said it stans
224.
HELP US
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
Come on ppl this whole album. Is so LAM E , This girl is so , so , so needy and desperate ,,,,,,,, i hate to Bring Rhi into this , but Beyonce is desperately,,, chasing Jay- Z love FANTASY ( Rhi ) ,,, and this whole entire ALBUM is a Mixture of stolen work,,,,,, Rhi and Beyonce is on two different level’s , AND NO MATTER HOW MUCH , THE THREE OR FIVE PPL THAT go from blog to blog, trying to make her work look like some prize ,,,, no one in their right mind believes YOU ,, unless your at that child like mind set of age 13 ,14 and mom pay’s the bill’s ,,,, AND I know THAT fact for sure because i get paid to KNOW Who’s that Hot POP star,, that the world is talking about , and want to look like ,,,, AND it’s not Beyonce ,
1 . 75% percent of my reader’s see her , As out dated , and this publication is in all cities across the US and the international Market .
2. 95% percent of them see’s her as a country fried Bad , tacky, classless Image .
3 . 100% percent see her as a Unoriginal ARTIST .
Now before beyonce fans get’s upset , most of my reader’s, are high fashion , high income families 100,000 and up , Over the age’s of 24 , international traveler’s , 95% Master degree’s , Best private school educations , Best college’s , Best neighborhoods complete country club World .
And , as a person that love,and research the Pop world , most of the world , and my reader’s can do without Beyonce fan’s trying to force feed,,, this frauds album to these gossip BLOGS …
225.
V .
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
@224 Help Us , I know who u are , I love reading your stuff and i am with you .she is a real Copy Cat and she’s so boring , And seems so unintelligent …
226.
SO WHAT!!!!
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
— WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BEYONCE LOOKS SO OLD YO SHE ATLEAST 45 YEARS OLD I SWEAR… LET ME FIND OUT! ROFLMAO
227.
GA
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
Her music is beyond overrated. Soulja Boy single handedly ruined hip hop…she is single handedly ruining music. I hope this is her final album.
228.
SO WHAT!!!!
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
—————- TOMORROW IS THE BIG DAY BEYONCE IS SO GONNA FLOP AND I SO CANT WAIT!!!!!
BEYONCES # 1 HATA !!! LMAO
229.
biological
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
Hate it or love it Rihanna is the first person to shake Beyonce up
230.
fresh
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
she dosnt look 45 but she def aint 27 either…them knowles are sneakier than people think they all seem like a bunch of robots every single one of them even solanges son has a robotic smile
231.
QUEEN BRITNEY
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
YEA I CANT WAIT…………………………………….. FOR BRITNEY SPEARS NEW ALBUM I LOVE HER!1!!!!
232.
QUEEN BRITNEY
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I LOVE BRITNEY SPEARS
233.
QUEEN BRITNEY
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
BRITNEY SPEARS IS MAKING AN HUGE COME BACK SHES GONNA KNOCK EVERYONE ON THERE ASS
234.
QUEEN BRITNEY
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
BRITNEY SPEARS IS THE SHIT FOR REAL
235.
QUEEN BRITNEY
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I LOVE BRITNEY SPEARS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
236.
QUEEN BRITNEY
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
BEYONCE IS TRASH…. ITS ALL ABOUT BRITNEY SPEARS BABY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
237.
QUEEN BRITNEY
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
GO BRITNEY SPEARS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
238.
QUEEN BRITNEY
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
BRITNEY IS S COOL AND HOT I LOVE BRITNEY OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1111111
239.
QUEEN BRITNEY IS BACK
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
FUCK BEYONCE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I LOVE BRITNEY AND SHES BACK TO TAKE HER SPOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
240.
QUEEN BRITNEY IS BACK
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
BRITNEYS NEW ALBUM IS GONNA BE VERY HOT !!!!!!!!!!!!! I CAINT WAIT
241.
J-Queen
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
Okay…Bey is my girl and everything…but this CD is str8t GARBAGE!!!!!! OMG…i can’t even begin to say how bad this cd actually is…it is boring as shit…I like beyonce, i really do…she can sing and dance her ass off, but people let’s be realistic 4 a second…say this wasn’t beyonce’s cd, say it was MJB, keyshia cole, rihanna, or ashanti’s shit…it would not be good AT ALL!!! so how da fuck are ya’ll saying this cd is incredible and personal and great and shit…i don’t see or hear anything great about this mess!!! this is a travesty, str8t chaos…first she stealing songs and ya’ll saying she wrote is from the heart, lie about writing songs, she sung it from the heart. come on, i am tired of this BS!!! there are artists who have way better cd’s than this that didn’t sell that much when they should have…baby just cuz u can sing that don’t mean shit….that’s y rihanna shitting on that ass!!! she need 2 find her own self and just be her and she’ll be str8t but no she wanna be fake and shit. bey i luv ya, but i gotta tell it like it is, u need 2 step yo game up and STOP STEALING shit, lmao!!!
242.
ThaRealz
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
FOR THOSE WHO CRITICIZE ASK YOUSELF THIS QUESTION:
What female artist can sing her ass off and dance at the same time that is presently in the game?
Beyonce competitors are Rihanna, Mariah Carey, Keyshia Cole, Mary J, Janet, Leona Lewis ect….
Which one of these ladies works harder than Beyonce?
Why hate on the hardest working lady in the business?
Her competitors are talented in their own right but no one does it quite like she does…. Dances her ass off sings her ass off and entertains her ass off
Beyonce does it again!
243.
Pink
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
Meka
it makes her desperate because she never did that before every other artist do aol sessions except madonna so far and britney beyonce tought she was too good for that shit and now she need all the promotion she can get cuz her dang singles aint gone number one nowhere but on itunes
244.
Pink
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
FOR THOSE WHO CRITICIZE ASK YOUSELF THIS QUESTION:
What female artist can sing her ass off and dance at the same time that is presently in the game?i’ LL GIVE YOU THAT BUT BESIDES TINA TURNER HOW MANY PEOPLE MADE IT OUT AS ICONS JUST BY SINGING AND USING THEIR VOICES? COME ON NOW IT AIN’ T ABOUT WHO DROP IT THE LOWER IT’ S ABOUT WHO CAN SING THEIR ASS OFF, YOU KNOW BEYONCE CAN’ T ENTERTAIN YOU IF SHE DOES A 2 HOUR CONCERT DOING NOTHING BUT SINGING YOU’ LL FALL ASLEEP ALICIA DOES THAT SO ALICIA HAS HER BEAT IN MY BOOK
Which one of these ladies works harder than Beyonce?
ILL GIVE YOU THAT TO BUT AT THE SAME TIME BEYONCE IS MARRIED AND STILL SACRIFICING HER TIMA AT HOME FOR A CD AND THE LIME LIGHT
SO NO SHE DONT WORK HARDER BUT SHE SURE LOVE THE BUSINESS THAN HER OWN LIFE
Why hate on the hardest working lady in the business?
WHAT DO YOU CALL HATING ? SO FAR PEOPLE BEENG GIVING HER HER PROPS THEY JUST SAY IT LIKE THEY SEE IT, THAT’ IMATURE OF U TO SAY THAT PEOPLE HATE BECAUSE THEY EXPRESS THEMSELVES
Honestly i’ m a huge beyonce fan but the truth is , a flop is what she needs to remind her that the reason we loved her on the first place was because she was doing good music, now she put garbage out and expect people to buy it just because her name is on it, that’ s bullshit and i can’ t imagine what stupid iresponsible person will put as much effort in making someone else than themselve rich and confortable yet have the nerve to defend them like their mamas, beyonce stans are touched by the recession yet have enough money to buy everything she put out how sad is that?
Yall need to get a life
245.
Kenny
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I really think people should not buy this album, honestly this is not her best work. Do not purchase an album just because you like the artist, the artist should be giving you their best work for your hard earned money. I agree with the above post, if this were Ashanti, Brandy, or Christina Milian everyone would think it garbage. Beyonce is to famous and rich for her not to be putting out better songs, Whitney, Celine, and Alicia have great lyrics really something to listen to 20 yrs from now… I cant imagine playing for my kids Single Ladies, Diva, Ego, or Video Phone. Beyonce knows her fans will buy anything, but why is she releasing garbage to black people? Sasha Fierce is ghetto and embarrassing, but I guess whoever likes it is ghetto too.
246.
Hotness
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
That’s all I am saying she uses such dumb lyrics for her “urban side” and then for her Beyonce side it is better quality. What is she trying to say? And Beyonce hasn’t sold 150 million worldwide, you stans stay lying about this girl’s achievement, the only person that has come close to that was MC. I try and be a critic so I heard the whole album, I like “Halo” but it confuses me how she says this was her most personal album but the song was written for Leona Lewis, shouldn’t the song have been written personally for her? “Diva” sounds cheap, if she is so successful why does she have to brag about it. And going on a world tour and bringing in $50 million isn’t really success, Christina Aguilera did that twice over so did Justin Timberlake, so I don’t get why she is bragging. I am excited though for the first time she has competition. Cause the last time she came out with an album she was the only artist really singing.
247.
aDORAble
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
First of all she never sold 50 million, for some reason she and everyone else wants to include DC numbers with hers. If you take DC’s numbers out, you would find Beyonce barely sold 20 million.
Next, this cd is below par, just like her target audience who buys her crap.She never grew as an artist but apperently she’s got awhole lo cocky, just listen to”Diva”. Need I say more? Like many other people have said there’s better talent currently out there. Case in point Alicia Keys, MJB, Jhud, and my gurl Brandy, whose cd is coming out and worth buying.
248.
SOUL
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
AW NAW, YOU DEN SAID SOMETHING ABOUT ALICIA! ALICIA DANCES AW WELL BUT DON’T HAVE TO SHOW HA ASS WHILE DOIN’ IT! AND I KNOW YOU AIN’T TALKIN ABOUT BORING WITH THEM TIRED ASS SLOW SONGS BEYONCE JUST RECORDED! DON’T BRING ALICIA IN THIS, CAUSE ALICIA KILLS BEYONCE!
1. SINGS WHILE PLAYING THE PIANO, GETS UP AND DANCE WHILE SINGING, AND SOUNDS FANTASTIC!
2. THE HIGHEST SELLING BLACK FEMALE IN FIRST WEEK (Beat Bey by almost 200,000k)
3. HAS 11 GRAMMYS!
4. DON’T HAVE TO SHAKE HA ASS TO GET ATTENTION!
Don’t bring Alicia in this. Alicia is not only a singer, BUT AN ARTIST.
249.
aDORAble
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
First of all she never sold 50 million copies.Let’s end that right now.She and everyone of her fans wanna include DC’s sales with her’s, which is false.If you look at her solo sales she barely sold over 20 mill.
As for the cd.LMAO at the people buying garbage, and to think she gets rich from the very same people who buys it.This is the same booty poppin songs and the forced ballads that were on previous albums.She hasn’t evolved at as an artist except being cocky, and this self centerness.Just listen to “Diva”. All I know I will be spending my money on “Real” talent like my gurl B-rocka whose new cd is coming out soon.
250.
aDORAble
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
^^^ Highest selling black female in first week? Are you kidding me? Umm have we forgot about Whitney and MC?
251.
SOUL
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
First week highest seller, not of all time^^
252.
SOUL
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
they have sold more all together, by Alicia beat Marys record last year with As I Am by selling about 750,000 cd’s first week
253.
FallBackHaters
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
That’s going straight in at #1 worldwide!!
Her album is HOT!
254.
THE H0USE OF BEYONCE
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
ALL I HAVE TO SAY IS EGO!!! IS GOING TO YOUTUBED SOMETHING MAJOR!! TRYNA GET MY ENERGY UP FOR IT LOL!!! I LOVE EGO! SO FAR THAT WAS INSTANTLY, COMPARED TO OTHER SONGS.
255.
wish i spoke french
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
Oh dear I actually like video phone. LOL. Will be coppin the CD tommorw. Dont love all the songs bt Scared of lonely/ hello/ ava maria /dissapear/ why dont u love me/ sweet dreams/ iiwab/sl/broken hearted girl - make up for the songs I dont like. Please dont compare her to Rihanna , I like Ri and have loved ‘rehab’ since last year and I cant wait to see the video but in all honesty they arent even in the same level, Alicia and Bey yes. Ri and Bey no.
256.
Original Diamond
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
SINGLE LADIES IS ON ITUNES NOW!!!! AND THE ALBUM IS IN STORES TODAY.
EVERYONE SUPPORT BEYONCE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Buy Single Ladies and the Album today!!!!
Make beyonce number one!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
257.
Original Diamond
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
THE ALBUM IS NUMBER ONE IN JAPAN!!!!!!!!!!!
258.
Original Diamond
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I like Britney too, but please dont even go there!
Who in their right mind is taking Brit Serious?!!!
IT’S BEY SEASON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11
259.
Dior
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
it’s hella funny how people ALWAYS have something negative to say about Bey. Just admit that the girl is DOIN HER THANG! and get over it! lol. THE GIRL IS ABD WHETHER U CHOOSE TO BELIEVE IT OR NOT! And this album will be #1. and I’m pretty sure THE HATERS will hear a song and be like ohh ok she iight! HATERS I TELL YA! hahahahah
THE GIRL IS DOIN HER THANG! AND THIS ALBUM IS THE BEST!
260.
Dior
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
correction: the GIRL IS BAD!*
261.
Soul Cry
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
…Video Phone…I probably played that 8 times on the way in this morning. I like Diva as well. I love iTunes, you can purchase only the songs you like.
262.
Stony Jones
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I AM OFFICIALLY SICK OUT THIS ISH…
I think Beyonce needs to be ASHAMED of this album. He is the problem I have. I saw her do an interview recently and she said she record over 70 songs for this album. So you mean to tell me out of 70+ songs those were the best? Beyonce is a great performer, however she is not held to the same standard as other singer. #19 and #40 I agree with you guys 100%. I have heard this album and reallllllllllly tired to get into it but I just cannot. B Day was forced on us. So you really had no other choice but to like it after a while. Everyone knows if Mya or Brook Valentine came out with this album then folks would be dogging them out on her.
#40 made a very good point. How in the hell can you introduce Sasha Fierce when no one still knows who Beyonce Knowles-Carter is? I am truly ANGRY….Not at Beyonce, but at her fans because they don’t expect must from her. So she gives the public FOOLISHNESS and people praise it like it is the best…Beyonce has NOT made a solid album yet. She has the genius to made a “Full Moon” type album yet she wants to steal Lil’Wayne’s music and make stupid song called “Diva”
This music review section is really losing its creditability with me. I understand Brian wants to be in the Knowles treehouse club however people us know the purpose of this site. Is it to give an your real opinions about music, or it is to be cool with these famous singer? Please let me know. I understand that we will not agree on everything. But lately you been getting out of hand.
And just because someone does not like this album doesn’t mean they are a hater
263.
Soul Cry
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
@stony jones
You say your mad at the music review section…but is it not based on opinion? Just as your opinion should be honoured so is that of the reviewer…with respectfully disagreeing.
That being said, I do not look for substance in a Bey album…just my next workout/dance tune.
People have to know where to place their expectations…I know that if I am looking for some substance I will pop in some Jill Scott, Me’Shell Ndegeocello, Anthony Hamilton, Prince, Maxwell, Leela James…to name a few.
Like beauty, music is in the eye of the beholder.
264.
Soul Cry
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I just don’t understand why people take Beyonce so personal. Why do you care if she does well or not? If people like her or not? Is the world going to stop because she has a fan? I mean it’s truly not that serious. She is an artist in the sea of many. Stick to your likes and ignore those you dislike.
You would think she snuck into your room and stole your favorite draws. lol
…I kid…I kid…
265.
jojo
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
DEB is a lame ass hoe!
266.
dee
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I can’t stress enough there is no emotion in this chick and nobody really know who she is and this ish seems very forced, let the haters come at me because you all know its true, what a price to pay for fame. TLC is forever the best girl group ever for me.
267.
TARA
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
HER NEW A;BUM STINKS THE WHOLE ALBUM IS PHONY WHY DO PEOPLE SAY ITS GOOD SHES NOTHING BUT A COPY CAT A HUGE FAKE
268.
MuZACK
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
So forreal, there is sa lot of unhappy in the world. I think if music is positive and it makes you feel good then why hate on it?(her) the girl can’t help the God-given talent she has… When are we as ppl going to stop throwing salt and respect the art of creating music. Those are her feelings, thoughts and experiences on her records… If you don’t like it then don’t respectfully… I don’t say that because she’s Beyonce’. I say that because she is human just like you and I. And she gives of herself…Just like we all can do if we stop bickering about who’s hot and who’s not… There are people dying and starving everyday… Get over this and go out there and help someone in need…. Everyday of the year!
269.
TARA
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
HER MUSIC SUCKS
270.
TY
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
BEYONCE IS A BITER SHES NOT ORIGINAL AT ALL
271.
dee
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
People Akeys is the highest selling female for first week sales. She is an artist end of story. Beyonce is forced no emotion.
272.
dee
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
@ 268 her music is not positive, all that drop it like its lhot ans showing her crotch and ass and shit, Where is that positive, J was getting that for eight years and just married her, who is she to give advise.
273.
MISSY
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
HER ALBUM IS SO PHONY HER CDS ARE CRAP HER VOICE IS NOT THAT STRONG SHE SCREAMS TOO MUCH SHE COPIES EVERYONE HER MUSIC STINKS SHE JUST WANTS THE MONEY THATS IT SHES NOT TRYING TO MAKE A GOOD ALBUM I LISTEN TO JAZMINE SULLIVAN THESE DAYS EVEN JENNIFER HUDSONS CD WAS SHITTY R AND B WAS DEAD UNTILL JAZMINE SULLIVAN CAME BACK OUT MARIAH CAREY SOUNDS LIKE CRAP NOW MY GIRL FAITH EVANS IS NOT OUT SO I JUST LISTEN TO THE OLD SHIT CAUSE WHEN BEYONCE STARTED COMING OUT SOLO THE WORLD CHANGED AND HER FANS THINK SHES THE BEST SINGER AND SHES NOT GIVE ME SOME SWV, XSCAPE ,MONICA,SHANICE , KELLY PRICE, THOSE ARE REALSINGERS BEYONCE IS NOT A REAL SINGER HER MUSIC AND LYRICS SUCK
274.
dee
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
@ 273 those are some real artist, thank you real singers.
275.
MIKE
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
RIHANNA IS BETTER THAN BEYONCE SHES ORIGINAL AND NOT CONCIETED LIKE BEYONCE NOT FAKE LIKE BEYONCE
276.
Jai
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
You were right Brian, haters,stans, and everyone in between will have SOMETHING to say about Bee’s new project, I love the album artwork and the songs you listed are GREAT! You should’ve listed “Ego” too. I just love that song! That’s my jam of the moment, but I’m sure it’ll chance after listening to the album all the way through a few times. LOL Bee has done it again!
277.
PRIMA
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
It sucks…I’m going with the LA times critic: close but not quite…
278.
Jai
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
And by the way, STOP WITH THE RIHANNA/BEE COMPARISONS! That shit is MAD OLD and MAD POINTLESS. Why are they even being compared in the first place? Bee isn’t going anywhere, period. She’s been doing this since she was what, 17 or 18 years old? She’s 27 now and known internationally. She is one of the most hardworking women in the business and she’s not going anywhere. Get over it! This blog was a review of her new album. Whoever brought Rihanna into the mix or anything not related to what Brian is trying to talk about here needs to go take a fuckin’ nap ASAP. All I have to say is…I can’t wait to see the Billboard charts next week. Some folks are gonna be madddd. Go Bee! Next up…KANYEEEE.
279.
Wherestheluv
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
@stony jones
You say your mad at the music review section…but is it not based on opinion? Just as your opinion should be honoured so is that of the reviewer…with respectfully disagreeing.
That being said, I do not look for substance in a Bey album…just my next workout/dance tune.
People have to know where to place their expectations…I know that if I am looking for some substance I will pop in some Jill Scott, Me’Shell Ndegeocello, Anthony Hamilton, Prince, Maxwell, Leela James…to name a few.
Like beauty, music is in the eye of the beholder.
I agree 100%. It has been said that Beyonce’s fans are shallow, stupid, etc. I am a Beyonce fan and I am far from shallow. I like all types of music from old school, new school, gospel,rock, pop, rap, country, r&b etc. Why do music fans have to be pigeonholed. Is it not possible to love and respect Beyonce and to simultaneously love and respect Jill Scott (whom I’ve admired since her first cd)? In the past year I’ve went to both artists concerts because you know what: I like to dance and I also like to chill sometimes. I am not one way ALL the time.
280.
PRIMA
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
#279
All Beyonce fans aren’t shallow but the ones who come on blogs and act like insane zealots ARE quite simple. It’s so annoying. There are Beyonce fansites, you know…they could go there and never have to be angry and attack us.
281.
g
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
AWWWWW PPL ON HERE ARE VERY SAD THAT BEYONCE IS OUT… BUT HEY LIKE BK SAID SHE CAN’T PLS EVERYONE SO WITH THAT BEING SAID B DID SELL OVER 150 ALBUMS THAT’S INCLUDED WITH DESTINYS CHILD… SO THAT WHERE SHE CAME FROM…. YALL ON HERE ARGUING ABOUT BEYONCE ALBUM THAT MAKES THE HATERS LOOK SO DUMB AND OBVIOUS CUZ WHEN U COMMENT ON SOM1 U DON’T LIKE U KEEP IT MOVN BUT IN THIS CASE THE HATERS STICK AROUND TALKN BULLSHIT…. I REALLY WONDER HOW OLD SOME OF U ARE..
282.
lauren
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I heard both Beyonce’s and Shontelles album already…both of them coming out on the same day and I must say I am very impressed with Shontelle’s. More so than B…her stuff is starting t to get old! Definitely go cop that Shontelle!
283.
Soul Cry
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
@Wherestheluv
THANK YOU!
284.
NYC
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I’m not gonna lie im a huge beyonce stan and i usually like everything she put out on the first listen but the first time I listened to this album I was like what is this shit but i listened to the album about 3 more times and it really grew on me. i guarantee that if all the people who say they dont like it listen to it a couple more times they are gonna love it… its just that the more albums and artist puts out the harder people are going to judge their work because there is so much other previous work to compare their new stuff to. I think the problem is that we were expecting for this album to sound a certain way and when beyonce completely stepped out of the box we were so suprised that we didnt even know how to respond to it, but just wait an see this album is a classic
285.
naturallysexy
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I love Beyonce, but her album doesn’t stand out from her other stuff. I just going to start supporting the new artists like Shontelle. Now her album is FYAH!! http://universalmotown.com/firstplay/shontelle/
286.
PRIMA
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
Okay, you fans can stop lying…Forgot about “Beyonce day” on 106…flipped past in route to something else and guess what? She was performing Single Ladies and she absolutely does lip sync! At least on the parts where she’s singing loudly! She missed the track on the bride and the camera was in her face!
287.
PRIMA
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I meant on the bridge
288.
Jace
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
AMAZING. Beyonce is such an AMAZING artist and the quality of her work is impeccable. I can’t stop listening to both disc. She had me at Hello…….
289.
jayla
Tuesday, November 18, 2008 /
I’m not getting the beyonce album…its way too overated! i just got the Shontelle ablum…loves it!
290.
Brownsista
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
Bottom line…this album is not worth the money. For someone who puts themselves on the highest pedestal possible, whether its her willing to outshine or overshine every female artist who dare to dominate the #1 spot (even her own group members), Beyonce really took a drink of confidence of splitting a 1 LP album into 2….NICE TRY!!!
There’s nothing here that brings out the Beyonce she knows she’s supposed to be. So its obvious that listening to this album is a fascade to the ear…with the exception of “Halo”, where she pulls off a nice Leona Lewis challenge, and the actually BANGER on this entire package is “Scared Of Lonely”. Those 2 songs are the reason for the 2 stars.
Once again…..It’s not worth it. Unless you are a CD collector or you just wanna see some sexy pics (5 star photography lol….hmmmm), this isn’t worth your money.
Also, she seems unable to recapture the charm and excitement that was “Crazy in love”.
If you go for the regular edition of the album, you miss most of the best songs (”Smash into you”, “Hello”, “Ego”, “Scared of lonely”, and bonus tracks “Save the hero” and “Why don’t you love me”). It’s really pointless getting the regular edition. All 11 songs on the regular edition could have conveniently fit onto a single disc.
I won’t be surprised if months down the line, she releases a deluxe deluxe edition including the good songs that should have been on the album in the first place, much like she did with “B’day”.
291.
Gossip Boi
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
Absolutely brilliant!
http://www.gossipboi.com/
292.
What i say goes
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
Beyonce is just in it 4 the money. When will yall realize?? These blogs give me a headache and i do believe that alot of people are on her pay roll. I honestly believe that beyonce reads these blogs. Smh. That is sad. I know her feelings be hurt, its not her fault. She cant please everyone. I think her cd is trash. Real talk. I dont like it and i dont have to apologize to anyone.But on a lighter note. Beyonce keep doing you cause if u like it then thats what matters. You already made your mark and thats the truth.
293.
get over it
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
people on this site are psycho.
lmao at beyonce haters watching her on 106 and park. ‘prima’ you sound like that crazy ass jscene/gem or whatever. you must been really paying close attention to her performance. all artists lip sync at some point and we all know beyonce can sing live so get a life.
beyonce has the #1 video song and album on itunes. her album has sold out in several stores so i guess ya’ll opinions dont matter because people are buying it.
when has alicia sold over 130 million records?
when has rihanna won 10 grammy’s?
when has mary jazmine, etc ever been as popular as beyonce?
beyonce is the most popular, most successful, and richest black female artist of this generation period.
get over it haters.
294.
AMBERFIERCE
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
THIS WAS DEFINITLY A DIFFERENT DIRECTION FOR BEYONCE I FIRST HEARD THE CD ON HER MYSPACE PAGE AND I WAS A LIL SKEPTICAL…BUT AFTER REALLY SITTING DOWN AND LISTENIN THE CD I WAS LIKE “OK” I’M LOVIN IT…….BEYONCE IS SO DIFFERENT AND SHE IS ALWAYS COMING OUT WITH WAYS TO REINVENT HERSELF….AND THAT IS WHAT MAKES HER A TRUE ARTIST!!! AND ALSO THE FACT THAT SHE CAN ACTUALLY DANCE AND SING IN A LIVE PERFORMANCE!! MAKES HER FIERCE! WHAT ARTIST OUT ACTUALLY SINGS IN A LIVE PERFORMANCE AND DANCES AT THE SAME TIME!!! PLEASE NAME ONE!!!! THERE IS NONE! YES THERE IS OTHER GREAT SNIGERS OUT!!!! BUT NO ONE SINGS AND DANCES AND PUTS ON A PERFORMANCE LIKE BEYONCE! SHE’S A BEAST! SHUTTIN EM DOWN!
I LOVE THE ACOUSTICS SHE USES IN HER SLOW SONGS ITS SO DIFFERENT…….SHE ALSO STAYS TRUE TO FORM WITH “VIDEO PHONE” AND “DIVA”………..
BEYONCE CAN PISS ON A SONG AND I WILL LISTEN 2 DAT!!!!
KEEP ENTERTAINING US AND STAYIN BEAUTIFUL AND HUMBLE B!
UR SOUL IS PURE…..I LOVE U!!
295.
PRIMA
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
#293
Who am I????? I know you’ve got no life but don’t be silly…really!! And you’re wrong…Beyonce’s album isn’t #1 on Itunes..it isn’t even 3… And it won’t be on the UK charts either. As for 106, I told you I was in route to another channel! And I happened to see her dancing and then the bridge…she was soooooooooo lipping…hahahahahahaha & it kills you, I guess. lol
296.
PRIMA
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
My bad. It’s #2… She’s got the #1 song on the top 100 on Itunes but Rihanna’s rehab is 20…so…lol
297.
Daw
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
The people that don’t like the album obviously and not really musically inclined. I agree that it’s not the “Normal” Beyonce but I LOVE the album. It’s different and shows growth and that’s what we all want right? Instead of the same R&B music that she has done. We want an artist to grow and release music different from the previous. I give Beyonce an A for effort cause this album is great and It has touched me already, I can literally feel the lyrics and feel where she’s coming from plus there are a few songs on the album that hits home for me! This album will prevail cause it is great work!!!!
298.
LOST ONE
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
I am a real big supporter of Beyonce, but I wasn’t impressed with this cd. I hear vocal renditions taken from DC3. For instance, Disappear seems like a spin on DC3’s Free and she sings similar tune taken from DC3’s Independent Woman Part 2. Also EGO track sounds very similar to a track from Fighting Temptations. In addition, I felt the overall cd wasn’t cohesive to pull off alter ego. I had expected more. I still like some songs on the cd. Oh well.
299.
WillPwr
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
As one who loves Beyonce because she represents my hometown (H-Town) I hate to say the CD lacks substance and artistic growth. This CD will not be a classic that people will continue to play years to come.
Rating: D-
300.
I Am Sasha Fierce Reviews | The Urban Daily
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
[...] at Concreteloop.com [...]
301.
Tamara
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
I don’t like this CD. It will sell because of her. Can we please talk about someone else? Beyonce is just doing too much!!!!! Growing sick of her.
302.
Da Best
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
This album is doing really well. It’s sold out everywhere and it’s gotten great reviews. I’m OVERLY IMPRESSED with her vocal powers on here. She even hit a #6 note in a few of the songs!
Beyonce is the best b*tch in this game.
303.
Thank You
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
Thank You Beyonce for being the beautiful woman you are
Thank You Beyonce for carrying yourself like a woman at all times
Thank You Beyonce for giving me THIS HOT C.D.!!!!
Thank You Beyonce for haivng such an AMAZING VOICE!!!
Thank You Beyonce for ALWAYS UPGRADING YOURSELF
Thank You Beyonce for ACTUALLY HAVING TALENT
Thank You Beyonce for holding down the ladies always
Thank You Beyonce for ALWAYS BEING HUMBLE
Thank You Beyonce for constantly challenging yourself musically
Thank You Beyonce for being the HCIG!!!
304.
CGJ
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
The “Beyonce” side is too pop for me - there is no soul. The “Sasha Fierce” side is too ghetto and pop.
She didn’t need to go pop to be iconic - ask Aretha and Mary J.
I bought it. I supported. Hopefully it grows on me.
Can’t wait til Brandy’s “Human” drops.
305.
TOREALFOR YA
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 /
man this cd literally SUCKZ !!! i usually love beyonce and i have been a fan since destinys child first came out , but i have to honestly say i am very very very very very very disappointed n the album……. she needs to find herself and fast.. yes the fans love her and she is always gonna be a performer but honestly do u fell that she is overrated at times.. j. hud and jas sullivan will blow her out the water,, but they cant dance like her but thier singing is amazin!!! but hopefully in the fututre… she will get it together…..
306.
TOYA
Thursday, November 20, 2008 /
Alot of people just flip thru music and dont listen to the music these people typically like everything thats on the radio, artist understand this so they make that basic stuff that simple people listen too. But if you actually listen and stop listening to find that catchy track …..That Ave maria is beautiful it almost had me in tears and i think you have to be in love to feel that one that much Ave maria means hail mary she speaks about mary at first then she compares her love to this her heaven on earth its too deep for them radio listeners u know …. BUT I LOVE every song in it own little way
People stop haten that why we cant get no good music out these artist cuz we got the radio listeners out here makin it hard am glad to hear music that got meaning great job B
307.
To
Thursday, November 20, 2008 /
yeah I think you being a little too nice but its agreeable
308.
June21
Thursday, November 20, 2008 /
Only good tune on tha album is EGO- LMAO Beyonce wit that tune!!
309.
Tiara
Thursday, November 20, 2008 /
The only thing I’m miffed about is how the iTunes version of the Deluxe album gonna be 13.99 AND include an extra song (save the hero) but my version I got from Best Buy which is normally 20.00 (on sale for 14.99) is lacking it? That just DOESNT make sense to me. Other than that It was cool.
310.
Tiara
Thursday, November 20, 2008 /
See…I just listened to it again and I’m ofically pissed! That song is FIRE! I stay tryna not bootleg and THIS is the thanks I get? Welp, Limewire here I come….
311.
D
Friday, November 21, 2008 /
@69
Saying that Jay’s “bottom fell out” is ridiculous. Both of them as a couple they are banking majorly…not just in the world of music
(http://omg.yahoo.com/news/hollywoods-top-earning-couples/15620?nc)
And DIVA is just a fun song…thats it. The album seems to be in sections. First half more radio-friendly…and even stuff to garner her a little critical acclaim (The “Ave Maria” covered was the sh*t on a cracker..in my opinion, haha). And making a comparison to Usher is bullshit. True…he hypes himself up as the “King of R&B” but he cant back that up. he’s had hit singles..but he hasnt had the crossover into other markets that B has. I see her more traditional fans maybe not being so big on this album, but I also think that those doubters will be replaced, by new and maybe even more fans who see her heart in this project…
312.
fiona
Monday, November 24, 2008 /
this albulm is crazy and trully horrible i am a beyonce fan and i know great music this is trully a dissapointment
313.
Toya
Monday, November 24, 2008 /
2 EVERY NEG COMMENT ABOUT SOMEONES WORK DONT LIKE IT DONT LISTEN AND IF YOU HATE THE ARTIST SO BAD STOP LOOKIN UP THEIR REVIEWS TO COMMENTS$$$$$$$$$$ BECAUSE IF YOU BOTHER COMMENTING THEN ITS SOMETHING YOU LOVE LMAO
314.
Banza
Monday, December 1, 2008 /
Ths album aint my fav bey album i only like a very select few number of songs,and y dus scared of lonely sound like right here departed.
..the one thng i dnt like abt mis bey is she neva really shws her own inginuity..i mean sum of her biggest songs either sample other sngs tht had bn prev released ..or lyk irreplaceable sumone else put in the hard wrk…to top it off iiwab was stolen frm sum whte gal who cudve sang the song herslf..halo was meant 4 leona l…i mean yea bee is gud but ..cn she actualy write her own hit…dnt tell abt survivor.
315.
kat
Monday, December 1, 2008 /
When I hear the word FIERCE, I expect it to be FIERCE!!!
With the exception of Diva (and that’s only because it sounds so much like “A Milli”), there’s nothing else on this album that I actually enjoyed. I honestly liked BDay a lot better. I was bored to death listening to the I am…side. And Sasha fierce was SASHA TAME. Better yet SASHA LAME. I expected more, I thought sure that the debate of her being a sub-par singer etc would be put to rest on THIS album, however, I was surely disappointed. I give this album a C, because I at least understand the concept, it just wasn’t bought into actualization.
316.
Melody
Tuesday, December 2, 2008 /
Hmm..
I’m in between with this. I loved B’Day…
But I think this should be called “I Am… Confused.”
I don’t see this Sasha Fierce she’s talking about in this album
It sounds good; her vocals are really good. But Sasha Fierce is a Diva and if you ask me not many of the songs on the double album reflect this.
I love “Smash Into You” and “Single Ladies”
I guess Sasha Fierce came out on “Single Ladies”
But the rest is all soppy; Broken Hearted Girl
Boring; Ave Maria, I’m Alone Now
And It’s ALL BEEN DONE BEFORE
“If I Were A Boy”; Ciara done did that and if you’re gonna steal a concept, do it better.
“Diva”; Lil Wayne… and this doesn’t even have a concept. The beats so weak you don’t even bother listened to it. It has no substance,
And a few of the tracks sound like they’ve been stolen off Rihanna’s next album.
I don’t know. I’m not really liking it. Her vocals are good; especially on “That’s Why You’re Beautiful…”
Time to make way for lil sis I think.
317.
my president is black
Wednesday, December 3, 2008 /
DONT LIKE THE ALBUM AT ALL, WAY TOO MUCH PROMOTION WAS DONE FOR IT AND IT WAS WEAK, THE SONGS R BORING ..SHIT EVEN THE DANCE SONGS R BORING, SINGLE LADIES & VIDEO PHONE R THE ONLY CATCHY ONES
ATLEAST I DIDNT BUY IT
318.
nikki
Thursday, December 25, 2008 /
I heard this CD for the first time. I will not be buying this CD. This is the worst Cd Beyonce every put out. Keyshia Cole and Brandy new CD sound 10 times better. I just hope this was not a rush job. Someone take the wheel…. help this child… if this CD go PLT…. I will be surprise……
319.
Keepitreal
Monday, December 29, 2008 /
Hello,
I really want to state facts Beyonce is making tons of money, traveling the globe, and highly visible…BUT she is not original. Her father and management staff takes ideas from the 70’s and use them today. This is a pretty genius concept (see Puffy), as most of her audience was born in the 80’s and 90’s so they have never heard the music. I really wish she would be herself…it’s probably difficult, since she has to focus on what will sell and make her money. One thing I can say to all bloggers spend less time hating and more time doing you….. Live your life and pray for celebrities. It can’t be easy being in the public eye and having everything you do be scrutinized. I’m thankful I can walk in the mall and not be harassed. Although I wouldn’t mind having millions of dollars and traveling the globe. Don’t worry I’ll have them one day. Love you all mwah
320.
**TRUE FAN**:)
Friday, January 2, 2009 /
Okay, the hating is becoming really ridiculous. Beyonce is the best singer there is, the smartest, the most talented, most gorgeous and the most well-rounded singer. I’m really not understanding why people are posting such negative comments about her. It’s very obvious that people are very jealous of her. My question is this: Why not support an artist that is ACTUALLY TALENTED? Most of the singers out there cannot really sing! Ya’ll are hating ther wrong celebrity. Hate those who are being paid for having absolutely no talent.
Beyonce is the best there is and anyone who cannot see that is just plain ignorant.
321.
**TRUE FAN**:)
Friday, January 2, 2009 /
@ 319
You’re telling people not to hate and scrutinize her but uh HELLO! you just did. So far, the biggest hater that I’ve seen is SALI. She is hating really hard and I really think that she needs prayer, so I will pray for her and hopefully others will as well.
As far as the album, it is extremely unique and each song fits beyonce because she wrote most of them independently and put her heart into each and everyone.
As far as referring to Beyonce as “money hungry,” well she deserves every penny because she is a very talented and exclusive artist. HOWEVER, she is not selfish and obviously not as “money hungry” as people think, considering the fact that she donated her entire salary from her movie Cadillac Records to a rehabilitation center and is a well-known philanthropist. So again, stop hating! She deserves the attention, she actually good!
322.
lol
Friday, January 9, 2009 /
This is the best album she has done. She is far and above the most talented singer around. halo single ladies and the fabulous ave maria stand out. A brilliant album, just wish tickets to see her were less expensive. The queen has reclaimed her throne.