WHO ROCK’D IT BETTER?: BEYONCE OR DAWN
Tuesday, January 13, 2009

( Photos: Beyonceworld/Getty )
For this edition of Who Rock’d It Better we have Beyonce and Danity Kane member Dawn Richards wearing the same Catherine Malandrino Jewelry Tank dress.
Beyonce first wore hers while on vacation during the Christmas holiday, and Dawn wore hers this week at an America’s Next Top Model party. Take your pick…








83 Comments
COMMENT PAGES: [1] 2 » Show All
1.
DejaStar7
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Beyonce’s body fills out the dress better. and she paired it nicely with those earrings.
B’s SHOES R HOT! Who makes em??????
2.
Kellz
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
B has the better body BUT I voted “neither” because that’s an ugly ass dress no matter who wears it.
3.
Kitoyah Miah
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Beyonce obviously..
4.
dee
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
I’m feeling the dress!! I’d rock it!!! Dawn never looks good in anything….so Beyonce wins this round.
5.
abbi
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
oh. She is sexy. Seems saw her before on ‘millionaire friends dot com’. Is she searching someone there?
6.
Kitoyah Miah
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
You guys should do a who rocked it better for tht necklace eva & beyonce wore at the golden globes..
7.
Lanalox
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Kellz, I agree Yo Dawn look like this dude I used to go to high school with. His name was Daryl and he was funny,she brings nostalgia every time I see her. Uhh neither rocked it better than the other,
8.
mack
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
this is a no brainer for sure! lol BEEEEEEEY!
9.
sweeti
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
hot
10.
KING TEXAS F@$H!0N Z3@L0T
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
OK! OF COURSE BEYONCE KILLZ U HOES YET AGAIN… IT WONT STOP JUS GET USED TO IT…. THA DRESS IS CUTE… I LIKE DAWN BUT JUS NOT IN DIS PIC…. BUT BEYONCE IS ON TOP OF THA GAME… WE ALL KNO DAT! YA DIGG!
11.
FallBackHaters
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
LOL. Likewe really need a poll. Beyonce got this on lock.
12.
I Style
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Beyonce’s shoes are by Yves Saint Laurent.. check out my blog for more insights into your favourite celeb’s styles.
http://istyleustyle.blogspot.com
13.
FirstLADY
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
B’s heels are SEX!!!
14.
*«Solid Rich Girl»*
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Dawn rock’d it better because her body fits it perfectly and her overall look makes the dress more “party like” other than Beyonce wearing it as if it’s a picnic dress.
15.
nadia
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
For this one Beyonce win hands down! She just have the body. The Dress look good on her.Nice! Her shoes are Sexy. I wonder how Beyonce will look like in Crocs! Maybe they can put some blings on it! LOL. Btw I saw a job post on Crocs. Just for laughs if anyone is interested.http://jobstaxi.com/viewjob.php?jobid=106495
16.
pshh
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
LMAO B getting 85 %! the other got 14 votes !
LMAO B wearing it on vacations while the other on red carpet
17.
UrbanChic
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Beyonce looks like a stuffed sausage in an already ugly dress, and Dawn’s body language does not even compliment the dress. They both look terrible.
18.
bigdaddyreg
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Beyonce rocked it well, and with much nicer shoes
19.
get_me_bodied
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
BEE DID THAT!
20.
trendsetter
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
This is the worst i’ve ever seen Dawn look
21.
Don't Argue With Me It's Just An Opinion
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Yeah right @ the possibility of Dawn rocking ANYTHING better than Beyonce.
22.
BBM
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Beyonce’ is definitely the prettier woman. Now Beyonce’ wears this better. However, Dawn has a nice body and looks good in most things she wears. Her weave is just always a mess lol.
23.
Nadine
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Beyonce looks like a sexy woman and Dawn looks like a little girl!
24.
beyonce stan
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
of course beyonce look at dat body! Dawn looks like a tranny. Plus bee wearin hers as a pajama set dawn wearin hers as an evening gown LMAO
25.
coko
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
dawn looks like a damn man in the face.
26.
E$
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Are ya’ll serious? Dawn vs Beyonce?
27.
Crystal
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Who gives a damn it’s a damn dress it’s ugly to me and why the hell does this post have more comments then the presiden’s post I guess people care about Beyonce more than they care about Obama sad!
28.
pede
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
omg i think b lookz good and even through i like dawn too but im sad to say that right here she look like a man like ughhh idk im a lil diappointed in dawn so hands down b took this one dawn better luck next time
29.
He'sASite2CSuiinLikeMe
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
LMFAO @ 16! She shytted all over Dawn in this one.. Dawn’s body is too small.. Beyonce fills the dress out with her curves and she MAKES the dress… Dawn looks like a hanger w/ the dress hanging on it. Just shapeless.
30.
He'sASite2CSuiinLikeMe
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Calm DOWN @ 27! Go to CNN if u want to be super political.
31.
Greg
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Dawn always looks like a dusty rag.
32.
AVENGE OSCAR GRANT'S DEATH NOW
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
They both look wack. The dress is cute. But Dawn is very ugly and B is fat. And B is rocking a long jheri curl to boot.
33.
BOOOOOOOOO!!!!
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Dawn = Fugly. How did she become the “star” of that group? Diddy be falling way off. He picked the most unattractive girls for that “group” and then they arent even the best singers. I DO NOT want to see another making of the band but Diddy does need to go WAY BACK to the drawing board. Cassie is the only good looking person Diddy ever signed. He likes to be the prettiest mofo in the room huh? ANYhoo Bey all day
34.
luvutu
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Dress ugly….but b fills it out bettr!
35.
luvutu
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
and I totally agree with BOOOOOOOO!!!!
36.
B
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Even though I can’t take them both personally B body fills out that dress alot better.She would get smashed all day!
37.
Superman's_Girl
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Dawn looks like she just woke up, so Beyonce wins. The dress is ugly though.
38.
Jenny J
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
DAWN IS A MANNNNNNNNNNNNN
39.
hood_shit
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Hands down Bey cuz she rocked it when it was appropriate and she fills it out
40.
ciara fan
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
honestly i like dawn…i’m a big danity kane fan but beyonce looks better in the dress and i agree she does make the dress look better because she made it pop by wearing the ear rings…
41.
me
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Dawn looks like a boy
42.
iknowdasrite
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
LOL yall need to step off my girl Dawn!
43.
Lauryn
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
I VOTED BEYONCÉ ONLY BECAUSE SHE’S PRETTIER AND HER BODY FEELS IT OUT BETTER. THAT SAID THE DRESS IS NASTY, SO I PROBABLY SHOULD OF VOTED NEITHER
44.
Vee1
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Now come one CL, I usually don’t comment on the Beyonce’ post because she is over rated. However, to put her in a who rock’d it better against that hideous girl from Danity Kane is just an injustice. The dress isn’t that cute in the first place, but Beyonce’ has the curves to fill it out and make it look good. I’m convinced that the world thinks Beyonce could wear a burlap bag and still be the “baddest chick in the game”.
45.
MRSJONES
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
OMG DAWN LOOKS TERRIBLE!! LIKE A MAN IN A DRESS. OF COURSE BEY WINS HANDS DOWN!
46.
MissMarcJacobs
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
BEYONCE!!!! DuHhHhHhHhH
@lL DEy D@T!!!!
Jeeze.
47.
Single ladies #1
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
WTF???? Now CL needs to stop playing. There is NOTHING DAWN could rock better than Beyonce.
@27……not trying to single you out, but honestly, I don’t come to CL for my political fix. I come to CL for the celeb gossip, new musics, and beyonce post. I watch CNN and MSNBC every morning before work, when I get off work, and before I go to bed. So it’s not that people don’t care about politics, we do, we just dont care to comment on those post.
48.
J.A Girl
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Beyonce is rocking it nice
Dawn looks nice 2 but beyonce looks better
49.
Sway
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
ummm.. i don’t usually post, but dayum Dawn musta been having a bad ass day.. did she not check the mirror? Did Diddy take away all the funds?
50.
Single ladies #1
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
I can’t believe yall think the dress is ugly…I LOVE it. My homegirl came home from vacation with this same dress. Now she said she paid like $600.00 for it. I don’t believe it was that expensive, but I think the dress is hott.
51.
☆ Lola A♏ ★
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Dawn’s hair looks a mess and the shoes are a no-no. Queen Bey gets my vote!
52.
Katherine
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Beyonce wins by default…Dawn isnt a fair opponent, she rarely ever looks good.
53.
T-Bag
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Bey def wins hands down. There is too much dress and not enough Dawn to fill it out.
Not to be a hater but, when is Dawn gonna step it up? She is looking very average…
54.
SALI
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Wonder why Beyonce never rocks her own stuff? Just asking.
55.
WhatIThinkIs
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Beyonce stays fighting with that weight. But no matter what she wears, she looks good.
56.
Miss. Tiandez Jones
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
clearly beyonce rocked it better..i dont even like her but come on, all hating aside, she fills out the dress more and paired with those fierce heels, she does the damn thing.
dawn looks like a dude in a dress…literally..are u sure her name isnt Dan? Face has manly features…neck- i think i see an adams apple..body looks like a 14 year old boy…yuck. how dare she!
57.
He'sASite2CSuiinLikeMe
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Damn right @ 44. Because SHE makes her outfits.. Which is the way it should always be
58.
GG
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Dawn may not be the prettiest girl, but she has such a sweet personality that you overlook her flaws. I agree, this dress is not for her, but she has a very nice toned body and should have chosen a style that flaunts it.
59.
HALCYONC
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
The dress is ugly either way.
60.
nick
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
uggh Dawn look like a crackhead (NO BODY) lord 4giv me-hahahaha, BEYONCE got it goin on, sorry, BEYONCE all the way MOS DEF !!!
61.
Roxie
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Beyonce hands down.
And Dawn has done something to her face… yeah… she did. Some type of surgery I can’t put my finger on it.
62.
Duchess
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
It just seems WRONG to wear ANYTHING ‘next’ to Bey and ask ‘who rocked it better’. Chile puhleez…Bey will always win…HANDS DOWN!!!!
63.
crunkpoet
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
yea beyonce looks better in it..hate to say…dawn, wtf is up wit this picture?
64.
msblknasty1
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
imma hafta go with bey .. dawn looks a lil mannish
65.
viola1
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
i chose beyonce, her implants fills out the dress more and she has more curves, and the shoes she has on is no joke, and the earrings are nice, luvs me some dawn but don’t luv the shoes and she has a very slinder body she look good in more a line dresses and skirts.
66.
Joe from Tx but Residing in NYC
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
WTF?? Is this really a question, Who rocked it better? CLEARLY Dawn looks a hott mess and can no way be compared to Beyonce’. Dawn looks like a broke down chick! Message to Dawn: Use some of the left over money you have left and upgrade yourself. Right now, you get no points from me… You look an official….MESS!
67.
Lena B
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
Lol Beyonce wore it the best.
But umm that dress is kinda ugly tho. I mean I wouldn’t buy it if I had they money
68.
LMAO
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
yall right Dawn is looking a lil MASCULINE here.. she’s not ugly tho, its just this pic, ive actually seen her look pretty good, but without makeup…………woooweh! I can pull off tha woman look better than she can! lol. No wonder Que gay ass on her so hard!
69.
beyonces true #1
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 /
come on now beyonce duh even if the dress is ugly i love dawn but she hasnt been looking good lately b body fills the dress and again c da different occasions each wear them 4 …u already b has this
70.
The Mix Mason
Wednesday, January 14, 2009 /
is this even debatable?
71.
peaches706
Wednesday, January 14, 2009 /
Beyonce looks better in the dress, her earrings, shoes and curves make the ugly dress look OK. But people please, Beyonce is a human being- not a goddess. Everything she does is not perfect and everything she wears does not look good. I personally think that she has no fashion sense-hence that hideous line of clothing, House of Dereon. She is beautiful and I love her body-No Homo! But really, she has walked out of the house looking bad, old fashioned and just, well, tacky.
I wonder how many people are going to attack my words!!! LOL
72.
kindanice
Wednesday, January 14, 2009 /
me no like the dress but Beyonce filled it out better.
73.
Theworldwillendin2012
Wednesday, January 14, 2009 /
Definitely Beyonce, plus her shoes are way too hot!!
74.
Me again
Wednesday, January 14, 2009 /
What is going on with Dawn’s hair? it looks awful.
75.
shanice gary
Wednesday, January 14, 2009 /
dam she fuggggglyyyy!!!! from the planet fugtron! she look like da mask not jim carey but cher son uglass from the movie nda 80’s. she look like a mailman..long face ass. big pizza dough face ass. green ass nails wit nothn green on face ass. wtf. box chevy face ass. hamburger helper face ass….matafact yall(concreteloop) bogus for puttn dat chick up there. yall sud be ashamed smh. chitown lol. face ass ass face
COMMENT PAGES: [1] 2 » Show All