For this edition of ‘Who Rock’d It Better’ we have singers Rihanna and Melody Thornton wearing the same Stella McCartney Thigh High Perforated Boots ($1595) during recent outings.
Rihanna was spotted wearing hers while out & about in NYC last month and Melody rock’d hers earlier this month while celebrating her 25th birthday in Cali. Take your pick.
what is that white fabric on riri’s right leg?
melody!! end of discussion and the riri STANS better not act like I’m not right. LOL
Neither if you ask me. Rihanna and that lipstick was getting on my nerve. Melody cant dress right to save her life.!
Melody
And its funny because usually I think Melody looks a mess and I think Rihanna dresses cute but thats not the case today…
How can People vote for Rihanna?! loool
I wud choose melody.bt i dont liek any of their outfits melodies looks to chavy nd Rihanna’s stylist finks she cn just throw anything on Rih nd it’ll work,,NAH M’DEAR dusent wrk dt way..bt on a gd note their both pretty with nice voice
Battle of the Mk-Ultra mind-controlled dolls. interesting..
They look better with Melody’s dress. You can tell Rihtard put them on because she wanted to be seen in them first.
i dont really like melanie!! didnt know who she was until i saw the pic…i like rihannas style..she needs to put on a bra, but i like the punk rock feel
oops, i mean melody**!! just proves that she is a STRANGER!! lmao
STFU
RIHANNA ROCK’D IT BETTER OF COURSE
They both look cute to me but I’ll always vote for Rih since she gets nothing but hate on this site.
PRINCESS RIHANNA!!!
LOL melody finally won somethinq
hahahaha but naa really shes thicker
so it looked a tad better . . .
MELODY! hands down.
Like I would CONSIDER wearing her outfit! Loove how the belt ties in with the boots!
But like others have said, this is really out-of-the-ordinary because I NEVER think Melody dresses proper .. and I usually like a lot of Rihanna’s outfit.
I LOVE THOSE BOOTS! THEY ARE SO COMFY TOO!
I CHOOSE BOTH. BOTH LADIES LOOK GOOD.
I voted Melody. She’s pretty.
Rihanna’s hair looks like ramen noodles and the top/dress/whatever that is, looks like a bed skirt. Total mess! she is falling off her fashion game.. actually she’s been fell off for a while now. I can’t remember the last time i liked an outfit of hers.
WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO HER STYLIST?
melody looks like she threw on a n f21 dress and belt
i chose riri. her face looks horrible though. she can’t pull off that hairstyle or makeup
RIHOENNA HAS THE MOST DELUSIONAL FANS OUT THERE…
MORE DELUSIONAL THAN C-HORROR’S WHO PRETEND SHE IS A POWERHOUSE…
THAN BERTNEY’S WHO PRETEND SHE IS A LIVE PERFORMANCE FORCE…
THAN BEYAWNCE’S WHO SWEAR SHE IS THE ORIGINATOR OF EVERY LIL THING UNDER THE SUN…
OR GARGOYLE’S WHO CLAIM SHE IS A CLASS ACT… SMH
I BELIEVE THEY WILL EVEN SAY RIHANNAS SH!T SMELLS LIKE CHANEL NUMBER FIVE. I NEEDTO CALL CHRIS WB BROWN SO HE CAN TRANSORM YA FACES.
NEITHER! THEY BOTH LOOK A HOT SMOKIN MESS YES STANS RIHANNA WHO INVENTED STYLE AND EGDE ALREADY IN BARBADOS HAS A FASHION FAIL BIG MOMENT PERIOD.
IF HER STANS ARE MAD GO EAT CHRIS BROWN’S SWEATY D!CK.
I like the boots on both of them, but Melody has the edge because her feet aren’t big like Rihanna’s.
Well atleast that’s the way it looks to me.
i voted neither…….both of these chicks are just wrong……….
Some people vote for Rihanna just for the sake of it.
Melody looks lovely. Not over-the-top, just simple and classy. Hopefully her debut is just as good. She looks younger than 25.
Melody (whoever that is) rocked it better..
AND SOME PEOPLE VOTE AGAINST RIHANNA JUST FOR THE SAKE OF IT TOO. IT GOES BOTH WAYS. BELIEVE THAT.
somehow I like the little gray number rihanna have on. I don’t know if the white piece was supposed to show, or the wind was blowing the gray dress up revealing that white under piece. Whatever it is, I like it.
Neither!
I say neither, and thats what I voted……………………but, then again Melody does look slightly better.
Those boots are hideous! Come on Stella!
Oh and neither.
Melody…CLEARLY
AT FIRST I SAID MELODY RIGHT OFF THE BAT BUT…I CHOOSE RIHANNA…SHE GIVES IT A LITTLE MORE SWAGG…MELODY WENT MORE FOR THE SAFE ROUTE. IMO
@LOVEY DOVEY IS RIGHT….PPL WILL VOTE FOR AND AGAINST RIHANNA JUST FOR THE SAKE OF IT…I HAD TO COVER UP BOTH THEIR FACES TO CHOOSE CUZ I HATE THAT HAIR ON RIHANNA…..RIHANNA PUSHED THE EDGE AND WENT TO THE NEXT STEP..I REALLY LIKE THAT GREY NUMBER.
DEAD @NEON SAYING MELODY’S LOOKS LIKE A DRESS FROM FOREVER 21
LMAO AT PPL CALLING HER MELANIE
MELODY THORNTON rocked it better! ….NOW THATS MEAN
THIS OUTFIT IS POSSESSED!
I PREFER RIHANNA’S LOOK. MELODY IS A BEAUTIFUL GIRL BUT SHE PLAYED IT KIND OF SAFE WITH THE BELT/BOOT MATCHY LOOK.
@ MARI I AGREE. I LOVE IT.
THOSE BOOTS ARE SEXY AS HELL THOUGH IMO.
@ #2
That’s your opinion honey. Calm down.
Geez I swear people on here are always looking for a fight with Rih Rih’s fans. Relax.
Love the boots, and Melody rocked the hell out of them
THE MEXICAN ONE
I love those boots but not the price.
Melody has great style, always looks dope!
The way Melody wore it is the same way I wouldve wore it…And I dont know who she is..
I actually think Rihanna looks very pretty…I like the GREY babydoll DRESS with the splash of white over the black leggings…I dont care for her hair…but her style comes off more appealing then Meloody..she looks typical like the average chick would easily rock that…But Rihanna took it to another level and came up with the unthinkable so she most certainly rockd it better.
ooOoh I didnt realize those where boots…dayuuuuum bad as hell. yez Rihanna killed it. love love love the ensemble
Any chick would rock it like Melody i chose Rihanna because its different.
Some of yall just want the Ri stans to come and get yall #2 u aint have to put that u could have kept it moving. Yall stay looking for drama. Calm down its just a blog. Its not a fact if somebody liked Melody then thats ok if they like Rihanna’s thats cool too. Why must yal have to fight?
Melody hands down….Ppl love voting based on favoritism & hate, judge the outfit not your love for the artists!
Also, to the ppl saying who is she Melody is from THE PUSSYCAT DOLLS! There are other artists out besides the ones posted on blogs 24/7…
LOL at Rihanna! She looks a MESSSSSSS! WTf is up with that dark lipstick? You can see her nipples poking throught the shirt, how predictable, and WTf is that white material peaking out from the side of it? It looks like the sleeves from a George Washington’s shirt.
Usually I think melody looks a mess and is unattractive, but she actually looks cute here. Love the whole outfit, except the belt. It’s a bit too much but Melody won this hands down!
I voted neither because these hooker boots r hideous yikes, RIRI’s lipstick and that hair with blond streaks threw me off big time lol and melody is just unattractive in my opinion, she always looks blah
Melody for once! I like this look on her.
as much as i love rihanna. cause she my wifey…melody did rock it better. sorry rihanna. but you get em all the time so it dont really matter. records too. NEXT!
i voted neither considering how hideous i find the boots but melody looks 100% better in them. suprisingly, rihanna got about 900 votes and melody about 2200 votes…..wow! for once, people are actually voting SENSIBLY! rihanna looks ridiculous with that get-up she has on
who the hell cares what Rhianna is wearing? I will choose anybody over her.
They both look fly in those boots but the belf that Melody is wearing, made the outfit a little something more…Just my opinion!!!!
They both Rock’d it!
If I owned a pair, I would rock it like Melody though.
Melo Melody wins Easilyyyy.
to me is rihanna dat rock dat better! the red dress on melody jus aint workin for me!
Melody rocked it better. Rihanna grey top may be expensive but it looks cheap and she needs to put on a bra.
I actually like Rihanna’s outfit, I think those pants and boots need the extra. The tunic Melonie has on is just too plain.