For this edition of ‘Who Rock’d It Better’ we have singers Rihanna and Keyshia Cole rocking the same Elizabeth & James fitted plaid shirt ($225) while out and about.
Rihanna rock’d it first while she was rehearsing for the AMAs back in November ’08 and Keyshia rock’d it this past weekend when she was out with her boyfriend. Take your pick..
Shout out to CL reader Irenroa for spotting this edition!
( Photos: GETTY IMAGES / ATLPICS.NET )





















The top looks nice on both young women
Rihanna (Needless to say)
I like them both I just feel rihanna comes way hard so this is definitely not her best which is expected of her. Ri’s jeans make her crotch look tall (no lesbo) not a good look. happy to see her back at it! keyshia looks happy like a stepford wife with the bangs aww.
PEOPLE ARE ALWAYS GONNA PICK RIHANNA EVEN IF SHE LOOKS WORSE, I SAY KEYSHIA
They both rock’d it!!!
They both wear it well, but $225 for a dang plaid shirt. These price tags are outrageous for what the clothes look like. I expect more bang for my buck.
And before everyone gets started on the you must be broke, if you care about the price tags. I’m not. I have a career and no kiddies. I could drop $225, just don’t see the point.
I’m gonna say Rihanna because her boots are cute and Keyshia is doing way tooo much with those boots. Are they fur? I HATE fur.
rhianna; well put together from head to toe
keyshia all the way
Ri Ri looks better in it but they both rocked it. Rihanna can wear the hell out of some clothes. Keyshia looks akward sometimes in what she wears, like she’s not comfortable or something.
And on another note…what’s up with nothing but light skinned women always on the blogs
**Come on brown skinned girls we need to make a move or something **sheesh** lol
They both look cute, I wish Keyshia woulda used a black rubberband though..
love the shirt.
and ri rocked it best with the skinny belt and dark denim.
take notes keyshia!
Keyshia. She looks efortessly chic!
Keisha looks better because of the belt around the waist. She that tatoo weakens her look. But over all she is better styled here than Rihanna.
And 225 for a shirt? Damn! I’d find ones that look a lot better on the high street! TM Lewin do nice shirts and even they’re not as pricey! I hope both of these girls got their outfits for free otherwise I can’t fathom why they’d spend so much on normal looking clothes
ANGEL PLEASE WILL YOU HOPE OFF RIHANNA THANKS !
Imma go with Riri…
i love rihanna but im gonna go with keyshia.
Keyshia. Accentuated her shape nicely the way she wore it with the belt–and finished it off with a Forever Tina Louboutin boot to really bring the whole outfit together. Best I seen her in a while. Rihanna? Meh.
Keyshia
i mean those shirts had better been free, who the hell pays $225 for a plaid shirt?? you can get a cuter plaid shirt at wetseal or forever21 for like $25?? gosh, i just don’t see the point! yeah i know you got money, but seriously though?
Rihanna looks betta, because she tucked the shirt in and made it look more fashionable!
Keyshia cole looks like a lite skin GORILLA
ive never found her pretty
shes got ugly features
Im shocked that she is half italian, wit mya you can tell she is half italian but wit Keyshia its like BLAH wateva.. ‘Ur sure Momma tellin you tha truth’ lol
Wudnt be suprised if keyshias dad isi biracial, I highly doubt he is italian
But keyshia can dream i guess
they both did it, Riri is more fashionable but Keisha just finished performing so I’m sure she just threw it on.
They practically wore it the same way…
Also damn can Concreteloop stop hanging on Rihannas nipple piercings, there’s more artists out there…SH!T
WISH I HAD $225 TO SPEND ON A SHIRT!
Listen @ 23 if you dont like the fact that CL talks about Rihanna a lot or any other celeb, either stop visiting the site, skip over the post, or shut the fuck up. DAMN. Is it that hard? Stop being a damn cry baby.
HANDS DOWN RIRI. @ NEXT BEST THING- I feel the same about Keyshia. Her pops is MEXICAN. FRANKIE WAS TOO HIGH TO REMEMBER…. LOL
Even tho Rhi Rhi sported the top first, I think Kish wore ithe shirt w/ more style! She is so graceful!!!
rihanna…keyshia too extra, and she a celeb, that thick belt look is kinda played or for the locals
Keyshia b/c it’s looks better on someone w/ a fuller top, IMO.
Rihanna all day! Rih looked better…
YO KEYSHIA DID …YALL NEED 2 PUT MII AND RIRI UP ON WHO ROCKED DA PURPLE BLAZERS BETTER ILL BET ILL BEAT HER ASS LOL MATTER A FACT IMMA DO IT ON MYSPACE LOL!
LMAO @ 31 WUTS UR LINK SO I CAN VOTE LOL!!!
THEY BOTH ROCKED IT IN THEY OWN WAY!
I see that some of us don’t read….lol. one girl said “I’m glad Rihanna is back and singing again” and clearly the picture says NOVEMBER 2008. I voted for Ri ri’s look. K.C’s look isn’t bad but why a waist belt with a plaid shirt…… kinda overdone. Rihanna knows how to wear a “look”. Plaid shirt with a vintage feel and higher waist jean that gives u chic vibe. A lot of girls can’t wear high jeans without looking like there potatoes in pouch.. and the reason why CL keeps featuring Rihanna….. cause WE KEEP CLICKING ON HER POSTS!!! Lol. The people like her…and clearly u do too!
21 UR A HATER! UR MAD CUZ SHE MUST LOOK BETTER THAN U …I SWEAR PEOPLE ARE SO DUM AS HELL!
KEYSHIA ROCKED IT BETTER EVEN THO IM A RI RI FAN
like, riri’s overall look was better than keysh but riri dont have keysh’s curves. so for the shirt alone I’d have to say keyshia.
they have very different styles, but i think the both rocked it in their own way, personally i would wear it how rih is wearin it. i love tucked plaid.
KEYSHIA
i personally don’t like the belt around the waist, i feel she could’ve kill it by tucking in the shirt and i don’t like those boots either other than that they both look good
I am so glad Keyshia is winning. I can’t stand that big headed b#tch Rihanna. She can’t sing, dance, and owes her stylist all the credit.
Keyshia is the whole package. Beautiful, better body, the VOICE, and she is real unlike Rihanna fake ass. F her stans. Rihanna aint nothin.
Love Keyshia’s shoes!
I truly LOVE Keyisha BUT she has NOOOO STYLE WHATSOEVER! SHE NEEDS A STYLIST, LIKE YESTERDAY!
^^^ She has style please! She owned this outfit!
^^^
HATER
She has style, and owned this look!
RIHANNA LOOKS LIKE A TRANNY!!!
LOL @ BigButtDiva defending Keyshia,
You stans are hilarious!
I admit Im a Ri Ri stan but cant we just be glad that BOTH of them look good in the shirt? Its no “battle of the shirts”, simply “who rocked it better” and to me both killed it so kudos to them : )
I admit Im a Ri Ri stan but cant we just be glad that BOTH of them look good in the shirt? Its no “battle of the shirts”, simply “who rocked it better” and to me both killed it so kudos to them : )
Keyshia!
Have mercy on these bloggers souls…pls give your posters a break and let this obsession be over after next week.
Looking forward to posting
R. I. P. rooster head.
*singing O Happy Day*
@44 you suck boo!!riri doesn’t look like a tranny!!
Riahnna probaly didnt even dress herself she has no style what so ever
and i think keyshia cole looks SO much betta than “riri”
keyshia is so more classier and prettier than Riahnna
anyways
GO KEYSHIA
I love\like both of em but imma rock with keyshia cole she got the body for it..
some of ya’ll just do too much. Anyways Rihanna looks better.
Keyshia.
i’m gonna say rihanna because of her boots & belt…gives the shirt that rustic cowboy look.
i don’t like keyshia’s boots too much…
Ok CL, Ya’ll are overdoing it a bit on these graphics. I can barely compare the outfits b/c the graphics are so distracting. I know you trying to keep folks from stealing your pics but damn…..
Keysha
It looks OK the way Rhi Rhi has it but Keysha look is better.
@21 – Who gives a Fly F***** if her father is black, brown, green or italian… She looks way better then Mya (and I love Mya) but seriously whats the rant about being itialian nobody cares but you. What are all Italian’s suppose to look like anyway?
There are way too many bitter women on this site. Why do people act like Rihanna is the only celeb that has a stylist?? Just about all of them do so don’t get mad at Rihanna for making her clothes look great when your favorite singer doesn’t even with a stylist. She just has it like that. Don’t hate.
@ BIGBUTTDIVA don’t be mad at Rihanna because you’re fat & ugly. It’s not her fault.
nice one…. i totally agree wit u @Dj Dave. way too many bitter women on dis site… tha fact is… all celebs got stylists…. ALL…. RIRI, KEISHA, BEYONCE, HALLE BERRY, J.LO, CIARA… ALLL!! SO STOP HATIN MAN… these celebs dnt even kno sum of yall xist, n yall bxtchin n slutin 2 represent em. tht shit dnt make no sense. doesnt matter the race, color, religion/creed… they dnt giva shit wut yall say… wen sed n dun theyr gonna live 2 plz emselves!!
BTW: RIRI look better, bcuz she made it stand out… keisha did tha obvious n wore tht waist belt, put her in a crowd of women in the same outfit… she wudv blended rite in. wile riri wudv stand out.
Keyshia does the shirt justice…Rihanna looks like she’s wearing a pair of mom jean leggings