WHO ROCK’D IT BETTER?: KEYSHIA OR KATY
Wednesday, February 11, 2009

(Photos: FreddyO/Wireimage)
For this edition of Who Rock’d It Better we have singers Keyshia Cole and Katy Perry wearing the same Herve Leger CHARCOAL BANDAGE DRESS WITH RIBBON APPLIQUE.
Keyshia first wore hers back in October for a BET Hip Hop Awards Afterparty and Katy wore hers this week at a party in Beverly Hills. Take your pick…








43 Comments
1.
ifunaya
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
oh my, keyshia so rocked this and katy looks so hideous
2.
Jameslyn
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
Love keyshia but katy mos def rocked it better! that dress looks better when ya a lil taller. P.s. As a mother, katy i hate ya first single! Try “splaining” to ya 8 year old daughter why girls kissing girls….not a good look..
3.
yumyo (3 week old bebe)
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
I think the shoes that Katy is wearing didnt do it justice which is why 64% picked Keisha
4.
Danny
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
I like it on both the ladies but I like the color Keyshia has on better. Katys shoes are cute.
5.
sunshine
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
THEY BOTH LOOK NICE BUT KEYSHIA..WOW, I LOVE HER NEW LOOK… THE NEW HER….GO GIRL
BE SURE TO CHECK OUT MY NEW ONLINE BABY STORE AT http://WWW.BABYCARESTORE.CO.CC
THANKSSS
6.
Sayanything
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
I like Keyshia’s shoes with the dress although I would so rock Katy’s shoes. Hey Jameslyn–please do talk with your daughter! 8 years old is not too young, trust! I have worked in schools from pre-k to high school and your heart would leap out of your CHEST if u knew what some of these kids are doing!!
7.
JaeSassy
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
Keyshia rocked it.. the shoes set it off.
8.
lilblackfan[praying for the auc]
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
mmmm…I EFFING LOVE THIS DRESS!
9.
kennedi
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
Ima have to go with Katy on this one…
10.
H-Town Chic***
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
Ummmm I’m going to say Katy but close call though.
11.
misskrisha
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
the shoes are the main reason i picked keyshia. the pop of color was needed.
12.
Highly opinionated and rightfully so!
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
Keyshia looks so cute and the dress looks cute on her…but at first glance I thought someone used like a pink marker on this dress and scratched out the middle with zigzag lines.
13.
Lis
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
I like the way Katy is wearing hers. I like Keisha, but she’s doing what most black women have a REAL BAD habit of doing….thinking you have to MATCH everything by the color (i.e. the dreadful, white-shirt-with-red-belt-at-the-waist-and-red-shoes-and-red-bracelets-and-red-earrings-and-necklace-and-red-pumps-and-red-handbag-with a pair of jeans. Everytime I see this chick, I wanna kick her down a flight of stairs at the mall), and that’s not how you make a fashion-statement. It’s about an entire streamline look and Katy nails it here.
14.
SexyQB
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
Keyshia rocked it!!!
15.
Lis
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
BTW, that dress drown Keyshia too. Katy’s fit her better.
16.
bassackwards
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
katy wears it better, but i do love the color of keyshias shoes.
17.
MRSJONES
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
I HAVE TO GO WITH KEYSH CUZ OF THE SHOES
18.
MLOVE
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
KEYSHIA…hands down!
19.
MLOVE
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
@ #13 I disagree! I think this time the shoes complimented the dress….along w/her hair and makeup…. the BLACK shoes that Katy rocked with the dress are dreadful!
20.
dukesman2000
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
—Come on now..no contest - Keisha. Although, I must say Katy looks good in that
–pic
21.
Slanted
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
I’m so sick of Herve dresses I dunno what to do….however its good that he’s venturing off of the typical bondage look…..with that said, its still an ugly dress but Key lo lo rocks it with the shoes and hair….
22.
rachelsoulmercedes
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
I’m gonna go with keyshia on this one. Katy perry is also gorgeous, but I love keyshia’s red shoe and finger waves.
23.
Sayanything
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
Lis #13–Have to disagree–I don’t think Keysha is being “matchy-matchy” at all and I HATE matchy-matchy! I had a girlfriend in college who would match from her earrings to her shoes and looked straight BAMA everytime! lol! I also don’t like when women feel they have to play it safe by sticking with black shoes for eeeeeervything! That looks just as country in my opinion.
24.
The Secret Life of Me... $$$
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
They both rock’d it but I think Kei’s shoes look a tad better with it becuz of the color!
I love Katy’s shoes!
25.
syn'ceRe
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
i love katy but keyshia rocked it waaaaaaaaaaaaay better!
keyshia keep on smilin …her eyes are pretty!!!
26.
dan
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
@ #2
why not explain her, that there are girls who like girls…lesbians?
its not what the song is about, but its a got explaining to give the child a view at the world and to get it tolerant…
i dont think its wrong to confront kids with different kinds of living…it makes them tolerant and open minded
27.
jess
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
I LIKE KEYSHIA’S DRESS OVERALL ..PERIOD
PLUS HER SHOE COLOR REALLY SETS THE DRESS OFF
KATIE’S DRESS LOOKS TO HARSH WITH THE BLACK SHOES
KEKE GOT THIS ONE !
28.
ashleighTDOT
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
FORGET THE DRESS TELL ME WHERE KEYSHIA GOT HER SHOES!!!! I NEED THEM I HAVE THE PERFECT OOUTFIT TO GO WITH THEM!!!!!
THE SHOES…ITS ALL ABOUT THE SHOES. and they’re my favourite colour too…purple…
need them. love them…
but for sake of argument. katy got this.
29.
SugarhoneyIcedtea
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
Of course Keisha Cole did and she did it properly!
Her body is on point and so is her make-up! The Purple on Grey combination worked for her, it matches with her skin! Fab hairstyle, fab shoes.
Katy Perry needs to disappear along with Marylin Manson.
30.
SugarhoneyIcedtea
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
But hey!….where has Keshia’s neck disappeared to? [*~*]
31.
☆ Lola A♏ ★
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
Katy!!! Her shorter length looks better
32.
Juicy SuperStar
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
Keyshia shoes look better and I love her hair with it… I picked Ms K. Cole. Katy looks cute too but I like Keyshia looks better.
33.
Lis
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
@23, yeah I hear you. But I’m a stylist and I’ve observed most people’s (especially women of color) fashion philosophy, and some sisters lack it for the most part. I believe it comes from when we were kids, in school, your “outfits” (that’s another thing, black women put together “outfits” while others do “looks” or “ensembles”) had to MATCH or that how you got teased by the other kids. Should you DARE go to an urban school wearing a yellow dress with maybe, cute pink shoes, you would’ve gotten teased, “Girl, that OUTFIT DON’T MATCH, LOL!”
If you look at Katy’s “LOOK”, she was going for streamline. I’ve also observed that most Caucasian women tend to use an “accent color” to make an outfit pop, or they will match their shoes with their haircolor or a hue similiar to force you to visually consider the entire look from head-to-toe. PLUS, like I said, Katy’s dress fits her better. Keyshia’s dress looks like someone dressed her up it. I love her shoes, but they are just too predictable for this look. IMO I love her hair too!
34.
Lis
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
Honestly, I’m completely with YOU #21!!!! The Herve Ledger dress is OVUAH!!!! Max Azria needs to go back and focus on his BCBG line before everything ends up in TJ Max or Marshall’s. The quality has been slipping lately.
35.
*«Solid Rich Girl»*
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
KEYSHIA COLE Rock’d It a million times better!!!
36.
M* of SunriseSUndown.Blogspot.com
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
AW MAN YALL GOT TO GET THE LOW DOWN ON THOSE SHOES KEYSHIA IS WEARING!!! THEY R BAD!
HERE’S ANOTHER KATY VS KEYSHIA BATTLE:
http://www.fabsugar.com/2793141
http://stuffflypeoplelike...33dasurs25200990442am.jpg
37.
andreanicole
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
I think the dress looks better on Katy, but I do like that pop of color that Keyshia threw in with the shoes…
Both ladies look amazing.
38.
hood_shit
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
That dress not cute
39.
Ta`Shia
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
I think Keyshia won this,her dress fits her like a glove! Katy looks nice as well,but I`m sure she could have looked in her closet and found a pair of shoes to compliment her dress that are better than the one`s she has on,her shoes makes her feet look big!
40.
bcc
Wednesday, February 11, 2009 /
I voted for Keyshia but #2 has a point…it looks like this dress is for a taller person. Keyshia dress is folding in the middle at the bottom, ha ha
41.
Rehab Drop Out
Friday, February 13, 2009 /
Keyshia!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
42.
nicegirl
Friday, February 13, 2009 /
she is so beautiful and lovely. every time i signed in ^^CelebMingle.com^^ and there were always many men talking about her how sexy and pretty … you know it is a site where rich women can seek young cute men and men can find extramarital affairs….they are picky, but they like her too.
43.
lenaBellla
Tuesday, February 17, 2009 /
keyshia cole loooks
FAB U L O U S!*
xoxo_bella