ConcreteLoop.com

LOGIN
----------------------------------
GRAVATAR | COMMENTING RULES

WHO ROCK’D IT BETTER?: KELLY OR BEYONCE

Thursday, December 4, 2008

( Photos: GETTY IMAGES )

For this edition of Who Rock’d It Better we have Destiny’s Child bandmates/best friends Kelly Rowland and Beyonce Knowles wearing similar mock necked catsuits.

Kelly first wore hers last year while performing in London and Beyonce rocked hers last week while performing on “The Today Show”. Take your pick…

107 CommentsCOMMENT?

Posted by: TIANNA

more info on the dope 21MC pharaoh's poncho way-back-like-cornrows callaloo-checks sportin-waves safari-dimebag

107 Comments


1.

FlygurlStacy

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

KELLY IS FREAKIN SLAMMIN!!!!!!!!!

2.

FlygurlStacy

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Kelly= So underated

3.

dale23

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

No camparison…

Kelly looks like she’s the one delivering the gifts to the kids this year lol…

Much as im tired of these beyonce posts, yall already knw she got this one.

4.

95

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

i actually think kelly for real she looks great

beys albums already went down to number 4 kayne knocked her out the box

5.

dee dee

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Catsuits are a bad idea no matter who wears them

6.

NinaBelle

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

it looks way better on beyonce. on kelly it jus looks weird. do they even hang out anymore? it doesnt seem like it!

7.

Today's User

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Kelly=Wifey

8.

dale23

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

ooohhh okay….much better pic for kelly this time…

Beyonce still won tho lol.

9.

Plumz

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

I say both rocked it in different ways…

Kelly looks like she should be going to a Christmas event in hers

10.

LEXXX

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Definately KELLY…Beyonce outfit looks way 2 simple and hair is OK…Kelly accessorizes it very well…Luv the boots and hair

11.

kriss.

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

WOW….SOMEONE ELSE WORE SOMETHING BEFORE THE UNHUMAN, DIVINE, GOD’S GIFT TO MANKIND, BEYONCE????

RING THE FUCKIN ALARMS.

12.

CALLAN

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

WHO CARES THE OUTFIT IS HIDEOUS!!!!!!!!!!!!! COME ON YALL TOO RICH FOR THIS CRAP! ANOTHER TINA KNOWLES CREATION! YUCK!!1

13.

Queen

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Who would have known that Kelly would win?lol That is sooo sad, but on a serious tip, Kelly looks really nice! I love her new look!

14.

kriss.

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

WOW….SOMEONE ELSE WORE SOMETHING BEFORE THE UNHUMAN, DIVINE, GOD’S GIFT TO MANKIND, BEYONCE????

RING THE FREAKIN ALARMS.

…better? lol

15.

Butterpecan

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Beyonce hands down! Her ensemble is more coordinated than kelly’s bedazzle outfit

16.

95

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

i think the only people bey hangs out with is solo her mom angie her stylist and jay z dont forget her bodygaurd, i dont think kelly hangs out anywhere but its worth it atleast shes not stalked and can live a normal life

17.

Honest Critic

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

The both rocked it in 2 different ways in my opinion.

18.

95

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

kellys belt and shoes are hotter bey looks plain

19.

95

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

the bangle bracelets and her hair look nice too,,she has so much more potential as a singer than she shows

20.

TASHA31

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Both of them are my girls but this one goes to Beyonce. Ditto at what #1 said. Bey’s curves are sick and she defiantly fills it out better but they both did their thing!! However, now since loop switched the picture for Kelly, I actually like hers a little better. I like how she accessorized it plus Kel’s boots are HOT!! They both look nice nonetheless!

21.

MWNY

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Is there any truth to the rumor about Kelly signing with Simon Fuller. I read she is really big in the UK.

22.

Express

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Kelly looks waaaaayyy better period.

This Phoney broad just won’t go away. Always copying off of someone else style, how Pathetic!

23.

Dame

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

They both have their own twist on it.

Congrats to Bey Single Ladies #1 on Billboard.

24.

linda

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

both of them look nice. but hands down don’t hate on kelly b is the shit but kelly has this one.

25.

mike

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

yeah well most of you are saying Kelly just to hate on Beyonce. LOL Kelly looks good u kno but Beyoces just has a much more bang body to fill it out nicer. More curves an ting!

26.

daddy swagga

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

how the hell u kno if dey don’t hang out anymore damn do u guys kno dem personally no yall dont I thnk dey both rocked it Beyonce body is amazing the outfit iz tightly fitted on hea sexy bkody n dem curves oh my god itz gettin hot n hea LOL. BEYONCE HANDZ DOWN NUMBER 1!!!!!

27.

BEAUTY Q.T.

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Kelly-the boots did it for me!

28.

Jeff

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Love Kelly sooo much, not to mention, although Beyonce’s “fanbase” is larger, Kelly’s is stronger!

29.

TESSA

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

love bee!

SINGEL LADIES IS #1 N THA NATION ON BILLBOARD CHARTS!
ya! now beyonce has 5 # 1 hits making her with the most in this decade! go head bee!

30.

pat

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

why do u have to be hatin on bey if u think KELLY looks better….and honestly i think she does in my opinion…..petite but curvy shapes always look better in catsuits to me….and her bootz are slammin

31.

Honest Critic

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

I honestly think Kelly and Beyonce look alike outside of the complexion and Beyonce has a more round face, but nose and smiles are alike. They are both pretty ladies.

32.

SexyQB

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Kelly has the better figure and those boots are FIERCE!!!

33.

mike

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Kelly accesorised it alot better tough

34.

mike

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Kelly has a better figure than Beyonce? Youre definitely a HATA!!! LOL

35.

awo

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

OF course Kelly looks wayyyyy better in this catsuit…her body is perfect for the outfit..and Bey i see is still copying off people…it’s a shame

36.

WHATDA

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

I DON’T LIKE B’S BOOTS ..THEY LOOK RETARDED WITH THE CAT SUIT kELLY DID HER THING WITH THIS ONE

37.

ora

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Beyonce was performing- Kelly’s got no good excuse to be wearing the catsuit OR that big Santa Claus belt.

38.

SexyQB

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

@ 34 In catsuits you can’t be too hippy. Bey is very hippy, that’s why Kelly looks way better. Plus, Bey’s accessories are boring and Kelly added flair to her outfit. Not hatin’, just stating an obvious fact.

39.

FINE-N-MELLOW

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Love the boots Kelly is rocking.

41.

B4ReAL

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

SINGLE LADIES #1 BILLBOARD TOP 100 12/4/08
JAY-Z’S B-DAY TODAY 12/4/08

CONGRATS TO THE KNOWLES-CARTER FAMILY.

THEY ROCK!!!!

42.

What i say goes

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

They both rocked it.. Damn people give it a rest. Anyways shout out to kelly.

43.

Liteskincookie

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

i vouch for the lightskin chick lol .

44.

B4ReAL

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

@SILK - Why don’t you start a petition to get better books and equipment in low income neighborhoods, or start a petition for people to organize to take back broken communities, or better yet start a petition for people to stop being dumba$$es and I think you should definitely be the first to sign it!

GET A LIFE & THEN DO SOMETHING POSITIVE WITH IT!

45.

Wagawagamamma

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

I knew beyonce stole her ideas and outfits from a lot of other people, but stealing from a fellow bandmate is an all time low!

Kelly is a little naive puppy that needs to realize that the knowles family don’t really care for her the way they do for their own daughters.

46.

Jay

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Kelly wins hands down. She has a smaller shape, Beyonce is kind of big.

The best catsuit to date has been Toni Braxton in the You’re Makin’ Me High Video and I like the one Aaliyah wore in her More Than A Woman video.

47.

Da~RealOne

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

kelly shoes aere bangin, but beyonce hair looks better. Kelly won tho!

Concrete why are y a’ll comparing 2 sisters?

48.

GIA

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Kelly’s is a full turtleneck, isn’t it? I think both of the belts are garish but the fit is a tie. They both look great in it. Now is it actually stylish, that’s the question. And the answer would be no, no, no - in catsuits and boots they look like tacky 57 year old bingo hags who meet at various locations every Friday night and call it, because they want to, “the spot”

49.

Yeah I Said It....And What???

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Love Beyonce’ BUT Kelly has a cuter shape in this one!

50.

Yeah I Said It...And What???

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

I love Beyonce, but Kelly won this one!

51.

Anonymous

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

THIS POST WAS STOLEN, YOU COULDN’T EVEN CREDIT THE SITE YOU GOT IT FROM!!!!!!!

52.

Be The Best YOU There Is...

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Like them both for performances, Kelly put in the extra, but Bey moves a lot and I have to give her and her band extra credit for not wearing coats that day cuz it was 32 deg in NY…

53.

RHIANNA ALL DAY EVERYDAY

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

BEYONCE WON THIS HANDS DOWN SOME OF YALL ARE JUST HATING BECAUSE YOU DON’T LIKE BEYONCE AND THAT’S A DUMB REASON TO GIVE PROPS TO SOMEBODY ELSE EVEN IF YOU HATE THEM OR NOT GIVE CREDIT WHERE CREDIT IS DUE. WHOEVER SAID YOU CAN’T BE HIPPY IN A CAT SUIT IS DEAD WRONG I KNOW I WOULDN’T WANT TO SEE SOMEBODY WITH SPONGE BOB SQUARE PANTS ASS HIPS IN A DAMN CAT SUIT YOU HAVE TO HAVE A BODY FOR THAT HALLE BERRY IS HIPPY AND SHE FILLED THAT DAMN SUIT OUT IN CAT WOMAN! GIVE THE SUIT TO RHIANNA SHE WOULD HAVE BLOWN BOTH OF THEM OUT THE WATER!!!!!!

54.

How can the silence be so loud?

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

LMAO @ people saying “I like Beyonce but..”. Are people really THAT intimidated by the stans that they feel like if they say something against Beyonce they will be attacked?

Anywho’s, This post isn’t even relevant. Beyonce is wearing a body suite totally different from Kelly. I think Beyonce rocked it better. The material looks better and her shape looks slammin’. Kelly just looks long and her weave or wig, is total mess.

55.

Kina

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

They both look fantastic.

56.

John

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Sexy Rowland beat Sasha Fierce this round.

58.

Beyonce Fan$$

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Beyonce got the # 1 single!!!!!!!!!! Single Ladies

59.

Lynn

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Kelly is working this look, but Bey is overated and I’m not a hata.

60.

F YOU

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

KELLY LOOKS GOOD BUT BEYONCE LOOKS BETTER - LESS ORNAMENTS.

ALSO, BEYONCE WINS BECAUSE KELLY HAS ON HER ROBERTO CAVALLI BOOTS - LOL.

61.

sassydancer

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Congrats on #1 single ladies,bey! As for the suit I like kelly’s ensemble best but they both look fierce! And yes kelly is much loved and appreciated over in the U.K.

62.

F YOU

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

#95 - OF COURSE KANYE WAS GOING TO GET THE #1 SPOT LIKE BRITNEY’S GOING TO KNOCK KANYE.

SHE STILL SOLD 257+K THIS WEEK HATER.

POST SOME SH*T THAT MAKES SENSE.

63.

BRWNCRAYOLA

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Um.. CL Beyonce and Miss Tina have rocked those boots Kelly is posing in. I know I’ve seen them joints like 4 years ago. I think Kelly Rocked it best though.

64.

BRANDY HUMAN DEC 9TH

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

FRIDAY, DEC. 5
7:00 a.m. ET Brandy (in studio) The Today Show

65.

Miss. Tiandez Jones

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

lmao look at beyonce’s camel toe, her punni is ALWAYS printed out! cotdamn! lollol.
kelly wins this and i dont even like her that much either.

but then again, im a hater. whatever, lol laughing at bey’s camel toe alllllll the way to the next post!

66.

Sunshine

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

lol….Even her fans petitioned to have removed

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-eW_naqNTA

67.

bambino

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

kelly no question

68.

sassydancer

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Britney spears sucks she def has no swag,style,cannot sing nor dance please don’t compare her to the likes of real artist like beyonce and kayne I could careless what she sells white ppl support her mess.

69.

April

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Since Beyonce is in this post, I want to bring this up because everyone talks about how bad she is at acting but I think we just cant get past the fact that she is a singer and we see her too much.

I was actually watching a re-run episode of Smart Guy on BET (don’t act like you don’t watch it) lol. Anyway, the original members of destiny child was on there. Beyonce was really pretty and fresh and I just thought personally that she did a great job on there acting. Maybe its just me. If anyone else has seen it tell me what you think.

70.

Anonymous

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

You have to have a nice shape to wear either of the suits. You can’t hide bulges or gut with that kind of material.

So both look good, but I like the way Kelly roc’d it.

71.

VEILOFIGNORANCE

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Congratulations to Beyonce on her 5th #1 Single as a solo artist and her 9th throughout her career!

All The “Single Ladies”…

http://www.billboard.com/...p;f=The+Billboard+Hot+100

72.

GET 'EM

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Congratulations to Beyonce on her 5th #1 Single as a solo artist and her 9th throughout her career!

All The “Single Ladies”…

http://www.billboard.com/...p;f=The+Billboard+Hot+100

*****************************

IF I WERE A BOY IS UP NEXT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

73.

F YOU

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

#66 - HER FANS DIDN’T DO THAT. IT WAS YOU OR THE WORK OF ANOTHER HATER, BUT GUESS WHAT?

IT AIN’T WORKING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

74.

truthfulsista

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Kelly looks very pretty in this picture. I can’t stand Bey, but she looks kinda good her outfit as well. I think they both wore it well, just with their own sense of style. Kelly’s boots and accessories are hot though.

75.

just

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Kelly, her belt the biz, eventhough she had quite a bit going on. bet they did that on purpose so kelly could get some blog time. just joking.

76.

wow

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY

i HATE TO ADMIT BUT KELLY HAS THIS ONE ON LOCK

77.

wow

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY
KELLY

i HATE TO ADMIT BUT KELLY HAS THIS ONE ON LOCK

78.

tay tay

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Most peop dont like kelly either so why would you think we are saying kelly to hate on bey, kelly rock that ish, and i dont like her or bey.

79.

platinum glam

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

69, I seen that episode quite some time ago last yr, lotoya and kelly was fun to watch, latavia was sassy, bey was natural and not forcing it, that episode was cute.

80.

callmewhatever81

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

I think Kelly is so underated. I think Beyonce is drop dead gorgeous but SO is Kelly. I really think they are neck and neck beauty wise and body wise but just in two different ways and thats something to be celebrated, not to compare at least in my opinion. Both look hot in the outfit but if I have to give it to one, it would be Kelly. I love Beyonce’s curvy body but I think for a catsuit, I like the long thinner body only because with a body like Beyonce, it can just look too sexual or porn like whereas someone like Kelly just looks like a supermodel in an outfit like this. I also love Kelly’s boots and her skin looks great here. I didnt think Kelly was beautiful when DC first started but she has really grown into a BEAUTIFUL woman.

81.

msblknasty1

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

kelly hands down ….bey looks like woody and dem cheap looking boots eww ..kelly finally you beat bey at sumfin lololol…. now they both needs to sit the hell down lolol

82.

jscene

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

KELLY HAS THE BETTER BODY, PERIOD.

WHEN BEYSTANKEY WEARS STUFF LIKE THIS, SHE LOOKS LIKE SHE GOT BODY ODOR AND A STANKEY CROUCH. YEP, I SAID IT.

83.

Joris de meetatalent

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Sorry Kelly i love you , but Beyonce it’s very beautiful in this dress

http://www.meetatalent.com

84.

YoYo

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

The second I saw it on the Today’s Show, I knew I had seen it before on someone else. Also, what about a black dress that Beyonce had on that Kelly wore over in the UK? It’s not the back-out black dress she and Ciara wore. It’s another one. And like the cat suit, Kelly looked a hell of a lot better.

Any who, I’m jealous. I don’t have the body to pull it off, but I’m also not nuts enough to buy it let alone wear it…………….LOL

85.

David Washington

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

The Beyonce stans need to back down. Be realistic. Give credit where, credit is Due. Kelly kilt it, and yall know it. But, because yall so fond of Beyonce, yall wanna say, Beyonce rocked it better, knowing damn well, Kelly did. It’s so obvious, Kelly rocked it better.

86.

Reccy

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

LMAO @ Jscene! Girl, u cracks me up!!! LOL!

87.

Single Ladies is #1 -- YOU GO BEY!

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

#82

I thought this was Concreteloop not Nickelodeon because that was beyond the most corniest + childish phrase I have ever read. It was not even funny at all. You need to grow up already. One day someone will be treating you the way you treat others so beware. Don’t reply back to me either talking all that ” I am a fat, dark Beyonce stan who is delusional” crap. This is my 2cnd time posting on CL but I’ve been here a while and I’ve been reading your comments and all. You are very, very miserable. I suggest Xanax.

I think they bothrocked it better. I like the texture of Beyonce’s more but the accessories on Kelly more.

88.

keonta

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Both of them rock’d it.Love kellys boots

89.

martinalutherking

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

Didn’t want to add my two cents, because if post a comment after 10 - no one really cares. But I had to rep for Kelly.

Kelly looks great in this outfit, it compliments her complexion and shape. She accessorized the outfit well, it doesn’t even look like the same outfit that Beyonce has on because the fabric looks like its a better quality.

And to those who said most people are saying Kelly to hate on Beyonce, can just give it up. Everyone is entitled to their opinion and just because you are obsessed w/ Beyonce and think everything she does is God’s gift to man, doesn’t mean that is everyone elses opinion.

Kelly and Beyonce are both beautiful, and sometimes one looks better than the other in a picture - and this time its Kelly.

90.

juicyb16

Thursday, December 4, 2008 /

I LIKE KELLY OUTFIT BETTER AND PLUS JUST FOUND OUT SHE LEFT BEY DAD BEHIND IN DUST. SO GOOD FOR KELLY DOING BIG THINGS!!

91.

Tatiana

Friday, December 5, 2008 /

Even though I like the outfit on the both of them I’d prefer Beyonce’s cat suit– I like the clean look that less accessories give, which explains why I actually hate that belt with those boots that Kelly has on. BUT but side by side I can see how people would say that Bey’s look is kinda plain.

The best combination would be Bey’s outfit with longer sleeves, then with Kelly’s gloves. Super fierce. Im kinda leaning towards Kelly’s hair style too. Since I picked items from both sides I voted for both.

92.

beyonces true fan

Friday, December 5, 2008 /

as much as i will cut for beyonce kelly did it this time i know b got curves but after she lost weigth i cant see em nemore…although kelly is skinnier u c her curves better in the suit n dats wat got me ….b looks plain shes been lookin g too plain comeon b give us the glamour but i c where u comin 4rm now u maried u more mellow…love u bey

93.

FallBackHaters

Friday, December 5, 2008 /

I love you B, but Kelly took this one.

94.

blog readers

Friday, December 5, 2008 /

89, we put in work for cl, people like me read all comments, your two cents are counted.

95.

nay

Friday, December 5, 2008 /

cat suits look best on small framed women…Beyonce got a lot of hips and really no backside to speak of, she only looks good from the front…hour glass view. But Kelly has the body for this more so. overall, Beyonce made it more simple with her choice of accessories, i am really not liking Kelly’s boots with this outfit, otherwise she would have won

96.

HOTMOMMA001

Friday, December 5, 2008 /

I’ma say NEITHER! Catsuits went out with the JERK! I don’t care who the Designer is, how much it costs, NOTHING!

BOOOO!

Accessories and hair are nice on both ladies!

97.

@ngie

Friday, December 5, 2008 /

kelly has always won.more shapely than *her*

98.

ctrlaltdelte

Friday, December 5, 2008 /

I concur #5

99.

PLEASE STOP...SERIOUSLY

Friday, December 5, 2008 /

BEYONCE DEF got this one!!!!
Kelly over-did it….she went waaaaay too far with it.

Bey, you got this one. But you can’t be RiRi.

100.

Beyonce/Sasha

Friday, December 5, 2008 /

Yall……Beyonce was performing, so of course she wouldn’t have the extra accessories. It’s not like Beyonce was wearing this walking down the street.

Anyway, I love both girls, so Kelly looked as if she may have worn her outfit to an event, while Beyonce looks like she was about to perform,

101.

Nelly

Friday, December 5, 2008 /

BEYONCE! KELLY LOOKED STUPID AS USUAL

102.

Borrowed

Tuesday, December 9, 2008 /

Kelly can’t rock it better when what she has on belongs to Beyonce - lmao.

103.

rajio

Thursday, December 11, 2008 /

They’d get it in the butt

104.

DINA

Friday, December 12, 2008 /

I will say Kelly, only because Bey Padded hers up in all the right places, so she is cheating…Check out other pics of her, even the bum pic, you see the padding…too much!

105.

KEISHA

Monday, December 15, 2008 /

Kelly looks way better in this.
#1: Beyonce is just too large to look good in a cat suit.
#2: Kelly accessorized her outfit much better. She looks more polished and refined. Beyonce looks like she hasn’t finished getting dressed yet.

106.

Gold

Wednesday, December 24, 2008 /

do I see cameltoe?
nah I’m just wishing lol.

107.

jumpey

Friday, January 16, 2009 /

bout freakin time! a fair challenge.. this a hard one.. both are curvy.. and look great! go kelly for holding down against a beyonce… i think it’s a tie though